Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » The Pandemic – some of this afternoon’s developments

SystemSystem Posts: 12,169
edited April 2020 in General

imagepoliticalbetting.com » Blog Archive » The Pandemic – some of this afternoon’s developments

We have just released new bookings for thousands more home testing kits. ?There is also availability to book a test for tomorrow across our network of regional testing sites. ?Check eligibility and book online now ??https://t.co/LmhXHg0tmR

Read the full story here


«134

Comments

  • MattWMattW Posts: 23,250
    edited April 2020
    First

    Looking at those last graphs, it appears to behave like slugs.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 59,935
    How long does it last on pineapple pizza?
  • MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,708
    Surely someone must ask about Test 5.

    Raab said in his intro that it is the critical test - but he has changed it and nobody has noticed.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,676
    The new numbers from CareHomes only include those that died that had been tested apparently not like ONS that has tested and untested deaths
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    FPT

    TGOHF666 said:

    52,400 tests yesterday.

    Now if only Hancock had promised 50k....
    Then we'd have probably just hit 25k yesterday ...
  • TGOHF666TGOHF666 Posts: 2,052
    Death Rigby a wee ray of sunshine as ever.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,222
    MikeL said:

    Surely someone must ask about Test 5.

    Raab said in his intro that it is the critical test - but he has changed it and nobody has noticed.

    "It would be an unnecessary distraction to speculate..."
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 62,766
    RobD said:

    How long does it last on pineapple pizza?

    It was deemed unethical by the ethics committee to undertake that test.
  • MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,708
    edited April 2020
    Rigby question made no sense - implied the peak had not yet been reached.

    Total deaths by date of report does show 7 day rolling average is falling to some degree.

    Question implies she hasn't seen / understood the slide.
  • ABZABZ Posts: 441

    The new numbers from CareHomes only include those that died that had been tested apparently not like ONS that has tested and untested deaths

    As the Deputy CMO stated: the only meaningful measure is excess mortality -- all of the raw number comparisons are confounded by how data are measured.
  • FlatlanderFlatlander Posts: 4,681
    MikeL said:

    Surely someone must ask about Test 5.

    Raab said in his intro that it is the critical test - but he has changed it and nobody has noticed.

    To be fair, I think the original test was meant to imply what it states specifically now. That's certainly how I read it.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,421
    Oh really, the BBC are just hopeless:

    Boris Johnson and Carrie Symonds announce birth of son https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-52469079

    Mr Johnson, 55, and Ms Symonds, 32, announced in March that they were expecting a baby in "early summer", and that they had become engaged at the end of last year.
    They are the first unmarried couple to move into Downing Street together.


    An exasperated David Lloyd George and Frances Stevenson wave hello.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,119
    MikeL said:

    Rigby question made no sense - implied the peak had not yet been reached.

    Total deaths by date of report does show 7 day rolling average is falling to some degree.

    Question implies she hasn't seen / understoood the slide.

    Well Prof Cricket had to educate Faisal Islam yesterday re the stats on the twitters and he was once a bloody economics editor.
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 48,720
    There seems to be a change in how the figures are calculated, not sure if national or local.

    Leicester now 484 discharged, 211 deaths, so inpatient mortality now a lower percentage, though still grim.
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 62,766
    Tim W been reading the Israeli professor's hypothesis?
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139
    eadric said:

    Keep an eye on Mexico. She’s quietly coming up on the inside.

    1569 deaths now, and rising fast: another 135 today

    Could be another Ecuador, but worse

    Global death rate per million 28, Mexico death rate per million 12

    https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 51,878
    HYUFD said:
    A bit premature to celebrate Victory over Epidemic Day?
  • rpjsrpjs Posts: 3,787
    HYUFD said:
    What about "Yes, so long as it's called 'Europe Day'"?
  • Tim_BTim_B Posts: 7,669
    ydoethur said:

    Oh really, the BBC are just hopeless:

    Boris Johnson and Carrie Symonds announce birth of son https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-52469079

    Mr Johnson, 55, and Ms Symonds, 32, announced in March that they were expecting a baby in "early summer", and that they had become engaged at the end of last year.
    They are the first unmarried couple to move into Downing Street together.


    An exasperated David Lloyd George and Frances Stevenson wave hello.

    What came to my mind was the time, back when Harold Wilson was prime minister, that he launched a campaign to attract more female party members. The headline was "Wilson to get 20,000 women in Labour".
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,421
    Tim_B said:

    ydoethur said:

    Oh really, the BBC are just hopeless:

    Boris Johnson and Carrie Symonds announce birth of son https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-52469079

    Mr Johnson, 55, and Ms Symonds, 32, announced in March that they were expecting a baby in "early summer", and that they had become engaged at the end of last year.
    They are the first unmarried couple to move into Downing Street together.


