I do hope Brexiters would read this soberly. The consequences are quite big. I work with industry. It is not the loss single market which is losing me sleep. It is the customs union. I cannot imagine the paperwork that would be have to be dealt with [ even if it was dealt with electronically ].
I have been saying this for some time. The only way out of this is a second referendum. People must decide on Brexit when they would know the consequences rather than it being just a bloody wish.
And yet Corbyn and the Labour party still failed to win the last GE by quite a large margin... Just imagine if Corbyn or Momentum are allowed to present the same manifesto again, especially up against a new Conservative Leader in a post Brexit era.. Something that the PCP are no doubt pondering right now....
You are wrong to immediately assume that the Labour party will automatically be more electable, or even more likely to become the largest party in a post Corbyn era when its equally obvious that neither May, Davis, Johnson or Hammont will be their opponents at the next GE.
So 'Anti-Tory' (15) and 'Anti-Labour' (16) are tied (so much for the 'anti-Tory majority' (sic)) and Corbyn was a greater negative motivator (14) than May (4)........It does underline what a shambles the Tory manifesto was though......
If Labour are led by someone who isn’t quite so polarising as Corbyn (or without the interesting backstory) then if all things are equal then Labour should end up as the largest party
Up to a point, Lord Copper - Corbyn was also a strong motivator of Labour voters (13%, third highest) - so maybe the two go hand in hand - Labour voters rally round a leader who motivates Tories to vote against him......
I think we can file the rest of the hypothesis ('all things being equal') under 'wild speculation'.......
"Paying a fee for access to this customs union ... " could have been expressed as "paying a fee to be behind the EU's Common External Tariff ". I wonder if as many as 24.5% of respondents would go for that?
And yet Corbyn and the Labour party still failed to win the last GE by quite a large margin... Just imagine if Corbyn or Momentum are allowed to present the same manifesto again, especially up against a new Conservative Leader in a post Brexit era.. Something that the PCP are no doubt pondering right now....
You are wrong to immediately assume that the Labour party will automatically be more electable, or even more likely to become the largest party in a post Corbyn era when its equally obvious that neither May, Davis, Johnson or Hammont will be their opponents at the next GE.
Why is it obvious that neither May, Davis, Johnson or Hammond will be their opponents at the next GE?
Where else will the Conservative Party find its new leader if not from the senior members of the Cabinet? It is in government so does not have the luxury of promoting a promising junior minister straight into Number 10. The last few leaders to take over in government were Jim Callaghan (Chancellor and former Home and Foreign Secretary), Gordon Brown (Chancellor) and John Major (Foreign Secretary and former Chancellor). And because Theresa May is too weak to reshuffle the Cabinet, its senior members are likely to be the same in two years time as now.
The only ways the Conservatives escape is if a deal is stitched up where Amber Rudd finds a safe seat -- probably Maidenhead where Theresa May will be standing down, or the Chancellor falls on his sword because he suddenly realises that he too works in the overpaid public sector where even a woman can carry a red box, thus enabling a reshuffle.
And yet Corbyn and the Labour party still failed to win the last GE by quite a large margin... Just imagine if Corbyn or Momentum are allowed to present the same manifesto again, especially up against a new Conservative Leader in a post Brexit era.. Something that the PCP are no doubt pondering right now....
You are wrong to immediately assume that the Labour party will automatically be more electable, or even more likely to become the largest party in a post Corbyn era when its equally obvious that neither May, Davis, Johnson or Hammont will be their opponents at the next GE.
Why is it obvious that neither May, Davis, Johnson or Hammond will be their opponents at the next GE?
Where else will the Conservative Party find its new leader if not from the senior members of the Cabinet? It is in government so does not have the luxury of promoting a promising junior minister straight into Number 10. The last few leaders to take over in government were Jim Callaghan (Chancellor and former Home and Foreign Secretary), Gordon Brown (Chancellor) and John Major (Foreign Secretary and former Chancellor). And because Theresa May is too weak to reshuffle the Cabinet, its senior members are likely to be the same in two years time as now.
The only ways the Conservatives escape is if a deal is stitched up where Amber Rudd finds a safe seat -- probably Maidenhead where Theresa May will be standing down, or the Chancellor falls on his sword because he suddenly realises that he too works in the overpaid public sector where even a woman can carry a red box, thus enabling a reshuffle.
Your logic is sound but the GE could be nearly 5 years away. Goodness knows plenty can change in 5 weeks, let alone 5 years. Remember Majors stints in the "Great Offices of State" amounted to only 18 months - so the next PM could be a junior minister or even on the back benches...
People don't understand what the customs union is - they are simply responding to press pressure and think that it is some kind of 'lite' single market.
Remaining in the customs union is utterly pointless if we have left the SM, which is why even the EEA members are not members of the customs union. The fact that EEA members are not in the CU, yet somehow manage to trade effectively with the EU without massive problems at their borders, demonstrates quote clearly that being outside the CU is not going to create unsolvable logistical problems after Brexit.
