Skip to content

Starmer was a drag on the Labour vote in Wales but the King of the North might need to become the Ki

1234579

Comments

  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 39,733
    edited May 8

    Streeting backing Starmer in media pool interview.....nobody is going to go over the top.are they.

    The Thatcher Cabinet backed her right up to the point when they didn't.
    Yes but thats the Tories who never stop plotting to oust their leader and their system makes it much easier.
    I suspect you are wrong this time. He's gone, Johnson style by conference. Bookmark here.

    Due to Starmer's travails does Badenoch fly under the radar? In any other circumstances she would have had a shocker of a day.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 59,748

    Streeting backing Starmer in media pool interview.....nobody is going to go over the top.are they.

    The Thatcher Cabinet backed her right up to the point when they didn't.
    "I fight on! I fight to win!"
  • No_Offence_AlanNo_Offence_Alan Posts: 5,492

    Still waiting for the Highlands and Islands regional list results. Who will end up second to the SNP - Labour or Reform?

    Labour I hope , I am on that bet at 7/4. Don't know what Ladbrokes will do if it is a tie (which is looking likely).
  • nico67nico67 Posts: 8,319
    There’s 3 years till the next GE .

    Labour MPs aren’t known for moving quickly but they still have plenty of time to remove Starmer. They certainly need someone more gobby and willing to pick a fight with Reform .

    The polite man in a suit might have worked in 2024 when the Tories self-destructed but it just won’t wash now .

    Time to let rip !
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949
    edited May 8

    Streeting backing Starmer in media pool interview.....nobody is going to go over the top.are they.

    The Thatcher Cabinet backed her right up to the point when they didn't.
    Yes but thats the Tories who never stop plotting to oust their leader and their system makes it much easier.
    I suspect you are wrong this time. He's gone, Johnson style by conference. Bookmark here.

    Due to Starmer's travails does Badenoch fly under the radar? In any other circumstances she would have had a shocker of a day.
    Her danger is next year, its the shires up for election. If they shit the bed, then all the we are turning it around narrative will be dead in the water.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 59,748
    South Woodford (Redbridge) - 2 Green, 1 Labour (TWO Green gains from Labour!)
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 136,842
    edited May 8

    Streeting backing Starmer in media pool interview.....nobody is going to go over the top.are they.

    The Thatcher Cabinet backed her right up to the point when they didn't.
    Yes but thats the Tories who never stop plotting to oust their leader and their system makes it much easier.
    I suspect you are wrong this time. He's gone, Johnson style by conference. Bookmark here.

    Due to Starmer's travails does Badenoch fly under the radar? In any other circumstances she would have had a shocker of a day.
    Tories second on NEV with Sky and some good results in areas like Westminster, Barnet, Harlow and Fareham secure her position.

    Starmer's team also ensured expectations were so low for Labour, even Labour beating the Greens and Tories and LDs on seats won seems like a reasonable result despite the heavy losses of Labour seats to Reform in particular. So I suspect he also survives
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 6,012

    Streeting backing Starmer in media pool interview.....nobody is going to go over the top.are they.

    The Thatcher Cabinet backed her right up to the point when they didn't.
    Yes but thats the Tories who never stop plotting to oust their leader and their system makes it much easier.
    If Labour had not kept bottling it, they might not have spent so long in opposition
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 6,012
    Why, 26 hours after the polls closed, are we still waiting for votes to be counted?
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 35,218
    nico67 said:

    There’s 3 years till the next GE .

    Labour MPs aren’t known for moving quickly but they still have plenty of time to remove Starmer. They certainly need someone more gobby and willing to pick a fight with Reform .

    The polite man in a suit might have worked in 2024 when the Tories self-destructed but it just won’t wash now .

    Time to let rip !

    I love how you think where Starmer is slipping up is too much polite restraint. Obviously not a big watcher of PMQs.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 59,748
    Indies gain another seat in Redbridge

    Seven Kings - 2 Lab, 1 Ind.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 32,559

    Why, 26 hours after the polls closed, are we still waiting for votes to be counted?

    God alone knows.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 32,559
    edited May 8

    Streeting backing Starmer in media pool interview.....nobody is going to go over the top.are they.

    The Thatcher Cabinet backed her right up to the point when they didn't.
    Yes but thats the Tories who never stop plotting to oust their leader and their system makes it much easier.
    I suspect you are wrong this time. He's gone, Johnson style by conference. Bookmark here.

    Due to Starmer's travails does Badenoch fly under the radar? In any other circumstances she would have had a shocker of a day.
    Her danger is next year, its the shires up for election. If they shit the bed, then all the we are turning it around narrative will be dead in the water.
    It's not very convincing right now tbh.
    Losing 40% of seats as opposed to 60% last year.
    It's progress. Of sorts. But pretty soon you'll have no base to build on whatsoever.
    The Tories may be clinging to decent results in some well to do places, but they are becoming utterly extinct in increasingly large areas of the country.
    The Labour Party results are cataclysmic. But we know the reason why. The least popular PM in history.
    But the Tories are pulling this off with the least unpopular Party leader.
    That's some achievement.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949
    edited May 8
    dixiedean said:

    Streeting backing Starmer in media pool interview.....nobody is going to go over the top.are they.

    The Thatcher Cabinet backed her right up to the point when they didn't.
    Yes but thats the Tories who never stop plotting to oust their leader and their system makes it much easier.
    I suspect you are wrong this time. He's gone, Johnson style by conference. Bookmark here.

    Due to Starmer's travails does Badenoch fly under the radar? In any other circumstances she would have had a shocker of a day.
    Her danger is next year, its the shires up for election. If they shit the bed, then all the we are turning it around narrative will be dead in the water.
    It's not very convincing right now tbh.
    We're losing 40% of our seats as opposed to 60% last year.
    It's progress. Of sorts. But pretty soon you'll have no base to build on whatsoever.
    The Tories may be clinging to decent results in some well to do places, but they are becoming utterly extinct in increasingly large areas of the country.
    The Labour Party results are cataclysmic. But we know the reason why. The least popular PM in history.
    But the Tories are pulling this off with the least unpopular Party leader.
    That's some achievement.
    I agree they are still in massive trouble. I dont know who is their base nowadays.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 6,012
    dixiedean said:

    Why, 26 hours after the polls closed, are we still waiting for votes to be counted?

    God alone knows.
    Not just me who thinks this should have been wrapped by mid afternoon at the latest.

    Good
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 59,748
    Three more Indy gains in Redbridge.

    Clementswood - 2 Lab, I Indy
    Valentines - 1 Lab, 2 Indy

    Just Hainault left!
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 59,748

    Three more Indy gains in Redbridge.

    Clementswood - 2 Lab, I Indy
    Valentines - 1 Lab, 2 Indy

    Just Hainault left!

    Reform gain a seat from Labour in Hainault! 2 Lab, 1 Ref
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 32,559
    edited May 8
    Got a Newcastle vote share total.