    An exasperated David Lloyd George and Frances Stevenson wave hello.

    What came to my mind was the time, back when Harold Wilson was prime minister, that he launched a campaign to attract more female party members. The headline was "Wilson to get 20,000 women in Labour".
    Blimey.

    I thought it was just the one he went chasing after.
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 50,370

    MikeL said:

    Rigby question made no sense - implied the peak had not yet been reached.

    Total deaths by date of report does show 7 day rolling average is falling to some degree.

    Question implies she hasn't seen / understoood the slide.

    Well Prof Cricket had to educate Faisal Islam yesterday re the stats on the twitters and he was once a bloody economics editor.
    Expecting the press reporting on a matter involving maths, to understand basic maths is fascism.

    Please cancel yourself.
  • TimTTimT Posts: 6,468
    Wow! The Economist has been extraordinarily slow to pick up on the NEJM paper. The results have been out for well over a month.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 51,878
    TimT said:

    Wow! The Economist has been extraordinarily slow to pick up on the NEJM paper. The results have been out for well over a month.

    I thought cardboard was safe after 24 hrs - looks more like 48 hrs?
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,608
    MikeL said:

    Rigby question made no sense - implied the peak had not yet been reached.

    Total deaths by date of report does show 7 day rolling average is falling to some degree.

    Question implies she hasn't seen / understood the slide.

    How surprising.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,608
    rpjs said:

    HYUFD said:
    What about "Yes, so long as it's called 'Europe Day'"?
    Statistically the same as zero.
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818
    edited April 2020
    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 59,935

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Even without a lockdown people are still not going to travel.
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818
    edited April 2020
    RobD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Even without a lockdown people are still not going to travel.
    I know that. Chances of reemployment anywhere?
  • TGOHF666TGOHF666 Posts: 2,052

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Not sure there is much demand for flights to locked down countries around the world.

    LHR to Stockholm ?

  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    @BigRich do you have a source for Sweden having a very broad corona virus death definition? As far as I can see they only include lab confirmed cases in their numbers.
  • justin124justin124 Posts: 11,527
    ydoethur said:

    Oh really, the BBC are just hopeless:

    Boris Johnson and Carrie Symonds announce birth of son https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-52469079

    Mr Johnson, 55, and Ms Symonds, 32, announced in March that they were expecting a baby in "early summer", and that they had become engaged at the end of last year.
    They are the first unmarried couple to move into Downing Street together.


    An exasperated David Lloyd George and Frances Stevenson wave hello.

    But Margaret Lloyd George did appear in Downing Street from time to time. Stevenson was kept out of view much of the time.
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,676
    TBF to the Government, including those Care Home deaths where people have died after testing positive is the right thing to do.

    I suspect the resultant death figures will draw extra criticism from many but excluding them was no longer tenable.

    It brings us in to line with France but now out of step with Italy.
  • TimTTimT Posts: 6,468

    TimT said:

    Wow! The Economist has been extraordinarily slow to pick up on the NEJM paper. The results have been out for well over a month.

    I thought cardboard was safe after 24 hrs - looks more like 48 hrs?
    Yep, I'd heard 24 hours previously. Maybe they are making a distinction between limit of detection and safe?
  • EndillionEndillion Posts: 4,976
    MikeL said:

    Rigby question made no sense - implied the peak had not yet been reached.

    Total deaths by date of report does show 7 day rolling average is falling to some degree.

    Question implies she hasn't seen / understood the slide.

    The reporting peak was today, because this was the first time the government has included non-hospital deaths in the figures.

    It's not in the national interest to have more than one metric, because that would make journalists' heads explode.
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139
    edited April 2020
    eadric said:

    Mexico is pretty much the perfect combination of mobile population, chaotic health care, rampant crime and corruption, weak state control, bad air pollution, and dire poverty.

    Eg Mexico City could be NYC multiplied.

    They must hope their younger population protects them

    Possibly and percentage over 70 and over 80 remains the key indicator of death rate but still though Mexico is slightly above global life expectancy of 73 at 75.

    https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/

    https://www.worldometers.info/demographics/life-expectancy/
  • TGOHF666TGOHF666 Posts: 2,052

    TBF to the Government, including those Care Home deaths where people have died after testing positive is the right thing to do.

    I suspect the resultant death figures will draw extra criticism from many but excluding them was no longer tenable.

    It brings us in to line with France but now out of step with Italy.

    Interesting point from the lady on the RHS lectern - in care homes there is limited time between symptoms to critical to perform a test.
  • another_richardanother_richard Posts: 26,620

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    How many extra deaths would you accept to end lockdown ?
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Lockdown isn't needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life. In all walks of life we are seeing jobs going into stasis via the furlough scheme - without the furlough scheme if we'd taken a complete laissez-faire approach (which is normally what I'd 100% support but this is a once-in-a-century pandemic) then far more would have been sacked already.

