Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » The BES polling chart that surely means that GE2017 was TMay’s

24

Comments

  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,227
    "Six in ten Leave voters and a third of Remain voters say significant damage to the economy would be a price worth paying to get their way on Brexit"

    https://yougov.co.uk/news/2017/08/01/britain-nation-brexit-extremists/
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,819
    edited August 2017

    Mr. Gin, the chassis and aerodynamics are actually pretty good. Even with a Renault engine, they'd be competitive for points often and the odd podium, I think.

    It all went wrong after 2012, when the car was unreliable but very quick. They went for a different suspension approach which lost them performance, then switched to Honda, which proved about as wise as accepting an offer of a handjob from Edward Scissorhands.

    Do you think there's still the "desire" there to race and to be competitive though?

    I always felt Ron Dennis himself was a large part of the "driving force" behind the motor racing operation... With him gone I could see McLarens focus going much more towards their "high-end" road car business and further away from competitive racing.

    Maybe I'm wrong though?
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,227
    YouGov: "Older Leave voters are significantly more willing than their younger counterparts to see the country, themselves and their families be economically compromised in order to achieve Brexit."

  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 54,001
    glw said:

    HHemmelig said:

    glw said:

    Plus GDP should be quoted as GDP per head of the population.

    Totally agree with that. It is a very misleading stat when population is growing rapidly.
    That's a pretty daft thing to say. Of course total GDP matters more than GDP per head, unless you are seriously trying to argue that Norway is more powerful than China or the US.
    Both are interesting stats depending on the context, but I do think that most people tend to want to know how well off they are or should be, which is what GDP is used by the press as a sort of proxy for. GDP per head would be better for that, GDP is misleading in that case if the country only has a large economy because of immigration and a rising birth rate.
    A rising birth rate will tend to drag on nominal GDP as (a) babies tend not to work, and (b) it pulls people out of the formal workforce and into childcare. (And a mother looking after her own child generates zero dollars of GDP.)
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,984
    Mr. Gin, I agree with your implied suggestion that the rise of McLaren's road cars has coincided with the decline of its F1 fortunes and that Dennis was a fierce competitor.

    However, the decline can be specifically linked to executive decisions (for 2013, I think it was, the suspension daftness, and, since then, going to Honda). Sling a Mercedes engine in this year's McLaren and Alonso would be a title contender.

    They need a different engine. With that, they can compete and claw their way back up the grid.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,307
    Must say I think that is surprising because the economy came out of 2016 with a fair bit of momentum. Q1 was a serious disappointment and Q2 is not much better. I think the falling off a cliff that some were forecasting in Q4 has been deferred, possibly indefinitely, but my own expectations for this year have gone down rather than up.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,067

    YouGov: "Older Leave voters are significantly more willing than their younger counterparts to see the country, themselves and their families be economically compromised in order to achieve Brexit."

    They'd be happy to invest their pension savings in Brexit Bonds to finance it then?
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,819

    Mr. Gin, I agree with your implied suggestion that the rise of McLaren's road cars has coincided with the decline of its F1 fortunes and that Dennis was a fierce competitor.

    However, the decline can be specifically linked to executive decisions (for 2013, I think it was, the suspension daftness, and, since then, going to Honda). Sling a Mercedes engine in this year's McLaren and Alonso would be a title contender.

    They need a different engine. With that, they can compete and claw their way back up the grid.

    OK, hope your right. Would be a shame to lose McLaren from the grid.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,929
    rcs1000 said:


    A rising birth rate will tend to drag on nominal GDP as (a) babies tend not to work, and (b) it pulls people out of the formal workforce and into childcare. (And a mother looking after her own child generates zero dollars of GDP.)

    Two mothers looking after each others kids for say £100 day that they pay between themselves would though. But if its their own, nil (Even though the end result is the same !)
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,984
    edited August 2017
    Mr. Gin, the current financial and decision-making set up, I believe, is helpful to McLaren. Not as much as Ferrari, but they're still top end.

    You are right, though, that this is a bad time and they need to get their act together. Apparently they'll make a decision on engines in September. The time for patience with Honda, I think, has ended.

    Edited extra bit: incidentally, the engines do at least appear more reliable since the last update, which may open betting opportunities.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,929
    edited August 2017
    HHemmelig said:

    glw said:

    Plus GDP should be quoted as GDP per head of the population.

    Totally agree with that. It is a very misleading stat when population is growing rapidly.
    That's a pretty daft thing to say. Of course total GDP matters more than GDP per head, unless you are seriously trying to argue that Norway is more powerful than China or the US.
    Only if you're inclined for over-nationalistic "we're at the top of the UN table" over the individual life prospects for you and your family.
    I'd take being an average Norwegian over an average Chinese any day of the week and twice on Sundays.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,307
    rcs1000 said:

    glw said:

    HHemmelig said:

    glw said:

    Plus GDP should be quoted as GDP per head of the population.

