Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

The Tory voter suppression plan appears to be working – politicalbetting.com

SystemSystem Posts: 12,217
edited April 2023 in General
The Tory voter suppression plan appears to be working – politicalbetting.com

The final figures are in: just 63,279 people met last night's 5pm deadline to apply for new Voter ID.That's a tiny 3% of the 2 MILLION people who lack the right ID to vote under the Govt's new rules.https://t.co/ZiuOOPVW9c

Read the full story here

«134567

Comments

  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,779
    I still wonder whether this is necessarily going to be to the Tories' benefit, given that older people may tend to lack ID, coupled with the fact that normally turnout among older people is probably substantially higher than turnout among younger people lacking ID.

    Has there been any proper demographic analysis to quantify the likely effect on support by party?
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736
    edited April 2023
    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736
    Chris said:

    I still wonder whether this is necessarily going to be to the Tories' benefit, given that older people may tend to lack ID, coupled with the fact that normally turnout among older people is probably substantially higher than turnout among younger people lacking ID.

    Has there been any proper demographic analysis to quantify the likely effect on support by party?

    Pensioners travel passes count young peoples travel passes dont
  • squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,842
    edited April 2023
    I think this means that those who are not allowed to vote won't be able to. Sounds good to me.
  • mwadamsmwadams Posts: 3,671
    Chris said:

    I still wonder whether this is necessarily going to be to the Tories' benefit, given that older people may tend to lack ID, coupled with the fact that normally turnout among older people is probably substantially higher than turnout among younger people lacking ID.

    Has there been any proper demographic analysis to quantify the likely effect on support by party?

    There was a thread on here a while back that suggested that it might be disproportionately negative for the Tories. But that remains to be seen.

    But, as these numbers clearly show, it has a disproportionate impact relative to any perceived benefit.

    The best thing all round would be for the Tories to have a disaster in the locals, and for them to put about the idea that this was because they suffered disproportionately from "issues related to voter id" (which sounds like an *excellent* excuse), and for it to get thrown out before the general.

  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,222
    Presumably a chunk of those 2 million have got postal votes, especially the older voters, so therefore don't need photo I.D.

    Indeed, none of the twelve registered voters at a one bedroom flat who have applied for postal votes need photo I.D. either.

    Which problem exists, and which problem is being addressed here?
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,222

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
  • mickydroymickydroy Posts: 316
    My Daughter has failed to register to the council for verification to vote, I don't know who she would have voted for, but it would not have been Tory, this will definitely suppress the vote. The Tories will do anything to cling on to power, this is just another desperate attempt by then, where i think they have missed a trick, is they should have started it just before the GE, people who miss out this time, will make sure it won't happen again, I expect a better than anticipated local election results for the Tories, because of this
  • OldBasingOldBasing Posts: 173
    Not a fan of the policy, but still of the view this is likely to be a dog that doesn't bark. Real voter surpression would be curtailing voting hours or numbers of polling stations. I'm struggling to compute whether the type of committed voters who tend to vote in local elections predominantly are the sort not to have any kind of ID. My gut says no.

    As for bus passes, would OAPs in rural areas have them where there are no buses? Still think it more likely to harm older voters than young - youngsters especially the pub / club going sort will have ID including ones on the acceptable voting list. NUS cards which are part of the PASS scheme count for example. Guess we will see next week. (My postal vote has been returned).
  • squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,842
    mickydroy said:

    My Daughter has failed to register to the council for verification to vote, I don't know who she would have voted for, but it would not have been Tory, this will definitely suppress the vote. The Tories will do anything to cling on to power, this is just another desperate attempt by then, where i think they have missed a trick, is they should have started it just before the GE, people who miss out this time, will make sure it won't happen again, I expect a better than anticipated local election results for the Tories, because of this

    Did you play for Chelsea?
  • squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,842

    33 reports of fraud and 1 conviction at GE 2019 compared with 250,000 disenfranchised (presumably predominantly) non-Conservative voters in 2024. In theory it could turn a Labour majority into a Conservative one.

    Nice work if Vladimir Putin is your role model.

    The Govt has not disenfranchised anyone.
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 28,910
    edited April 2023

    33 reports of fraud and 1 conviction at GE 2019 compared with 250,000 disenfranchised (presumably predominantly) non-Conservative voters in 2024. In theory it could turn a Labour majority into a Conservative one.

    Nice work if Vladimir Putin is your role model.

    The Govt has not disenfranchised anyone.
    Wrong!

    Check out the Tory leaflets in Norwich South telling voters they don't need ID to vote- now pulled!

    In the I newspaper

    Can't embed at the moment, also paywalled.
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 23,156

    33 reports of fraud and 1 conviction at GE 2019 compared with 250,000 disenfranchised (presumably predominantly) non-Conservative voters in 2024. In theory it could turn a Labour majority into a Conservative one.

    Nice work if Vladimir Putin is your role model.

    The Govt has not disenfranchised anyone.
    People who had the right to vote but now don't have the right to vote have been disenfranchised. That is what the word means! That 3% of them have gone out of their way to regain that right does not change that this is disenfranchisement.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,779

    Chris said:

    I still wonder whether this is necessarily going to be to the Tories' benefit, given that older people may tend to lack ID, coupled with the fact that normally turnout among older people is probably substantially higher than turnout among younger people lacking ID.

    Has there been any proper demographic analysis to quantify the likely effect on support by party?

