I think that was predestination, rather than free will. People like to believe that they have free will, and justify their actions, but maybe it is all laid out in advance. Perhaps as the predestined future is unknown our illusion of free will exists only in the mind.
The ancient theological discussion on predestination vs free will does have interesting parallells with modern genetics. For example is homosexuality genetic (predestined) or a product of free choice; or indeed a complex mixture of genetics and nurture (another more complex form of predetermination)?
"Exactly right. An omnipotent all-good being that let's horrific things happen to the innocent."
It's one of the great misunderstandings among the "religious", God gave us the free will to make the world what we want. In general we allow it to be made into a hell. Atheists are no better, or worse.
Giving us free will was surely the ultimate act of evil.
Spoken like a true Labour authoritarian. The man on Primrose Hill knows best.
Why give people the power to inflict pain and suffering on earth and in doing so consign them to spend eternity in hell?
Because free will is what makes us human. Without it we would be no better than the angels. And a damn sight less cool than the Cherubim*
* who, incidentally, are most definitely not little boys with wings and chubby cheeks, despite various attempts to portray them as such...
Free will is one thing but you'd hope God might step in with his pretty formidable countermeasures now and again.
Perhaps he does. It was quite lucky that Churchill existed at the time of Hitler's Germany. Cometh the hour, cometh the man.
I was wondering why Uruguay have 4 stars on their badge when they've only only 2 world cups. Answer: they have also won gold at the Olympics twice in the pre-world cup era.
That's because tim isn't here to be on George's case. He was pretty effective at doing him down. Now George is king off all he surveys... until it all goes tits up. !
I was wondering why Uruguay have 4 stars on their badge when they've only only 2 world cups. Answer: they have also won gold at the Olympics twice in the pre-world cup era.
2 + 2 = 4!
Haven't England ever won the Olympics in football?
EDIT: Looked it up. England never have, but Great Britain have three times.
Mr. Rentool's right ...... why don't you include the Greens' poll numbers in your total for the so-called "Progressives" (whatever that is supposed to mean) ?
Well who'd have thunk it? ComRes threatening ICM as the new gold standard, well gold plated comedy bafta standard anyway. It does however bring into question the yoyo polling of YouGov, especially in the past 3 weeks.
Meanwhile build up to the Papal States/Kingdom of the Two Sicilies v South Britain match. Wonder if the Holy Father will be praying in Spanish, English or Italian tonight? Queen will be relaxing with her gin and dubonet, feet up and "One Loves Steven Gerrard CBE" shirt on while HRH of Edinburgh sulks into his kebab and curses that Maggie should just have blown up all South America 30 years ago.
I was wondering why Uruguay have 4 stars on their badge when they've only only 2 world cups. Answer: they have also won gold at the Olympics twice in the pre-world cup era.
2 + 2 = 4!
Haven't they got any world tiddlywinks titles to add to the Olympic football wins?
Can anyone see the possibility of a Tory/Labour coalition in the next few years?
What happens if neither can get a working majority or a coalition with the Lib Dems in the 2015 election, then they decide to go to the country again and get the same result?
In fact it might be the only way of them being able to continue to ignore the calls for PR since they'd have more than 50% of the votes between them.
Can anyone see the possibility of a Tory/Labour coalition in the next few years?
What happens if neither can get a working majority or a coalition with the Lib Dems in the 2015 election, then they decide to go to the country again and get the same result?
In fact it might be the only way of them being able to continue to ignore the calls for PR since they'd have more than 50% of the votes between them.
If the next government brings in PR, which is a possibility, the Tories will need to mend their fences with UKIP pretty quickly.
There can be no deal with kippers - too incoherent and shallow.
No deal with the LibDems either - they ratted on Commission-approved Boundary changes. Also doubtful whether their greatly reduced number of seats will be critical either way.
Can anyone see the possibility of a Tory/Labour coalition in the next few years?