    Green 27.0%
    Reform 24.2%
    LD. 23.1%
    Labour 17.9%
    Indies. 4.0%
    Con. 3.7%
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 59,748
    edited May 8
    Labour hold on to Redbridge:

    Lab 43
    Redbridge Indies 9
    Con 5
    Green 5
    Reform 1

    Lab -15
    Green +5
    Indies +9
    Ref +1
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 59,834
    Shabana speaks:

    https://x.com/shabanamahmood/status/2052875177503936513

    A devastating night in Birmingham and across the country. Good public servants, colleagues and friends have lost their seats. This was a verdict on us not them. The PM has rightly said we must do better. It is a privilege to serve the British people and we must live up to it.
  • BatteryCorrectHorseBatteryCorrectHorse Posts: 7,113

    Shabana speaks:

    https://x.com/shabanamahmood/status/2052875177503936513

    A devastating night in Birmingham and across the country. Good public servants, colleagues and friends have lost their seats. This was a verdict on us not them. The PM has rightly said we must do better. It is a privilege to serve the British people and we must live up to it.

    But better how? In aid of what?

    It’s all nonsense.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 32,559
    dixiedean said:

    Got a Newcastle vote share total.

    Green 27.0%
    Reform 24.2%
    LD. 23.1%
    Labour 17.9%
    Indies. 4.0%
    Con. 3.7%

    That's become LD 25, Reform 24, Green 24, Labour 2, Indy 3 Con 0 in seats.

    FPTP pretty brutal if you're below 20%.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 6,012

    Shabana speaks:

    https://x.com/shabanamahmood/status/2052875177503936513

    A devastating night in Birmingham and across the country. Good public servants, colleagues and friends have lost their seats. This was a verdict on us not them. The PM has rightly said we must do better. It is a privilege to serve the British people and we must live up to it.

    Word soup

    As bad as Starmer for that
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949

    Shabana speaks:

    https://x.com/shabanamahmood/status/2052875177503936513

    A devastating night in Birmingham and across the country. Good public servants, colleagues and friends have lost their seats. This was a verdict on us not them. The PM has rightly said we must do better. It is a privilege to serve the British people and we must live up to it.

    Word soup

    As bad as Starmer for that
    ChatGPT-ization of politics.
  • MustaphaMondeoMustaphaMondeo Posts: 547
    So Kier blocked Burnham in Gorton and it has cost Labour dear. Gorton felt pivotal. I even bothered to doorknock. Burnham could have won, maybe. But instead we got Hannah and Kier got another few months.

    Jeeze the selfishness and carelessness of ambition.

    Labour must dispose of Sir Kier asap or they will be toast.

    And another thing.
    These are smart people, why can’t they see the trend?

  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 28,755

    Shabana speaks:

    https://x.com/shabanamahmood/status/2052875177503936513

    A devastating night in Birmingham and across the country. Good public servants, colleagues and friends have lost their seats. This was a verdict on us not them. The PM has rightly said we must do better. It is a privilege to serve the British people and we must live up to it.

    But better how? In aid of what?

    It’s all nonsense.
    Exactly. Starmerism in a nutshell.
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 32,559

    So Kier blocked Burnham in Gorton and it has cost Labour dear. Gorton felt pivotal. I even bothered to doorknock. Burnham could have won, maybe. But instead we got Hannah and Kier got another few months.

    Jeeze the selfishness and carelessness of ambition.

    Labour must dispose of Sir Kier asap or they will be toast.

    And another thing.
    These are smart people, why can’t they see the trend?

    Yep.
    And don't you reckon the blocking of Burnham has led to the shockingly bad results across Greater Manchester tonight?
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 28,755
    HYUFD said:

    Streeting backing Starmer in media pool interview.....nobody is going to go over the top.are they.

    The Thatcher Cabinet backed her right up to the point when they didn't.
    Yes but thats the Tories who never stop plotting to oust their leader and their system makes it much easier.
    I suspect you are wrong this time. He's gone, Johnson style by conference. Bookmark here.

    Due to Starmer's travails does Badenoch fly under the radar? In any other circumstances she would have had a shocker of a day.
    Tories second on NEV with Sky and some good results in areas like Westminster, Barnet, Harlow and Fareham secure her position...
    It's a LD strategy: retreat to Con comfort zones, hold out in their hold-out and wait for the storm to pass. It's a good strategy...if your ambition is to come third and be the junior partner in a RefCon coalition.

  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 28,755
    131 of 136 councils

    Ref 1,443 (+1,441)
    Lab 959 (-1,395)
    Lib 834 (+151)
    Con 773 (-555)
    Gre 511 (+370)

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/c1428pev1n0t
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 6,012

    Shabana speaks:

    https://x.com/shabanamahmood/status/2052875177503936513

    A devastating night in Birmingham and across the country. Good public servants, colleagues and friends have lost their seats. This was a verdict on us not them. The PM has rightly said we must do better. It is a privilege to serve the British people and we must live up to it.

    Word soup

    As bad as Starmer for that
    ChatGPT-ization of politics.
    I just used Grok to create the following:

    Statement from Sir Keir Starmer

    The British people have rejected the Labour government I lead. This is a catastrophic result, and I take full responsibility for it without hesitation or qualification.I was on the ballot.

    I was the one who set the direction. The failures — on delivery, on listening to communities, on fixing the issues that matter most to working people — happened under my leadership. For that, I am truly sorry.Tonight, the voters have spoken clearly.

    They have lost trust in us, and that loss of trust is down to me. I will not point fingers at others. I will not make excuses about headwinds or inherited problems.

    This defeat is on me.I will contact the party chair immediately to begin the process of a smooth transition to new leadership. Labour needs to take a long, hard look at itself and change course. We must go back to being the party that truly serves working people, not distant from their concerns.

    The country deserves better, and it is right that I now step aside so that Labour can rebuild.

  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 28,755
    edited May 9
    The Rallings and Thrasher NEV early Friday morning and Parliament projected from that vote
    • REF 284 seats (27% of vote)
    • LAB 110 seats (15% of vote)
    • CON 96 seats (20% of vote)
    • LIB 80 seats (14% of vote)
    • SNP 36 (? of vote)
    • PCU 13 (? of vote)
    • GRE 13 (14% of vote)
    https://news.sky.com/story/english-council-elections-what-the-results-so-far-are-telling-us-in-maps-and-charts-13541348
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 64,489
    viewcode said:

    The Rallings and Thrasher NEV early Friday morning and Parliament projected from that vote


    • REF 284 seats (27% of vote)
    • LAB 110 seats (15% of vote)
    • CON 96 seats (20% of vote)
    • LIB 80 seats (14% of vote)
    • SNP 36 (? of vote)
    • PCU 13 (? of vote)
    • GRE 13 (14% of vote)
    https://news.sky.com/story/english-council-elections-what-the-results-so-far-are-telling-us-in-maps-and-charts-13541348
    Something for everyone to be little bit unhappy about.
  • carnforthcarnforth Posts: 9,224

    Shabana speaks:

    https://x.com/shabanamahmood/status/2052875177503936513

    A devastating night in Birmingham and across the country. Good public servants, colleagues and friends have lost their seats. This was a verdict on us not them. The PM has rightly said we must do better. It is a privilege to serve the British people and we must live up to it.

    Word soup

    As bad as Starmer for that
    ChatGPT-ization of politics.
    I just used Grok to create the following:

    Statement from Sir Keir Starmer

    The British people have rejected the Labour government I lead. This is a catastrophic result, and I take full responsibility for it without hesitation or qualification.I was on the ballot.