BTW the wording in the poll is completely incorrect and misleading.
And yet Corbyn and the Labour party still failed to win the last GE by quite a large margin... Just imagine if Corbyn or Momentum are allowed to present the same manifesto again, especially up against a new Conservative Leader in a post Brexit era.. Something that the PCP are no doubt pondering right now....
You are wrong to immediately assume that the Labour party will automatically be more electable, or even more likely to become the largest party in a post Corbyn era when its equally obvious that neither May, Davis, Johnson or Hammont will be their opponents at the next GE.
Why is it obvious that neither May, Davis, Johnson or Hammond will be their opponents at the next GE?
Where else will the Conservative Party find its new leader if not from the senior members of the Cabinet? It is in government so does not have the luxury of promoting a promising junior minister straight into Number 10. The last few leaders to take over in government were Jim Callaghan (Chancellor and former Home and Foreign Secretary), Gordon Brown (Chancellor) and John Major (Foreign Secretary and former Chancellor). And because Theresa May is too weak to reshuffle the Cabinet, its senior members are likely to be the same in two years time as now.
The only ways the Conservatives escape is if a deal is stitched up where Amber Rudd finds a safe seat -- probably Maidenhead where Theresa May will be standing down, or the Chancellor falls on his sword because he suddenly realises that he too works in the overpaid public sector where even a woman can carry a red box, thus enabling a reshuffle.
Your logic is sound but the GE could be nearly 5 years away. Goodness knows plenty can change in 5 weeks, let alone 5 years. Remember Majors stints in the "Great Offices of State" amounted to only 18 months - so the next PM could be a junior minister or even on the back benches...
True but unless Hammond resigns, as suggested, or one of the others does, it is hard to see how this star backbencher or junior minister can be promoted. Theresa May cannot sack, demote or reshuffle anyone. (And I've just noticed I forgot to add May herself to the list of Callaghan, Brown and Major as senior cabinet members who took over as prime minister.)
And yet Corbyn and the Labour party still failed to win the last GE by quite a large margin... Just imagine if Corbyn or Momentum are allowed to present the same manifesto again, especially up against a new Conservative Leader in a post Brexit era.. Something that the PCP are no doubt pondering right now....
You are wrong to immediately assume that the Labour party will automatically be more electable, or even more likely to become the largest party in a post Corbyn era when its equally obvious that neither May, Davis, Johnson or Hammont will be their opponents at the next GE.
Why is it obvious that neither May, Davis, Johnson or Hammond will be their opponents at the next GE?
Where else will the Conservative Party find its new leader if not from the senior members of the Cabinet? It is in government so does not have the luxury of promoting a promising junior minister straight into Number 10. The last few leaders to take over in government were Jim Callaghan (Chancellor and former Home and Foreign Secretary), Gordon Brown (Chancellor) and John Major (Foreign Secretary and former Chancellor). And because Theresa May is too weak to reshuffle the Cabinet, its senior members are likely to be the same in two years time as now.
The only ways the Conservatives escape is if a deal is stitched up where Amber Rudd finds a safe seat -- probably Maidenhead where Theresa May will be standing down, or the Chancellor falls on his sword because he suddenly realises that he too works in the overpaid public sector where even a woman can carry a red box, thus enabling a reshuffle.
Your logic is sound but the GE could be nearly 5 years away. Goodness knows plenty can change in 5 weeks, let alone 5 years. Remember Majors stints in the "Great Offices of State" amounted to only 18 months - so the next PM could be a junior minister or even on the back benches...
True but unless Hammond resigns, as suggested, or one of the others does, it is hard to see how this star backbencher or junior minister can be promoted. Theresa May cannot sack, demote or reshuffle anyone. (And I've just noticed I forgot to add May herself to the list of Callaghan, Brown and Major as senior cabinet members who took over as prime minister.)
Even going back to the war, we can add Sir Alec Douglas Home (Foreign Secretary), Harold Macmillan (Chancellor) and Sir Anthony Eden (Foreign Secretary). Even Churchill himself in 1940, though First Lord of the Admiralty, had previously been Chancellor of the Exchequer.
People don't understand what the customs union is - they are simply responding to press pressure and think that it is some kind of 'lite' single market.
Remaining in the customs union is utterly pointless if we have left the SM, which is why even the EEA members are not members of the customs union. The fact that EEA members are not in the CU, yet somehow manage to trade effectively with the EU without massive problems at their borders, demonstrates quote clearly that being outside the CU is not going to create unsolvable logistical problems after Brexit.
BTW the wording in the poll is completely incorrect and misleading.
Trade happens when you've got something the other party wants at the right price. Napoleon bought British coats for the Russian campaign despite having personally instigated a trade war with Britain. If Brexiters were coming up with ways of improving our trading position by creating better goods and services I might take them a bit more seriously.