    Pensioners travel passes count young peoples travel passes dont
    Sorry, but I don't think that quite qualifies as "proper demographic analysis".
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 8,832

    33 reports of fraud and 1 conviction at GE 2019 compared with 250,000 disenfranchised (presumably predominantly) non-Conservative voters in 2024. In theory it could turn a Labour majority into a Conservative one.

    Nice work if Vladimir Putin is your role model.

    The Govt has not disenfranchised anyone.
    It's at least arguable:
    - People without ID were able to vote
    - People without ID are now not able to vote

    That looks like disenfranchisement. Of course, people could take action to avoid being disenfranchised, but I'm not sure that enough was done to make the requirement obvious. They have at least introduced it for locals rather than a GE.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,967
    You don't need ID to vote by post of course and many voters, especially older voters, will already have sent their postal votes in.

    Personally as said before I don't think the photo ID requirement is needed. Though most will still be able to use passport or driving licence even if they weren't able to get new voter ID
  • Chris said:

    I still wonder whether this is necessarily going to be to the Tories' benefit, given that older people may tend to lack ID, coupled with the fact that normally turnout among older people is probably substantially higher than turnout among younger people lacking ID.

    Has there been any proper demographic analysis to quantify the likely effect on support by party?

    Good afternoon

    Many if not most elderly voters use postal votes to be fair
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 23,156

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    So you are asking why he is polling at a level that Blair exceeded but no other Labour leader has sustained? Not Blairite enough perhaps?
  • HYUFD said:

    You don't need ID to vote by post of course and many voters, especially older voters, will already have sent their postal votes in.

    Personally as said before I don't think the photo ID requirement is needed. Though most will still be able to use passport or driving licence even if they weren't able to get new voter ID

    Is there any polling on this
  • mickydroymickydroy Posts: 316

    mickydroy said:

    My Daughter has failed to register to the council for verification to vote, I don't know who she would have voted for, but it would not have been Tory, this will definitely suppress the vote. The Tories will do anything to cling on to power, this is just another desperate attempt by then, where i think they have missed a trick, is they should have started it just before the GE, people who miss out this time, will make sure it won't happen again, I expect a better than anticipated local election results for the Tories, because of this

    Did you play for Chelsea?
    Unfortunately not, but he was my favourite player back in the day, an odd one I agree, but he almost single handedly kept Chelsea alive back in the dark days of 1982, with the help from a goal by Clive Walker, away to Bolton.Chelsea were on the brink of extinction for sure
  • OldBasingOldBasing Posts: 173
    mickydroy said:

    My Daughter has failed to register to the council for verification to vote, I don't know who she would have voted for, but it would not have been Tory, this will definitely suppress the vote. The Tories will do anything to cling on to power, this is just another desperate attempt by then, where i think they have missed a trick, is they should have started it just before the GE, people who miss out this time, will make sure it won't happen again, I expect a better than anticipated local election results for the Tories, because of this

    Still time for your daughter to get a Citizen card in time for 3 May which is acceptable voter ID: https://www.citizencard.com/ See also their Twitter feed - can get one for free for students.
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 8,832
    edited April 2023
    Selebian said:

    33 reports of fraud and 1 conviction at GE 2019 compared with 250,000 disenfranchised (presumably predominantly) non-Conservative voters in 2024. In theory it could turn a Labour majority into a Conservative one.

    Nice work if Vladimir Putin is your role model.

    The Govt has not disenfranchised anyone.
    It's at least arguable:
    - People without ID were able to vote
    - People without ID are now not able to vote

    That looks like disenfranchisement. Of course, people could take action to avoid being disenfranchised, but I'm not sure that enough was done to make the requirement obvious. They have at least introduced it for locals rather than a GE.
    Although I think the problem being addressed is miniscule but the 'solution' probably not causing major issues either (but more issues than the thing it supposedly 'fixes'). Although I might be shown to be wrong on 'not causing major issues'.
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 8,832
    edited April 2023

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    So you are asking why he is polling at a level that Blair exceeded but no other Labour leader has sustained? Not Blairite enough perhaps?
    Or not Blairlike enough!

    (And, in addition, Blair had the advantage of a Labour brand largely detoxified by Kinnock and Smith - Starmer started from the Corbyn era, much more of a task. Although Blair did make major changes, clause 4 etc)
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    So you are asking why he is polling at a level that Blair exceeded but no other Labour leader has sustained? Not Blairite enough perhaps?
    Blair was a Titan by Comparison

    By not Blairite enough I presume you mean offering a Broad Church and offering some radical Policies attractive to Socialists
  • squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,842
    mickydroy said:

    mickydroy said:

    My Daughter has failed to register to the council for verification to vote, I don't know who she would have voted for, but it would not have been Tory, this will definitely suppress the vote. The Tories will do anything to cling on to power, this is just another desperate attempt by then, where i think they have missed a trick, is they should have started it just before the GE, people who miss out this time, will make sure it won't happen again, I expect a better than anticipated local election results for the Tories, because of this

    Did you play for Chelsea?
    Unfortunately not, but he was my favourite player back in the day, an odd one I agree, but he almost single handedly kept Chelsea alive back in the dark days of 1982, with the help from a goal by Clive Walker, away to Bolton.Chelsea were on the brink of extinction for sure
    Saw some of it on the Big Match revisited.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736
    Selebian said:

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    So you are asking why he is polling at a level that Blair exceeded but no other Labour leader has sustained? Not Blairite enough perhaps?
    Or not Blairlike enough!