    Totally agree with that. It is a very misleading stat when population is growing rapidly.
    That's a pretty daft thing to say. Of course total GDP matters more than GDP per head, unless you are seriously trying to argue that Norway is more powerful than China or the US.
    Both are interesting stats depending on the context, but I do think that most people tend to want to know how well off they are or should be, which is what GDP is used by the press as a sort of proxy for. GDP per head would be better for that, GDP is misleading in that case if the country only has a large economy because of immigration and a rising birth rate.
    A rising birth rate will tend to drag on nominal GDP as (a) babies tend not to work, and (b) it pulls people out of the formal workforce and into childcare. (And a mother looking after her own child generates zero dollars of GDP.)
    Mind you a higher birth rate can also be indicative of an injection of youth into the work force by immigration or otherwise which will have the opposite effect as a higher percentage of the overall population is of working age. Immigration has helped our demographics in recent years, certainly compared to many areas of Europe, and it is not a coincidence that we have record overall employment.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,067
    Pulpstar said:

    HHemmelig said:

    glw said:

    Plus GDP should be quoted as GDP per head of the population.

    Totally agree with that. It is a very misleading stat when population is growing rapidly.
    That's a pretty daft thing to say. Of course total GDP matters more than GDP per head, unless you are seriously trying to argue that Norway is more powerful than China or the US.
    Only if you're inclined for over-nationalistic "we're at the top of the UN table" over the individual life prospects for you and your family.
    I'd take being an average Norwegian over an average Chinese any day of the week and twice on Sundays.
    The polling suggests that Brexiteers are more keen on the Chinese option than the Norwegian. They're happy to trade prosperity for national pride.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,678
    DavidL said:

    Must say I think that is surprising because the economy came out of 2016 with a fair bit of momentum. Q1 was a serious disappointment and Q2 is not much better. I think the falling off a cliff that some were forecasting in Q4 has been deferred, possibly indefinitely, but my own expectations for this year have gone down rather than up.
    I suspect the forecasters were overly pessimistic a year ago - and until I saw today's PMI would have said they were verging on over-optimism now - time will tell!
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,929
    edited August 2017
    Off topic:

    How long will interest rates stay low, as I'll (Hopefully) be getting a somewhat larger mortgage than my current one shortly..
    To 2 yr or 5 yr..
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,307
    Pulpstar said:

    Off topic:

    How long will interest rates stay low, as I'll (Hopefully) be getting a somewhat larger mortgage than my current one shortly..
    To 2 yr or 5 yr..

    The expectation is that interest rates will increase modestly in the next 6-9 months. IIRC that has been the expectation for about 3 or 4 years now!

    My own guess would be that interest rates will struggle to get above 1% in the next 18 months. Inflation is already moderating and the post Brexit devaluation will start to fall out of the year on year comparisons shortly. An economy that is growing slightly below trend with low inflation does not seem an obvious candidate for interest rate rises.
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,190
    Pulpstar said:

    Off topic:

    How long will interest rates stay low, as I'll (Hopefully) be getting a somewhat larger mortgage than my current one shortly..
    To 2 yr or 5 yr..

    If you'd asked that question five years ago I'd have said go five year and I'd have been utterly wrong. Quite frankly I think you'd be better off flipping a coin to decide.
  • Options
    OchEyeOchEye Posts: 1,469

    Lynton Crosby should not expect a call from the next Conservative leader.

    With Crosby's recent record in Australia, Canada and now UK, even Kim il Sung would be hesitant in hiring him to help his election chances.....
  • Options
    All credit to him for standing up to the thugs. Hope he is okay.
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,850
    DavidL said:

    currystar said:

    Sean_F said:

    PMI data has been far better than official numbers, so far this year, but the latter do get revised.
    I think the estimated GDP figures published each quarter are just nonsense. The last one said that Construction had fallen. I dont think the construction industry in this Country has ever been busier.
    Yep, if you believed the published construction figures for the last few years our construction industry would be someone fitting double glazing to a flat in north London. It has officially been shrinking pretty much continuously with the odd revisal up again for years.

    When I was down at the Test I noticed that notwithstanding these figures the south side of the Thames seems to be as covered with cranes as ever.
    Construction output is now calculated to have risen by 20% between May 2013 and May 2017, but you would never believe it from the initial figures that the ONS released. Assuming that the figures for Q2 2017 are revised upwards, the real increase in output is probably even higher.
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,453
    edited August 2017
    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488
  • Options
    stevefstevef Posts: 1,044
    I think we should remember that no prime minister with a working majority who has held a snap election before 4 years has passed has ever won that election.
    We should also remember that "liking" a party leader has no bearing on his/her electoral chances. Margaret Thatcher was one of the most disliked politicians of the twentieth century and yet won three times. Professor Anthony King wrote a book showing how personalities of party leaders made little difference.
    Older voters were turned off by the attack on their social care and pensions.
    Younger voters were bribed by the tuition fees promise -and because they saw Corbyn as a "Che Guevera" type way of rebelling against the older generation.

    But the biggest factor was that many people wanted to stop a hard or no deal Brexit.

    An election post 2019 might be very different.
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,227

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Seems Leavers wont mind, then, when we go off an economic cliff.

    Somehow I get the feeling that people wont actually feel this way when it really happens.
  • Options
    glwglw Posts: 9,549
    rcs1000 said:

    glw said:

    HHemmelig said:

    glw said:

    Plus GDP should be quoted as GDP per head of the population.