What happens if neither can get a working majority or a coalition with the Lib Dems in the 2015 election, then they decide to go to the country again and get the same result?
In fact it might be the only way of them being able to continue to ignore the calls for PR since they'd have more than 50% of the votes between them.
Only in an emergency.
A major currency/financial crisis (not of either party's making, say the Euro goes mammary glands up) or a major war.
Why is it these South American national anthems all sound like they're from 19th C operas?
Because that is when most of them became independent countries.
Yeah but they are all far too fast and flamboyant
Have you noticed how they are still singing about 5 minutes after the music stops? Either they are trying to catch up with the music or singing a very rude 2nd verse. Always reminds me of the Billy Connelly sketch where he suggested we have the Archers theme tune instead of GSTQ.
That's because tim isn't here to be on George's case. He was pretty effective at doing him down. Now George is king off all he surveys... until it all goes tits up. !
tim was very much like Labour - he had certain strengths, but economics ain't one!
Can anyone see the possibility of a Tory/Labour coalition in the next few years?
What happens if neither can get a working majority or a coalition with the Lib Dems in the 2015 election, then they decide to go to the country again and get the same result?
In fact it might be the only way of them being able to continue to ignore the calls for PR since they'd have more than 50% of the votes between them.
Only in an emergency.
A major currency/financial crisis (not of either party's making, say the Euro goes mammary glands up) or a major war.
I think the only scenario is a major world war. Labour would never do it not even Ed is useless enough to want to emulate Ramsey MacDonald
I was wondering why Uruguay have 4 stars on their badge when they've only only 2 world cups. Answer: they have also won gold at the Olympics twice in the pre-world cup era.
2 + 2 = 4!
Haven't England ever won the Olympics in football?
EDIT: Looked it up. England never have, but Great Britain have three times.
The Olympics is a Mickey Mouse tournament at football. It's just embarrassing that Uruguay count that as two stars.
Why is it these South American national anthems all sound like they're from 19th C operas?
Because that is when most of them became independent countries.
Yeah but they are all far too fast and flamboyant
Have you noticed how they are still singing about 5 minutes after the music stops? Either they are trying to catch up with the music or singing a very rude 2nd verse. Always reminds me of the Billy Connelly sketch where he suggested we have the Archers theme tune instead of GSTQ.
Don't forget we have a verse of the national anthem that's very rude to those north of Berwick.
Why is it these South American national anthems all sound like they're from 19th C operas?
Because that is when most of them became independent countries.
Yeah but they are all far too fast and flamboyant
Have you noticed how they are still singing about 5 minutes after the music stops? Either they are trying to catch up with the music or singing a very rude 2nd verse. Always reminds me of the Billy Connelly sketch where he suggested we have the Archers theme tune instead of GSTQ.
Don't forget we have a verse of the national anthem that's very rude to those north of Berwick.
only the rebellious ones!! My family was on the winning side. Indeed the head of the family at the time was at the side of the Duke of Cumberland at Culloden.
@StigAbell: Pity production journalists tonight, who'll be doing a hell of a job. Papers have to be printed on the final whistle. No late dramas please.
Can anyone see the possibility of a Tory/Labour coalition in the next few years?
What happens if neither can get a working majority or a coalition with the Lib Dems in the 2015 election, then they decide to go to the country again and get the same result?
In fact it might be the only way of them being able to continue to ignore the calls for PR since they'd have more than 50% of the votes between them.
Interesting that in Canada under FTTP where there is (or was) a four party system hung parliaments have been far more common than in the UK yet there is no history of coalitions, only minority governments, with three in a row until Harper finally got a majority with the collapse of the Liberals and BQ.
I'm on 1-1 with money back if it is goalless. Also got Cahill anytime scorer at 18/1, he is good at getting on the end of set pieces and with Baines excellent delivery will probably get at least one sight of goal.