    I was the one who set the direction. The failures — on delivery, on listening to communities, on fixing the issues that matter most to working people — happened under my leadership. For that, I am truly sorry.Tonight, the voters have spoken clearly.

    They have lost trust in us, and that loss of trust is down to me. I will not point fingers at others. I will not make excuses about headwinds or inherited problems.

    This defeat is on me.I will contact the party chair immediately to begin the process of a smooth transition to new leadership. Labour needs to take a long, hard look at itself and change course. We must go back to being the party that truly serves working people, not distant from their concerns.

    The country deserves better, and it is right that I now step aside so that Labour can rebuild.

    Why has it missed out spaces after some of the full stops? Did you edit it?
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 28,755
    rcs1000 said:

    viewcode said:

    The Rallings and Thrasher NEV early Friday morning and Parliament projected from that vote


    • REF 284 seats (27% of vote)
    • LAB 110 seats (15% of vote)
    • CON 96 seats (20% of vote)
    • LIB 80 seats (14% of vote)
    • SNP 36 (? of vote)
    • PCU 13 (? of vote)
    • GRE 13 (14% of vote)
    https://news.sky.com/story/english-council-elections-what-the-results-so-far-are-telling-us-in-maps-and-charts-13541348
    Something for everyone to be little bit unhappy about.
    I should imagine Deputy Prime Minister and Lord President of the Council Kemi Badenoch would be very happy with it

    :)
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 6,012
    carnforth said:

    Shabana speaks:

    https://x.com/shabanamahmood/status/2052875177503936513

    A devastating night in Birmingham and across the country. Good public servants, colleagues and friends have lost their seats. This was a verdict on us not them. The PM has rightly said we must do better. It is a privilege to serve the British people and we must live up to it.

    Word soup

    As bad as Starmer for that
    ChatGPT-ization of politics.
    I just used Grok to create the following:

    Statement from Sir Keir Starmer

    The British people have rejected the Labour government I lead. This is a catastrophic result, and I take full responsibility for it without hesitation or qualification.I was on the ballot.

    I was the one who set the direction. The failures — on delivery, on listening to communities, on fixing the issues that matter most to working people — happened under my leadership. For that, I am truly sorry.Tonight, the voters have spoken clearly.

    They have lost trust in us, and that loss of trust is down to me. I will not point fingers at others. I will not make excuses about headwinds or inherited problems.

    This defeat is on me.I will contact the party chair immediately to begin the process of a smooth transition to new leadership. Labour needs to take a long, hard look at itself and change course. We must go back to being the party that truly serves working people, not distant from their concerns.

    The country deserves better, and it is right that I now step aside so that Labour can rebuild.

    Why has it missed out spaces after some of the full stops? Did you edit it?
    I split it into paragraphs so may have removed a space or two but no editing of actual content
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 64,489
    Final numbers are in from Scotland, with the list seats from Highlands & Islands.

    SNP is on 58, -6
    Labour 17, -4
    Reform on 17, +17
    Green 15, +6
    Conservatives 12, -19
    LibDem 10, +6

    Looks like Reform just beat out Labour in vote share in the list vote.
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 28,755
    rcs1000 said:

    Final numbers are in from Scotland, with the list seats from Highlands & Islands.

    SNP is on 58, -6
    Labour 17, -4
    Reform on 17, +17
    Green 15, +6
    Conservatives 12, -19
    LibDem 10, +6

    Looks like Reform just beat out Labour in vote share in the list vote.

    I assume a SNP/Green coalition (Bute House II) is not viable since last time, which leaves... what?
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 6,012
    rcs1000 said:

    Final numbers are in from Scotland, with the list seats from Highlands & Islands.

    SNP is on 58, -6
    Labour 17, -4
    Reform on 17, +17
    Green 15, +6
    Conservatives 12, -19
    LibDem 10, +6

    Looks like Reform just beat out Labour in vote share in the list vote.

    How will this work in terms of precedence for questions, committees abd so forth?
  • BatteryCorrectHorseBatteryCorrectHorse Posts: 7,113
    Labour seems to have done badly in Scotland but not as horrendously as I expected. I’m surprised as they’ve been wiped out there before.
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 6,012

    Labour seems to have done badly in Scotland but not as horrendously as I expected. I’m surprised as they’ve been wiped out there before.

    Perhaps Sarwar distancing himself from Starmer helped in that?
  • viewcodeviewcode Posts: 28,755
    edited May 9
    Can I big up the Welsh Senedd election? Not in terms of the result, but the electoral method and graphics. All sorted out by mid-afternoon and nice graphics (see below for an example)

    https://x.com/BBCWalesNews/status/2052799869530583081
  • oxfordsimonoxfordsimon Posts: 6,012
    viewcode said:

    Can I big up the Welsh Senedd election? Not in terms of the result, but the electoral method and graphics. All sorted out by mid-afternoon and nice graphics (see below for an example)

    https://x.com/BBCWalesNews/status/2052799869530583081

    The method is simple and reasonably fast.

    But perhaps the thresholds are too high. 11/12% is demanding. Particularly for smaller parties and independents. Doesn't make the end result as representative as it might be.

    Must research how resignations/Party switches ate to be handled
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 60,371

    Streeting backing Starmer in media pool interview.....nobody is going to go over the top.are they.

    Nobody going over the top in their praise of Starmer, for sure.

    They know. Another year in the toaster is just going to result in very blackened toast.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 56,826

    dixiedean said:

    Streeting backing Starmer in media pool interview.....nobody is going to go over the top.are they.

    The Thatcher Cabinet backed her right up to the point when they didn't.
    Yes but thats the Tories who never stop plotting to oust their leader and their system makes it much easier.
    I suspect you are wrong this time. He's gone, Johnson style by conference. Bookmark here.

    Due to Starmer's travails does Badenoch fly under the radar? In any other circumstances she would have had a shocker of a day.
    Her danger is next year, its the shires up for election. If they shit the bed, then all the we are turning it around narrative will be dead in the water.
    It's not very convincing right now tbh.
    We're losing 40% of our seats as opposed to 60% last year.
    It's progress. Of sorts. But pretty soon you'll have no base to build on whatsoever.
    The Tories may be clinging to decent results in some well to do places, but they are becoming utterly extinct in increasingly large areas of the country.
    The Labour Party results are cataclysmic. But we know the reason why. The least popular PM in history.
    But the Tories are pulling this off with the least unpopular Party leader.
    That's some achievement.
    I agree they are still in massive trouble. I dont know who is their base nowadays.
    The plutogerontocracy. Rich elderly people.
  • Penddu2Penddu2 Posts: 931
    edited May 9

    viewcode said:

    Can I big up the Welsh Senedd election? Not in terms of the result, but the electoral method and graphics. All sorted out by mid-afternoon and nice graphics (see below for an example)

    https://x.com/BBCWalesNews/status/2052799869530583081

    The method is simple and reasonably fast.

    But perhaps the thresholds are too high. 11/12% is demanding. Particularly for smaller parties and independents. Doesn't make the end result as representative as it might be.

    Must research how resignations/Party switches ate to be handled
    If a MS dies/resigns he/she is replaced by next person on list. There are no byelections.

    If a MS resigns from party he/she remains as independent MS - original party loses official funding for that individual. If defecting to another party, i dont think funding follows to new party.