    Totally agree with that. It is a very misleading stat when population is growing rapidly.
    That's a pretty daft thing to say. Of course total GDP matters more than GDP per head, unless you are seriously trying to argue that Norway is more powerful than China or the US.
    Both are interesting stats depending on the context, but I do think that most people tend to want to know how well off they are or should be, which is what GDP is used by the press as a sort of proxy for. GDP per head would be better for that, GDP is misleading in that case if the country only has a large economy because of immigration and a rising birth rate.
    A rising birth rate will tend to drag on nominal GDP as (a) babies tend not to work, and (b) it pulls people out of the formal workforce and into childcare. (And a mother looking after her own child generates zero dollars of GDP.)
    A fair point. I really should have just said demographic changes, as there are a whole load of underlying changes, including things like part versus full time work, retirement age, more women in the workforce etc.

    I still think that when most people hear that GDP is up what they are thinking is "how much better off am I, or should I be", not how much larger is the UK economy as a whole. It's interesting to compare the size of economies, but for policy making how well-off individuals are compared to other nations would surely be more important. And yes I realise GDP per head is in itself an over-simplification without accounting for differing demographics of comparable nations.
  • Options

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Seems Leavers wont mind, then, when we go off an economic cliff.

    Somehow I get the feeling that people wont actually feel this way when it really happens.
    They are like Corbynites.

    They'd rather trash the country for the sake of ideological purity.
  • Options
    glwglw Posts: 9,549

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    It is a bit of a silly question, as it doesn't mean people desire a bad outcome. And you could frame whole load of questions about historic events from fighting the second world war to women's suffrage along such emotive lines if you wanted to. But yes some of us think there are more important things than money.
  • Options
    AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    "Venezuela key opposition leaders seized after poll"

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-40787830
  • Options
    glwglw Posts: 9,549
    Sean_F said:

    Construction output is now calculated to have risen by 20% between May 2013 and May 2017, but you would never believe it from the initial figures that the ONS released. Assuming that the figures for Q2 2017 are revised upwards, the real increase in output is probably even higher.

    Do the people at the ONS not have windows in their offices?
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,067

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Entitlement freaks don't think things like this could ever affect their own wallets. After all, they're entitled.
  • Options

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
  • Options
    welshowlwelshowl Posts: 4,460
    glw said:

    Sean_F said:

    Construction output is now calculated to have risen by 20% between May 2013 and May 2017, but you would never believe it from the initial figures that the ONS released. Assuming that the figures for Q2 2017 are revised upwards, the real increase in output is probably even higher.

    Do the people at the ONS not have windows in their offices?
    Possibly not, as to be fair the view from the HQ would be of an industrial park just outside Newport, so I could understand any reluctance to have openings on to the world.
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling
  • Options

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again

    Over 50% of Leave voters in the 65+ bracket would be willing to see significant economic harm and their family members lose jobs in order to achieve Brexit. Of course, they have their incomes guaranteed.

  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,067

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in
    But if they'd voted to stay in they wouldn't have had control; they wouldn't have had £350m a week for the NHS; they wouldn't have gone global and they would have had 80m Turks walking through an open door. It was a complete no-brainer.
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in
    But if they'd voted to stay in they wouldn't have had control; they wouldn't have had £350m a week for the NHS; they wouldn't have gone global and they would have had 80m Turks walking through an open door. It was a complete no-brainer.
    you lost

    and you'd lose again
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again

    Over 50% of Leave voters in the 65+ bracket would be willing to see significant economic harm and their family members lose jobs in order to achieve Brexit. Of course, they have their incomes guaranteed.

    so now you criticise the elderly for doing what you do ?
  • Options
    nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755
    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.
    from the people who gave us £50k uni fees and then undercut the market with cheap labour so that the loans would default youre hardly in a position to argue fiscal rectitude

    rectal fistitude for grads is more your space.
  • Options

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling
    Clearly you weren't paying attention.

    I was a strong supporter of George Osborne's policy to keep on raising the personal substantially.

    Look on the bright side, your economic terrorism will ultimately see the UK rejoin the EU, replete with membership of the Euro and Schengen.

    The Union forever! Hurrah, boys, hurrah!
    Down with the traitors, up with the stars;
    While we rally round the flag, boys, we rally once again,
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!

    We are springing to the call for three hundred thousand more,
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
    And we'll fill the vacant ranks of our brothers gone before
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
  • Options

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again

    Over 50% of Leave voters in the 65+ bracket would be willing to see significant economic harm and their family members lose jobs in order to achieve Brexit. Of course, they have their incomes guaranteed.

    so now you criticise the elderly for doing what you do ?

    What do I do?

    If lots of old people with protected incomes are happy to inflict harm on the economy because they do not like foreigners there is very little I can do. I can note, however, that they will not be affected. It's the young and the employed - who largely voted Remain - who will suffer the consequences.

  • Options
    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264

  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling
    Clearly you weren't paying attention.

    I was a strong supporter of George Osborne's policy to keep on raising the personal substantially.

    Look on the bright side, your economic terrorism will ultimately see the UK rejoin the EU, replete with membership of the Euro and Schengen.

    The Union forever! Hurrah, boys, hurrah!
    Down with the traitors, up with the stars;
    While we rally round the flag, boys, we rally once again,
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!