Just over 20% of Labour votes were essentially negative; close to 40% of Tory ones were. The anti-Labour vote much bigger than the anti-Tory one. Corbyn specifically a net drag on Labour's return. Interesting, but not surprising. Suggests the Tory vote has the potential to fall further than Labour's, but that there is still a significant upside for them if they can pull through their current shitshow - especially with the Labour left consumed by hubris.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
All parties rushed their manifestos because of the snap election, so none were as fettled as they should be. It is quite likely that Labour will be better prepared next time.
I cannot see May enjoying the conference season. Surely she is toasted enough already?
Just over 20% of Labour votes were essentially negative; close to 40% of Tory ones were. The anti-Labour vote much bigger than the anti-Tory one. Corbyn specifically a net drag on Labour's return. Interesting, but not surprising. Suggests the Tory vote has the potential to fall further than Labour's, but that there is still a significant upside for them if they can pull through their current shitshow - especially with the Labour left consumed by hubris.
The trick in politics is to be popular with your tribe without being a recruiting sergeant for your opponents.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
Anti Tory = Anti Brexit
The Labour party and its leaders are not anti-Brexit, but wish to achieve a different style of Brexit than the Tories. In GB, parties that are anti-Brexit, the LDs/Greens/SNP/PC, performed poorly at the last GE. Parties that endorse Brexit gained over 80% of the vote.
Trade happens when you've got something the other party wants at the right price. Napoleon bought British coats for the Russian campaign despite having personally instigated a trade war with Britain. If Brexiters were coming up with ways of improving our trading position by creating better goods and services I might take them a bit more seriously.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
Anti Tory = Anti Brexit
The Labour party and its leaders are not anti-Brexit, but wish to achieve a different style of Brexit than the Tories. In GB, parties that are anti-Brexit, the LDs/Greens/SNP/PC, performed poorly at the last GE. Parties that endorse Brexit gained over 80% of the vote.
The Tories were dangerous in 2017. Their ideological hard Brexit needed to be stopped.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
All parties rushed their manifestos because of the snap election, so none were as fettled as they should be. It is quite likely that Labour will be better prepared next time.
I cannot see May enjoying the conference season. Surely she is toasted enough already?
Conference will be interesting as thousands of activists compare notes on where the election was lost -- with each other and with dozens of journalists in the bar.
Trade happens when you've got something the other party wants at the right price. Napoleon bought British coats for the Russian campaign despite having personally instigated a trade war with Britain. If Brexiters were coming up with ways of improving our trading position by creating better goods and services I might take them a bit more seriously.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
All parties rushed their manifestos because of the snap election, so none were as fettled as they should be. It is quite likely that Labour will be better prepared next time.
I cannot see May enjoying the conference season. Surely she is toasted enough already?
The next Labour manifesto will be much further to the left than the last one. The party leadership has decided that on 8th June 12.8 million people voted for socialism. I am not sure that's the right call.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
All parties rushed their manifestos because of the snap election, so none were as fettled as they should be. It is quite likely that Labour will be better prepared next time.
I cannot see May enjoying the conference season. Surely she is toasted enough already?
The next Labour manifesto will be much further to the left than the last one. The party leadership has decided that on 8th June 12.8 million people voted for socialism. I am not sure that's the right call.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
Anti Tory = Anti Brexit
The Labour party and its leaders are not anti-Brexit, but wish to achieve a different style of Brexit than the Tories. In GB, parties that are anti-Brexit, the LDs/Greens/SNP/PC, performed poorly at the last GE. Parties that endorse Brexit gained over 80% of the vote.
The Tories were dangerous in 2017. Their ideological hard Brexit needed to be stopped.
If the UK is outwith the single market and customs union, and not subject to the jurisdiction of the ECJ, as both the Tories and Labour accept, it will be a hard Brexit.
In any case, the EU27 will be making the decisions - the 4 freedoms are fundamental to the EU (and EEA membership) and all 4 need to be accepted without caveats for a soft Brexit.
The seeds for Brexit were sown in autumn 1992 when the UK crashed out of the EEM. Its economy has not been fit to join the Euro (i.e. worse than Spain et al) and hence the UK has been on the outer fringe of the EU ever since. Look at how many Spanish companies now run or sell services to the UK - BAA/BA/CAF/Santander.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
All parties rushed their manifestos because of the snap election, so none were as fettled as they should be. It is quite likely that Labour will be better prepared next time.
I cannot see May enjoying the conference season. Surely she is toasted enough already?
The next Labour manifesto will be much further to the left than the last one. The party leadership has decided that on 8th June 12.8 million people voted for socialism. I am not sure that's the right call.
There was some good stuff in there. Hadn't seen a more straightforward and popular expression of Labours offer since 97, which was far more radical.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
Anti Tory = Anti Brexit
The Labour party and its leaders are not anti-Brexit, but wish to achieve a different style of Brexit than the Tories. In GB, parties that are anti-Brexit, the LDs/Greens/SNP/PC, performed poorly at the last GE. Parties that endorse Brexit gained over 80% of the vote.