    Danger for Tories is if they lose two MS they lose group status -and lots of £.

    If say a group of 6 Reform MS defect to Restore - they would not be recognised as a group and would not qualify for funding.
  • Penddu2Penddu2 Posts: 931
    The Senedd arithmetic means that Plaid > (Reform & Cons). Green would probably back Plaid in most votes, and single LD wont make a difference - so in majority of votes, it all comes down to Labour.

    As kingmakers they can either actively support Plaid (and be accused of propping up Plaid) - or actively support Reform (and be accused of worse). So expect a series of tactical abstensions.

    FIRST DECISIONS:
    1. Election of Llywydd (Presiding Officer) & Deputy

    Reform have said they expect this role (as official opposition) but there is no precedent for this and I expect Plaid & Labour to work together to block this as it would lead to chaos (simply due to inexperience).

    Instead I expect Llywydd to be Huw Irranca Davies (Labour) and Deputy maybe Peter Fox (Conservative). Old hands who should be able to control Senedd business. And maintaining party balance (or voting bloc balance).

    2. Election of First Minister

    Plaid will nominate Rhun ap Iorwerth - who will probably be backed by Green - giving 45 votes. Not a majority.

    Reform will nominate Dan Thomas. He might get Conservative support - giving 41 votes - but more likely Conservatives will not support at this stage.

    Other parties will go through motions of nominating their own leaders who will all fall way short. Votes then repeated - Labour will abstain and so Rhun will be elected

    Then tge fun begins
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 66,561
    viewcode said:

    rcs1000 said:

    Final numbers are in from Scotland, with the list seats from Highlands & Islands.

    SNP is on 58, -6
    Labour 17, -4
    Reform on 17, +17
    Green 15, +6
    Conservatives 12, -19
    LibDem 10, +6

    Looks like Reform just beat out Labour in vote share in the list vote.

    I assume a SNP/Green coalition (Bute House II) is not viable since last time, which leaves... what?
    Why would a SNP/Green deal not be viable?

    If it isn't SNP will try and govern as a minority.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 66,561
    Labour aren't going to do anything about Starmer. And Burnham can't move.

    So this year he stays.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 66,561
    Leon said:

    Omnium said:

    Leon said:

    Omnium said:

    Leon said:

    Why is Greek white wine now the best in the world, when it used to be the worst?

    Leon said:

    Why is Greek white wine now the best in the world, when it used to be the worst?

    It is very good. Totally with you on that. (A local aside - I presume you know the wine shop in Queens Park that has lots of wines from lesser regarded countries?)

    No, I don't. I get all my fancy wines from Vivino, generally

    The only problem with Greek white wine is that everyone else has also discovered that it is brilliant. I am old enough to remember when I was basically the first to realise, and I was getting these dreamy dreamy assyrtikos for under a tenner a bottle. Now they are over £20
    Well go and look. I absolutely promise you it's a great place. They have a magnificent range of wines. As posted in my edit: Salusbury wines. Obviously I have no connection etc.

    Greek white wine has improved. I was in Thessaloniki last year and you can wander into food and wine that would get michelin stars here.
    Yes. Greek food is also improving fast - following the wine

    I went to Athens in the post Covid summer of 2022 and had it basically to myself. It was glorious. And I ate in loads of cool new restaurants. The food was generally excellent

    The Greeks know how to keep it simple yet delicious

    I don’t know why the wine suddenly got so good. But it did
    Greek food is great, for the first three days.

    After that it gets very repetitive and boring.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 66,561

    Ratters said:

    A few observations from tonight:

    1) Reform have done great, but I don't think well enough to win a majority. Not yet. Their areas of strength will see them to north of 200 seats but short of a majority as there is significant opposition, and it's becoming clear who is competitive regionally.

    2) The Tories aren't dead. They are losing seats to Reform and aren't recovering in the Southern Wall lost to the Lib Dems. But there are still certain areas that are uniquely Tory and not susceptible to either of these.

    3) The Greens haven't reached the 'tipping point'. They have done well but their vote is not as well distributed as some of the other parties. At this level they'd probably be similar to Reform last time: lots of second places but disappointingly few wins. It remains to be seen if they can continue to build on their momentum.

    4) Given the above, I expect a Reform-Tory coalition or similar is the most likely next government. But three years is a long time in politics so who knows...

    The uniquely Tory point is an interesting one, and one I’ve also clocked. There are still plenty of redoubts up and down the country. One of the things I have long thought is that if Reform were on course for a majority those Tory wards (which I think are generally the leafy affluent suburbs of population centres) would reliably start flipping. But they haven’t - not yet - at least not in the numbers to give Reform the numbers to win.
    Because Reform are crass, angry, ineffective, somewhat unpleasant, and a bit low-brow.

    It's not actually their policies that are the problem - that's a centrist Dad take - it's them.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 81,137
    Birmingham council final seat is provisionally 1 worker, 1 rfm pending a Monday recount
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 81,137
    Pulpstar said:

    Birmingham council final seat is provisionally 1 worker, 1 rfm pending a Monday recount

    Possible coalitions are Tory, Rfm, LD or Lab, Green, LD and some indies
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949
    edited May 9
    I am the change...

    The king’s speech on Wednesday will also include policy announcements, though a cabinet reshuffle is not expected.

    https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/may/08/keir-starmer-under-pressure-to-agree-exit-plan-after-election-mauling
  • rkrkrkrkrkrk Posts: 9,352
    edited May 9
    Labour MPs should wait to replace Keir because:

    1) They need to get decision right. Who is best to take on Farage and persuade Green vote to return are my two key questions. I don't think answer to either is clear at the moment.

    2) Iran/Hormuz crisis may require taking some very tough and unpopular decisions. Not good for country if they are being taken during a leadership campaign.

    3) Starmer (at least until now) still had a lot of membership support. Him going quietly is probably the best option.

    But they shouldn't wait too long. Christmas seems reasonable?
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 39,733
    BBC confirm Badenoch is doing very well as LOTO and remains secure despite council losses in England and an absolute pasting in Scotland and Wales.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cnvp5rqrde3o

    I wonder if Starmer takes the sting and the fall as she flies under the radar.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949
    edited May 9
    someone analyzed all 5000+ accepted papers at ICLR 2026, and it's a good signal who's pushing the research of AI:
    > China has surpassed the US with 43.7% of the papers
    > Europe's contribution is surprisingly small (5.3% including UK)

    https://x.com/Hesamation/status/2052792603997814914?s=20

    The government wittering on about the UK only second to the US in AI, bulllllshit. Need to get serious on this.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 79,488
    rkrkrk said:

    Labour MPs should wait to replace Keir because:

    1) They need to get decision right. Who is best to take on Farage and persuade Green vote to return are my two key questions. I don't think answer to either is clear at the moment.

    2) Iran/Hormuz crisis may require taking some very tough and unpopular decisions. Not good for country if they are being taken during a leadership campaign.

    3) Starmer (at least until now) still had a lot of membership support. Him going quietly is probably the best option.

    But they shouldn't wait too long. Christmas seems reasonable?

    If seeing Starmer go would give them an immediate and significant bounce - and all the signs are it would - then 2028 would be their best date, just before calling the next election.