    We are springing to the call for three hundred thousand more,
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
    And we'll fill the vacant ranks of our brothers gone before
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
    I have no doubt you supported Osborne raising his personal wealth substantially, but the point of being CoE is to do it for the couintry as a whole

    how's that northern powerhouse coming along ?
  • Options
    AllanAllan Posts: 262

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again

    Over 50% of Leave voters in the 65+ bracket would be willing to see significant economic harm and their family members lose jobs in order to achieve Brexit. Of course, they have their incomes guaranteed.

    so now you criticise the elderly for doing what you do ?

    If lots of old people with protected incomes are happy to inflict harm on the economy because they do not like foreigners there is very little I can do. I can note, however, that they will not be affected. It's the young and the employed - who largely voted Remain - who will suffer the consequences.
    It is the young and the employed who will gain from fewer EU unskilled immigrants because that will push up wage levels and reduce housing costs.

    It is the older people that own properties especially BTL that will lose out from fewer EU unskilled immigrants.

    In many respects people voted against their best economic interest. Ironic. Maybe "gaining control" mattered more to the older voters?
  • Options
    Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091
    What if May, despite all her flaws, is still the least-worst option for the Tories?

    Short of getting Ruth Davidson eligible for the leadership, or getting John Major out of retirement, I genuinely don't see in terms of their personalities or "leadership skills" anyone who would be a bigger hit with the public.
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264

    is it more shocking than 100,000 + premature deaths because the EU wont take action against diesel corporate fatcats ?
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,067

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264
    The age old story of the old sacrificing their children for their ideas. Evil.
  • Options

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

  • Options

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling
    Clearly you weren't paying attention.

    I was a strong supporter of George Osborne's policy to keep on raising the personal substantially.

    Look on the bright side, your economic terrorism will ultimately see the UK rejoin the EU, replete with membership of the Euro and Schengen.

    The Union forever! Hurrah, boys, hurrah!
    Down with the traitors, up with the stars;
    While we rally round the flag, boys, we rally once again,
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!

    We are springing to the call for three hundred thousand more,
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
    And we'll fill the vacant ranks of our brothers gone before
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
    I have no doubt you supported Osborne raising his personal wealth substantially, but the point of being CoE is to do it for the couintry as a whole

    how's that northern powerhouse coming along ?
    The Northern Powerhouse has gone to shit since Osborne left, the pound shop Gordon Brown and Chris Grayling are pising off the North so much.

    Billions can be found for Crossrail but a few million can't be found to electrify The Pennine routes.
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264
    The age old story of the old sacrificing their children for their ideas. Evil.
    that would be all those people from the generation who voted to stay in in the seventies

    better that a sinner repent etc.
  • Options
    glwglw Posts: 9,549
    nichomar said:

    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    That has nothing to do with the referendum, you would get that sort of answer for almost any economic or fiscal question. It's not news that almost everybody favours other people paying more taxes, or picking up the tab.
  • Options
    Allan said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again

    Over 50% of Leave voters in the 65+ bracket would be willing to see significant economic harm and their family members lose jobs in order to achieve Brexit. Of course, they have their incomes guaranteed.

    so now you criticise the elderly for doing what you do ?

    If lots of old people with protected incomes are happy to inflict harm on the economy because they do not like foreigners there is very little I can do. I can note, however, that they will not be affected. It's the young and the employed - who largely voted Remain - who will suffer the consequences.
    It is the young and the employed who will gain from fewer EU unskilled immigrants because that will push up wage levels and reduce housing costs.

    It is the older people that own properties especially BTL that will lose out from fewer EU unskilled immigrants.

    In many respects people voted against their best economic interest. Ironic. Maybe "gaining control" mattered more to the older voters?

    If older Leave voters were interested in looking after the young they would not be saying that economic downturn and job losses are prices worth paying for Brexit.

  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,819

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264
    The age old story of the old sacrificing their children for their ideas. Evil.
    Do you want to try and be a bit more melodramatic?
  • Options
    nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264

    I know quite a few older relatively wealthy pensioners, 70+ and whilst it's wrongto sterotype people this view of "it's worth others paying when we leave as it wont impact me" is quite typical
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,067

    Allan said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again

    Over 50% of Leave voters in the 65+ bracket would be willing to see significant economic harm and their family members lose jobs in order to achieve Brexit. Of course, they have their incomes guaranteed.

    so now you criticise the elderly for doing what you do ?

    If lots of old people with protected incomes are happy to inflict harm on the economy because they do not like foreigners there is very little I can do. I can note, however, that they will not be affected. It's the young and the employed - who largely voted Remain - who will suffer the consequences.
    It is the young and the employed who will gain from fewer EU unskilled immigrants because that will push up wage levels and reduce housing costs.

    It is the older people that own properties especially BTL that will lose out from fewer EU unskilled immigrants.

    In many respects people voted against their best economic interest. Ironic. Maybe "gaining control" mattered more to the older voters?

    If older Leave voters were interested in looking after the young they would not be saying that economic downturn and job losses are prices worth paying for Brexit.