The Tories were dangerous in 2017. Their ideological hard Brexit needed to be stopped.
Looks like both big party leaderships are very focused on securing a hard Brexit to me. That makes them both equally dangerous to the UK's economic prospects.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
All parties rushed their manifestos because of the snap election, so none were as fettled as they should be. It is quite likely that Labour will be better prepared next time.
I cannot see May enjoying the conference season. Surely she is toasted enough already?
The next Labour manifesto will be much further to the left than the last one. The party leadership has decided that on 8th June 12.8 million people voted for socialism. I am not sure that's the right call.
People thought that Labour were offering hope and fairness and support for the ordinary person against the rich and big business.
It made a change from the grim misery and support for the establishment offered by the other parties and by Labour in 2015.
On the plus side, I did have an 8 winner (effectively, it was 26 each way for pole for Raikkonen) pre-practice.
Not really. When you ask many Conservatives why they vote as they do, it is extremely common for the first words of reply to be along the lines of 'Labour would be terrible....".
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
Anti Tory = Anti Brexit
The Labour party and its leaders are not anti-Brexit, but wish to achieve a different style of Brexit than the Tories. In GB, parties that are anti-Brexit, the LDs/Greens/SNP/PC, performed poorly at the last GE. Parties that endorse Brexit gained over 80% of the vote.
The Tories were dangerous in 2017. Their ideological hard Brexit needed to be stopped.
Looks like both big party leaderships are very focused on securing a hard Brexit to me. That makes them both equally dangerous to the UK's economic prospects.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
Anti Tory = Anti Brexit
The Labour party and its leaders are not anti-Brexit, but wish to achieve a different style of Brexit than the Tories. In GB, parties that are anti-Brexit, the LDs/Greens/SNP/PC, performed poorly at the last GE. Parties that endorse Brexit gained over 80% of the vote.
People vote for candidates, and candidates who were remainders are in a bigger majority this parliament than the last....
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
All parties rushed their manifestos because of the snap election, so none were as fettled as they should be. It is quite likely that Labour will be better prepared next time.
I cannot see May enjoying the conference season. Surely she is toasted enough already?
Conference will be interesting as thousands of activists compare notes on where the election was lost -- with each other and with dozens of journalists in the bar.
Yesterday's Times reckoned the week after Tory Conference was the target date for demaying. Today's Sundays seem to suggest some are still aiming earlier.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
All parties rushed their manifestos because of the snap election, so none were as fettled as they should be. It is quite likely that Labour will be better prepared next time.
I cannot see May enjoying the conference season. Surely she is toasted enough already?
Conference will be interesting as thousands of activists compare notes on where the election was lost -- with each other and with dozens of journalists in the bar.
Yesterday's Times reckoned the week after Tory Conference was the target date for demaying. Today's Sundays seem to suggest some are still aiming earlier.
"I hear that she has told her closest friends that the election result was the most devastating thing to have happened in her life since the deaths of her parents when she was in her 20s. Mrs May’s inability, even a month on, to give a coherent explanation of why she thinks the election went so horribly wrong for her suggests that she has yet to process the trauma fully."
"Mrs May is still in office because her party fears what it might do to itself in a chaotic and vicious Tory leadership contest. There is no widely agreed candidate to replace her as prime minister. There is no name that could be put to the cabinet and receive overwhelming support as the next occupant of Number 10."
The problem with this kind of poll is that people probably vote for this or that party because they know what they are doing, they are inspiring, the other lot are dangerous or incompetent, or because they always vote that way. This poll forces people to rationalize their vote by choosing THINGS.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
Anti Tory = Anti Brexit
The Labour party and its leaders are not anti-Brexit, but wish to achieve a different style of Brexit than the Tories. In GB, parties that are anti-Brexit, the LDs/Greens/SNP/PC, performed poorly at the last GE. Parties that endorse Brexit gained over 80% of the vote.
The Tories were dangerous in 2017. Their ideological hard Brexit needed to be stopped.
Looks like both big party leaderships are very focused on securing a hard Brexit to me. That makes them both equally dangerous to the UK's economic prospects.
Starmer is the safer bet.
Yep - I wish he had some meaningful role in the process, but he doesn't.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
Anti Tory = Anti Brexit
The Labour party and its leaders are not anti-Brexit, but wish to achieve a different style of Brexit than the Tories. In GB, parties that are anti-Brexit, the LDs/Greens/SNP/PC, performed poorly at the last GE. Parties that endorse Brexit gained over 80% of the vote.
The Tories were dangerous in 2017. Their ideological hard Brexit needed to be stopped.
Looks like both big party leaderships are very focused on securing a hard Brexit to me. That makes them both equally dangerous to the UK's economic prospects.
What if hard Brexit is the only Brexit that exists? That seems to be the clear view of the EU27 as expressed by Barnier and Tusk.