    And, helpfully, that's the time that would suit him as well.

    I've always thought he was going nowhere - in all senses - and nothing I've seen in the last 36 hours has changed my view.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 79,488
    Oh, and did I hear that Labour didn't do very well in Wales.

    Pause.


    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

    gasps

    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 60,371

    BBC confirm Badenoch is doing very well as LOTO and remains secure despite council losses in England and an absolute pasting in Scotland and Wales.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cnvp5rqrde3o

    I wonder if Starmer takes the sting and the fall as she flies under the radar.

    Exactly as I said yesterday.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 60,371
    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Birmingham council final seat is provisionally 1 worker, 1 rfm pending a Monday recount

    Possible coalitions are Tory, Rfm, LD or Lab, Green, LD and some indies
    They will likely take longe rto put together than they will last.

    Welcome to PR without the PR voting system.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949

    BBC confirm Badenoch is doing very well as LOTO and remains secure despite council losses in England and an absolute pasting in Scotland and Wales.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cnvp5rqrde3o

    I wonder if Starmer takes the sting and the fall as she flies under the radar.

    And you get a new leader...and you get a new leader.....everybody gets a new leader...
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 39,733

    BBC confirm Badenoch is doing very well as LOTO and remains secure despite council losses in England and an absolute pasting in Scotland and Wales.

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cnvp5rqrde3o

    I wonder if Starmer takes the sting and the fall as she flies under the radar.

    Exactly as I said yesterday.
    As someone who doesn't want a Conservative Government I am more than content to see Badenoch thrive as Conservative leader.

    However, if the direct correlation coefficient between Reform and Conservative is as I think it is, I would prefer to see someone less, er crap.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949
    This is the obvious thing to do if you wanted to stop fascism. But they don’t.

    https://x.com/PhilipProudfoot/status/2052818798290370910?s=20

    There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK

    https://x.com/tnewtondunn/status/2052802123671220348?s=20

    Looks at Wales and Scotland to see how trying to rig the system works out.....

  • Peter_the_PunterPeter_the_Punter Posts: 15,648
    rcs1000 said:

    viewcode said:

    The Rallings and Thrasher NEV early Friday morning and Parliament projected from that vote


    • REF 284 seats (27% of vote)
    • LAB 110 seats (15% of vote)
    • CON 96 seats (20% of vote)
    • LIB 80 seats (14% of vote)
    • SNP 36 (? of vote)
    • PCU 13 (? of vote)
    • GRE 13 (14% of vote)
    https://news.sky.com/story/english-council-elections-what-the-results-so-far-are-telling-us-in-maps-and-charts-13541348
    Something for everyone to be little bit unhappy about.
    That's true.

    Reform underperformed, Labour and Tories suffered huge losses, LDs failed to capitalise, and the Greens will also be disappointed with their return.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 79,488

    This is the obvious thing to do if you wanted to stop fascism. But they don’t.

    https://x.com/PhilipProudfoot/status/2052818798290370910?s=20

    There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK

    https://x.com/tnewtondunn/status/2052802123671220348?s=20

    Looks at Wales and Scotland to see how trying to rig the system works out.....

    If anything, I would have thought List PR would be more likely to put Reform into government. It would benefit them enormously in terms of seats and momentum. Yes, they would have to form a coalition but they would be doing so from a position of strength while under FPTP it's likely they would still be doing so from a position of weakness.

    To block Reform AV would be a better choice (and I'm hoping TSE is still asleep and doesn't read that...)
  • MexicanpeteMexicanpete Posts: 39,733

    rcs1000 said:

    viewcode said:

    The Rallings and Thrasher NEV early Friday morning and Parliament projected from that vote


    • REF 284 seats (27% of vote)
    • LAB 110 seats (15% of vote)
    • CON 96 seats (20% of vote)
    • LIB 80 seats (14% of vote)
    • SNP 36 (? of vote)
    • PCU 13 (? of vote)
    • GRE 13 (14% of vote)
    https://news.sky.com/story/english-council-elections-what-the-results-so-far-are-telling-us-in-maps-and-charts-13541348
    Something for everyone to be little bit unhappy about.
    That's true.

    Reform underperformed, Labour and Tories suffered huge losses, LDs failed to capitalise, and the Greens will also be disappointed with their return.
    And I am not sure how, but the big winner through the smoke and mirrors of catastrophic defeat would seem to be Kemi Badenoch.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949
    edited May 9
    ydoethur said:

    This is the obvious thing to do if you wanted to stop fascism. But they don’t.

    https://x.com/PhilipProudfoot/status/2052818798290370910?s=20

    There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK

    https://x.com/tnewtondunn/status/2052802123671220348?s=20

    Looks at Wales and Scotland to see how trying to rig the system works out.....

    If anything, I would have thought List PR would be more likely to put Reform into government. It would benefit them enormously in terms of seats and momentum. Yes, they would have to form a coalition but they would be doing so from a position of strength while under FPTP it's likely they would still be doing so from a position of weakness.

    To block Reform AV would be a better choice (and I'm hoping TSE is still asleep and doesn't read that...)
    The Vote for 16 year olds probably already going to backfire for Labour.
  • RogerRoger Posts: 23,124
    edited May 9
    Strange that Kemi has avoided the flak. The once mighty Tories have not only had the worst day of all the parties and are clearly going backwards but under her leadership are the ones most certain not to be in contention for anything in 2028-9.

    Perhaps the newshounds are giving SKS a going over before they turn their guns on her? Surely her chances of surviving the year as leader must be very slim indeed?
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 66,561
    Penddu2 said:

    The Senedd arithmetic means that Plaid > (Reform & Cons). Green would probably back Plaid in most votes, and single LD wont make a difference - so in majority of votes, it all comes down to Labour.

    As kingmakers they can either actively support Plaid (and be accused of propping up Plaid) - or actively support Reform (and be accused of worse). So expect a series of tactical abstensions.

    FIRST DECISIONS:
    1. Election of Llywydd (Presiding Officer) & Deputy

    Reform have said they expect this role (as official opposition) but there is no precedent for this and I expect Plaid & Labour to work together to block this as it would lead to chaos (simply due to inexperience).

    Instead I expect Llywydd to be Huw Irranca Davies (Labour) and Deputy maybe Peter Fox (Conservative). Old hands who should be able to control Senedd business. And maintaining party balance (or voting bloc balance).

    2. Election of First Minister

    Plaid will nominate Rhun ap Iorwerth - who will probably be backed by Green - giving 45 votes. Not a majority.

    Reform will nominate Dan Thomas. He might get Conservative support - giving 41 votes - but more likely Conservatives will not support at this stage.

    Other parties will go through motions of nominating their own leaders who will all fall way short. Votes then repeated - Labour will abstain and so Rhun will be elected

    Then tge fun begins

    I think the maths is such that Plaid can effectively govern as a minority, maybe with a side deal with the Greens.

    All the other parties will rarely agree to unite to knock it down. They are just too different and dispersed.

    So it'll only be on totemic stuff or budgets, if that.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949
    edited May 9
    Roger said:

    Strange that Kemi has avoided the flak. The once mighty Tories have not only had the worst day of all the parties and are clearly going backwards but the Tories under her leadership is the one most certain not to be in contention for anything in 2028-9.

