Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » The LDs appear to have chosen their next two leaders without a

SystemSystem Posts: 12,260
edited June 2017 in General

imagepoliticalbetting.com » Blog Archive » The LDs appear to have chosen their next two leaders without a single vote being cast

The veteran former Business Secretary, Sir Vince Cable, has now moved to a 60%+ chance of becoming Farron’s successor following an extraordinary 36 hours when the party appears to have decided who should get the job AND who should succeed Vince.

Read the full story here


«134

Comments

  • JackWJackW Posts: 14,787
    OGH and Jnr for LibDem leader and deputy !!
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,274
    Second like the Democrats in Georgia.
  • DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    edited June 2017
    Young cardinals, old popes. Should we double up with Hammond (61) for the Conservatives?

    Edit: on second thoughts, that is probably why May is still there -- she is 60 and has not gone out of her way to discourage speculation about stepping down before the next election.
  • IcarusIcarus Posts: 994
    What about someone with age and gravitas - Jack W for leader (Mrs Jack W could have the luxury cobblers shadow portfolio)
  • IcarusIcarus Posts: 994
    Theresa May to govern with "humility and resolve" the DUP not being available (or Hammond not providing a big enough bribe)
  • DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    Icarus said:

    Theresa May to govern with "humility and resolve" the DUP not being available (or Hammond not providing a big enough bribe)

    Or Hammond has come up with the wonga and part of the deal is plausible deniability which would suit both parties -- the DUP after the pasting the LibDems took, and the Conservatives to avoid being tainted by the DUP's poor reputation on the mainland.
  • JackWJackW Posts: 14,787
    Icarus said:

    What about someone with age and gravitas - Jack W for leader (Mrs Jack W could have the luxury cobblers shadow portfolio)

    Talking cobblers again @Icarus .... :smile:
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,345
    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,345
    On topic, young Cardinals prefer an old Bishop of Rome.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,215
    Is Theresa not going to feel a mere stripling at 60 facing this lot? She may think she could have one more go to restore her reputation. Of course the party may think otherwise.

    As for Jo Swinson, have Lib Dem members not worked out she is a girl yet?
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,215

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    And they think that helps the UK's negotiating position how exactly?
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 43,718
    DavidL said:

    Is Theresa not going to feel a mere stripling at 60 facing this lot? She may think she could have one more go to restore her reputation. Of course the party may think otherwise.

    As for Jo Swinson, have Lib Dem members not worked out she is a girl yet?

    She must have had a hard paper round
  • philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780


    I guess that shows how stupid MPs can be.

    If the deal on offer is financially worse than no deal they want too take the worst option.

    It is a view. All views are pretty useless without the facts and terms of the negotiations. When you know what is available you can make a choice. Posturing before then is for precocious children.
  • PeterCPeterC Posts: 1,275
    DavidL said:

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    And they think that helps the UK's negotiating position how exactly?
    What is more, do they really understand Article 50?
  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,229
    Oh, that's odd.

    I was expecting a long sermon on how 'appointing leaders' was a bad thing and a 'full election campaign' would allow them to demonstrate their campaigning skills.

    But perhaps that only applies to Tories?
  • BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 8,755
    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.
  • philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704
    On topic, and you trust Vince, with his inflated opinion of himself and monstrous ego to step down in a couple of years? Don't forget he has pocket missiles to ward off attackers.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,215
    malcolmg said:

    DavidL said:

    Is Theresa not going to feel a mere stripling at 60 facing this lot? She may think she could have one more go to restore her reputation. Of course the party may think otherwise.

    As for Jo Swinson, have Lib Dem members not worked out she is a girl yet?

    She must have had a hard paper round
    I'm thinking maybe the name Jo has confused them.
  • AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 25,712

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
  • philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704
    edited June 2017
    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
  • AlanbrookeAlanbrooke Posts: 25,712
    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.
    a woman and ethnic

    LDs dont do either
  • Vince is a terrible idea. He's everything that's wrong about certain groups in politics in that he always seems quite insufferably smug.

    And standing behind Tim Farron at Farron's resignation he also looked old and knackered.
  • rkrkrkrkrkrk Posts: 8,407
    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    Elected five minutes ago and with a tiny majority.
    She might be a future leader - but surely too soon?
  • philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704

    Vince is a terrible idea. He's everything that's wrong about certain groups in politics in that he always seems quite insufferably smug.

    And standing behind Tim Farron at Farron's resignation he also looked old and knackered.

    Was he holding a heavy knife whilst strategically placed behind Farron?
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,215

    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.
    a woman and ethnic

    LDs dont do either
    In fairness her parents had excellent taste in music so we might be able to let them off the ethnic thing.
  • RogerRoger Posts: 20,062
    Just listening to an interview with Damian Green .....'But do you agree with Liam Fox that we have shared values with Roderigo Duterte of the Phillipines"



  • foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    edited June 2017
    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    I have no idea as to whether Moran plans to stand, but Barnesian is merely quoting from the LD website, which has potted biographies of all 12 MP's.

    http://www.libdems.org.uk/layla_moran

    I think Lamb will stand, and certainly there needs to be a contested election, coronations rarely end well. There needs to be a debate on future direction.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,215
    I hope Lamb in particular has the bottle to make a contest of this rather than a coronation. If Vince is the answer the Lib Dems are definitely asking the wrong question.
  • philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704
    edited June 2017

    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    I have no idea as to whether Moran plans to stand, but Barnesian is merely quoting from the LD website, which has potted biographies of all 12 MP's.

    http://www.libdems.org.uk/layla_moran
    WOW! The libdems website says she could be the stop Vince candidate. I'm shocked.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 57,892
    Early footage of Vince Cable discovered!