    Once lockdown ends and furlough ends then hopefully the economy can recover quickly. But with or without a lockdown there is economic carnage and lay-offs either way as people lockdown of their own initiative without any support since its not official.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139
    edited April 2020

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    How many extra deaths would you accept to end lockdown ?
    Under 50s have a less than 0.5% death rate from Covid, now we are passed the peak most of the workforce can get back to work with no likely significant rise in deathrate.

    Just get mass testing up and advise over 70s to stay indoors unless absolutely necessary to travel or go outside
  • another_richardanother_richard Posts: 26,620
    A question about Rt.

    What is the timescale used ? Is it one week or two or something else ?

    Because if we assume Rt is 0.75 then 3 time periods would see the number of infected reduced to 42% of the original whereas 6 time periods would see it reduced to 18%.
  • So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    So Germany seeing Lufthansa considering bankruptcy as bailout stalls, Scandinavian airline SAS cut 5,000 jobs, and US airlines in deep trouble are all because of our lockdown
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    Its worth noting that in America before statewide lockdowns were announced millions were already added to the unemployment rolls.

    Any idea that economic carnage now would be avoided without a lockdown is completely farcical. As is any idea that any government borrowing now (for a once-in-a-century pandemic) would cripple the government expenditure, that is also economically illiterate.
  • So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
  • ABZABZ Posts: 441
    For those interested, this is the first day the positive tests for critical / essential workers has exceeded the number of positives for individuals tested due to an urgent medical need. The latter number, even given the many additional tests, is lower than at any point since just after the lockdown and, as a percentage of the number of tests, is now much lower.
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,675

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Lockdown isn't needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life. In all walks of life we are seeing jobs going into stasis via the furlough scheme - without
    the furlough scheme if we'd taken a complete laissez-faire approach (which is normally what I'd 100% support but this is a once-in-a-century pandemic)
    then far more would have been sacked already.

    Once lockdown ends and furlough ends then hopefully the economy can recover quickly. But with or without a lockdown there is economic carnage and lay-offs either way as people lockdown of their own initiative without any support since its not official.
    There is nothing to say this is a once in a century Pandemic. There are been three outbreaks of Coronaviruses this century alone. A nasty flu could be just around the corner and Covid-20 could be a thing.

    The critical point is that we were warned about this and could have taken measures to limit economic harm.
  • HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position

    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
    Of course it is. Including in nations without a lockdown like in Sweden.

    Without an official lockdown people still take matters into their own hands and lockdown as much as they are able to do so. Without an official lockdown or furlough scheme what would have happened?

    The hospitality, travel, tourism and similar sectors would all have been devastated and gone bust as their number of customers plummeted but with zero support or furlough scheme the employees would have all lost their jobs. As has happened in other nations.

    Our unemployment numbers aren't changing as much because of the furlough scheme.
  • HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    How many extra deaths would you accept to end lockdown ?
    Under 50s have a less than 0.5% death rate from Covid, now we are passed the peak most of the workforce can get back to work with no likely significant rise in deathrate.

    Just get mass testing up and advise over 70s to stay indoors unless absolutely necessary to travel or go outside
    The Trump school of dealing with the crisis on view

  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position

    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    How many extra deaths would you accept to end lockdown ?
    Under 50s have a less than 0.5% death rate from Covid, now we are passed the peak most of the workforce can get back to work with no likely significant rise in deathrate.

    Just get mass testing up and advise over 70s to stay indoors unless absolutely necessary to travel or go outside
    The Trump school of dealing with the crisis on view

    No, the common sense view, as you are over 80 and retired you might want to stay indoors longer but for most young people in the workforce there is very little risk of dying from Covid
  • HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position

    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    At times you are so naive
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 49,868

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
    Of course it is. Including in nations without a lockdown like in Sweden.

    Without an official lockdown people still take matters into their own hands and lockdown as much as they are able to do so. Without an official lockdown or furlough scheme what would have happened?

    The hospitality, travel, tourism and similar sectors would all have been devastated and gone bust as their number of customers plummeted but with zero support or furlough scheme the employees would have all lost their jobs. As has happened in other nations.

    Our unemployment numbers aren't changing as much because of the furlough scheme.
    The US scheme has the upside that everyone gets some money to tide them over, but many self employed business have gone bankrupt and unemployment is sharply up. The UK schemes have the upside that many people have been subsidised to remain employed, but the downside that it is easy to fall between the cracks.
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,675
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position




    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    It’s not panic. It’s confidence. Will you get health insurance?
  • HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    How many extra deaths would you accept to end lockdown ?
    Under 50s have a less than 0.5% death rate from Covid, now we are passed the peak most of the workforce can get back to work with no likely significant rise in deathrate.