I was wondering why Uruguay have 4 stars on their badge when they've only only 2 world cups. Answer: they have also won gold at the Olympics twice in the pre-world cup era.
2 + 2 = 4!
Haven't England ever won the Olympics in football?
EDIT: Looked it up. England never have, but Great Britain have three times.
The Olympics is a Mickey Mouse tournament at football. It's just embarrassing that Uruguay count that as two stars.
Their Olympic wins were pre-world cup era. Back then, the Olympic gold medalists were considered to be world champs.
More legit than Man City having 3 stars on their badge, anyway!
Why is it these South American national anthems all sound like they're from 19th C operas?
Because that is when most of them became independent countries.
Yeah but they are all far too fast and flamboyant
Have you noticed how they are still singing about 5 minutes after the music stops? Either they are trying to catch up with the music or singing a very rude 2nd verse. Always reminds me of the Billy Connelly sketch where he suggested we have the Archers theme tune instead of GSTQ.
Don't forget we have a verse of the national anthem that's very rude to those north of Berwick.
only the rebellious ones!! My family was on the winning side. Indeed the head of the family at the time was at the side of the Duke of Cumberland at Culloden.
My family's entanglement with the Royals was alas much earlier including loaning Richard II 20,000 marks of silver.
According to many media sources, Raheem Sterling is starting tonight, just backed him as FGS at 14/1 with Paddy Power.
Excellent bet, especially as if this should prove to be a losing bet, PP will refund should Italy win. In normal circumstances probably a 10/1 shot, with this refund element, probably a 7/1 shot or thereabouts. BTW, are you backing the outsider in tonight's two games? .... * Chortles *
I'm on 1-1 with money back if it is goalless. Also got Cahill anytime scorer at 18/1, he is good at getting on the end of set pieces and with Baines excellent delivery will probably get at least one sight of goal.
I was wondering why Uruguay have 4 stars on their badge when they've only only 2 world cups. Answer: they have also won gold at the Olympics twice in the pre-world cup era.
2 + 2 = 4!
I'm not watching the Uruguay, my missus likes the National Lottery quiz so she is watching that. It's a little bit disconcerting as some poor bloke is now in Dale's red area.
One of the massive constitutional changes of this parliament has been the fixed term parliament act. This makes it nigh on impossible for a party that doesn't get a majority to rule as a minority for a few months before going to the country again.
I'm on 1-1 with money back if it is goalless. Also got Cahill anytime scorer at 18/1, he is good at getting on the end of set pieces and with Baines excellent delivery will probably get at least one sight of goal.
Seems a good call to me,you kept calling it right on Demichelis and his booking ;-)
I was wondering why Uruguay have 4 stars on their badge when they've only only 2 world cups. Answer: they have also won gold at the Olympics twice in the pre-world cup era.
2 + 2 = 4!
I'm not watching the Uruguay, my missus likes the National Lottery quiz so she is watching that. It's a little bit disconcerting as some poor bloke is now in Dale's red area.
It's looking more and more unlikely that UKIP will be down to 5% by the time of the general election, which is in just 46 weeks' time.
I agree. I'm expecting about 10% with smaller shares in the key battlegrounds & higher ones where it doesn't matter. Tonight's poll, however, is from the firm that most overstated UKIP on May 22nd and understated CON.
According to many media sources, Raheem Sterling is starting tonight, just backed him as FGS at 14/1 with Paddy Power.
Excellent bet, especially as if this should prove to be a losing bet, PP will refund should Italy win. In normal circumstances probably a 10/1 shot, with this refund element, probably a 7/1 shot or thereabouts. BTW, are you backing the outsider in tonight's two games? .... * Chortles *
Good winner for you yesterday.
I've backed Italy prior to today, am waiting for the inevitable pre-match price boost, to back England.
Given how enjoyable the matches have been so far, I'm fairly certain now England v Italy will deliver the tournament's first (turgid) nil nil, available at 13/2 with William Hill.