    (And, in addition, Blair had the advantage of a Labour brand largely detoxified by Kinnock and Smith - Starmer started from the Corbyn era, much more of a task. Although Blair did make major changes, clause 4 etc)
    Tony Benn and Jeremy Corbyn were MPs under Blair as was John Reid and Blunkett

    A Broad Church

    Labour won as a Broad Church

    Not even the biggest SKS fan could describe the SKS Party as that
  • squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,842
    One should add the just because OGH says it's voter suppression doesn't mean.
    It is.... the Thread header is not Gospel.
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 23,156

    Selebian said:

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    So you are asking why he is polling at a level that Blair exceeded but no other Labour leader has sustained? Not Blairite enough perhaps?
    Or not Blairlike enough!

    (And, in addition, Blair had the advantage of a Labour brand largely detoxified by Kinnock and Smith - Starmer started from the Corbyn era, much more of a task. Although Blair did make major changes, clause 4 etc)
    Tony Benn and Jeremy Corbyn were MPs under Blair as was John Reid and Blunkett

    A Broad Church

    Labour won as a Broad Church

    Not even the biggest SKS fan could describe the SKS Party as that
    John McDonnell is still an MP, a wide range of views are within the Labour party and parliamentary party. Be as socialist as you like but stop those anti semitic rants that those who have lost the whip tend to keep repeating every few months.
  • TazTaz Posts: 15,049

    One should add the just because OGH says it's voter suppression doesn't mean.
    It is.... the Thread header is not Gospel.

    Did not Bart post a link showing this was recommended by the Electoral Comission, hardly a bastion of the Tory Party.

    As an aside Parties do promote policies aimed at their electoral advantage. The Lib Dems want PR, Labour votes for 16 and 17 year olds.
  • mickydroymickydroy Posts: 316

    mickydroy said:

    mickydroy said:

    My Daughter has failed to register to the council for verification to vote, I don't know who she would have voted for, but it would not have been Tory, this will definitely suppress the vote. The Tories will do anything to cling on to power, this is just another desperate attempt by then, where i think they have missed a trick, is they should have started it just before the GE, people who miss out this time, will make sure it won't happen again, I expect a better than anticipated local election results for the Tories, because of this

    Did you play for Chelsea?
    Unfortunately not, but he was my favourite player back in the day, an odd one I agree, but he almost single handedly kept Chelsea alive back in the dark days of 1982, with the help from a goal by Clive Walker, away to Bolton.Chelsea were on the brink of extinction for sure
    Saw some of it on the Big Match revisited.
    They were proper shit back in the day, tbh a lot of the players didn't care, they weren't always paid on time etc, but Droy was determined not to see Chelsea fold
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,222

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    Stop painting me as an SKS fan - I voted Nandy.

    However, I accept that Starmer won the leadership, and I wish him and his team well in securing a GE victory.

    Getting rid of the Tories is my priority- what's yours?
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 23,156

    This actually makes me feel a bit sick.

    His smile is indeed a bit cheesy but not sure it should induce someone being sick?
  • mickydroymickydroy Posts: 316

    This actually makes me feel a bit sick.

    I agree it makes you sick to the stomach, they will stoop to any depths to win again, they can hardly run on their record can they
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 23,156
    edited April 2023
    Selebian said:

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    So you are asking why he is polling at a level that Blair exceeded but no other Labour leader has sustained? Not Blairite enough perhaps?
    Or not Blairlike enough!

    (And, in addition, Blair had the advantage of a Labour brand largely detoxified by Kinnock and Smith - Starmer started from the Corbyn era, much more of a task. Although Blair did make major changes, clause 4 etc)
    Starmer is much closer to Smith than Blair in terms of both style and positioning. And I think that is what Labour needed at the time of his appointment.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,792

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    Stop painting me as an SKS fan - I voted Nandy.

    However, I accept that Starmer won the leadership, and I wish him and his team well in securing a GE victory.

    Getting rid of the Tories is my priority- what's yours?
    The return of his hero – Boris Johnson
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,792

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    You are weirdly obsessed. Try posting about something else for a change.

    You are boring.
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,222
    Off topic: Why does Ed Sheeran go to the same barber as Boris Johnson?
  • 2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    You are weirdly obsessed. Try posting about something else for a change.

    You are boring.
    If so - just ignore his posts
  • EndillionEndillion Posts: 4,976
    That tweet in the header is utterly stupid. The 3% figure is just the proportion of those who didn't have ID with 1 day to go, who now do. It's relevant to precisely nothing.
  • HeathenerHeathener Posts: 7,085
    Absolutely disgraceful
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 8,832

    This actually makes me feel a bit sick.

    His smile is indeed a bit cheesy but not sure it should induce someone being sick?
    He should in fact be looking mighty pissed off in the circumstances. But maybe he's not bothered about voting?
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 8,832

    Off topic: Why does Ed Sheeran go to the same barber as Boris Johnson?

    I went to the same barber as my dad for several years :wink:

    (most definitely not an allegation of paternity, just an observation on my experiences)
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,792

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    You are weirdly obsessed. Try posting about something else for a change.

    You are boring.
    If so - just ignore his posts
    Hard to do so when on some days they constitute 30% of posts on the thread saying exactly the same thing over and again
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 8,832
    edited April 2023

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    You are weirdly obsessed. Try posting about something else for a change.

    You are boring.
    If so - just ignore his posts
    Hard to do so when on some days they constitute 30% of posts on the thread saying exactly the same thing over and again
    We badly need to find an SKS fan to explain, so there's no more need to post the question.

    I mean, there must be one, surely? Somewhere?

    ETA: Afterall, we even had Milifandom!
  • eekeek Posts: 28,592

    I think this means that those who are not allowed to vote won't be able to. Sounds good to me.