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXMapqiDsqs
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,345
    I want Norman Lamb to be the Lib Dem leader, he was an excellent Health Minister, plus his surname offers much potential for puns than Cable does.
  • philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704
    edited June 2017

    I want Norman Lamb to be the Lib Dem leader, he was an excellent Health Minister, plus his surname offers much potential for puns than Cable does.

    I don't know,

    Cable car crash.... for starters
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,345
    philiph said:

    I want Norman Lamb to be the Lib Dem leader, he was an excellent Health Minister, plus his surname offers much potential for puns than Cable does.

    I don't know,

    Cable car crash.... for starters
    If he plans high rates of taxation, 'Cable theft'
  • alex.alex. Posts: 4,658
    Presumably Vince remains a strong supporter of his tuition fees policy?
  • foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    philiph said:

    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    I have no idea as to whether Moran plans to stand, but Barnesian is merely quoting from the LD website, which has potted biographies of all 12 MP's.

    http://www.libdems.org.uk/layla_moran
    WOW! The libdems website says she could be the stop Vince candidate. I'm shocked.
    No, but the potted bio comes from there.

    I don't think the LDs should follow the Tories down the cul de sac of tokenism. The leadership should be about ideas and direction, not chromosomes. The Tories wanted another Maggie that way, and got a female Gordon Brown without the personal charm.

    The newbie MP's need to prove themselves in the Commons first.

    I will be voting against Cable, principally because of his record.
  • GeoffMGeoffM Posts: 6,071
    PeterC said:

    DavidL said:

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    And they think that helps the UK's negotiating position how exactly?
    What is more, do they really understand Article 50?
    646 days 4h 37 min left in the EU!
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,215
    This is really weird. French Ministers resigning because they have been abusing or falsely taking public money? Whatever next? I blame the heat, people are becoming irrational.
  • rkrkrkrkrkrk Posts: 8,407

    philiph said:

    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    I have no idea as to whether Moran plans to stand, but Barnesian is merely quoting from the LD website, which has potted biographies of all 12 MP's.

    http://www.libdems.org.uk/layla_moran
    WOW! The libdems website says she could be the stop Vince candidate. I'm shocked.
    No, but the potted bio comes from there.

    I don't think the LDs should follow the Tories down the cul de sac of tokenism. The leadership should be about ideas and direction, not chromosomes. The Tories wanted another Maggie that way, and got a female Gordon Brown without the personal charm.

    The newbie MP's need to prove themselves in the Commons first.

    I will be voting against Cable, principally because of his record.
    What don't you like in his record?
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,215

    philiph said:

    I want Norman Lamb to be the Lib Dem leader, he was an excellent Health Minister, plus his surname offers much potential for puns than Cable does.

    I don't know,

    Cable car crash.... for starters
    If he plans high rates of taxation, 'Cable theft'
    Cable hanging by a thread? Cable unwinds?

    But he is the wrong direction and tone for the Lib Dems.
  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,229
    edited June 2017
    Of course 'Cable' also refers to the GBP:USD exchange rate.....Cable falters, Cable plunges, Cable hits new low.....

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_(foreign_exchange)
  • philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704
    edited June 2017

    philiph said:

    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    I have no idea as to whether Moran plans to stand, but Barnesian is merely quoting from the LD website, which has potted biographies of all 12 MP's.

    http://www.libdems.org.uk/layla_moran
    WOW! The libdems website says she could be the stop Vince candidate. I'm shocked.
    No, but the potted bio comes from there.

    I don't think the LDs should follow the Tories down the cul de sac of tokenism. The leadership should be about ideas and direction, not chromosomes. The Tories wanted another Maggie that way, and got a female Gordon Brown without the personal charm.

    The newbie MP's need to prove themselves in the Commons first.

    I will be voting against Cable, principally because of his record.
    There is good reason to vote against Vince.

    Also it is a very negative message to be sending out.

    Will have this old codger for a couple of years, by then we hope someone else will be up to doing the job.

    The libdems should be sorting out a centre ground position that attracts sensible labour and sensible tory supporters.

    Both parties are ripe for pillaging of supporters.
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 43,919

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    Looks like the Conservative Party will have two competing sets of 'bastards' this time.

    The Eurosceptics might be getting a taste of their own medicine.
  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981

    philiph said:

    I want Norman Lamb to be the Lib Dem leader, he was an excellent Health Minister, plus his surname offers much potential for puns than Cable does.