    Perhaps the newshounds are giving SKS a going over before they turn their guns on her? Surely her chances of surviving the year as leader must be very slim indeed?

    I think she gets to live on until next local elections because same problem as Labour, who is up to the job and actually wants to do it. Also with the tetonic plates shifting under Labour, I presume the Tories will want to know who they are actually going to be up against come the GE. If they get another spanking in the locals in a years time, this time in much more shire heavy locals, then all the "I am turning around the titanic" narrative will be done for.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 79,488

    ydoethur said:

    This is the obvious thing to do if you wanted to stop fascism. But they don’t.

    https://x.com/PhilipProudfoot/status/2052818798290370910?s=20

    There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK

    https://x.com/tnewtondunn/status/2052802123671220348?s=20

    Looks at Wales and Scotland to see how trying to rig the system works out.....

    If anything, I would have thought List PR would be more likely to put Reform into government. It would benefit them enormously in terms of seats and momentum. Yes, they would have to form a coalition but they would be doing so from a position of strength while under FPTP it's likely they would still be doing so from a position of weakness.

    To block Reform AV would be a better choice (and I'm hoping TSE is still asleep and doesn't read that...)
    The Vote for 16 year olds probably already going to backfire for Labour.
    Well, they haven't enacted it yet and teenagers don't vote anyway, so I'm not sure I agree.

    But if they do any other changes I think it will be to the Lords rather than the electoral system.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949
    edited May 9
    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    This is the obvious thing to do if you wanted to stop fascism. But they don’t.

    https://x.com/PhilipProudfoot/status/2052818798290370910?s=20

    There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK

    https://x.com/tnewtondunn/status/2052802123671220348?s=20

    Looks at Wales and Scotland to see how trying to rig the system works out.....

    If anything, I would have thought List PR would be more likely to put Reform into government. It would benefit them enormously in terms of seats and momentum. Yes, they would have to form a coalition but they would be doing so from a position of strength while under FPTP it's likely they would still be doing so from a position of weakness.

    To block Reform AV would be a better choice (and I'm hoping TSE is still asleep and doesn't read that...)
    The Vote for 16 year olds probably already going to backfire for Labour.
    Well, they haven't enacted it yet and teenagers don't vote anyway, so I'm not sure I agree.

    But if they do any other changes I think it will be to the Lords rather than the electoral system.
    I thought they had passed the legislation, no? I didn't realise until yesterday they hadn't even passed the Hillsborough law yet and obviously stuff like assisted dying got totally bogged down, they are literally getting f##k all done, even stuff that should be easy for them with such a massive majority.
  • Alasdair_Alasdair_ Posts: 22

    This is the obvious thing to do if you wanted to stop fascism. But they don’t.

    https://x.com/PhilipProudfoot/status/2052818798290370910?s=20

    There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK

    https://x.com/tnewtondunn/status/2052802123671220348?s=20

    Looks at Wales and Scotland to see how trying to rig the system works out.....

    PR Now ! FPTP is unsuitable for multi-party elections.
  • Peter_the_PunterPeter_the_Punter Posts: 15,648

    rcs1000 said:

    viewcode said:

    The Rallings and Thrasher NEV early Friday morning and Parliament projected from that vote


    • REF 284 seats (27% of vote)
    • LAB 110 seats (15% of vote)
    • CON 96 seats (20% of vote)
    • LIB 80 seats (14% of vote)
    • SNP 36 (? of vote)
    • PCU 13 (? of vote)
    • GRE 13 (14% of vote)
    https://news.sky.com/story/english-council-elections-what-the-results-so-far-are-telling-us-in-maps-and-charts-13541348
    Something for everyone to be little bit unhappy about.
    That's true.

    Reform underperformed, Labour and Tories suffered huge losses, LDs failed to capitalise, and the Greens will also be disappointed with their return.
    And I am not sure how, but the big winner through the smoke and mirrors of catastrophic defeat would seem to be Kemi Badenoch.
    Yes, only the Tories can claim to have beaten expectations, despite the losses.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 79,488

    Penddu2 said:

    The Senedd arithmetic means that Plaid > (Reform & Cons). Green would probably back Plaid in most votes, and single LD wont make a difference - so in majority of votes, it all comes down to Labour.

    As kingmakers they can either actively support Plaid (and be accused of propping up Plaid) - or actively support Reform (and be accused of worse). So expect a series of tactical abstensions.

    FIRST DECISIONS:
    1. Election of Llywydd (Presiding Officer) & Deputy

    Reform have said they expect this role (as official opposition) but there is no precedent for this and I expect Plaid & Labour to work together to block this as it would lead to chaos (simply due to inexperience).

    Instead I expect Llywydd to be Huw Irranca Davies (Labour) and Deputy maybe Peter Fox (Conservative). Old hands who should be able to control Senedd business. And maintaining party balance (or voting bloc balance).

    2. Election of First Minister

    Plaid will nominate Rhun ap Iorwerth - who will probably be backed by Green - giving 45 votes. Not a majority.

    Reform will nominate Dan Thomas. He might get Conservative support - giving 41 votes - but more likely Conservatives will not support at this stage.

    Other parties will go through motions of nominating their own leaders who will all fall way short. Votes then repeated - Labour will abstain and so Rhun will be elected

    Then tge fun begins

    I think the maths is such that Plaid can effectively govern as a minority, maybe with a side deal with the Greens.

    All the other parties will rarely agree to unite to knock it down. They are just too different and dispersed.

    So it'll only be on totemic stuff or budgets, if that.
    Labour only has to abstain on key votes for a Plaid/Green confidence and supply arrangement to be pretty comfortable. If both the Llywydd and the Dirprwy are from the opposition - say, Huw Irranca-Davies and Jane Dodds - the maths looks even better. I don't think Plaid will want to enter a formal coalition if they can avoid it as the other parties are too openly sectional and their first goal is (or should be ) to show they can reach beyond their Welsh-speaking heartlands and govern for all of Wales.

    Rhun ap Iorwerth has had pretty much the best result he could hope for and actually Plaid are the one party who should be absolutely ecstatic.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949
    Most Labour members think Starmer cannot revive party fortunes, poll finds

    Exclusive: Mayor of Greater Manchester Andy Burnham is preferred choice of new leader for 42% of those surveyed

    https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2026/may/09/labour-members-keir-starmer-party-fortunes-poll
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 79,488

    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    This is the obvious thing to do if you wanted to stop fascism. But they don’t.

    https://x.com/PhilipProudfoot/status/2052818798290370910?s=20

    There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK

    https://x.com/tnewtondunn/status/2052802123671220348?s=20

    Looks at Wales and Scotland to see how trying to rig the system works out.....

    If anything, I would have thought List PR would be more likely to put Reform into government. It would benefit them enormously in terms of seats and momentum. Yes, they would have to form a coalition but they would be doing so from a position of strength while under FPTP it's likely they would still be doing so from a position of weakness.

    To block Reform AV would be a better choice (and I'm hoping TSE is still asleep and doesn't read that...)
    The Vote for 16 year olds probably already going to backfire for Labour.
    Well, they haven't enacted it yet and teenagers don't vote anyway, so I'm not sure I agree.