    It means those poor / without a passport / driving licences can't vote.

    But old biddies can if they remember their bus pass.
  • eekeek Posts: 28,592
    Endillion said:

    That tweet in the header is utterly stupid. The 3% figure is just the proportion of those who didn't have ID with 1 day to go, who now do. It's relevant to precisely nothing.

    2 million don't have suitable Id that allows them to vote.
    70,000 have discovered the fact in time to get suitable ID

    there are 1,930,000 people who may turn up at the polling station to discover they've been disenfranchised.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 72,243

    Chris said:

    I still wonder whether this is necessarily going to be to the Tories' benefit, given that older people may tend to lack ID, coupled with the fact that normally turnout among older people is probably substantially higher than turnout among younger people lacking ID.

    Has there been any proper demographic analysis to quantify the likely effect on support by party?

    Good afternoon

    Many if not most elderly voters use postal votes to be fair
    Don't you mean "to be unfair" ?
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 8,832
    Taz said:

    One should add the just because OGH says it's voter suppression doesn't mean.
    It is.... the Thread header is not Gospel.

    Did not Bart post a link showing this was recommended by the Electoral Comission, hardly a bastion of the Tory Party.

    As an aside Parties do promote policies aimed at their electoral advantage. The Lib Dems want PR, Labour votes for 16 and 17 year olds.
    Blasphemy! The LDs want PR purely for good governance* reasons.

    *more chance of LDs in governments, which leads to good governance :innocent:
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    Stop painting me as an SKS fan - I voted Nandy.

    However, I accept that Starmer won the leadership, and I wish him and his team well in securing a GE victory.

    Getting rid of the Tories is my priority- what's yours?
    If SKS wins we are not getting rid of the Tories we are replacing Tories with Tories

    My Priority is holding the bloke who lied his way to the Leadership to Account

    Holding to account the bloke who asked a lawyer to look into Racism in the Party and then ignored his findings.

    Aforesaid SKS appointed Lawyer says Labour has a hierarchy of racism “Anti-black racism and Islamophobia is not taken as seriously as antisemitism within the Labour party"

    My Priority is to ensure the factional tool in charge of Labour does not win a GE

    My Priority is to bore PB Centrists till GE 2024 or till SKS goes whichever is the sooner

  • kamskikamski Posts: 5,208

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    You are weirdly obsessed. Try posting about something else for a change.

    You are boring.
    Not only boring but stupid. SKS has been leader of the Labour party since April 2020. Does BJO offer an 'explanation' every time the Labour party has improved in the polls in the last 3 years?

    When he became leader Labour were about 20 points behind in the polls. People can demand that SKS fans explain when Labour start doing worse than that.
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 8,832
    Nigelb said:

    Chris said:

    I still wonder whether this is necessarily going to be to the Tories' benefit, given that older people may tend to lack ID, coupled with the fact that normally turnout among older people is probably substantially higher than turnout among younger people lacking ID.

    Has there been any proper demographic analysis to quantify the likely effect on support by party?

    Good afternoon

    Many if not most elderly voters use postal votes to be fair
    Don't you mean "to be unfair" ?
    I don't think I count as elderly, but I use postal votes to be lazy :smile:

    (although I first registered as out of the country on polling day so had good reason, then figured I might as well tick the 'permanent' box - my polling station is all of five minutes' walk away)
  • Pro_RataPro_Rata Posts: 5,352
    Sunak is having what counts as his honeymoon now, I think. It has been delayed by the whole Truss and party meltdown thing, but a little bit of personableness here, a little professionalism there, a solution here has done wonders.

    But, for every success there is something like this. Much of the political and moral bankruptcy hangover from previous leaders remains and it is hitting on almost a daily basis. And, it appears, Sunak is quite content with it. So for every step forward (not with me, I'm still gone), but with blue wallers and Cameroon's, there is a step back. I'm not sure they will just drift back when GE time comes when their politics is being punched in the stomach on a routine basis. And these are not low info voters who are just going to miss it.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 72,243
    Powerful Haaretz editorial.

    The Israeli Flag Is in Our Hands
    https://www.haaretz.com/opinion/editorial/2023-04-25/ty-article-opinion/the-israeli-flag-is-in-our-hands/00000187-b4e0-d3b7-abcf-b5e454d10000
    ...This enormous protest movement managed to achieve something incredible. Not only has it stopped the legal overhaul for now, but it has also reappropriated the Israeli flag. This year, the flag represents a liberated Israel that seeks peace and normalcy. Masses of people who for years had reservations about it and felt growing alienation from it will now fly it with great pride.

    This reappropriation of the Israeli flag is one of the protests’ greatest achievements, and it symbolizes much more than the flag itself. Effectively, this reappropriation of the flag foreshadows the achievement of the protests’ supreme goal – not allowing Jewish nationalists to shape the country and Israel’s fate in their own image. It symbolizes an end to our passivity, the realization that there are millions of other Israelis who feel powerless when they see everything they believed in going to hell, and the fact that we are uniting and fighting together over the character of our country.

    After the holiday, the Knesset’s spring recess will end and the sword of the overhaul legislation will once again hover over us. The protests will resume as well, and they will keep expanding and intensifying until the government caves in and shelves its malicious plans. On this 75th Independence Day, the Israeli flag is in our hands.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 43,046

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    Stop painting me as an SKS fan - I voted Nandy.

    However, I accept that Starmer won the leadership, and I wish him and his team well in securing a GE victory.