    I don't know,

    Cable car crash.... for starters
    If he plans high rates of taxation, 'Cable theft'
    "Cable is 1.26" is nicely ambiguous ATM - is it an exchange rate or betting odds?
  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,229
    DavidL said:

    This is really weird. French Ministers resigning because they have been abusing or falsely taking public money? Whatever next? I blame the heat, people are becoming irrational.
    We'll know the world's turned upside down when one of them has to go for a sex scandal.....
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    Of course 'Cable' also refers to the GBP:USD exchange rate.....Cable falters, Cable plunges, Cable hits new low.....

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cable_(foreign_exchange)

    Cable knit
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 61,247

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 57,892
    DavidL said:

    philiph said:

    I want Norman Lamb to be the Lib Dem leader, he was an excellent Health Minister, plus his surname offers much potential for puns than Cable does.

    I don't know,

    Cable car crash.... for starters
    If he plans high rates of taxation, 'Cable theft'
    Cable hanging by a thread? Cable unwinds?

    But he is the wrong direction and tone for the Lib Dems.
    Milky milky.
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 43,919

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    LOL.

    Yes, just like the Eurosceptic 'bastards' didn't do with Major.
  • BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 8,755

    philiph said:

    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    I have no idea as to whether Moran plans to stand, but Barnesian is merely quoting from the LD website, which has potted biographies of all 12 MP's.

    http://www.libdems.org.uk/layla_moran
    WOW! The libdems website says she could be the stop Vince candidate. I'm shocked.
    No, but the potted bio comes from there.

    I don't think the LDs should follow the Tories down the cul de sac of tokenism. The leadership should be about ideas and direction, not chromosomes. The Tories wanted another Maggie that way, and got a female Gordon Brown without the personal charm.

    The newbie MP's need to prove themselves in the Commons first.

    I will be voting against Cable, principally because of his record.
    I'll be voting for Cable, in spite of his record (and his ego).
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,345

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    They've been taking lessons from IDS and Bill Cash.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 61,247

    Vince is a terrible idea. He's everything that's wrong about certain groups in politics in that he always seems quite insufferably smug.

    And standing behind Tim Farron at Farron's resignation he also looked old and knackered.

    As far as I can tell Cable's main qualification for the job seems to be that he cracked one good joke at the despatch box about 10 years ago.
  • MarkSeniorMarkSenior Posts: 4,699
    DavidL said:

    philiph said:

    I want Norman Lamb to be the Lib Dem leader, he was an excellent Health Minister, plus his surname offers much potential for puns than Cable does.

    I don't know,

    Cable car crash.... for starters
    If he plans high rates of taxation, 'Cable theft'
    Cable hanging by a thread? Cable unwinds?

    But he is the wrong direction and tone for the Lib Dems.
    Strong and Cable a tried and successful campaign slogan .
  • foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    rkrkrk said:

    philiph said:

    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    I have no idea as to whether Moran plans to stand, but Barnesian is merely quoting from the LD website, which has potted biographies of all 12 MP's.

    http://www.libdems.org.uk/layla_moran
    WOW! The libdems website says she could be the stop Vince candidate. I'm shocked.
    No, but the potted bio comes from there.

    I don't think the LDs should follow the Tories down the cul de sac of tokenism. The leadership should be about ideas and direction, not chromosomes. The Tories wanted another Maggie that way, and got a female Gordon Brown without the personal charm.

    The newbie MP's need to prove themselves in the Commons first.

    I will be voting against Cable, principally because of his record.
    What don't you like in his record?
    He was disloyal in coalition, architect of tuition fees and is too close to Labour.


  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,229

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    The Eurosceptics might be getting a taste of their own medicine.
    Much as it 'couldn't happen to nicer people' I hope all concerned are sensible (been at the gin? - ed.)
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,215

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    I worry that the modern Conservative party does not have the self discipline to cope with minority government. This sort of self indulgence is not encouraging.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,345

    Vince is a terrible idea. He's everything that's wrong about certain groups in politics in that he always seems quite insufferably smug.

    And standing behind Tim Farron at Farron's resignation he also looked old and knackered.

    As far as I can tell Cable's main qualification for the job seems to be that he cracked one good joke at the despatch box about 10 years ago.
    He was a very good Business Secretary who had the balls to do what Thatcher chickened out from doing, privatising Royal Mail.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453


    They've been taking lessons from IDS and Bill Cash.

    https://twitter.com/barristersecret/status/876893984840454144
  • BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 8,755
    edited June 2017

    rkrkrk said:

    philiph said:

    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    I have no idea as to whether Moran plans to stand, but Barnesian is merely quoting from the LD website, which has potted biographies of all 12 MP's.

    http://www.libdems.org.uk/layla_moran
    WOW! The libdems website says she could be the stop Vince candidate. I'm shocked.
    No, but the potted bio comes from there.

    I don't think the LDs should follow the Tories down the cul de sac of tokenism. The leadership should be about ideas and direction, not chromosomes. The Tories wanted another Maggie that way, and got a female Gordon Brown without the personal charm.

    The newbie MP's need to prove themselves in the Commons first.

    I will be voting against Cable, principally because of his record.
    What don't you like in his record?
    He was disloyal in coalition, architect of tuition fees and is too close to Labour.


    My problem with Cable is that he is the architect and defender of tuition fees, seller of Royal Mail at knockdown price and too close to the Tories (in spite of his Labour history).