    Just get mass testing up and advise over 70s to stay indoors unless absolutely necessary to travel or go outside
    The Trump school of dealing with the crisis on view

    No, the common sense view, as you are over 80 and retired you might want to stay indoors longer but for most young people in the workforce there is very little risk of dying from Covid
    You are far more like Trump then you may want to admit.

    And I am not over 80
  • contrariancontrarian Posts: 5,818

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
    Oh just accept it then right?

    you can't get a job in your own industry, you can;t retrain because colleges are locked down, your prospects of a job in another industry are close to zero for years to come because lockdown has smashed every industry, you can;t even meet someone face to face to try to convince them you might be worth employing.

    This is your future. An enforced breadline existence you cannot get out of. For years. While some academic argues whether R is at one or not.

    That is what millions of moderate and low paid workers in our country face. How long do you or anybody else think we can keep the lid on that? whether Corona deaths are at twenty, fifty or even 100,000?
  • AndrewAndrew Posts: 2,900
    HYUFD said:


    Global death rate per million 28, Mexico death rate per million 12

    Basically zero testing though.
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,675
    Big G is right.

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    How many extra deaths would you accept to end lockdown ?
    Under 50s have a less than 0.5% death rate from Covid, now we are passed the peak most of the workforce can get back to work with no likely significant rise in deathrate.

    Just get mass testing up and advise over 70s to stay indoors unless absolutely necessary to travel or go outside
    The Trump school of dealing with the crisis on view




    No, the common sense view, as you are over 80 and retired you might want to stay indoors longer but for most young people in the workforce there is very little risk of dying from Covid
    You are far more like Trump then you may want to admit.

    And I am not over 80
    Big G is right on this.

  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 49,868

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position

    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    For cruising, I can see travel insurance becoming a compulsory requirement. Thereby excluding the more elderly and ill passengers who travel uninsured and rely on being helilifted off the ship when the worst happens. Which is probably a good thing.
  • squareroot2squareroot2 Posts: 6,729
    Jonathan said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Lockdown isn't needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life. In all walks of life we are seeing jobs going into stasis via the furlough scheme - without
    the furlough scheme if we'd taken a complete laissez-faire approach (which is normally what I'd 100% support but this is a once-in-a-century pandemic)
    then far more would have been sacked already.

    Once lockdown ends and furlough ends then hopefully the economy can recover quickly. But with or without a lockdown there is economic carnage and lay-offs either way as people lockdown of their own initiative without any support since its not official.
    There is nothing to say this is a once in a century Pandemic. There are been three outbreaks of Coronaviruses this century alone. A nasty flu could be just around the corner and Covid-20 could be a thing.

    The critical point is that we were warned about this and could have taken measures to limit economic harm. </blockquote
    List those measures.


    What measures?
  • So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
    Oh just accept it then right?

    you can't get a job in your own industry, you can;t retrain because colleges are locked down, your prospects of a job in another industry are close to zero for years to come because lockdown has smashed every industry, you can;t even meet someone face to face to try to convince them you might be worth employing.

    This is your future. An enforced breadline existence you cannot get out of. For years. While some academic argues whether R is at one or not.

    That is what millions of moderate and low paid workers in our country face. How long do you or anybody else think we can keep the lid on that? whether Corona deaths are at twenty, fifty or even 100,000?
    I am afraid it is what it is worldwide and governments have to plot a way through it and beyond

    Moaning is not going to change where we are
  • IanB2 said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position

    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    For cruising, I can see travel insurance becoming a compulsory requirement. Thereby excluding the more elderly and ill passengers who travel uninsured and rely on being helilifted off the ship when the worst happens. Which is probably a good thing.
    On all the cruises I have been on we had to have travel insurance confirmed before we boarded
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139
    edited April 2020
    Jonathan said:

    Big G is right.

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    How many extra deaths would you accept to end lockdown ?
    Under 50s have a less than 0.5% death rate from Covid, now we are passed the peak most of the workforce can get back to work with no likely significant rise in deathrate.

    Just get mass testing up and advise over 70s to stay indoors unless absolutely necessary to travel or go outside
    The Trump school of dealing with the crisis on view




    No, the common sense view, as you are over 80 and retired you might want to stay indoors longer but for most young people in the workforce there is very little risk of dying from Covid
    You are far more like Trump then you may want to admit.

    And I am not over 80
    Big G is right on this.