I agree, it's terrible to see all this nonsense concocted by the unionists who don't like anyone disagreeing with them. Here's a related perspective (from a Unionist newspaper, no less).
"The absence of anything resembling a proper campaign by Better Together has forced it into the realms of fantasy and this is one of them. In its desperation, it now portrays any criticism of the unionist cause as "vile cybernat abuse".
This was embarrassingly apparent in the lamentable television appearance last week by John McTernan, a former Labour special adviser in its bottomless department of special advice. McTernan was talking about some of the abuse JK Rowling had received for donating £1m to the Better Together campaign. As he began visibly lose to all sense of reality, McTernan, who genuinely seemed to be in some distress, began blaming Gunn for the billionaire author's online ordure.
[...]
Behind all the online frivolity and gloriously manufactured sense of outrage, there is a serious warning for Better Together, and one that it needs to heed quickly if blue is to remain in the union jack. The unionists need to be aware of the consequences of constantly seeking to portray the Scottish nationalists as goggle-eyed brigands with personality disorders, as is the case with their ill-judged "Project Fear" campaign. [...] Better Together needs to think much more carefully about its tactics from now on until the death, because this campaign is slipping away from it."
I was wondering why Uruguay have 4 stars on their badge when they've only only 2 world cups. Answer: they have also won gold at the Olympics twice in the pre-world cup era.
2 + 2 = 4!
Haven't England ever won the Olympics in football?
EDIT: Looked it up. England never have, but Great Britain have three times.
The Olympics is a Mickey Mouse tournament at football. It's just embarrassing that Uruguay count that as two stars.
Their Olympic wins were pre-world cup era. Back then, the Olympic gold medalists were considered to be world champs.
More legit than Man City having 3 stars on their badge, anyway!
FIFA should regulate the stars. City have no EC wins ergo should have no stars.
Think about Forest - a club that have more legitimate shirt stars than Chelsea, City, Arsenal, Tottenham, Everton and Newcastle combined.
Why is it these South American national anthems all sound like they're from 19th C operas?
Because that is when most of them became independent countries.
Yeah but they are all far too fast and flamboyant
Have you noticed how they are still singing about 5 minutes after the music stops? Either they are trying to catch up with the music or singing a very rude 2nd verse. Always reminds me of the Billy Connelly sketch where he suggested we have the Archers theme tune instead of GSTQ.
Don't forget we have a verse of the national anthem that's very rude to those north of Berwick.
only the rebellious ones!! My family was on the winning side. Indeed the head of the family at the time was at the side of the Duke of Cumberland at Culloden.
My family's entanglement with the Royals was alas much earlier including loaning Richard II 20,000 marks of silver.
Irresistible, I have to ask, did they get it back with interest??
One of the massive constitutional changes of this parliament has been the fixed term parliament act. This makes it nigh on impossible for a party that doesn't get a majority to rule as a minority for a few months before going to the country again.
The Fixed Term Parliament act also had a massive effect on the betting markets.
We'd all be speculating now, would Dave and Nick call an election sometime this year?
Clearly, a poll to settle Conservative nerves after one or two modest YouGov outings this week. In effect, we're almost back to the pre-Euros situation with Labour easing back toward the Conservatives in the low to mid-30s.
The UKIP number continues to vary wildly from poll to poll but seems to be around the mid-teens with the Liberal Democrats having eased back to 7-9%.
An Amazonian amount of water to flow under the proverbial bridge yet...
I'm on 1-1 with money back if it is goalless. Also got Cahill anytime scorer at 18/1, he is good at getting on the end of set pieces and with Baines excellent delivery will probably get at least one sight of goal.
Seems a good call to me,you kept calling it right on Demichelis and his booking ;-)
That's a tempting bet gents. Nigel has a good track record on footie tips and remember fondly backing Terry as FGS at long odds and cashing in. Centre backs can often make nice bets.