    Edit: I don't mind his age. He is two weeks younger than me.
  • paulyork64paulyork64 Posts: 2,507
    Despi-Cable Me 3. Out in cinemas soon.

  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,520
    Morning all! Back after a week away from most internet and TV, nursing a massively reduced balance in the Betfair account. Big thanks to whoever tipped the Scottish Con >10 seats bet (@GeoffM?) as that was all that saved me from a four figure loss, finished about £700 in the red by the time it all played out, a severe lesson learned about 1/4 and 1/5 'value' bets getting overturned.

    Watching the events of the past ten days, I can't help the feeling that I don't understand the UK any more, maybe being abroad for 80% of the past decade has finally caught up with me? The overriding feeling is that everything is becoming massively polarised and politicised, more American and not in a good way. Everyone needs to chill out and calm down the language and rhetoric before we see serious civil disobedience on the streets.

    As one of many examples, how can a senior member of the opposition front bench honestly justify calling for a march on Parliament to overturn the election result, a week after the election took place? Did Corbyn actually suggest requisitioning property to deal with a few hundred homeless in a city with several hundred thousand hotel rooms?
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,520
    May - She's made it this far so leave in place, public gave her 13.6m votes a week ago, she can't be seen to go in the face of the mob nor replaced by yet another PM without a mandate. Osborne and 'friends' need to rein themselves in and get behind her, the papers are predictably be full of plot stories which need to be shut down quickly. Once QS is done she's probably okay for the summer if not for a couple of years. Letting Corbyn in on purpose, as suggested by Mr Herdson is IMO a mad idea. Election post-mortem needs to focus on why Labour's uncosted manifesto wasn't challenged and what happened with the social care policy in their own.

    Corbyn - missed in the chaos that was last week is that he did almost no reshuffle, all the big players are still on the backbenches and the cronies in the shadow cabinet so expect a return to their infighting in short order. Good to see that we saw McDonnell exposed for what he is with protests to overturn the election result. Corbyn needs to get a grip on this to avoid being overtaken by events and seen to support the summer's inevitable riots. His letter to the PM struck the right chord.

    Farron - sad to see him go, and that the modern liberal party have such illiberal values and are overcome by PC. Lamb to replace him maybe? Cable too old and too much baggage, Swinson probably a little young but will make a good deputy.
  • RogerRoger Posts: 20,062
    Having listened to an interview with the normally urbane Damian Green it's becoming clear that having taken possession of Brexit the Tories are entering a very dark place. Being forced to fawn over the likes of Duterte reminds me of a time when Pinochet was the pin-up boy

    No one does righteous indignation like Vince and now the youth have started voting it looks like he might be the perfect leader at the perfect moment.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,520
    edited June 2017
    Press - what a bad completely terrible week for them, both written and TV MSM on all sides full of conspiracy theories, Hillsborough comparisons and D-notices with this fire - not just metaphorically fanning the flames...

    George Osborne in particular is still the Class A c*** I described him as last week, he really needs to shut up given his very recent major role in government - his constant haranguing of his own party during the election campaign may well have been the difference between a majority and not, yet he appears determined to keep sticking the knife in and is outwardly enjoying it. Really not a good look.

    On one positive note, The Last Leg was the best programme on television last week, brilliantly humourous (especially all the politicians in comedy sketches) but I challenge anyone to watch it without a big box of tissues close to hand. Awesome TV, well done Channel 4 and all involved :+1:
  • peter_from_putneypeter_from_putney Posts: 6,956
    edited June 2017
    Off Topic

    Via Alliance News - Soros not backward in coming forward once again:

    Billionaire currency trader George Soros has said Britain is approaching a tipping point that could see the economy slow to such an extent that Brexit might even be reversed, Reuters reported on Tuesday.

    Soros used Quantum Fund in 1992 to bet successfully that sterling was over-valued against the Deutsche Mark, forcing then-Prime Minister John Major to pull the pound out of the European Exchange Rate Mechanism.

    Soros, in an article emailed to reporters, said economic reality was starting to catch up with a UK that voted 52% to 48% to leave the European Union in a June 23 referendum, according to Reuters.

    "The moment of truth is fast approaching," Soros said in the article. "The fact is that Brexit is a lose-lose proposition, harmful both to Britain and the European Union. It cannot be undone, but people can change their minds."

    Soros said that if Prime Minister Theresa May wanted to stay in power, she would have to change her approach and take account of young people who he said wanted to find well-paying jobs. She should, Soros said, seek to keep Britain in the EU's single market as Britain tried to extract itself.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 37,726

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    The Conservatives' most passionate and deep-rooted hatred is for each other.
  • Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 62,074
    Good morning, everyone.

    Very good threadstarter which explains something that had puzzled me yesterday. I'm a bit annoyed with myself for altering my positions (I'm actually not that much down on Cable relative to beforehand, but then I was green on Betfair as well, and had planned to lay the other two when I could).

    So, still ahead, but only on Ladbrokes. Bit of an admin cock-up on my part. Stupid Cable, announcing first.