    Getting rid of the Tories is my priority- what's yours?
    If SKS wins we are not getting rid of the Tories we are replacing Tories with Tories

    My Priority is holding the bloke who lied his way to the Leadership to Account

    Holding to account the bloke who asked a lawyer to look into Racism in the Party and then ignored his findings.

    Aforesaid SKS appointed Lawyer says Labour has a hierarchy of racism “Anti-black racism and Islamophobia is not taken as seriously as antisemitism within the Labour party"

    My Priority is to ensure the factional tool in charge of Labour does not win a GE

    My Priority is to bore PB Centrists till GE 2024 or till SKS goes whichever is the sooner

    Good for you.

    You are letting the good be the enemy of the perfect, the perfect being the restoration of a "hard left" RCP-type loon who would nationalise Tescos. And you are perfectly entitled to that view.

    Nigel Farage campaigned for Brexit for years and years before it became a thing and now look at us so good luck with it all.

    We need out there people and you appear to be one such.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 72,243
    Selebian said:

    Nigelb said:

    Chris said:

    I still wonder whether this is necessarily going to be to the Tories' benefit, given that older people may tend to lack ID, coupled with the fact that normally turnout among older people is probably substantially higher than turnout among younger people lacking ID.

    Has there been any proper demographic analysis to quantify the likely effect on support by party?

    Good afternoon

    Many if not most elderly voters use postal votes to be fair
    Don't you mean "to be unfair" ?
    I don't think I count as elderly, but I use postal votes to be lazy :smile:

    (although I first registered as out of the country on polling day so had good reason, then figured I might as well tick the 'permanent' box - my polling station is all of five minutes' walk away)
    Mine is anyway, so I vote in person.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    You are weirdly obsessed. Try posting about something else for a change.

    You are boring.
    Does this count as something else?

    https://www.newsandstar.co.uk/news/23477035.outrage-harraby-community-centre-bans-jeremy-corbyn-film/
  • FrankBoothFrankBooth Posts: 9,928
    Can any literary pbers help?

    When I did my GCSE English literature in 1998 one of the texts was a short story translated from Russian. It was about a boy who is always late for school to the consternation of his teacher who later discovers it is because he spends ages walking through a forest on his way to school.

    The story is a lesson on the wonders of nature and was written in the 'optimistic' years after Stalin's death. I do not remember the name but would be grateful to anyone who can tell me!
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 23,156

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    You are weirdly obsessed. Try posting about something else for a change.

    You are boring.
    Does this count as something else?

    https://www.newsandstar.co.uk/news/23477035.outrage-harraby-community-centre-bans-jeremy-corbyn-film/
    No.
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 18,913
    Chris said:

    I still wonder whether this is necessarily going to be to the Tories' benefit, given that older people may tend to lack ID, coupled with the fact that normally turnout among older people is probably substantially higher than turnout among younger people lacking ID.

    Has there been any proper demographic analysis to quantify the likely effect on support by party?

    Oldies are big postal voters so don't need photo ID for that.
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 8,832
    JohnLoony said:

    The fact that there was only 1 prosecution for voter impersonation does not mean that it is not a problem. The whole point is that we don't know how much it happens, or what size of problem it is, because a lot of it goes undetected. Only hysterical revolutionaries fail to understand this basic common sense fact.

    There's some truth in that.

    We also don't know 'a lot of it goes undetected'. We might detect 100%, for all we know.

    We do know that there aren't many people turning up at polling stations to vote only to discover that they've already been counted as having voted. If it was really widespread, then that would happen. So it's either quite small or very well targeted towards those who will not vote. Doing that would be tricky - you might know your neighbour is housebound, but you don't know she hasn't got a postal or proxy vote.

    It's hard to see how you'd do it on a useful scale without detection - you'd need a team to cast multiple votes (as the same person voting many times at one polling station would be risky) and you'd need excellent targeting of registered voters who would not vote. There aren't that many seats where it would even look feasible, I think. It looks far easier to abuse postal voting, to me.

    All the above for GEs, national votes. Somewhat easier to game local votes given lower turnouts and margins, I guess (which could also be important).
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 43,489
    Selebian said:

    Off topic: Why does Ed Sheeran go to the same barber as Boris Johnson?

    I went to the same barber as my dad for several years :wink:

    (most definitely not an allegation of paternity, just an observation on my experiences)
    My dad and I used the same barber for years, and it was quite an unusual one as it was a combined barber shop and railway bookshop. He retired a few years back, sadly, as I really wanted my son to get a haircut there.

    He seemed to know everyone in the city.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 43,046
    I see the government has reached its target for 20,000 new police officers, a pledge made in the 2019 manifesto.

    That's pretty shocking. Govt makes good on manifesto pledge is not something you see every day.

    If only the police's reputation wasn't in the gutter this might have positive polling implications for the Cons. It still might.
  • kinabalukinabalu Posts: 42,679

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    Stop painting me as an SKS fan - I voted Nandy.

    However, I accept that Starmer won the leadership, and I wish him and his team well in securing a GE victory.

    Getting rid of the Tories is my priority- what's yours?
    So did I. Every PB Lab member voted Nandy. Not sure what this says but it says something.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 72,243
    JohnLoony said:

    The fact that there was only 1 prosecution for voter impersonation does not mean that it is not a problem. The whole point is that we don't know how much it happens, or what size of problem it is, because a lot of it goes undetected. Only hysterical revolutionaries fail to understand this basic common sense fact.

    It's possible.
    But we've discussed this at length, and if significant personation* were happening, the great majority of it would likely be postal, and not be via in person voting.