In which case I prefer the workers Brexit to the bosses Brexit.
Is this another thread where numerous posters miss the point that only the main reason was asked for?
What stands out for me is how much of the Conservative vote was anti-Labour or anti-Corbyn. The equivalent among Labour supporters is much lower. Labour have serious brand problems.
Blair may be wrong but why is it delusional to suggest that (say) Angela Merkel has any great objection in principle to the sort of controls her own government imposed until recently?
On topic, the next election most likely takes place post Brexit. That means that the strongest reason to vote Tory will be history, but all the strong reasons to vote Labour will still be active issues.
I was very puzzled by his claims. If they were true surely such a deal may have been offered to Cameron? If it were truly offered now the UK would surely grab it with both hands and why are they 'saying' this to him but not to anyone else. Very hard not to draw the obvious conclusion that he hopes straightforward lies are the only option left to him.
Well I never not a single labour voter mentioned Brexit despite a handful of lefties on here droning on all day about it.
I'm beginning to realise the penny will never drop for you poor souls.
Anti-Tory, anti-Theresa May = anti-Tory Brexit
More delusion. Just accept it mate, the tories are obsessed with Brexit, your lot don't give a toss, never have.
My lot absolutely do care about Brexit. The Labour leadership doesn't, I grant.
Well I'm afraid to say your lot are a small minority - you have read the thread header as well as previous similar ones?
Anti-Tories, anti-Mays are a decent sized minority.
Of course, the anti tories have always been there, always will, its nothing to do with Brexit. Only you and a few others on here need treatment for your obsession. I'm opening a Priory type home specialising in Brexit rehab.
In one school she visited she was horrified — and said parents would be “surprised” — to see a class of 11-year-olds taken through GCSE mark schemes instead of being taught geography.
Top marks to that Teacher for changing that day's lesson..
Is this another thread where numerous posters miss the point that only the main reason was asked for?
What stands out for me is how much of the Conservative vote was anti-Labour or anti-Corbyn. The equivalent among Labour supporters is much lower. Labour have serious brand problems.
Yep - that was my point below. Labour got the support it did despite close to 40% of the Tory vote being inspired by anti-Labour voters. That said, over 20% of Labour votes were negative, too. All in all, though, it's pretty clear Corbyn and co are the Tories' best friends.
Well I never not a single labour voter mentioned Brexit despite a handful of lefties on here droning on all day about it.
I'm beginning to realise the penny will never drop for you poor souls.
Anti-Tory, anti-Theresa May = anti-Tory Brexit
More delusion. Just accept it mate, the tories are obsessed with Brexit, your lot don't give a toss, never have.
My lot absolutely do care about Brexit. The Labour leadership doesn't, I grant.
Well I'm afraid to say your lot are a small minority - you have read the thread header as well as previous similar ones?
Perpetually you miss the point that the coin is only half way to the floor.
It doesn't matter so much what people think now; it will matter hugely come 2019, when the bad news facing us will be all too clear.
In that case for the sake of your health you should try another approach for a couple of years, bury yourself in a time capsule and then emerge triumphant when the rest of us are all living in caves because of Brexit.
Is this another thread where numerous posters miss the point that only the main reason was asked for?
What stands out for me is how much of the Conservative vote was anti-Labour or anti-Corbyn. The equivalent among Labour supporters is much lower. Labour have serious brand problems.
Yes and no. You too have missed the point but in the other direction -- that *any reason at all* was asked for. Conservative supporters asked to rationalise their votes have very few choices since the party did not campaign in favour of anything. That's why a full 45% (anti-Corbyn, anti-Labour, best of a bad bunch, and better suited to govern) gave essentially the same answer, and that's without considering 21% said Brexit which is probably the only policy they could remember -- but Labour also committed to Brexit so aside from a handful of ex-LDs, that cannot be the actual reason.
Is this another thread where numerous posters miss the point that only the main reason was asked for?
What stands out for me is how much of the Conservative vote was anti-Labour or anti-Corbyn. The equivalent among Labour supporters is much lower. Labour have serious brand problems.
Agreed - indeed the Survation poll last night shows the Tory vote holding up astonishingly well against an overwhelmingly negative media background. Labour looks more flaky and Despite the 'cult of Corbyn' we keep reading about Labour would be doing way better under more centrist leadership. And if the Tories did get their act together again.......
Is this another thread where numerous posters miss the point that only the main reason was asked for?
What stands out for me is how much of the Conservative vote was anti-Labour or anti-Corbyn. The equivalent among Labour supporters is much lower. Labour have serious brand problems.
Yep - that was my point below. Labour got the support it did despite close to 40% of the Tory vote being inspired by anti-Labour voters. That said, over 20% of Labour votes were negative, too. All in all, though, it's pretty clear Corbyn and co are the Tories' best friends.
I don't think you can conclude that, without looking at similar surveys from time past. As I said below, many conservatives justify their support first and foremost by keeping Labour from power, and it has been this way for decades.