    Mr. Sandpit, yeah, think it was Mr. M. I didn't back that. Humbug.
  • RogerRoger Posts: 20,062

    Vince is a terrible idea. He's everything that's wrong about certain groups in politics in that he always seems quite insufferably smug.

    And standing behind Tim Farron at Farron's resignation he also looked old and knackered.

    Old and knackered is fashionable. Get with the program
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 57,892
    Sandpit said:

    Farron - sad to see him go, and that the modern liberal party have such illiberal values and are overcome by PC. Lamb to replace him maybe? Cable too old and too much baggage, Swinson probably a little young but will make a good deputy.

    Sad to see Farron go? A shouty student politician who managed to see the LibDems go backwards in vote share when up against Corbyn and May.

    You might not like the way he was toppled, but the LDs should be very grateful.
  • rkrkrkrkrkrk Posts: 8,407
    Barnesian said:


    He was disloyal in coalition, architect of tuition fees and is too close to Labour.


    My problem with Cable is that he is the architect and defender of tuition fees, seller of Royal Mail at knockdown price and too close to the Tories (in spite of his Labour history).

    Edit: I don't mind his age. He is two weeks younger than me.
    Interesting clash of perspectives.

    On tuition fees - I do think the LDs made a big effort to make it fairer, once they knew they would break their promise. I shudder to think what the Tories would have done unfettered...

    Royal Mail a massive giveaway to investors and naively handled IMO.
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 42,359
    Cable laid.
    Nb: not actual betting advice.
  • fitalassfitalass Posts: 4,320
    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.



    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    .


    +1

  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    philiph said:

    I want Norman Lamb to be the Lib Dem leader, he was an excellent Health Minister, plus his surname offers much potential for puns than Cable does.

    I don't know,

    Cable car crash.... for starters
    Cabled ("cobbled") together?

    For the older amongst us Cable & Witless
  • MortimerMortimer Posts: 14,158
    How many recessions has cable predicted for this year, so far?
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    LOL.

    Yes, just like the Eurosceptic 'bastards' didn't do with Major.
    The difference was Maastricht was voted on in Parliament so they had a direct say. On this they don't, so it's just undermining the UK's negotiation position
  • TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633
    Happy Day of Rage to all Labour supporters and voters - hope the kettleing quality is up there with previous years.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 57,892
    Re Soros:

    The issue the UK has, and has had for some time, is that economy is fundamentally unbalanced.

    In the wake of the financial crisis, many countries were forced to fundamentally rebalance. Places like Spain needed to see dramatic falls in consumption and real wages to bring income and expense in-line.

    We did the opposite. Osborne and Cameron pursued a consumption first policy keep the economy moving. And it worked: our economy bounced back more quickly than those that went the other direction. But the price was high. We now run a horrendous trade deficit, and the UK has the lowest saving rate in 40 years (and quite possibly all time; I don't have a longer time series).

    This makes us uniquely vulnerable. If we slip into recession, the ability of the government to stimulate consumer spending (by adding yet more debt) is almost non-existent. Of course, we could add fiscal stimulus, but it is worth remembering that this would happen at a time when our budget deficit would be going in the wrong way already (and when our government debt levels are already elevated).

    The UK economy looks very like Spain in 2007: a low savings rate, a huge trade deficit, and a complacent view that the economic model is working.

    I fear we're going to hit a horrible economic roadblock almost completely unrelated to Brexit in the middle of Brexit negotiations. It will hammer the Conservative reputation for economic competence and potentially lead to a Corbyn or McDonnell government.
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 63,533
    Sean_F said:

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    The Conservatives' most passionate and deep-rooted hatred is for each other.
    Just to reiterate my prediction that Brexit won't actually happen.

    You can all start sending abuse now.
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,207

    DavidL said:

    philiph said:

    I want Norman Lamb to be the Lib Dem leader, he was an excellent Health Minister, plus his surname offers much potential for puns than Cable does.

    I don't know,

    Cable car crash.... for starters
    If he plans high rates of taxation, 'Cable theft'
    Cable hanging by a thread? Cable unwinds?

    But he is the wrong direction and tone for the Lib Dems.
    Strong and Cable a tried and successful campaign slogan .
    Well, he does have a nuclear missile
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    Barnesian said:

    rkrkrk said:

    philiph said:

    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    I have no idea as to whether Moran plans to stand, but Barnesian is merely quoting from the LD website, which has potted biographies of all 12 MP's.

    http://www.libdems.org.uk/layla_moran
    WOW! The libdems website says she could be the stop Vince candidate. I'm shocked.
    No, but the potted bio comes from there.

    I don't think the LDs should follow the Tories down the cul de sac of tokenism. The leadership should be about ideas and direction, not chromosomes. The Tories wanted another Maggie that way, and got a female Gordon Brown without the personal charm.

    The newbie MP's need to prove themselves in the Commons first.

    I will be voting against Cable, principally because of his record.
    What don't you like in his record?
    He was disloyal in coalition, architect of tuition fees and is too close to Labour.


    My problem with Cable is that he is the architect and defender of tuition fees, seller of Royal Mail at knockdown price and too close to the Tories (in spite of his Labour history).