    But if they do any other changes I think it will be to the Lords rather than the electoral system.
    I thought they had passed the legislation, no? I didn't realise until yesterday they hadn't even passed the Hillsborough law yet and obviously stuff like assisted dying got totally bogged down, they are literally getting f##k all done, even stuff that should be easy for them with such a massive majority.
    They only put the bill forward two months ago, never mind passed it!
  • BattlebusBattlebus Posts: 3,238
    Morning all. New teal-coloured dawn down here. We've switched from 32/50 seats for Labour/Conservatives to .....4/50. The peasants have revolted. Now looking forward to have the potholes fixed; social care well financed; bins emptied; and excellence in education,

    Or maybe not.
  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 36,323

    This is the obvious thing to do if you wanted to stop fascism. But they don’t.

    https://x.com/PhilipProudfoot/status/2052818798290370910?s=20

    There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK

    https://x.com/tnewtondunn/status/2052802123671220348?s=20

    Looks at Wales and Scotland to see how trying to rig the system works out.....

    That analysis rather begs the question. In particular, this part: "The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority..."

    Are LibDems on the left? They entered a coalition with the Conservatives within living memory. If the LibDems are properly classified as centre-right, then does ‘the left’ have a majority?

    We can ask the same question of the Greens. Some greens want the environment preserved in aspic, or even turned back to some golden age by rewilding and general NIMBYism. Sounds a bit small-c conservative. And what of their new-found Middle East wing? A touch of extreme social conservatism there.

    So if the Greens and LibDems are not part of it, where is the author's claimed PR majority for ‘the left’?

    Frankly it would be more convincing to take the economically left parts of Reform's support. Reform is NOTA, regardless of what Tory retreads and Brexiteers think. A large number of their voters come from the economically disadvantaged who would traditionally support Labour. At least that would suggest TND had thought about the issue.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 60,371
    Roger said:

    Strange that Kemi has avoided the flak. The once mighty Tories have not only had the worst day of all the parties and are clearly going backwards but under her leadership are the ones most certain not to be in contention for anything in 2028-9.

    Perhaps the newshounds are giving SKS a going over before they turn their guns on her? Surely her chances of surviving the year as leader must be very slim indeed?

    Worst day of all parties? Labour lost c.58% of the seats it was defending. Conservatives lost c.42% of the seats they were defending.

    And Labour lost its hegemony in Wales.

    Kemi had a bad day. Starmer had a far worse one.

  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 36,323
    ydoethur said:

    Penddu2 said:

    The Senedd arithmetic means that Plaid > (Reform & Cons). Green would probably back Plaid in most votes, and single LD wont make a difference - so in majority of votes, it all comes down to Labour.

    As kingmakers they can either actively support Plaid (and be accused of propping up Plaid) - or actively support Reform (and be accused of worse). So expect a series of tactical abstensions.

    FIRST DECISIONS:
    1. Election of Llywydd (Presiding Officer) & Deputy

    Reform have said they expect this role (as official opposition) but there is no precedent for this and I expect Plaid & Labour to work together to block this as it would lead to chaos (simply due to inexperience).

    Instead I expect Llywydd to be Huw Irranca Davies (Labour) and Deputy maybe Peter Fox (Conservative). Old hands who should be able to control Senedd business. And maintaining party balance (or voting bloc balance).

    2. Election of First Minister

    Plaid will nominate Rhun ap Iorwerth - who will probably be backed by Green - giving 45 votes. Not a majority.

    Reform will nominate Dan Thomas. He might get Conservative support - giving 41 votes - but more likely Conservatives will not support at this stage.

    Other parties will go through motions of nominating their own leaders who will all fall way short. Votes then repeated - Labour will abstain and so Rhun will be elected

    Then tge fun begins

    I think the maths is such that Plaid can effectively govern as a minority, maybe with a side deal with the Greens.

    All the other parties will rarely agree to unite to knock it down. They are just too different and dispersed.

    So it'll only be on totemic stuff or budgets, if that.
    Labour only has to abstain on key votes for a Plaid/Green confidence and supply arrangement to be pretty comfortable. If both the Llywydd and the Dirprwy are from the opposition - say, Huw Irranca-Davies and Jane Dodds - the maths looks even better. I don't think Plaid will want to enter a formal coalition if they can avoid it as the other parties are too openly sectional and their first goal is (or should be ) to show they can reach beyond their Welsh-speaking heartlands and govern for all of Wales.

    Rhun ap Iorwerth has had pretty much the best result he could hope for and actually Plaid are the one party who should be absolutely ecstatic.
    Otoh maybe Plaid's goal should be to ram through as much Welsh nationalism as possible while they've got the chance. And remember, most of their members believe the population will love it once freed from English oppression. Win-win.
  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 63,925
    Good morning, everyone.

    Ramming through PR, disregarding buggering the electoral system for partisan advantage, would be absolutely the last thing to do if you wanted to stop Reform.

    There's a strong anti-Reform sentiment among many people, but they also have relatively high levels of support. Tactical voting is way harder with PR. Coalition is near certain. Reform could easily end up with most seats.
  • MattWMattW Posts: 33,475
    edited May 9
    We have our first Reform UK Defenestrato of this cohort.

    Farage has got around to expelling The Holocaust Denying One, Jay Leslie Cooper elected for Bootle West, in Sefton. He was told a fortnight ago, but did nothing until he was elected and the media started asking questions. It's a tricky one to combine with reaching out to the Jewish community.

    JLC stated on Facebook last year of Hitler: "I don’t agree with him murdering innocent people. But the Hallocaust [sic] is a hoax. There wasn’t [sic] even 6 million Jews in Europe at the time. Propaganda.”, amongst a lot of conspiracy theories.

    https://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/nigel-farage-says-new-merseyside-33915457
    https://www.jewishnews.co.uk/reform-uk-face-questions-after-holocaust-is-a-hoax-candidate-elected/

    I'm sure we were informed on good authority earlier that Ref UK are not a far-right party. I'd suggest it is more like a fruitcake, with all kinds of fruit and nuts in it with a full range from Grumpy Labour to neo-Nazis.

    I sure hope Farage has a pre-printed supply of "a few bad apples always get through the world class vetting system" press releases.
  • Dura_AceDura_Ace Posts: 15,624
    edited May 9

    Roger said:

    Strange that Kemi has avoided the flak. The once mighty Tories have not only had the worst day of all the parties and are clearly going backwards but the Tories under her leadership is the one most certain not to be in contention for anything in 2028-9.

    Perhaps the newshounds are giving SKS a going over before they turn their guns on her? Surely her chances of surviving the year as leader must be very slim indeed?

    I think she gets to live on until next local elections because same problem as Labour, who is up to the job and actually wants to do it. Also with the tetonic plates shifting under Labour, I presume the Tories will want to know who they are actually going to be up against come the GE. If they get another spanking in the locals in a years time, this time in much more shire heavy locals, then all the "I am turning around the titanic" narrative will be done for.
    The Kemical Weapon has proved surprisingly durable. If only she were 20-30% less black, she might actually have a shot at being PM.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 81,137

    ydoethur said:

    ydoethur said:

    This is the obvious thing to do if you wanted to stop fascism. But they don’t.

    https://x.com/PhilipProudfoot/status/2052818798290370910?s=20

    There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK

    https://x.com/tnewtondunn/status/2052802123671220348?s=20

    Looks at Wales and Scotland to see how trying to rig the system works out.....