    We cannot destroy the economy and the livelihoods of the young with an indefinite lockdown now we are passed the peak. The main reason we had the lockdown in the first place was to save some over 70s and over 80s who are retired anyway, younger people cannot be expected to sacrifice even more of their wages and jobs when they have very little risk of mortality from Covid
  • RobDRobD Posts: 59,935

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
    Oh just accept it then right?

    you can't get a job in your own industry, you can;t retrain because colleges are locked down, your prospects of a job in another industry are close to zero for years to come because lockdown has smashed every industry, you can;t even meet someone face to face to try to convince them you might be worth employing.

    This is your future. An enforced breadline existence you cannot get out of. For years. While some academic argues whether R is at one or not.

    That is what millions of moderate and low paid workers in our country face. How long do you or anybody else think we can keep the lid on that? whether Corona deaths are at twenty, fifty or even 100,000?
    Ending the lockdown wouldn't change any of this.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,357
    FPT
    Carnyx said:

    » show previous quotes
    Death rate is actually pretty flat if you take the weekend effects out by looking at the 7 day average (look at the graph for New Daily Deaths Comparisons). One could just as well argue that the Scots got the death rate increase under control earlier but it's flatlining [edited]. But I don't really know!

    Someone below (can't relocate it, sorry) was claiming a double the English death rate pro rata below. But the figures are nothing like that level of difference. There is (now) a small excess over the English figure, but I don't know enough about the procedural and recording differences which could well explain it.

    You don't see too many comparisons but last one I saw had Scotland significantly lower than England per head of population but they will not really want to bandy it about much. Whether with our later peak we are catching up a bit but still about 250 per million versus England's 350 per million. This is a good site, or looks like it to me, I am sure some expert will say it is crap.
    https://www.travellingtabby.com/scotland-coronavirus-tracker/
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,357
    FPT
    Philip_Thompson said:

    » show previous quotes
    Thanks that was my guess but I wonder how a later peak has come about in Scotland and Wales given that means it must have continued growing while in lockdown? Seems like an interesting oddity.

    All those infected buggers coming up from London spreading it willy nilly.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139
    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position




    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    It’s not panic. It’s confidence. Will you get health insurance?
    If you are under 50 certainly, though the cruise industry might be hit a bit more admittedly
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,675
    There are going to be new cruise ships where you spend the whole time locked in your locked cabin, which is immediately ejected from the ship into the ocean if the onboard sensors register a temperature above 38degrees. This is the new normal.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,357
    FPT


    DougSeal said:

    » show previous quotes
    "Never include them". That pesky Westminster Government looking to hide the figures by releasing them through a that shadowy secretive body, the Office for National Statistics.

    Never change, Malc, you're a gem.

    Obfuscation, split them , show them differently etc , different graphs so no-one has a clue what real numbers are and they can pretend they are not the worst in the developed world. Tories will never change.
    Flag Quote · Off Topic Like
  • HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    Big G is right.

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    How many extra deaths would you accept to end lockdown ?
    Under 50s have a less than 0.5% death rate from Covid, now we are passed the peak most of the workforce can get back to work with no likely significant rise in deathrate.

    Just get mass testing up and advise over 70s to stay indoors unless absolutely necessary to travel or go outside
    The Trump school of dealing with the crisis on view




    No, the common sense view, as you are over 80 and retired you might want to stay indoors longer but for most young people in the workforce there is very little risk of dying from Covid
    You are far more like Trump then you may want to admit.

    And I am not over 80
    Big G is right on this.

    We cannot destroy the economy and the livelihoods of the young with an indefinite lockdown now we are passed the peak. The main reason we had the lockdown in the first place was to save over 70s and over 80s who are retired anyway, younger people cannot be expected to sacrifice even more of their wages and jobs when they have very little risk of mortality from Covid
    Whoever said an indefinite lockdown.

    I have never suggested or expected such a thing

    And you are an image of Trump in many ways
  • Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,821

    MikeL said:

    Surely someone must ask about Test 5.

    Raab said in his intro that it is the critical test - but he has changed it and nobody has noticed.

    To be fair, I think the original test was meant to imply what it states specifically now. That's certainly how I read it.
    Yes. From the Guardian live blog:

    the [Downing St] spokesman said the wording has been changed just to better reflect what Raab actually said when he set out the five tests at a press conference on 16 April. The spokesman was right. This is what Raab said in his speech at the time:

    "We need to be confident that any adjustments to the current measures will not risk a second peak of infections that overwhelm the NHS."


  • ABZABZ Posts: 441
    Not a 'knockout' but still something, especially since this is a proper RCT:

    From the FT (https://www.ft.com/content/1625275b-9981-49f4-b788-661f8243890d)

    “It doesn’t seem like a knockout . . . But it is a very important proof of concept,” Dr Fauci said in press briefing also attended by the president. “It is a very positive event,” Mr Trump said.