    To be charitable, perhaps they think that it's all part of the Brexit war effort and that they have to tell pollsters that, regardless of their views, because they think it helps convince Brussels that we're really, really serious.
  • Options
    nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264

    is it more shocking than 100,000 + premature deaths because the EU wont take action against diesel corporate fatcats ?
    So you believe the UK goverment post exit will not behave in the same way?
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling
    Clearly you weren't paying attention.

    I was a strong supporter of George Osborne's policy to keep on raising the personal substantially.

    Look on the bright side, your economic terrorism will ultimately see the UK rejoin the EU, replete with membership of the Euro and Schengen.

    The Union forever! Hurrah, boys, hurrah!
    Down with the traitors, up with the stars;
    While we rally round the flag, boys, we rally once again,
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!

    We are springing to the call for three hundred thousand more,
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
    And we'll fill the vacant ranks of our brothers gone before
    Shouting the battle cry of freedom!
    I have no doubt you supported Osborne raising his personal wealth substantially, but the point of being CoE is to do it for the couintry as a whole

    how's that northern powerhouse coming along ?
    The Northern Powerhouse has gone to shit since Osborne left, the pound shop Gordon Brown and Chris Grayling are pising off the North so much.

    Billions can be found for Crossrail but a few million can't be found to electrify The Pennine routes.
    just shows how little Osborne actually committed to the North - but he's safely licking his wallet in the City
  • Options

    Allan said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again

    Over 50% of Leave voters in the 65+ bracket would be willing to see significant economic harm and their family members lose jobs in order to achieve Brexit. Of course, they have their incomes guaranteed.

    so now you criticise the elderly for doing what you do ?

    If lots of old people with protected incomes are happy to inflict harm on the economy because they do not like foreigners there is very little I can do. I can note, however, that they will not be affected. It's the young and the employed - who largely voted Remain - who will suffer the consequences.
    It is the young and the employed who will gain from fewer EU unskilled immigrants because that will push up wage levels and reduce housing costs.

    It is the older people that own properties especially BTL that will lose out from fewer EU unskilled immigrants.

    In many respects people voted against their best economic interest. Ironic. Maybe "gaining control" mattered more to the older voters?

    If older Leave voters were interested in looking after the young they would not be saying that economic downturn and job losses are prices worth paying for Brexit.

    To be charitable, perhaps they think that it's all part of the Brexit war effort and that they have to tell pollsters that, regardless of their views, because they think it helps convince Brussels that we're really, really serious.

    To drop the knockaround for a bit, I am sure that when actually faced with the consequences a lot of respondents saying they are happy with economic Armageddon would be horrified. I am not sure how much genuine thought people give to these questions before they answer them. What is interesting, though, is that older Leavers with protected incomes are much more likely to accept the possibility of job losses and downturn than those in younger age groups.

  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755
    nichomar said:

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264

    is it more shocking than 100,000 + premature deaths because the EU wont take action against diesel corporate fatcats ?
    So you believe the UK goverment post exit will not behave in the same way?
    it has the chance to behave differently in the EU it must fall in to line with Germany

    oddly the biggest shake will probably come from Trump and then the shit will hit the fan
  • Options
    MikeSmithsonMikeSmithson Posts: 7,382

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,067
    edited August 2017

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest

    It's a shame James Goldsmith isn't still here so we could have a more sophisticated version of this argument put forward. As it is, I don't think anybody at all is suggesting that real Brexit would mean also leaving the WTO which would be the logical conclusion of your position.
  • Options
    AndrewAndrew Posts: 2,900
    DavidL said:


    My own guess would be that interest rates will struggle to get above 1% in the next 18 months. Inflation is already moderating and the post Brexit devaluation will start to fall out of the year on year comparisons shortly.

    Going the opposite way now too, pound up to $1.32 now. Another 5c and it'll be back at the Feb16 low before the Brexit referendum.
  • Options

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest

    Well, we are about to find out if that is the case, I guess. If you are right we should expect to see rising living standards and higher paid jobs over the coming years. What timeframe do you envisage?

    What I don't understand, though, is why this can happen in other EU member states right now, but not in the UK.

  • Options

    just shows how little Osborne actually committed to the North - but he's safely licking his wallet in the City

    He's still Chairman and doing his best, which is a lot more than the government is doing.
  • Options
    Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,820
    edited August 2017
    Spectacularly off all known topics: I've been doing some historical research using the stunningly good facility for keyword-search of old newspapers (going right back to the eighteenth century) on findmypast.co.uk. One gentleman I'm researching is a William Tooth who lived in Sussex in the early part of the nineteenth century. He was a wealthy farmer and possibly a wine merchant. When I search on him, I'm coming across repeated cases where there is a newspaper notice like this (from the Sussex Advertiser, May 1839):

    WILLIAM KENWARD'S ASSIGNMENT - Notice is hereby given that William Kenward, of Buxted, in the county of Sussex, farmer, hath by Indenture dated the 15th day of May 1839, assigned all his Estate and Effects unto William Tooth, of Mayfield, in the same county, farmer... in trust for the benefit of all the creditors of the same William Kenward, who shall execute the said Indenture, which is lying at my office for that purpose.... Benjamin Buss, Solicitor to the Trustees

    Does anyone know what this signifies? Was William Tooth going around buying up the assets and liabilities of people who'd got into financial trouble, a bit like a hedge fund buying up distressed assets today?
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124
    OT - QTWAIY!
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,242