    (* impersonation can be for entirely legal as well as illegal purposes.)
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 28,910
    HYUFD said:

    You don't need ID to vote by post of course and many voters, especially older voters, will already have sent their postal votes in.

    Personally as said before I don't think the photo ID requirement is needed. Though most will still be able to use passport or driving licence even if they weren't able to get new voter ID

    The ludicrous thing HY is postal voting was an area of fraudulent concern. And what have they done-nothing?! There is a very unpleasant smell surrounding this issue.
  • kamskikamski Posts: 5,208
    OldBasing said:

    Not a fan of the policy, but still of the view this is likely to be a dog that doesn't bark. Real voter surpression would be curtailing voting hours or numbers of polling stations. I'm struggling to compute whether the type of committed voters who tend to vote in local elections predominantly are the sort not to have any kind of ID. My gut says no.

    As for bus passes, would OAPs in rural areas have them where there are no buses? Still think it more likely to harm older voters than young - youngsters especially the pub / club going sort will have ID including ones on the acceptable voting list. NUS cards which are part of the PASS scheme count for example. Guess we will see next week. (My postal vote has been returned).

    The rule will also apply at general elections.

    And there could be a big additional bonus for the tories if longer queues at polling stations discourage busy people from voting.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 72,243

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    Stop painting me as an SKS fan - I voted Nandy.

    However, I accept that Starmer won the leadership, and I wish him and his team well in securing a GE victory.

    Getting rid of the Tories is my priority- what's yours?
    If SKS wins we are not getting rid of the Tories we are replacing Tories with Tories

    My Priority is holding the bloke who lied his way to the Leadership to Account

    Holding to account the bloke who asked a lawyer to look into Racism in the Party and then ignored his findings.

    Aforesaid SKS appointed Lawyer says Labour has a hierarchy of racism “Anti-black racism and Islamophobia is not taken as seriously as antisemitism within the Labour party"

    My Priority is to ensure the factional tool in charge of Labour does not win a GE

    My Priority is to bore PB Centrists till GE 2024 or till SKS goes whichever is the sooner

    You're doing a great job on the last point.
    Keep it up.
  • SelebianSelebian Posts: 8,832
    edited April 2023
    kinabalu said:

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    Stop painting me as an SKS fan - I voted Nandy.

    However, I accept that Starmer won the leadership, and I wish him and his team well in securing a GE victory.

    Getting rid of the Tories is my priority- what's yours?
    So did I. Every PB Lab member voted Nandy. Not sure what this says but it says something.
    PB labourites not good at backing the winner? :disappointed:

    Or maybe non-PB labourites not good at backing a winner :open_mouth:

    ETA: As a wet lettuce centrist LD-sympathiser, I think I'd have voted for Starmer, given the vote. Not quite convinced by Nandy. But I haven't seen a great deal of her.
  • eristdooferistdoof Posts: 5,065
    eek said:

    Endillion said:

    That tweet in the header is utterly stupid. The 3% figure is just the proportion of those who didn't have ID with 1 day to go, who now do. It's relevant to precisely nothing.

    2 million don't have suitable Id that allows them to vote.
    70,000 have discovered the fact in time to get suitable ID

    there are 1,930,000 people who may turn up at the polling station to discover they've been disenfranchised.
    The turnout at British local elections is usually pretty low, so I'm sure the polling stations won't have to turn away 1.93 million voters because they posess no ID. I would even expect people who rarely vote in local elections to be disproportionaly more likely to be the ones without any valid voter ID.

    I foresee a much bigger polling day problem, that many who DO have valid ID leave it at home, and are turned away. Some of those won't bother to return later in the day.

    If Voter ID is to be introduced it makes sense to do this in a non GE year.
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 28,910
    JohnLoony said:

    The fact that there was only 1 prosecution for voter impersonation does not mean that it is not a problem. The whole point is that we don't know how much it happens, or what size of problem it is, because a lot of it goes undetected. Only hysterical revolutionaries fail to understand this basic common sense fact.

    So you consider the disenfranchisement of potentially hundreds of thousands of voters to be a proportional response?

    This is Trumpian politics.
  • kinabalukinabalu Posts: 42,679

    Off topic: Why does Ed Sheeran go to the same barber as Boris Johnson?

    Well, just thinking out loud here, because an unruly mop helps him to get it on?
  • WillGWillG Posts: 2,366

    JohnLoony said:

    The fact that there was only 1 prosecution for voter impersonation does not mean that it is not a problem. The whole point is that we don't know how much it happens, or what size of problem it is, because a lot of it goes undetected. Only hysterical revolutionaries fail to understand this basic common sense fact.

    So you consider the disenfranchisement of potentially hundreds of thousands of voters to be a proportional response?

    This is Trumpian politics.
    How is it disenfranchisement? They can very easily get ID and most have it already. Are people in Northern Ireland who already have this system disenfranchised? This is hardly gerrymandering or making people wait hours to vote.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,543
    Turnout in local elections is about one third. That one third are sufficiently engaged to have I/D, so I can't see it making any difference.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 72,243
    edited April 2023

    Off topic: Why does Ed Sheeran go to the same barber as Boris Johnson?

    Couldn't think of one on his own, so had to copy someone ?
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736
    edited April 2023
    kinabalu said:

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    Stop painting me as an SKS fan - I voted Nandy.

    However, I accept that Starmer won the leadership, and I wish him and his team well in securing a GE victory.

    Getting rid of the Tories is my priority- what's yours?
    So did I. Every PB Lab member voted Nandy. Not sure what this says but it says something.
    I did too BTW

    If i knew what I know now i would have voted for RLB but at the time I believed the Party need to move a bit to the right.