    Dr Fauci’s National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases has not yet released the full results of the trial of remdesivir, which has been touted as one of the most promising Covid-19 treatments. But he said they would be submitted to a medical journal and peer-reviewed.

    There was about a 31 per cent improvement in patients taking the drug compared with placebo, Dr Fauci said. Some 8 per cent of the group taking remdesivir died, compared with 11 per cent in the control group. 
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,675
    HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position




    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business


    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    It’s not panic. It’s confidence. Will you get health insurance?
    If you are under 50 certainly, though the cruise industry might be hit a bit more admittedly
    You fancy dealing with CV19 during a family holiday in Spain. Not sure I fancy it.
  • another_richardanother_richard Posts: 26,620
    edited April 2020

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
    Oh just accept it then right?

    you can't get a job in your own industry, you can;t retrain because colleges are locked down, your prospects of a job in another industry are close to zero for years to come because lockdown has smashed every industry, you can;t even meet someone face to face to try to convince them you might be worth employing.

    This is your future. An enforced breadline existence you cannot get out of. For years. While some academic argues whether R is at one or not.

    That is what millions of moderate and low paid workers in our country face. How long do you or anybody else think we can keep the lid on that? whether Corona deaths are at twenty, fifty or even 100,000?
    I am afraid it is what it is worldwide and governments have to plot a way through it and beyond

    Moaning is not going to change where we are
    He thinks if we pretend the virus doesn't exist then everything will return to 'normal'.
  • Jonathan said:

    There are going to be new cruise ships where you spend the whole time locked in your locked cabin, which is immediately ejected from the ship into the ocean if the onboard sensors register a temperature above 38degrees. This is the new normal.

    That is so funny
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,357

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
    Oh just accept it then right?

    you can't get a job in your own industry, you can;t retrain because colleges are locked down, your prospects of a job in another industry are close to zero for years to come because lockdown has smashed every industry, you can;t even meet someone face to face to try to convince them you might be worth employing.

    This is your future. An enforced breadline existence you cannot get out of. For years. While some academic argues whether R is at one or not.

    That is what millions of moderate and low paid workers in our country face. How long do you or anybody else think we can keep the lid on that? whether Corona deaths are at twenty, fifty or even 100,000?
    I am afraid it is what it is worldwide and governments have to plot a way through it and beyond

    Moaning is not going to change where we are
    Lots of fruit picking jobs, Tesco and other supermarkets hiring by the shedload.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139
    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position




    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business


    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    It’s not panic. It’s confidence. Will you get health insurance?
    If you are under 50 certainly, though the cruise industry might be hit a bit more admittedly
    You fancy dealing with CV19 during a family holiday in Spain. Not sure I fancy it.
    No difference to dealing with it at home but with warmer weather unless you need hospital treatment which is still unlikely if you are a young family or young singles
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,751

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
    Oh just accept it then right?

    you can't get a job in your own industry, you can;t retrain because colleges are locked down, your prospects of a job in another industry are close to zero for years to come because lockdown has smashed every industry, you can;t even meet someone face to face to try to convince them you might be worth employing.

    This is your future. An enforced breadline existence you cannot get out of. For years. While some academic argues whether R is at one or not.

    That is what millions of moderate and low paid workers in our country face. How long do you or anybody else think we can keep the lid on that? whether Corona deaths are at twenty, fifty or even 100,000?
    I am afraid it is what it is worldwide and governments have to plot a way through it and beyond

    Moaning is not going to change where we are
    He thinks is we pretend the virus doesn't exist then everything will return to 'normal'.
    Perhaps he thinks the virus can be destroyed if people radiate sufficiently strong entitlement.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,357

    HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    Big G is right.

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    How many extra deaths would you accept to end lockdown ?
    Under 50s have a less than 0.5% death rate from Covid, now we are passed the peak most of the workforce can get back to work with no likely significant rise in deathrate.

    Just get mass testing up and advise over 70s to stay indoors unless absolutely necessary to travel or go outside
    The Trump school of dealing with the crisis on view




    No, the common sense view, as you are over 80 and retired you might want to stay indoors longer but for most young people in the workforce there is very little risk of dying from Covid
    You are far more like Trump then you may want to admit.

    And I am not over 80
    Big G is right on this.

    We cannot destroy the economy and the livelihoods of the young with an indefinite lockdown now we are passed the peak. The main reason we had the lockdown in the first place was to save over 70s and over 80s who are retired anyway, younger people cannot be expected to sacrifice even more of their wages and jobs when they have very little risk of mortality from Covid
    Whoever said an indefinite lockdown.