    Spectacularly off all known topics: I've been doing some historical research using the stunningly good facility for keyword-search of old newspapers (going right back to the eighteenth century) on findmypast.co.uk. One gentleman I'm researching is a William Tooth who lived in Sussex in the early part of the nineteenth century. He was a wealthy farmer and possibly a wine merchant. When I search on him, I'm coming across repeated cases where there is a newspaper notice like this (from the Sussex Advertiser, May 1839):

    WILLIAM KENWARD'S ASSIGNMENT - Notice is hereby given that William Kenward, of Buxted, in the county of Sussex, farmer, hath by Indenture dated the 15th day of May 1839, assigned all his Estate and Effects unto William Tooth, of Mayfield, in the same county, farmer... in trust for the benefit of all the creditors of the same William Kenward, who shall execute the said Indenture, which is lying at my office for that purpose.... Benjamin Buss, Solicitor to the Trustees

    Does anyone know what this signifies? Was William Tooth going around buying up the assets and liabilities of people who'd got into financial trouble, a bit like a hedge fund buying up distressed assets today?

    The honest answer is I don't know, but looking at the wording might he have been the receiver designated by the local courts? There was a function of some sort under the Bankruptcy Act of 1825, which was formalised and put on a national basis in 1883. Was he a JP perhaps?
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest

    Well, we are about to find out if that is the case, I guess. If you are right we should expect to see rising living standards and higher paid jobs over the coming years. What timeframe do you envisage?

    What I don't understand, though, is why this can happen in other EU member states right now, but not in the UK.

    we had this yesterday SO

    you ask me a question you couldnt attempt to answer yourself
  • Options

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


    So a UK issue, not an EU one.

  • Options
    NigelbNigelb Posts: 62,623

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


    And how will Brexit change that ?
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    just shows how little Osborne actually committed to the North - but he's safely licking his wallet in the City

    He's still Chairman and doing his best, which is a lot more than the government is doing.
    Dave flounced off

    I guess Eton dont make them like they used to
  • Options
    MikeSmithsonMikeSmithson Posts: 7,382

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


    Well that is not the EU to blame but British Labour laws.
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    The polling is mad but save us your faux concern for ordinary folk please. People tend to look after themselves and the entitled classes are particularly good at this - demanding the that the 'poor plebs' subsidise their privately educated hothoused thicko offspring at university while lapping up universal benefits to underpay their foreign nannies and cleaners!
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


    Well that is not the EU to blame but British Labour laws.
    Of course

    but there is no appetite in the UK to change to EU Labour law


  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755
    Nigelb said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


    And how will Brexit change that ?
    with the current exchange rate I'd say moving to the Netherlandslooks pretty unprofitable
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,067

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


    Well that is not the EU to blame but British Labour laws.
    Of course

    but there is no appetite in the UK to change to EU Labour law
    "UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies"

    You are contradicting yourself.
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,937
    edited August 2017

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest

    Well, we are about to find out if that is the case, I guess. If you are right we should expect to see rising living standards and higher paid jobs over the coming years. What timeframe do you envisage?

    What I don't understand, though, is why this can happen in other EU member states right now, but not in the UK.

    we had this yesterday SO

    you ask me a question you couldnt attempt to answer yourself

    I am very happy to answer. I don't think Leaving will make any positive difference at all to living standards and wages growth. Furthermore, I think it will also lead to higher prices and deeper public spending cuts. That's why I voted Remain.

  • Options
    Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091
    felix said:

    OT - QTWAIY!

    Who do you believe would do better in a general election than May?
  • Options
    felix said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    The polling is mad but save us your faux concern for ordinary folk please. People tend to look after themselves and the entitled classes are particularly good at this - demanding the that the 'poor plebs' subsidise their privately educated hothoused thicko offspring at university while lapping up universal benefits to underpay their foreign nannies and cleaners!
    I'm a patrician one nation Tory, never hidden that, so you're wrong.
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


    So a UK issue, not an EU one.

    as you keep reminding me we are still part of the EU

    so an EU issue

    large single market so what's the hit for moving ?
  • Options
    Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,820
    ydoethur said:

    The honest answer is I don't know, but looking at the wording might he have been the receiver designated by the local courts? There was a function of some sort under the Bankruptcy Act of 1825, which was formalised and put on a national basis in 1883. Was he a JP perhaps?

    Thanks, that's a good theory, although none of the notices that I've found give any indication that there was a court order involved.
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264

    Of course it's crazy but it's the underlying reasoning behind this which needs to be understood. Howls of outrage just compound the problem and the country remains as divided as ever with neither side wanting to hear the others' point of view.
  • Options
    AllanAllan Posts: 262

    Allan said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again

    Over 50% of Leave voters in the 65+ bracket would be willing to see significant economic harm and their family members lose jobs in order to achieve Brexit. Of course, they have their incomes guaranteed.

    so now you criticise the elderly for doing what you do ?

    If lots of old people with protected incomes are happy to inflict harm on the economy because they do not like foreigners there is very little I can do. I can note, however, that they will not be affected. It's the young and the employed - who largely voted Remain - who will suffer the consequences.
    It is the young and the employed who will gain from fewer EU unskilled immigrants because that will push up wage levels and reduce housing costs.