Indeed I was thinking yeterday that the middle class's traditional support for the Tories rests principally on trusting their safer hands on the economy and otherwise wanting to be left alone. Consequently the Tories get in when they focus in economic competence, and get turfed out whenever Tories delude themselves that the support they get indicates desire for all the other Tory-political stuff, which in reality few people want. Labour and Tory being pretty much level in middle class support right now is striking.
The Tories' biggest problem right now is that their political obsession with the EU has once again led them to wander away from managing the economy.
Is this another thread where numerous posters miss the point that only the main reason was asked for?
What stands out for me is how much of the Conservative vote was anti-Labour or anti-Corbyn. The equivalent among Labour supporters is much lower. Labour have serious brand problems.
Agreed - indeed the Survation poll last night shows the Tory vote holding up astonishingly well against an overwhelmingly negative media background. Labour looks more flaky and Despite the 'cult of Corbyn' we keep reading about Labour would be doing way better under more centrist leadership. And if the Tories did get their act together again.......
Or...
Corbyn's Labour do better in real campaigns. Outside of the campaign polls flatter the Tories.
Would be rather ironic if you started to draw comfort from the polls that deceived you so recently.
Well I never not a single labour voter mentioned Brexit despite a handful of lefties on here droning on all day about it.
I'm beginning to realise the penny will never drop for you poor souls.
Anti-Tory, anti-Theresa May = anti-Tory Brexit
More delusion. Just accept it mate, the tories are obsessed with Brexit, your lot don't give a toss, never have.
My lot absolutely do care about Brexit. The Labour leadership doesn't, I grant.
Well I'm afraid to say your lot are a small minority - you have read the thread header as well as previous similar ones?
Perpetually you miss the point that the coin is only half way to the floor.
It doesn't matter so much what people think now; it will matter hugely come 2019, when the bad news facing us will be all too clear.
In that case for the sake of your health you should try another approach for a couple of years, bury yourself in a time capsule and then emerge triumphant when the rest of us are all living in caves because of Brexit.
Seeing the results of your own spell in a time capsule is hardly encouraging!
Blair may be wrong but why is it delusional to suggest that (say) Angela Merkel has any great objection in principle to the sort of controls her own government imposed until recently?
Well I never not a single labour voter mentioned Brexit despite a handful of lefties on here droning on all day about it.
I'm beginning to realise the penny will never drop for you poor souls.
Anti-Tory, anti-Theresa May = anti-Tory Brexit
More delusion. Just accept it mate, the tories are obsessed with Brexit, your lot don't give a toss, never have.
My lot absolutely do care about Brexit. The Labour leadership doesn't, I grant.
Well I'm afraid to say your lot are a small minority - you have read the thread header as well as previous similar ones?
Anti-Tories, anti-Mays are a decent sized minority.
Of course, the anti tories have always been there, always will, its nothing to do with Brexit. Only you and a few others on here need treatment for your obsession. I'm opening a Priory type home specialising in Brexit rehab.
I fully accept the referendum result, even though I regret it. What terrifies me is the complete mess the government is making of the withdrawal process and the damage its incompetence will cause.
I had made up my mind to break the habit of a lifetime and vote Tory (on anti-Corbyn grounds), but this declaration made me switch back to Labour just a couple of days before the vote:
Is this another thread where numerous posters miss the point that only the main reason was asked for?
What stands out for me is how much of the Conservative vote was anti-Labour or anti-Corbyn. The equivalent among Labour supporters is much lower. Labour have serious brand problems.
Agreed - indeed the Survation poll last night shows the Tory vote holding up astonishingly well against an overwhelmingly negative media background. Labour looks more flaky and Despite the 'cult of Corbyn' we keep reading about Labour would be doing way better under more centrist leadership. And if the Tories did get their act together again.......
Or...
Corbyn's Labour do better in real campaigns. Outside of the campaign polls flatter the Tories.
Would be rather ironic if you started to draw comfort from the polls that deceived you so recently.
Survation were the most accurate pollster of the GE campaign but I don't rely on them for much of anything generally. However, given the current circumstances the fact that the Tory support appears to be holding up quite well [ even on the evidence of local election results] is little short of miraculous. That must i believe be down to a weakness in the Labour off/leadership/both.
Well I never not a single labour voter mentioned Brexit despite a handful of lefties on here droning on all day about it.
I'm beginning to realise the penny will never drop for you poor souls.
Anti-Tory, anti-Theresa May = anti-Tory Brexit
More delusion. Just accept it mate, the tories are obsessed with Brexit, your lot don't give a toss, never have.
My lot absolutely do care about Brexit. The Labour leadership doesn't, I grant.
Well I'm afraid to say your lot are a small minority - you have read the thread header as well as previous similar ones?
Anti-Tories, anti-Mays are a decent sized minority.