    I have never suggested or expected such a thing

    And you are an image of Trump in many ways
    That is an insult to Trump G. Also passed = past if I am being pedantic about previous post.
  • another_richardanother_richard Posts: 26,620
    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position




    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business


    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    It’s not panic. It’s confidence. Will you get health insurance?
    If you are under 50 certainly, though the cruise industry might be hit a bit more admittedly
    You fancy dealing with CV19 during a family holiday in Spain. Not sure I fancy it.
    Catching it on a foreign holiday and then returning to work, infecting other people and then going off sick is also going to make you very unpopular.
  • StereotomyStereotomy Posts: 4,092

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    How many extra deaths would you accept to end lockdown ?
    Under 50s have a less than 0.5% death rate from Covid, now we are passed the peak most of the workforce can get back to work with no likely significant rise in deathrate.

    Just get mass testing up and advise over 70s to stay indoors unless absolutely necessary to travel or go outside
    The Trump school of dealing with the crisis on view

    No, the common sense view, as you are over 80 and retired you might want to stay indoors longer but for most young people in the workforce there is very little risk of dying from Covid
    You are far more like Trump then you may want to admit.

    And I am not over 80
    Even more like Ezekiel Emanuel, one of the architects of Obamacare:

    Q: What’s wrong with simply enjoying an extended life?

    A: These people who live a vigorous life to 70, 80, 90 years of age—when I look at what those people “do,” almost all of it is what I classify as play. It’s not meaningful work. They’re riding motorcycles; they’re hiking. Which can all have value—don’t get me wrong. But if it’s the main thing in your life? Ummm, that’s not probably a meaningful life.


    Part of his argument for why people over the age of 75 shouldn't get healthcare.
  • AndrewAndrew Posts: 2,900
    Germans estimating Rt back at 0.75, so the apparent bounce was seemingly just noise. Probably quite important for our policy-makers.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
    Oh just accept it then right?

    you can't get a job in your own industry, you can;t retrain because colleges are locked down, your prospects of a job in another industry are close to zero for years to come because lockdown has smashed every industry, you can;t even meet someone face to face to try to convince them you might be worth employing.

    This is your future. An enforced breadline existence you cannot get out of. For years. While some academic argues whether R is at one or not.

    That is what millions of moderate and low paid workers in our country face. How long do you or anybody else think we can keep the lid on that? whether Corona deaths are at twenty, fifty or even 100,000?
    I am afraid it is what it is worldwide and governments have to plot a way through it and beyond

    Moaning is not going to change where we are
    He thinks is we pretend the virus doesn't exist then everything will return to 'normal'.
    Facts are facts, you have an over 99.5% chance of surviving this virus even if you catch it if you are under 50.

    Blocking under 50s from returning to work indefinitely will result in mass unemployment and depression with consequences far worse than not having a lock down outside the peak
  • HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position




    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business


    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    It’s not panic. It’s confidence. Will you get health insurance?
    If you are under 50 certainly, though the cruise industry might be hit a bit more admittedly
    You fancy dealing with CV19 during a family holiday in Spain. Not sure I fancy it.
    No difference to dealing with it at home but with warmer weather unless you need hospital treatment which is still unlikely if you are a young family or young singles
    The way you are going I waiting for you to call covid a 'hoax' !!!
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,675
    HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position




    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business


    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain
    really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant
    there.
    It’s not panic. It’s confidence. Will you get health insurance?
    If you are under 50 certainly, though the cruise industry might be hit a bit more admittedly
    You fancy dealing with CV19 during a family holiday in Spain. Not sure I fancy it.
    No difference to dealing with it at home but with warmer weather unless you need hospital treatment which is still unlikely if you are a young family or young singles
    There are huge differences to dealing with it at home. Medical Repatriation, contract tracing with a foreign government and all the extra hassle and delay. Nah. If you’re going to get it, you’ll want to get it at home.
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position

    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    At times you are so naive
    Your first two words were redunadant.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position




    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business


    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    It’s not panic. It’s confidence. Will you get health insurance?
    If you are under 50 certainly, though the cruise industry might be hit a bit more admittedly
    You fancy dealing with CV19 during a family holiday in Spain. Not sure I fancy it.
    Catching it on a foreign holiday and then returning to work, infecting other people and then going off sick is also going to make you very unpopular.
    Catching it after going to the pub, restaurant, gym, cinema or clothes shop or hairdresser in the town where you live and passing it onto others at work would also make you very unpopular.

    We cannot stop most of life indefinitely
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position

    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    At times you are so naive
    Your first two words were redunadant.
    Says the man who cannot even spell correctly!
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position




    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    It’s not panic. It’s confidence. Will you get health insurance?
    If you are under 50 certainly, though the cruise industry might be hit a bit more admittedly
    Just for starters no travel insurance will cover you if you go on holiday against all but essential travel advice from the fco which is now in place, and when you get to Spain even if you aren't quarantined you will be under lockdown rules, so not too much beach time. Or any.
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    This is the case in millions of jobs worldwide
    Oh just accept it then right?

    you can't get a job in your own industry, you can;t retrain because colleges are locked down, your prospects of a job in another industry are close to zero for years to come because lockdown has smashed every industry, you can;t even meet someone face to face to try to convince them you might be worth employing.