    On that basis i should be an SKS fan but moving a bit and becoming a Socialist hating non Democratic hierarchy of racism Party is not a bit!
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 28,910

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    You are weirdly obsessed. Try posting about something else for a change.

    You are boring.
    If so - just ignore his posts
    It's not that easy when on those occasions he posts they come in thick and fast.
  • FrankBoothFrankBooth Posts: 9,928
    JohnLoony said:

    The fact that there was only 1 prosecution for voter impersonation does not mean that it is not a problem. The whole point is that we don't know how much it happens, or what size of problem it is, because a lot of it goes undetected. Only hysterical revolutionaries fail to understand this basic common sense fact.

    Welcome back.

    I thought you had morphed into DecrepitJohnL.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736
    Nigelb said:

    Off topic: Why does Ed Sheeran go to the same barber as Boris Johnson?

    Couldn't think of one on his own, so had to copy someone ?
    He did the same Yesterday
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 23,156
    eristdoof said:

    eek said:

    Endillion said:

    That tweet in the header is utterly stupid. The 3% figure is just the proportion of those who didn't have ID with 1 day to go, who now do. It's relevant to precisely nothing.

    2 million don't have suitable Id that allows them to vote.
    70,000 have discovered the fact in time to get suitable ID

    there are 1,930,000 people who may turn up at the polling station to discover they've been disenfranchised.
    The turnout at British local elections is usually pretty low, so I'm sure the polling stations won't have to turn away 1.93 million voters because they posess no ID. I would even expect people who rarely vote in local elections to be disproportionaly more likely to be the ones without any valid voter ID.

    I foresee a much bigger polling day problem, that many who DO have valid ID leave it at home, and are turned away. Some of those won't bother to return later in the day.

    If Voter ID is to be introduced it makes sense to do this in a non GE year.
    Whats the spread on number of people who turn up without id? And how many come back having gone home to get it.

    I will go with 100,000 turn up without it, of which 20,000 come back later. Will these numbers be recorded?
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 23,156
    Nigelb said:

    Off topic: Why does Ed Sheeran go to the same barber as Boris Johnson?

    Couldn't think of one on his own, so had to copy someone ?
    Thats certainly a bad habit.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736
    edited April 2023

    Nigelb said:

    Off topic: Why does Ed Sheeran go to the same barber as Boris Johnson?

    Couldn't think of one on his own, so had to copy someone ?
    He did the same Yesterday

    Nigelb said:

    Off topic: Why does Ed Sheeran go to the same barber as Boris Johnson?

    Couldn't think of one on his own, so had to copy someone ?
    He did the same Yesterday
    And Sheeran/ Johnson haircuts are also 74% off

    https://www.groupon.co.uk/deals/chaplins-hair-beauty-6?p=3&offer_type=SALE&nlp=&CID=UK&uu=ba222450-095e-11eb-b87f-0242ac120002&tx=0&utm_source=merchandising&utm_medium=email&sid=65fe2b79-0c7f-4ac0-be9c-56359fc9a13f_0_20230426&t_division=sheffield&date=20232604&sender=rm&s=body&c=image&d=deal-page
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 43,046

    kinabalu said:

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    Stop painting me as an SKS fan - I voted Nandy.

    However, I accept that Starmer won the leadership, and I wish him and his team well in securing a GE victory.

    Getting rid of the Tories is my priority- what's yours?
    So did I. Every PB Lab member voted Nandy. Not sure what this says but it says something.
    I did too BTW

    If i knew what I know now i would have voted for RLB but at the time I believed the Party need to move a bit to the right.

    On that basis i should be an SKS fan but moving a bit and becoming a Socialist hating non Democratic hierarchy of racism Party is not a bit!
    Thing is, yours, as per my post previously, is a wholly legitimate view. As is the view of RefUK or UKIP. But the end result is to make it harder for the lesser evil (presumably? Or is SKS = Cons Party in your mind, I know you have said this) to come to power cf RefUK/UKIP and the Cons.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 72,243
    edited April 2023
    Interesting.

    I had a long and meaningful phone call with 🇨🇳 President Xi Jinping. I believe that this call, as well as the appointment of Ukraine's ambassador to China, will give a powerful impetus to the development of our bilateral relations.
    https://twitter.com/ZelenskyyUa/status/1651184756623802368

    First conversation since the invasion.
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 28,910
    edited April 2023
    WillG said:

    JohnLoony said:

    The fact that there was only 1 prosecution for voter impersonation does not mean that it is not a problem. The whole point is that we don't know how much it happens, or what size of problem it is, because a lot of it goes undetected. Only hysterical revolutionaries fail to understand this basic common sense fact.

    So you consider the disenfranchisement of potentially hundreds of thousands of voters to be a proportional response?

    This is Trumpian politics.
    How is it disenfranchisement? They can very easily get ID and most have it already. Are people in Northern Ireland who already have this system disenfranchised? This is hardly gerrymandering or making people wait hours to vote.
    Did you not catch my earlier post from Norwich where official Conservative Party literature tells voters in Labour wards they don't need ID?

    The very fact that you are relaxed about the whole affair suggests it is to your party political advantage.
  • TheValiantTheValiant Posts: 1,882
    Chris said:

    I still wonder whether this is necessarily going to be to the Tories' benefit, given that older people may tend to lack ID, coupled with the fact that normally turnout among older people is probably substantially higher than turnout among younger people lacking ID.