    Edit: I don't mind his age. He is two weeks younger than me.
    It wasn't a knock down price. 3 years on the company is trading at IPO price. Which means the total shareholder return has been the dividend payments (@pulpstar). Not sure what the yield is but assuming 3-4%.

    If your pension fund had bought shares at, say, 600p and they were now trading at 450p I doubt you'd be congratulation the government on a job well done
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    If Jo Swinson isn't going to run (and her decision not to do so is a mistake in my opinion), Vince Cable is the right choice. The Lib Dems lack relevance most of all. Vince Cable remains box office and has a chance of getting them the airtime they need.

    The dry-as-dust Conservative Eurosceptic vote is not one he will be chasing in the short term, so the fact he annoys many pbers in that demographic probably isn't fatal to his chances with the public.
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,207
    TGOHF said:

    Happy Day of Rage to all Labour supporters and voters - hope the kettleing quality is up there with previous years.

    This year will be nothing, just wait til the trots get their "peoples militia" set up.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 61,247

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    They've been taking lessons from IDS and Bill Cash.
    Don't be enthusiastically factional.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 61,247
    DavidL said:

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    I worry that the modern Conservative party does not have the self discipline to cope with minority government. This sort of self indulgence is not encouraging.
    I despair.
  • Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 61,247
    rcs1000 said:

    Re Soros:

    The issue the UK has, and has had for some time, is that economy is fundamentally unbalanced.

    In the wake of the financial crisis, many countries were forced to fundamentally rebalance. Places like Spain needed to see dramatic falls in consumption and real wages to bring income and expense in-line.

    We did the opposite. Osborne and Cameron pursued a consumption first policy keep the economy moving. And it worked: our economy bounced back more quickly than those that went the other direction. But the price was high. We now run a horrendous trade deficit, and the UK has the lowest saving rate in 40 years (and quite possibly all time; I don't have a longer time series).

    This makes us uniquely vulnerable. If we slip into recession, the ability of the government to stimulate consumer spending (by adding yet more debt) is almost non-existent. Of course, we could add fiscal stimulus, but it is worth remembering that this would happen at a time when our budget deficit would be going in the wrong way already (and when our government debt levels are already elevated).

    The UK economy looks very like Spain in 2007: a low savings rate, a huge trade deficit, and a complacent view that the economic model is working.

    I fear we're going to hit a horrible economic roadblock almost completely unrelated to Brexit in the middle of Brexit negotiations. It will hammer the Conservative reputation for economic competence and potentially lead to a Corbyn or McDonnell government.

    It will be blamed on Brexit.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    Well behaved women seldom make history.
  • BromBrom Posts: 3,760

    Sean_F said:

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    The Conservatives' most passionate and deep-rooted hatred is for each other.
    Just to reiterate my prediction that Brexit won't actually happen.

    You can all start sending abuse now.
    My view is when people hear the speech at 11.30 today many of the remains few doubters will awake to the fact it's happening. A pivotal moment with even less scope for turning back judging by the content.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 54,215

    If Jo Swinson isn't going to run (and her decision not to do so is a mistake in my opinion), Vince Cable is the right choice. The Lib Dems lack relevance most of all. Vince Cable remains box office and has a chance of getting them the airtime they need.

    The dry-as-dust Conservative Eurosceptic vote is not one he will be chasing in the short term, so the fact he annoys many pbers in that demographic probably isn't fatal to his chances with the public.

    I agree about Jo Swinson. If she had the level of support that Mike indicates she should have gone for it now. There would have been time to learn on the job.
  • foxinsoxukfoxinsoxuk Posts: 23,548
    edited June 2017

    rcs1000 said:

    Re Soros:

    The issue the UK has, and has had for some time, is that economy is fundamentally unbalanced.

    In the wake of the financial crisis, many countries were forced to fundamentally rebalance. Places like Spain needed to see dramatic falls in consumption and real wages to bring income and expense in-line.

    We did the opposite. Osborne and Cameron pursued a consumption first policy keep the economy moving. And it worked: our economy bounced back more quickly than those that went the other direction. But the price was high. We now run a horrendous trade deficit, and the UK has the lowest saving rate in 40 years (and quite possibly all time; I don't have a longer time series).

    This makes us uniquely vulnerable. If we slip into recession, the ability of the government to stimulate consumer spending (by adding yet more debt) is almost non-existent. Of course, we could add fiscal stimulus, but it is worth remembering that this would happen at a time when our budget deficit would be going in the wrong way already (and when our government debt levels are already elevated).

    The UK economy looks very like Spain in 2007: a low savings rate, a huge trade deficit, and a complacent view that the economic model is working.

    I fear we're going to hit a horrible economic roadblock almost completely unrelated to Brexit in the middle of Brexit negotiations. It will hammer the Conservative reputation for economic competence and potentially lead to a Corbyn or McDonnell government.

    It will be blamed on Brexit.
    Brexit will be the trigger, and the state of the economy that RCS describes shows how poorly prepared we are economically. Hammond is right to prioritise jobs and business in the Brexit talks.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 57,892

    rcs1000 said:

    Re Soros:

    The issue the UK has, and has had for some time, is that economy is fundamentally unbalanced.