    If anything, I would have thought List PR would be more likely to put Reform into government. It would benefit them enormously in terms of seats and momentum. Yes, they would have to form a coalition but they would be doing so from a position of strength while under FPTP it's likely they would still be doing so from a position of weakness.

    To block Reform AV would be a better choice (and I'm hoping TSE is still asleep and doesn't read that...)
    The Vote for 16 year olds probably already going to backfire for Labour.
    Well, they haven't enacted it yet and teenagers don't vote anyway, so I'm not sure I agree.

    But if they do any other changes I think it will be to the Lords rather than the electoral system.
    I thought they had passed the legislation, no? I didn't realise until yesterday they hadn't even passed the Hillsborough law yet and obviously stuff like assisted dying got totally bogged down, they are literally getting f##k all done, even stuff that should be easy for them with such a massive majority.
    Like the arse end of Sunak's ministry
  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 63,925
    F1: signs your engine regs are rather shit:
    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/formula1/articles/c8jvee3x3wro

    Team bosses agree to changes for 2027. They'll need more substantial changes later, I think. Totally shit the bed with current rules.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949

    Roger said:

    Strange that Kemi has avoided the flak. The once mighty Tories have not only had the worst day of all the parties and are clearly going backwards but under her leadership are the ones most certain not to be in contention for anything in 2028-9.

    Perhaps the newshounds are giving SKS a going over before they turn their guns on her? Surely her chances of surviving the year as leader must be very slim indeed?

    Worst day of all parties? Labour lost c.58% of the seats it was defending. Conservatives lost c.42% of the seats they were defending.

    And Labour lost its hegemony in Wales.

    Kemi had a bad day. Starmer had a far worse one.

    Given I heard nothing of Magic Grandpa's YourParty winning anything, they clearly also smashed it.
  • FeersumEnjineeyaFeersumEnjineeya Posts: 5,314
    Pulpstar said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Birmingham council final seat is provisionally 1 worker, 1 rfm pending a Monday recount

    Possible coalitions are Tory, Rfm, LD or Lab, Green, LD and some indies
    There is no way the LDs will work with Reform, and working with most of the Indies is also a pretty big ask.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 91,949
    Clive Betts has become the latest Labour MP to call for Keir Starmer to resign
  • RogerRoger Posts: 23,124
    Starmer is a coward. A Jobsworth. It's been obvious since he went on his Farage tribute act six months ago and appointed Mahmood and started curbing the use of innocuous slogans that he was finished.

    Very decent Labour supporters who were not 'anti anything' became infuriated. Watching 80 year old women pastors being dragged into police vans became the norm and Starmer's Britain became a very grim place indeed. He was unlucky only in the sense that The Greens turned up and reminded then what a middle of the road Party which didn't hate immigrants could look like.
  • MattWMattW Posts: 33,475
    Does anyone have a link to a list of all Councils elected and majorities therein, for all parties?

    I can't find anywhere with information that detailed.
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 25,447
    Another area where the Tories have suffered (albeit from a low base) is Lancashire towns beginning with B:

    Bury - wiped out
    Burnley - wiped out
    Blackburn - wiped out
    Bolton - lost half their seats

  • DecrepiterJohnLDecrepiterJohnL Posts: 36,323
    MattW said:

    Does anyone have a link to a list of all Councils elected and majorities therein, for all parties?

    I can't find anywhere with information that detailed.

    Give it a couple of days. Many results are yet to be announced.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 56,826

    Roger said:

    Strange that Kemi has avoided the flak. The once mighty Tories have not only had the worst day of all the parties and are clearly going backwards but under her leadership are the ones most certain not to be in contention for anything in 2028-9.

    Perhaps the newshounds are giving SKS a going over before they turn their guns on her? Surely her chances of surviving the year as leader must be very slim indeed?

    Worst day of all parties? Labour lost c.58% of the seats it was defending. Conservatives lost c.42% of the seats they were defending.

    And Labour lost its hegemony in Wales.

    Kemi had a bad day. Starmer had a far worse one.

    When we look at council byelections the Tory vote often holds up better at local level than national polling. To a greater degree than other parties voters make a distinction between Tory local government than national.

    Add in that the Opposition should be making sweeping gains at this time in the Parliamentary cycle and things look very grim for the Tories in England. Scotland and Wales look even worse.

    Birmingham Council is the one to watch. That is the sort of result that Parliament will have in 2029. Try to form a government from that!
  • RogerRoger Posts: 23,124
    Dura_Ace said:

    Roger said:

    Strange that Kemi has avoided the flak. The once mighty Tories have not only had the worst day of all the parties and are clearly going backwards but the Tories under her leadership is the one most certain not to be in contention for anything in 2028-9.

    Perhaps the newshounds are giving SKS a going over before they turn their guns on her? Surely her chances of surviving the year as leader must be very slim indeed?

    I think she gets to live on until next local elections because same problem as Labour, who is up to the job and actually wants to do it. Also with the tetonic plates shifting under Labour, I presume the Tories will want to know who they are actually going to be up against come the GE. If they get another spanking in the locals in a years time, this time in much more shire heavy locals, then all the "I am turning around the titanic" narrative will be done for.
    The Kemical Weapon has proved surprisingly durable. If only she were 20-30% less black, she might actually have a shot at being PM.
    If she found herself a sense of humour and stopped reminding everyone of their least favourite headmistress I don't think anyone would care less what Pantone she was using
  • FishingFishing Posts: 6,355
    edited May 9

    ydoethur said:

    This is the obvious thing to do if you wanted to stop fascism. But they don’t.

    https://x.com/PhilipProudfoot/status/2052818798290370910?s=20

    There is an escape route for Labour from certain disaster at the general election: use their Commons majority to ram through PR. It’s cynical, + they’d never govern alone again, but it locks Reform out of No10. The left (Lab, Gr, LD) still have a majority over the right in the UK

    https://x.com/tnewtondunn/status/2052802123671220348?s=20

    Looks at Wales and Scotland to see how trying to rig the system works out.....

    If anything, I would have thought List PR would be more likely to put Reform into government. It would benefit them enormously in terms of seats and momentum. Yes, they would have to form a coalition but they would be doing so from a position of strength while under FPTP it's likely they would still be doing so from a position of weakness.

    To block Reform AV would be a better choice (and I'm hoping TSE is still asleep and doesn't read that...)
    The Vote for 16 year olds probably already going to backfire for Labour.
    See Thomas Chester on youtube if you want an insight into the mind of a coherent and articulate 17-year-old Restore supporter. Here are his local election projections:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gECL5zECMk

    Sir John Curtice doesn't need to be too worried just yet ...

    Makes me glad they didn't have youtube or twitter when I was 17 or God knows what would be out there on me.
  • bondegezoubondegezou Posts: 20,916
    What’s the lowest winning percentage? The Greens won a Birmingham ward on 20.5%.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 66,561

    Another area where the Tories have suffered (albeit from a low base) is Lancashire towns beginning with B:

    Bury - wiped out
    Burnley - wiped out
    Blackburn - wiped out
    Bolton - lost half their seats

    Yes, which is a problem for forming a majority government again.
This discussion has been closed.