    Has there been any proper demographic analysis to quantify the likely effect on support by party?

    I could easily see a situation where the old couple stroll down to their local station to vote Conservative, as they always have done, with their polling card in hand, as they always have done.

    No ID in hand, they've not even noticed the adverts. Afterall, this is the usual May late afternoon stroll, and they didn't need to take their purse or bag.

    Get to the station and get into a massive fight with the returning officer. Never needed this before, it's undemocratic etc etc etc.
    I wonder if a few might just be allowed to vote anyway, to avoid the fight? Many will not.

    Return home and straight on Facebook to moan long and loud in the 'Bickerstaff on Sea Community Group'. Either way.... they didn't get to vote Conservative after all and can't now be bothered going back to the polling station afterall.

    I wonder how likely.......
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736

    JohnLoony said:

    The fact that there was only 1 prosecution for voter impersonation does not mean that it is not a problem. The whole point is that we don't know how much it happens, or what size of problem it is, because a lot of it goes undetected. Only hysterical revolutionaries fail to understand this basic common sense fact.

    Welcome back.

    I thought you had morphed into DecrepitJohnL.
    I thought the "John Loony" name was trolling me
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,029
    TOPPING said:

    I see the government has reached its target for 20,000 new police officers, a pledge made in the 2019 manifesto.

    That's pretty shocking. Govt makes good on manifesto pledge is not something you see every day.

    If only the police's reputation wasn't in the gutter this might have positive polling implications for the Cons. It still might.

    They’re measuring inputs, rather than outputs.

    20,000 more officers working on trivial motoring offences and policing ‘hate crime’ on Twitter - while house burglaries, car thefts and street robberies lead to little interest - isn’t going to go down well with the general public.
  • TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 43,046
    Sandpit said:

    TOPPING said:

    I see the government has reached its target for 20,000 new police officers, a pledge made in the 2019 manifesto.

    That's pretty shocking. Govt makes good on manifesto pledge is not something you see every day.

    If only the police's reputation wasn't in the gutter this might have positive polling implications for the Cons. It still might.

    They’re measuring inputs, rather than outputs.

    20,000 more officers working on trivial motoring offences and policing ‘hate crime’ on Twitter - while house burglaries, car thefts and street robberies lead to little interest - isn’t going to go down well with the general public.
    Plus there's the new Prime Minister's detachment. On the running machines and Peloton as we speak.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,736

    WillG said:

    JohnLoony said:

    The fact that there was only 1 prosecution for voter impersonation does not mean that it is not a problem. The whole point is that we don't know how much it happens, or what size of problem it is, because a lot of it goes undetected. Only hysterical revolutionaries fail to understand this basic common sense fact.

    So you consider the disenfranchisement of potentially hundreds of thousands of voters to be a proportional response?

    This is Trumpian politics.
    How is it disenfranchisement? They can very easily get ID and most have it already. Are people in Northern Ireland who already have this system disenfranchised? This is hardly gerrymandering or making people wait hours to vote.
    Did you not catch my earlier post from Norwich where official Conservative Party literature tells voters in Labour wards they don't need ID?

    The very fact that you are relaxed about the whole affair suggests it is to your party political advantage.
    SKS has not said he will reverse it has he?
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 23,156
    edited April 2023
    WillG said:

    JohnLoony said:

    The fact that there was only 1 prosecution for voter impersonation does not mean that it is not a problem. The whole point is that we don't know how much it happens, or what size of problem it is, because a lot of it goes undetected. Only hysterical revolutionaries fail to understand this basic common sense fact.

    So you consider the disenfranchisement of potentially hundreds of thousands of voters to be a proportional response?

    This is Trumpian politics.
    How is it disenfranchisement? They can very easily get ID and most have it already. Are people in Northern Ireland who already have this system disenfranchised? This is hardly gerrymandering or making people wait hours to vote.
    Most the people who have been disenfranchised didn't have the necessary ID already by definition, none of them did. 97% of them still don't.
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 28,910
    edited April 2023
    Great header OGH. This should be the scandal of the century. Despite protestations on here justifying that this is already the case in NI, its introduction in England (and Wales) is so transparently malign, I am shocked anyone feels they can justify its introduction.
  • kinabalukinabalu Posts: 42,679
    Selebian said:

    kinabalu said:

    2ND like SKS in LE 2023 vote count

    In actual votes cast or national equivalent vote share?

    A very bold prediction if the latter!
    The former

    So now we have SKS Fans on board perhaps I can get an answer on my FPT question

    Ten Weeks ago SKS Party had a 28 point lead according to YG

    Today they have it at 15

    SKS Fans please explain

    https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/r2r7ejhs5x/TheTimes_VI_230215_W_.pdf
    Stop painting me as an SKS fan - I voted Nandy.

    However, I accept that Starmer won the leadership, and I wish him and his team well in securing a GE victory.

    Getting rid of the Tories is my priority- what's yours?
    So did I. Every PB Lab member voted Nandy. Not sure what this says but it says something.
    PB labourites not good at backing the winner? :disappointed:

    Or maybe non-PB labourites not good at backing a winner :open_mouth:

    ETA: As a wet lettuce centrist LD-sympathiser, I think I'd have voted for Starmer, given the vote. Not quite convinced by Nandy. But I haven't seen a great deal of her.
    No, we don't let 'wet lettuce LD-sympathisers' stick their oar into who our leader should be, but he didn't need you as it turned out. It was never in doubt really. Starmer was one of the most solid odds-on shots in recent political betting. Hopefully you troughed some.
This discussion has been closed.