    This is your future. An enforced breadline existence you cannot get out of. For years. While some academic argues whether R is at one or not.

    That is what millions of moderate and low paid workers in our country face. How long do you or anybody else think we can keep the lid on that? whether Corona deaths are at twenty, fifty or even 100,000?
    Who said the lockdown would last years? 🙄

    There would be more economic devastation without a lockdown as you'd have had just as much economic devastation as people take their own actions to avoid risk but with zero government support.

    The government borrowing for a once-in-a-century pandemic can easier pay for people's wages than the companies that would have gone bust otherwise. We'd have millions unemployed by now not ten thousand in one industry without a lockdown.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 123,139
    IshmaelZ said:

    HYUFD said:

    Jonathan said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position




    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    It’s not panic. It’s confidence. Will you get health insurance?
    If you are under 50 certainly, though the cruise industry might be hit a bit more admittedly
    Just for starters no travel insurance will cover you if you go on holiday against all but essential travel advice from the fco which is now in place, and when you get to Spain even if you aren't quarantined you will be under lockdown rules, so not too much beach time. Or any.
    If lockdown is lifted then so should be the advice against all but essential travel. By then Spain will also likely have lifted its lockdown
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,357
    I think it must have been a joke but just saw that the Great Clunking Fist Broon has been chosen by Welsh AM to advise Wales on Covid strategy, how mental can Wales be.
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 71,421
    edited April 2020
    justin124 said:

    ydoethur said:

    Oh really, the BBC are just hopeless:

    Boris Johnson and Carrie Symonds announce birth of son https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-52469079

    Mr Johnson, 55, and Ms Symonds, 32, announced in March that they were expecting a baby in "early summer", and that they had become engaged at the end of last year.
    They are the first unmarried couple to move into Downing Street together.


    An exasperated David Lloyd George and Frances Stevenson wave hello.

    But Margaret Lloyd George did appear in Downing Street from time to time. Stevenson was kept out of view much of the time.
    Stevenson was not kept out of view. She even accompanied Lloyd George to official state functions, FFS. One of the reasons the Tory Right, the likes of Stanley Baldwin, Joynson-Hicks and Lloyd-Greame turned against Lloyd George was because they and their constituency parties were angry at DLlG being ‘the first Prime Minister since the Duke of Grafton to live openly with his mistress.‘

    This fed into the atmosphere of moral decay around the government epitomised by the blatant sale of honours for Lloyd George’s personal benefit.
  • Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    edited April 2020
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    So Mr Raab what do you say to a sacked BA worker today?

    Well persisting with lockdown measures means the economy is going to be completely smashed to pieces for years to come so the the chances of re-employment at a decent standard are very low for a long period ahead.

    We forecast that for the foreseeable future you'll be having a totally rotten life on meagre benefits due to our enormous debt, with poorer public services.

    Now, back to those PPE supply problems Piers Morgan is so concerned about.

    Don't be an idiot. Countries all across the entire globe have stopped air travel, the BA workers would have been laid off with or without a domestic lockdown.

    In fact without a domestic lockdown causing a domestic furlough scheme its likely all airlines would have sacked even more workers already.
    OK I'll put that question to YOU since I'm such an idiot.

    What would YOU say to a sacked BA worker today?

    retrain in another industry? when Lockdown is needlessly destroying jobs in all walks of life?

    These poor people must be in a world of sh8t. No jobs in their industry. No jobs anywhere else either.
    Probably most of them will be rehired by BA next year on lower wages and with fewer perks once air travel picks up.

    I would hope though BA executives have also cut their own pay and bonuses first
    No they will not.

    This is huge and is long term, fundamentally changing the industry.

    Travel insurance will also be an issue going forward, as is the prospect of flying itself in an unsafe environment, and even a possible quarantine position

    I agree on executive salaries and dividend payments across all business

    The action by Airbus tells you all you need to know about the medium term prospects of the aircraft industry
    They will if people stop panicking, given coronavirus is now across the developed world you are not any more at risk going on holiday to Spain really than walking down the high street and going to a pub or restaurant there.
    At times you are so naive
    Your first two words were redunadant.
    Says the man who cannot even spell correctly!
    I can. Typos happen.

    To paraphrase a great man you are naive, and what's more you are disgusting naive. But tomorrow I'd spell that word correctly and you will still be disgustingly naive.
This discussion has been closed.