    In the wake of the financial crisis, many countries were forced to fundamentally rebalance. Places like Spain needed to see dramatic falls in consumption and real wages to bring income and expense in-line.

    We did the opposite. Osborne and Cameron pursued a consumption first policy keep the economy moving. And it worked: our economy bounced back more quickly than those that went the other direction. But the price was high. We now run a horrendous trade deficit, and the UK has the lowest saving rate in 40 years (and quite possibly all time; I don't have a longer time series).

    This makes us uniquely vulnerable. If we slip into recession, the ability of the government to stimulate consumer spending (by adding yet more debt) is almost non-existent. Of course, we could add fiscal stimulus, but it is worth remembering that this would happen at a time when our budget deficit would be going in the wrong way already (and when our government debt levels are already elevated).

    The UK economy looks very like Spain in 2007: a low savings rate, a huge trade deficit, and a complacent view that the economic model is working.

    I fear we're going to hit a horrible economic roadblock almost completely unrelated to Brexit in the middle of Brexit negotiations. It will hammer the Conservative reputation for economic competence and potentially lead to a Corbyn or McDonnell government.

    It will be blamed on Brexit.
    Of course. And SeanT will have an epic meltdown because his Camden Primrose Hill apartment is not worth what he paid for it.

    As an aside, Osborne and Cameron need to take a fair amount of the blame. They chose the path of stimulating consumption over rebalancing. The solution to "too much debt" is never "more debt". Yet they will instead snipe from the sidelines.

    And then we will elect the equivalent of a Syriza government.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    TGOHF said:

    Happy Day of Rage to all Labour supporters and voters - hope the kettleing quality is up there with previous years.

    https://twitter.com/tnewtondunn/status/877422945932595200
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 63,533
    Brom said:

    Sean_F said:

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    The Conservatives' most passionate and deep-rooted hatred is for each other.
    Just to reiterate my prediction that Brexit won't actually happen.

    You can all start sending abuse now.
    My view is when people hear the speech at 11.30 today many of the remains few doubters will awake to the fact it's happening. A pivotal moment with even less scope for turning back judging by the content.
    You could argue that twelve months on, I am stuck in the denial stage of grief. I accept this is possible. I think though it's not denial, but thinking that the the state of the economy is so poor (and getting worse as we enter another recession) that Brexit will not be deliverable.

    The people will change their minds.

    I guess there's only a few like me and Nick Clegg and Ken Clarke clinging to this now.
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,207
    Scott_P said:

    TGOHF said:

    Happy Day of Rage to all Labour supporters and voters - hope the kettleing quality is up there with previous years.

    https://twitter.com/tnewtondunn/status/877422945932595200
    All rather fair comment
  • rkrkrkrkrkrk Posts: 8,407
    Charles said:

    Barnesian said:

    rkrkrk said:

    philiph said:

    philiph said:

    Barnesian said:

    Layla Moran, age 34, LibDem MP for Oxford West and Abingdon, could be the "Stop Vince Cable" candidate. Her mother is a Christian Arab from Jerusalem, and her father is a British EU Ambassador. She has lived in many countries including Belgium, Greece, Ethiopia, Jamaica and Jordan and speaks French fluently along with some Spanish, Arabic and Greek.

    None of which qualify you as a leader or indicate you have leadership skills.

    Edit. Personally I think the best stop Vince candidate is Vince Cable
    I have no idea as to whether Moran plans to stand, but Barnesian is merely quoting from the LD website, which has potted biographies of all 12 MP's.

    http://www.libdems.org.uk/layla_moran
    WOW! The libdems website says she could be the stop Vince candidate. I'm shocked.
    No, but the potted bio comes from there.

    I don't think the LDs should follow the Tories down the cul de sac of tokenism. The leadership should be about ideas and direction, not chromosomes. The Tories wanted another Maggie that way, and got a female Gordon Brown without the personal charm.

    The newbie MP's need to prove themselves in the Commons first.

    I will be voting against Cable, principally because of his record.
    What don't you like in his record?
    He was disloyal in coalition, architect of tuition fees and is too close to Labour.


    My problem with Cable is that he is the architect and defender of tuition fees, seller of Royal Mail at knockdown price and too close to the Tories (in spite of his Labour history).

    Edit: I don't mind his age. He is two weeks younger than me.
    It wasn't a knock down price. 3 years on the company is trading at IPO price. Which means the total shareholder return has been the dividend payments (@pulpstar). Not sure what the yield is but assuming 3-4%.

    If your pension fund had bought shares at, say, 600p and they were now trading at 450p I doubt you'd be congratulation the government on a job well done
    Is that correct? This says shares sold at 330p and taxpayers lost £1bn.

    http://www.bbc.com/news/business-28250963
  • FF43FF43 Posts: 17,405
    rcs1000 said:

    Re Soros:

    The issue the UK has, and has had for some time, is that economy is fundamentally unbalanced.

    In the wake of the financial crisis, many countries were forced to fundamentally rebalance. Places like Spain needed to see dramatic falls in consumption and real wages to bring income and expense in-line.

    We did the opposite. Osborne and Cameron pursued a consumption first policy keep the economy moving. And it worked: our economy bounced back more quickly than those that went the other direction. But the price was high. We now run a horrendous trade deficit, and the UK has the lowest saving rate in 40 years (and quite possibly all time; I don't have a longer time series).