    It is the older people that own properties especially BTL that will lose out from fewer EU unskilled immigrants.

    In many respects people voted against their best economic interest. Ironic. Maybe "gaining control" mattered more to the older voters?

    If older Leave voters were interested in looking after the young they would not be saying that economic downturn and job losses are prices worth paying for Brexit.
    I take a medium term view that after 3 to 5 years, economically it will be better for my 20+ year old children than Remain. They agree with me having studied Economics and Business.
    For a few years it may be a little worse for me, but if so a price worse paying in lower rental profits.
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264
    The age old story of the old sacrificing their children for their ideas. Evil.
    Hurling wild accusations like that is just plain dumb. Many of the leavers I argued with were adamant they sought to 'save their country' for their grankids. I consider they were wrong but to call them evil is beneath contempt and goes a long way to explaining the result.
  • Options
    AllanAllan Posts: 262
    Project Reality News
    "MEPs have been warned in a behind closed-doors meeting in Brussels that three quarters of employees working at the European Medicines Agency do not want to leave Britain after its withdrawal from the bloc."
    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/08/01/uk-set-poach-top-eu-talent-amid-mutiny-75-tell-brussels-dont/
  • Options

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


    So a UK issue, not an EU one.

    as you keep reminding me we are still part of the EU

    so an EU issue

    large single market so what's the hit for moving ?

    I find it hard to believe that the Dutch or any other EU member state will penalise UK companies for relocating to their territory post-Brexit. In fact, if the approaches we are currently receiving from various member states are anything to go by they will be offering greater incentives than they are able to currently. Of course, if we put in place protective tariffs then some businesses with mainly UK client-bases are unlikely to move, so maybe the HP sauce factory specifically might have stayed (though what would be the tariff on HP sauce?), but I wonder how many businesses like that have relocated in that way over the years.

  • Options
    AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    So a majority of Leavers are maniacs who would prefer to see the country impoverished and people out of work than see it prosper in the EU. And they wonder why I'm so pessimistic about Britain's prospects for the foreseeable future.
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124
    Danny565 said:

    felix said:

    OT - QTWAIY!

    Who do you believe would do better in a general election than May?
    I would like to 'skip a generation' and look at some of the younger options - someone the likes of Johnny Mercer or Esther Mc Vey. Sadly I doubt it will happen.
  • Options
    NigelbNigelb Posts: 62,623

    Nigelb said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your sympathy for the poor plebs never seemed to be active when we were in the EU otherwise they would have voted to stay in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries closed as their work was sent overseas to boosts corporate profits and the folks in London rubbed their hands for the fees it generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


    And how will Brexit change that ?
    with the current exchange rate I'd say moving to the Netherlandslooks pretty unprofitable
    Yes, they'll probably look at one of the lower wage European economies instead. Or are you proposing another 40% devaluation ?
  • Options
    Allan said:

    Project Reality News
    "MEPs have been warned in a behind closed-doors meeting in Brussels that three quarters of employees working at the European Medicines Agency do not want to leave Britain after its withdrawal from the bloc."
    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2017/08/01/uk-set-poach-top-eu-talent-amid-mutiny-75-tell-brussels-dont/

    Well, of course they don't. They have made their lives here. I imagine you would get a similar response form many of the EU nationals now thinking about leaving.
  • Options
    nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    felix said:

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264
    The age old story of the old sacrificing their children for their ideas. Evil.
    Hurling wild accusations like that is just plain dumb. Many of the leavers I argued with were adamant they sought to 'save their country' for their grankids. I consider they were wrong but to call them evil is beneath contempt and goes a long way to explaining the result.
    That was a claim i heard frequently, when asked to justify it no one was able to explain what it meant but it was in the daily mail. Similarly when asked what had the EU imposed on the UK they didn't like they could only come up with something about bananas.
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124

    felix said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    The polling is mad but save us your faux concern for ordinary folk please. People tend to look after themselves and the entitled classes are particularly good at this - demanding the that the 'poor plebs' subsidise their privately educated hothoused thicko offspring at university while lapping up universal benefits to underpay their foreign nannies and cleaners!
    I'm a patrician one nation Tory, never hidden that, so you're wrong.
    Hmmm methinks the sore spot has been well and truly hit. You seem be strangely attracted though to the 'patrician wing' of the party when it comes to leadership. for all her faults May is basically a one nation Tory too - I guess she went to the wrong school.
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,242

    ydoethur said:

    The honest answer is I don't know, but looking at the wording might he have been the receiver designated by the local courts? There was a function of some sort under the Bankruptcy Act of 1825, which was formalised and put on a national basis in 1883. Was he a JP perhaps?

    Thanks, that's a good theory, although none of the notices that I've found give any indication that there was a court order involved.
    On doing a little more research, farmers were specifically exempted from bankruptcy until 1861. I am wondering now if he might have been the equivalent of an independent arbiter appointed by all sides to oversee the estate of a debtor whose assets could not be liquidated. The thing that gets me is the 'for the benefit of his creditors,' which doesn't tie in with your idea of vulture capitalism.