Of course, the anti tories have always been there, always will, its nothing to do with Brexit. Only you and a few others on here need treatment for your obsession. I'm opening a Priory type home specialising in Brexit rehab.
I fully accept the referendum result, even though I regret it. What terrifies me is the complete mess the government is making of the withdrawal process and the damage its incompetence will cause.
You need to relax, you are becoming increasingly shrill and hyperbolic, every survey shows that nobody is either listening or concerned. You are a doom merchant, everybody avoids them.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
Anti Tory = Anti Brexit
The Labour party and its leaders are not anti-Brexit, but wish to achieve a different style of Brexit than the Tories. In GB, parties that are anti-Brexit, the LDs/Greens/SNP/PC, performed poorly at the last GE. Parties that endorse Brexit gained over 80% of the vote.
The Tories were dangerous in 2017. Their ideological hard Brexit needed to be stopped.
Looks like both big party leaderships are very focused on securing a hard Brexit to me. That makes them both equally dangerous to the UK's economic prospects.
What if hard Brexit is the only Brexit that exists? That seems to be the clear view of the EU27 as expressed by Barnier and Tusk.
In which case I prefer the workers Brexit to the bosses Brexit.
The EU27 have heard what government ministers have been saying for the last year. In the absence of any coherent UK proposals for how a future relationship might work they have reached the only conclusion about the UK's intentions it is possible to reach.
In one school she visited she was horrified — and said parents would be “surprised” — to see a class of 11-year-olds taken through GCSE mark schemes instead of being taught geography.
In my day, we did not do this.
One reason exam pass rates went up year on year is that teachers and pupils became far more sophisticated in exam technique. We coffin-dodgers were expected to learn maths, say, or history, and then answer whatever questions were thrown at us.
These days, teachers teach narrowly to the test and pupils are drilled into how to analyse questions to provide exactly what is demanded -- even if they know nothing. If the question is about triangles but you can remember neither geometry nor trigonometry, then before skipping to the next question, at least draw a flaming triangle because there will be 1 or 2 marks (out of 20) for that tiny part of the full, correct answer.
Is this another thread where numerous posters miss the point that only the main reason was asked for?
What stands out for me is how much of the Conservative vote was anti-Labour or anti-Corbyn. The equivalent among Labour supporters is much lower. Labour have serious brand problems.
Yep - that was my point below. Labour got the support it did despite close to 40% of the Tory vote being inspired by anti-Labour voters. That said, over 20% of Labour votes were negative, too. All in all, though, it's pretty clear Corbyn and co are the Tories' best friends.
The Corbyn factor is real in repelling some Tory voters. But I think there is an anti-labour vote that's solid regardless of the leader.
Very interesting polling. Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour. Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
All parties rushed their manifestos because of the snap election, so none were as fettled as they should be. It is quite likely that Labour will be better prepared next time.
I cannot see May enjoying the conference season. Surely she is toasted enough already?
The next Labour manifesto will be much further to the left than the last one. The party leadership has decided that on 8th June 12.8 million people voted for socialism. I am not sure that's the right call.
Agreed. Take the Labour position on tuition fees, its already been tried and found to have failed in Scotland. Something worth remembering.
A term that seems to come from the writing of Engels in The Condition of the Working Class in England.
It was probably bollocks in Engels' time in so far as poverty just became more obvious with urbanisation and industrialisation. It certainly shouldn't be applied to Grenfell Tower. Too bad John McDonnell didn't name any names.
Comments
Just imagine if Corbyn or Momentum are allowed to present the same manifesto again, especially up against a new Conservative Leader in a post Brexit era.. Something that the PCP are no doubt pondering right now....
You are wrong to immediately assume that the Labour party will automatically be more electable, or even more likely to become the largest party in a post Corbyn era when its equally obvious that neither May, Davis, Johnson or Hammont will be their opponents at the next GE.
Up to a point, Lord Copper - Corbyn was also a strong motivator of Labour voters (13%, third highest) - so maybe the two go hand in hand - Labour voters rally round a leader who motivates Tories to vote against him......
I think we can file the rest of the hypothesis ('all things being equal') under 'wild speculation'.......
https://twitter.com/GoodwinMJ/status/886385153563426817
And literally untrue – surely one of Labour's core values is to stand up for minorities of various sorts.
* https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/may/23/no-religion-outnumber-christians-england-wales-study
I think a pattern is emerging.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-latin-america-40622273
I wonder if as many as 24.5% of respondents would go for that?
58% don't want to be in the Single Market, 27% do.....
Where else will the Conservative Party find its new leader if not from the senior members of the Cabinet? It is in government so does not have the luxury of promoting a promising junior minister straight into Number 10. The last few leaders to take over in government were Jim Callaghan (Chancellor and former Home and Foreign Secretary), Gordon Brown (Chancellor) and John Major (Foreign Secretary and former Chancellor). And because Theresa May is too weak to reshuffle the Cabinet, its senior members are likely to be the same in two years time as now.