Why is it these South American national anthems all sound like they're from 19th C operas?
Because that is when most of them became independent countries.
Yeah but they are all far too fast and flamboyant
Have you noticed how they are still singing about 5 minutes after the music stops? Either they are trying to catch up with the music or singing a very rude 2nd verse. Always reminds me of the Billy Connelly sketch where he suggested we have the Archers theme tune instead of GSTQ.
Don't forget we have a verse of the national anthem that's very rude to those north of Berwick.
only the rebellious ones!! My family was on the winning side. Indeed the head of the family at the time was at the side of the Duke of Cumberland at Culloden.
My family's entanglement with the Royals was alas much earlier including loaning Richard II 20,000 marks of silver.
Irresistible, I have to ask, did they get it back with interest??
It sometimes takes a while for political 'incidents' to unravel fully, or to put another way, for the wood to be seen for the trees. With a couple of days behind us this Miliband spat with The Sun is starting to look disastrous for him. However right he was to backtrack, he has made a terrible, terrible, mistake. Many on here may dislike The Sun, but that is very different from invoking their ire.
This is a terrible misjudgement which may cause permanent damage.
One of the massive constitutional changes of this parliament has been the fixed term parliament act. This makes it nigh on impossible for a party that doesn't get a majority to rule as a minority for a few months before going to the country again.
The Fixed Term Parliament act also had a massive effect on the betting markets.
We'd all be speculating now, would Dave and Nick call an election sometime this year?
It also has an impact on economics because previously governments timed the election to fit the economic cycle, now the Chancellor will be trying to time the economy to the political cycle.
It sometimes takes a while for political 'incidents' to unravel fully, or to put another way, for the wood to be seen for the trees. With a couple of days behind us this Miliband spat with The Sun is starting to look disastrous for him. However right he was to backtrack, he has made a terrible, terrible, mistake. Many on here may dislike The Sun, but that is very different from invoking their ire.
This is a terrible misjudgement which may cause permanent damage.
Clearly, a poll to settle Conservative nerves after one or two modest YouGov outings this week. In effect, we're almost back to the pre-Euros situation with Labour easing back toward the Conservatives in the low to mid-30s.
The UKIP number continues to vary wildly from poll to poll but seems to be around the mid-teens with the Liberal Democrats having eased back to 7-9%.
An Amazonian amount of water to flow under the proverbial bridge yet...
As for the football, I've had a small interest on England to win 1-0 at 6/1. I don't see it as the most unlikely thing that could happen and last night's result suggests the European sides may not be as predictable as some imagine.
Comments
Very good poll for Con after the general recent widening of the Lab lead post Euros.
In Tower Hamlets even the candidates might be fake
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/10900132/First-fake-voters-now-police-look-into-bogus-councillors-in-Tower-Hamlets.html?utm_content=buffere2ccb&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer
Flag Quote · Off Topic
Progressives 41%
COA 39%
LAB 34%
JackW will be pleased.
It's the Sun wot won it!
Red-Green alliance 38%
We'll have you next time :-)
*chortle*
2 + 2 = 4!
EDIT: Looked it up. England never have, but Great Britain have three times.
Which leader of the Liberal Democrats do you consider would result in the party securing the most seats at the next General Election:
Nick Clegg
Vince Cable
A N Other
Meanwhile build up to the Papal States/Kingdom of the Two Sicilies v South Britain match. Wonder if the Holy Father will be praying in Spanish, English or Italian tonight? Queen will be relaxing with her gin and dubonet, feet up and "One Loves Steven Gerrard CBE" shirt on while HRH of Edinburgh sulks into his kebab and curses that Maggie should just have blown up all South America 30 years ago.
What happens if neither can get a working majority or a coalition with the Lib Dems in the 2015 election, then they decide to go to the country again and get the same result?
In fact it might be the only way of them being able to continue to ignore the calls for PR since they'd have more than 50% of the votes between them.