    The only time I can think of off-hand where such an arrangement happened - although it must have happened many times - is over the Great Eastern in the 1850s where its builder, John Scott Russell, went bankrupt but due to the law could not be declared bankrupt as he wasn't within one of the qualifying professions. As a result, outside observers were appointed by his creditors to oversee the business in the hope of winding it up on reasonable terms. It seems possible Tooth was doing something similar for farmers. There might be something there to look at that could help in the Great Eastern. Try the work of George Emerson.
  • Options
    NigelbNigelb Posts: 62,623

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class?... about.
    your in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property and move production. UK workers were dead easy to get rid of - no social plan needed, no courts involved no heavy premiums for sacking them.

    UK law doesnt have the worker protection of most mainstream European economies as a result UK workers will always lose out in an economy which is based round German and French labour laws but where multinats can play freebooting to suit their bonuses.


    So a UK issue, not an EU one.

    as you keep reminding me we are still part of the EU

    so an EU issue

    large single market so what's the hit for moving ?

    I find it hard to believe that the Dutch or any other EU member state will penalise UK companies for relocating to their territory post-Brexit. In fact, if the approaches we are currently receiving from various member states are anything to go by they will be offering greater incentives than they are able to currently. Of course, if we put in place protective tariffs then some businesses with mainly UK client-bases are unlikely to move, so maybe the HP sauce factory specifically might have stayed (though what would be the tariff on HP sauce?), but I wonder how many businesses like that have relocated in that way over the years.

    There might be a certain logic in arguing for freedom to set higher tariff barriers post Brexit - but Leavers seem to be arguing for the opposite of that.
  • Options
    felix said:

    felix said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    The polling is mad but save us your faux concern for ordinary folk please. People tend to look after themselves and the entitled classes are particularly good at this - demanding the that the 'poor plebs' subsidise their privately educated hothoused thicko offspring at university while lapping up universal benefits to underpay their foreign nannies and cleaners!
    I'm a patrician one nation Tory, never hidden that, so you're wrong.
    Hmmm methinks the sore spot has been well and truly hit. You seem be strangely attracted though to the 'patrician wing' of the party when it comes to leadership. for all her faults May is basically a one nation Tory too - I guess she went to the wrong school.
    Nope. She employed bullies and condoned their behaviour, I dislike people like that.
  • Options
    AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 23,755

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    Middle class? How dare you madam! I did a quiz recently which said I was upper class. Plus what entitlements?

    I can weather Brexit, it's the poor plebs who can't cope I worry about.
    your in

    corporate pork barrelling

    If Leave voters were concerned about the incomes of the poor they would not be prepared to accept economic harm and job losses in order to achieve Brexit.

    you appear to ignore that for many that was the reality of the EU

    industries generated

    the EU worked for a select few and stuffed the rest
    That doesn't follow.
    Round the corner from one of my factories was the old HP sauce factory .

    The factory was closed and production shifted to the "low cost" Netherlands everybody lost their job.

    For Heinz it was easy to close a UK factory, sell the property anuit their bonuses.


    So a UK issue, not an EU one.

    as you keep reminding me we are still part of the EU

    so an EU issue

    large single market so what's the hit for moving ?

    I find it hard to believe that the Dutch or any other EU member state will penalise UK companies for relocating to their territory post-Brexit. In fact, if the approaches we are currently receiving from various member states are anything to go by they will be offering greater incentives than they are able to currently. Of course, if we put in place protective tariffs then some businesses with mainly UK client-bases are unlikely to move, so maybe the HP sauce factory specifically might have stayed (though what would be the tariff on HP sauce?), but I wonder how many businesses like that have relocated in that way over the years.

    In manufacturing lots

    Peugeot Ryton transferred to Slovakia
    Bendicks mints to Germany - fucking mints !

    I could bore the tits off you, but it simply illustrates the UK establishment doesnt understand the consequences of being in the EU , nor does it care and if the peasants are revolting they shouldnt be shocked

    anyway I have to go see a customer about a project where Im reshoring products from china

    tiocfaidh ar la. :-)
  • Options
    felixfelix Posts: 15,124
    nichomar said:

    felix said:

    nichomar said:

    Leavers really are economic terrorists

    https://twitter.com/pswidlicki/status/892337757196095488

    Middle class entitlement freak worries about his wallet

    again
    What a suprise leavers dont care if the "economy" suffers as long as it's some one elses "economy" but if it were to hurt me, well thats different.

    It really is a shocker. But not a surprise.

    https://twitter.com/faisalislam/status/892350642966155264
    The age old story of the old sacrificing their children for their ideas. Evil.
    Hurling wild accusations like that is just plain dumb. Many of the leavers I argued with were adamant they sought to 'save their country' for their grankids. I consider they were wrong but to call them evil is beneath contempt and goes a long way to explaining the result.
    That was a claim i heard frequently, when asked to justify it no one was able to explain what it meant but it was in the daily mail. Similarly when asked what had the EU imposed on the UK they didn't like they could only come up with something about bananas.
    My friends were blunter - they don't like the immigration and its impact on communities - in some parts of the UK they have a point. But put simply they see a whole way of life disappearing before their eyes and they don't like it. I think they are wrong but to call them 'evil' is a very clear explanation of the result.
This discussion has been closed.