The only ways the Conservatives escape is if a deal is stitched up where Amber Rudd finds a safe seat -- probably Maidenhead where Theresa May will be standing down, or the Chancellor falls on his sword because he suddenly realises that he too works in the overpaid public sector where even a woman can carry a red box, thus enabling a reshuffle.
Ayn Rand
Suggests Brexit not that significant for Labour voters?
And also that the manifesto and policies were a clear positive for Labour.
Logically then they should keep them for next time around.
Remaining in the customs union is utterly pointless if we have left the SM, which is why even the EEA members are not members of the customs union. The fact that EEA members are not in the CU, yet somehow manage to trade effectively with the EU without massive problems at their borders, demonstrates quote clearly that being outside the CU is not going to create unsolvable logistical problems after Brexit.
BTW the wording in the poll is completely incorrect and misleading.
The shenanigans at the moment are pathetic.. the greasy pole and all that.
https://www.gov.uk/government/history/past-prime-ministers
Quite surprised the anti-Labour reason is 1 point ahead of the anti-Conservative reason.
F1: I'm afraid my tip isn't the most thrilling: http://enormo-haddock.blogspot.co.uk/2017/07/united-kingdom-pre-race-2017.html
On the plus side, I did have an 8 winner (effectively, it was 26 each way for pole for Raikkonen) pre-practice.
I cannot see May enjoying the conference season. Surely she is toasted enough already?
Blair got this
Cameron got this
May, Corbyn not so much.
The Labour party takes action against prominent members who express/endorse antisemitic views, such as Ken Livingstone and Naz Shah.
http://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/napoleons-army-may-have-suffered-from-the-greatest-wardrobe-malfunction-in-history-92535444/
In any case, the EU27 will be making the decisions - the 4 freedoms are fundamental to the EU (and EEA membership) and all 4 need to be accepted without caveats for a soft Brexit.
The seeds for Brexit were sown in autumn 1992 when the UK crashed out of the EEM. Its economy has not been fit to join the Euro (i.e. worse than Spain et al) and hence the UK has been on the outer fringe of the EU ever since. Look at how many Spanish companies now run or sell services to the UK - BAA/BA/CAF/Santander.
It made a change from the grim misery and support for the establishment offered by the other parties and by Labour in 2015.
I'm beginning to realise the penny will never drop for you poor souls.
"Mrs May is still in office because her party fears what it might do to itself in a chaotic and vicious Tory leadership contest. There is no widely agreed candidate to replace her as prime minister. There is no name that could be put to the cabinet and receive overwhelming support as the next occupant of Number 10."
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jul/16/theresa-may-could-still-have-a-future---as-a-human-sponge
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4027310/delusional-tony-blair-slammed-for-claiming-eu-wants-to-do-a-deal-on-migrants-to-block-brexit/
The polling is saying is that Brexit wasn't the main issue for Labour voters..
Doesn't mean they don't care about it.
Tbh that doesn't surprise me that much. If you really hated brexit you'd vote lib dems and the election didn't really focus all that much on Brexit.
In which case I prefer the workers Brexit to the bosses Brexit.
What stands out for me is how much of the Conservative vote was anti-Labour or anti-Corbyn. The equivalent among Labour supporters is much lower. Labour have serious brand problems.
https://twitter.com/KateHoeyMP/status/886214644389621760
It doesn't matter so much what people think now; it will matter hugely come 2019, when the bad news facing us will be all too clear.
Indeed I was thinking yeterday that the middle class's traditional support for the Tories rests principally on trusting their safer hands on the economy and otherwise wanting to be left alone. Consequently the Tories get in when they focus in economic competence, and get turfed out whenever Tories delude themselves that the support they get indicates desire for all the other Tory-political stuff, which in reality few people want. Labour and Tory being pretty much level in middle class support right now is striking.
The Tories' biggest problem right now is that their political obsession with the EU has once again led them to wander away from managing the economy.
Corbyn's Labour do better in real campaigns. Outside of the campaign polls flatter the Tories.
Would be rather ironic if you started to draw comfort from the polls that deceived you so recently.
Would you buy a reformed CAP from Mr Blair?
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/jun/06/theresa-may-rip-up-human-rights-laws-impede-new-terror-legislation
So, I voted for the anti-Brexit, Rupa Huq, in Ealing Central and Acton (with apologies to Topping and Nunu).
One reason exam pass rates went up year on year is that teachers and pupils became far more sophisticated in exam technique. We coffin-dodgers were expected to learn maths, say, or history, and then answer whatever questions were thrown at us.
These days, teachers teach narrowly to the test and pupils are drilled into how to analyse questions to provide exactly what is demanded -- even if they know nothing. If the question is about triangles but you can remember neither geometry nor trigonometry, then before skipping to the next question, at least draw a flaming triangle because there will be 1 or 2 marks (out of 20) for that tiny part of the full, correct answer.
But I think there is an anti-labour vote that's solid regardless of the leader.