A major currency/financial crisis (not of either party's making, say the Euro goes mammary glands up) or a major war.
BBC Sport's Dan Roan in Manaus
England v Italy (23:00 BST)
Posted at
"The England team tonight:
"Hart: Johnson, Jagielka, Cahill, Baines; Gerrard, Henderson; Welbeck, Sterling, Rooney; Sturridge."
More legit than Man City having 3 stars on their badge, anyway!
Lab 332
Con 272
LD 18
Others 28
BTW, are you backing the outsider in tonight's two games? .... * Chortles *
Good winner for you yesterday.
One of the massive constitutional changes of this parliament has been the fixed term parliament act. This makes it nigh on impossible for a party that doesn't get a majority to rule as a minority for a few months before going to the country again.
Given how enjoyable the matches have been so far, I'm fairly certain now England v Italy will deliver the tournament's first (turgid) nil nil, available at 13/2 with William Hill.
Has been a profitable world cup so far.
Back the outsider is my golden rule.
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jun/14/better-together-mistakes-scottish-independence
"The absence of anything resembling a proper campaign by Better Together has forced it into the realms of fantasy and this is one of them. In its desperation, it now portrays any criticism of the unionist cause as "vile cybernat abuse".
This was embarrassingly apparent in the lamentable television appearance last week by John McTernan, a former Labour special adviser in its bottomless department of special advice. McTernan was talking about some of the abuse JK Rowling had received for donating £1m to the Better Together campaign. As he began visibly lose to all sense of reality, McTernan, who genuinely seemed to be in some distress, began blaming Gunn for the billionaire author's online ordure.
[...]
Behind all the online frivolity and gloriously manufactured sense of outrage, there is a serious warning for Better Together, and one that it needs to heed quickly if blue is to remain in the union jack. The unionists need to be aware of the consequences of constantly seeking to portray the Scottish nationalists as goggle-eyed brigands with personality disorders, as is the case with their ill-judged "Project Fear" campaign. [...] Better Together needs to think much more carefully about its tactics from now on until the death, because this campaign is slipping away from it."
Think about Forest - a club that have more legitimate shirt stars than Chelsea, City, Arsenal, Tottenham, Everton and Newcastle combined.
We'd all be speculating now, would Dave and Nick call an election sometime this year?
Clearly, a poll to settle Conservative nerves after one or two modest YouGov outings this week. In effect, we're almost back to the pre-Euros situation with Labour easing back toward the Conservatives in the low to mid-30s.
The UKIP number continues to vary wildly from poll to poll but seems to be around the mid-teens with the Liberal Democrats having eased back to 7-9%.
An Amazonian amount of water to flow under the proverbial bridge yet...
Stig Abell @StigAbell 1m
Asked Sun on Sunday Deputy Ed if all is ready. "It's Saturday Night FIFA", comes the reply. These people can't help themselves.
This is a terrible misjudgement which may cause permanent damage.
http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2014/06/14/sun-ed-miliband-_n_5494504.html
Football is on the telly.
No one cares.
That's 90 minutes of my life I won't be getting back.
Where is the 18-1 on Cahill FGS?
Meanwhile, Uruguay look mediocre to me. Nothing for England to be scared of.
Still from the person who claimed "Liberals don't like football", we're not going to get anything approaching coherent or sensible analysis, are we ?
The definition of rape must not be as I remembered it ^^;
Football fans (YouGov)
Lab 45
Con 31
Kip 12
Lib 4
I bumped into a couple of Celtic fans in the pub earlier.
I said I wanted Scotland back in tournaments. They travel in huge numbers and create atmosphere in the host cities.
It would also have the added benefit of stopping Easterross moaning every time England play.
Labour wants talks on teaching of religion as poll shows 58% of the public urge abolition or axing of state funds
http://www.theguardian.com/education/2014/jun/14/taxpayers-should-not-fund-faith-schools