    This makes us uniquely vulnerable. If we slip into recession, the ability of the government to stimulate consumer spending (by adding yet more debt) is almost non-existent. Of course, we could add fiscal stimulus, but it is worth remembering that this would happen at a time when our budget deficit would be going in the wrong way already (and when our government debt levels are already elevated).

    The UK economy looks very like Spain in 2007: a low savings rate, a huge trade deficit, and a complacent view that the economic model is working.

    I fear we're going to hit a horrible economic roadblock almost completely unrelated to Brexit in the middle of Brexit negotiations. It will hammer the Conservative reputation for economic competence and potentially lead to a Corbyn or McDonnell government.

    At the very least Brexit is a huge distraction from dealing with our real problems.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 57,892
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,345

    At least 30 Conservative MPs have indicated to their own Government that they will not accept leaving the European Union without an agreed deal.

    Sky News has been told the MPs informed whips that the economic impact of a "cliff-edge" Brexit, alongside the failure of the Conservatives to win a majority for its manifesto, should lead to a rethink of the position that "no deal is better than a bad deal".

    http://news.sky.com/story/amp/no-brexit-deal-unacceptable-30-tory-mps-tell-number-10-10921780

    lol

    poor old tezza

    she holds an election so the headbangers cant blackmail her and instead the Diane Abbott wing of the party do
    I can't say I'm surprised but this is the sort of behaviour that will tear the Conservatives apart in office.

    They should go and make representations to May privately and always back her publicly.
    They've been taking lessons from IDS and Bill Cash.
    Don't be enthusiastically factional.
    I'm not.

    I'm just amused by the irony and hypocrisy.
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,207
    rcs1000 said:

    rcs1000 said:

    Re Soros:

    The issue the UK has, and has had for some time, is that economy is fundamentally unbalanced.

    In the wake of the financial crisis, many countries were forced to fundamentally rebalance. Places like Spain needed to see dramatic falls in consumption and real wages to bring income and expense in-line.

    We did the opposite. Osborne and Cameron pursued a consumption first policy keep the economy moving. And it worked: our economy bounced back more quickly than those that went the other direction. But the price was high. We now run a horrendous trade deficit, and the UK has the lowest saving rate in 40 years (and quite possibly all time; I don't have a longer time series).

    This makes us uniquely vulnerable. If we slip into recession, the ability of the government to stimulate consumer spending (by adding yet more debt) is almost non-existent. Of course, we could add fiscal stimulus, but it is worth remembering that this would happen at a time when our budget deficit would be going in the wrong way already (and when our government debt levels are already elevated).

    The UK economy looks very like Spain in 2007: a low savings rate, a huge trade deficit, and a complacent view that the economic model is working.

    I fear we're going to hit a horrible economic roadblock almost completely unrelated to Brexit in the middle of Brexit negotiations. It will hammer the Conservative reputation for economic competence and potentially lead to a Corbyn or McDonnell government.

    It will be blamed on Brexit.
    Of course. And SeanT will have an epic meltdown because his Camden Primrose Hill apartment is? not worth what he paid for it.

    As an aside, Osborne and Cameron need to take a fair amount of the blame. They chose the path of stimulating consumption over rebalancing. The solution to "too much debt" is never "more debt". Yet they will instead snipe from the sidelines.

    And then we will elect the equivalent of a Syriza government.
    We are utterly fecked aren't we.

    Odds on the enthusiastic Corbynistas (including late converts) slinking away when it all goes south, as it will, in spades?

  • PatrickPatrick Posts: 225
    FF43 said:

    rcs1000 said:

    Re Soros:

    The issue the UK has, and has had for some time, is that economy is fundamentally unbalanced.

    In the wake of the financial crisis, many countries were forced to fundamentally rebalance. Places like Spain needed to see dramatic falls in consumption and real wages to bring income and expense in-line.

    We did the opposite. Osborne and Cameron pursued a consumption first policy keep the economy moving. And it worked: our economy bounced back more quickly than those that went the other direction. But the price was high. We now run a horrendous trade deficit, and the UK has the lowest saving rate in 40 years (and quite possibly all time; I don't have a longer time series).

    This makes us uniquely vulnerable. If we slip into recession, the ability of the government to stimulate consumer spending (by adding yet more debt) is almost non-existent. Of course, we could add fiscal stimulus, but it is worth remembering that this would happen at a time when our budget deficit would be going in the wrong way already (and when our government debt levels are already elevated).

    The UK economy looks very like Spain in 2007: a low savings rate, a huge trade deficit, and a complacent view that the economic model is working.

    I fear we're going to hit a horrible economic roadblock almost completely unrelated to Brexit in the middle of Brexit negotiations. It will hammer the Conservative reputation for economic competence and potentially lead to a Corbyn or McDonnell government.

    At the very least Brexit is a huge distraction from dealing with our real problems.
    Unfortunately we just discovered that there are no votes in dealing with our problems. Voters actually think we've been experiencing austerity. Shit's gonna get ALOT worse before it gets better.
This discussion has been closed.