Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Theresa May – the first national polling since she became P

24

Comments

  • glwglw Posts: 10,019

    I see this poll busts another false narrative that was pushed in some quarters of this nationwide regret & mass desire for a second referendum / chance to change our mind.

    This polling tallies with my personal experience working in a heavily remain dominated sector that think it is the wrong outcome but are just getting on with things with the assumption it is going to happen in the next few years.

    It's typical behaviour for referendum losers to assert that the voters for the winning side are having second thoughts, or that they are thick and didn't understand the question, or that the campaign lied and cheated.
  • JWisemannJWisemann Posts: 1,082

    John_M said:

    On topic, even allowing for the fact these figures are the apotheosis of Theresa May's honeymoon, these are horrific numbers for Corbyn and Labour.

    @MSmithsonPB: By 40% to 36% LAB GE2015 voters tell ComRes that May would make a better PM than Corbyn.

    AND AND Mrs May is beating Jez by nearly 10 to 1 with over 65s

    77% of those aged 65+ think that Theresa May would make a better PM, compared to 8% who said the same for Corbyn

    Do you know, I'm beginning to suspect that Mr Corbyn is a bit crap. I don't know why. Possibly I'm psychic.
    Corbyn knows he is crap. He is but John the baptist. He will stay until he is confident that someone from the hard left with charisma and ability can safely succeed him and then bide his time until the Tory party is exhausted from office and/or events discredit them - then will come the Glorious Day when Britain embraces true socialism, and heaven help us if that day arrives.

    These guys are long term planners.
    Corbyn is soft left these days (basic social democracy). It is just a sign of how far right the seditious wing of the party has gone that they can paint him as beyond the pale. Which in turn is why vast swathes of very moderate normal membership like myself are getting ever firmer behind him.
  • DadgeDadge Posts: 2,052

    I see this poll busts another false narrative that was pushed in some quarters of this nationwide regret & mass desire for a second referendum / chance to change our mind.

    This polling tallies with my personal experience working in a heavily remain dominated sector that think it is the wrong outcome but are just getting on with things with the assumption it is going to happen in the next few years.

    It's only a particular faction of Remainers who've been calling for a second referendum. At this early stage of Brexit the concept of a second referendum is wishy-washy wishful thinking. As Brexit unfolds, people's opinions of it will form and perhaps then it might appear to a plurality of people that a referendum is needed, but for the time being it's up to the government to decide whether and how the will of the people should be interpreted.
  • anotherDaveanotherDave Posts: 6,746
    The only group who prefer Cameron to May are young voters. Doesn't look like he made much of an impact on the electorate.

    p.4
    http://www.comres.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Independent_SundayMirror_July2016-Poll_tables.pdf
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,411

    Not necessarily, they could be really poor books
    Glen's a friend, and I've read the first book, so I'm a little biased but I enjoyed it.
  • SandraMSandraM Posts: 206

    I can't help thinking that the only way to understand what is going on in France is to view it as a sequel of The Algerian War.

    I watched the film "The Battle of Algiers" about six months ago and I have been thinking on those lines. I'd advise anyone who hasn't seen the film to watch it.
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,769
    edited July 2016
    JWisemann said:

    John_M said:

    On topic, even allowing for the fact these figures are the apotheosis of Theresa May's honeymoon, these are horrific numbers for Corbyn and Labour.

    @MSmithsonPB: By 40% to 36% LAB GE2015 voters tell ComRes that May would make a better PM than Corbyn.

    AND AND Mrs May is beating Jez by nearly 10 to 1 with over 65s

    77% of those aged 65+ think that Theresa May would make a better PM, compared to 8% who said the same for Corbyn

    Do you know, I'm beginning to suspect that Mr Corbyn is a bit crap. I don't know why. Possibly I'm psychic.
    Corbyn knows he is crap. He is but John the baptist. He will stay until he is confident that someone from the hard left with charisma and ability can safely succeed him and then bide his time until the Tory party is exhausted from office and/or events discredit them - then will come the Glorious Day when Britain embraces true socialism, and heaven help us if that day arrives.

    These guys are long term planners.
    Corbyn is soft left these days (basic social democracy). It is just a sign of how far right the seditious wing of the party has gone that they can paint him as beyond the pale. Which in turn is why vast swathes of very moderate normal membership like myself are getting ever firmer behind him.
    It's not a question of left vs right anymore. It's a question of avoiding annihilation. Those still fighting Blairites or fighting Trots need to wake up to that. They are fighting the last war.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,158
    Excellent poll. ComRes confirmed as new Gold Standard :D
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 22,450
    edited July 2016

    On topic, even allowing for the fact these figures are the apotheosis of Theresa May's honeymoon, these are horrific numbers for Corbyn and Labour.

    @MSmithsonPB: By 40% to 36% LAB GE2015 voters tell ComRes that May would make a better PM than Corbyn.

    AND AND Mrs May is beating Jez by nearly 10 to 1 with over 65s

    77% of those aged 65+ think that Theresa May would make a better PM, compared to 8% who said the same for Corbyn

    If she can orchestrate a crisis that would require an autumn election it must be tempting on these numbers...

    Enter Nicola, stage left? ;)
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,411
    RobD said:

    Excellent poll. ComRes confirmed as new Gold Standard :D

    The scientist in you is going to love my morning thread, especially the opening.

    Everyone else, it contains rancorous filth.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,158
    edited July 2016

    RobD said:

    Excellent poll. ComRes confirmed as new Gold Standard :D

    The scientist in you is going to love my morning thread, especially the opening.

    Everyone else, it contains rancorous filth.
    Then I will love all of the thread (especially the rancorous bit) :p
  • jonny83jonny83 Posts: 1,270
    Terribad polling for Labour. Seen one Labour MP already tweeting the 40% of Lab GE2015 voters prefer May over Corbyn polling.
  • HurstLlamaHurstLlama Posts: 9,098
    JWisemann said:

    I see this poll busts another false narrative that was pushed in some quarters of this nationwide regret & mass desire for a second referendum / chance to change our mind.

    This polling tallies with my personal experience working in a heavily remain dominated sector that think it is the wrong outcome but are just getting on with things with the assumption it is going to happen in the next few years.

    I think a lot of Remainers are putting their faith in the good old British Establishment to set its wheels in motion and ensure that in reality very little actually changes.
    If so, Mr Wisemann, I fear those people are going to be terribly disappointed. I sense that the political wind has changed in a way that it hasn't since just after the 1983 election. For good or ill, I think TM is taking us off in a new direction.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    Interesting historical US election table

    image
  • anotherDaveanotherDave Posts: 6,746
    Deutsche Welle had a good 'why France again?' article. Their reasoning:

    1. French military active in Iraq and Syria
    2. large muslim population, dual citizenship common.
    3. high unemployment amongst young immigrant community
    4. easier to get to france from middle east than USA/UK.

    http://www.dw.com/en/why-france-again/a-19403348
  • nunununu Posts: 6,024

    Deutsche Welle had a good 'why France again?' article. Their reasoning:

    1. French military active in Iraq and Syria
    2. large muslim population, dual citizenship common.
    3. high unemployment amongst young immigrant community
    4. easier to get to france from middle east than USA/UK.

    http://www.dw.com/en/why-france-again/a-19403348
    also muslim population are msinly from Arab countries.
  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503
    jonny83 said:

    Terribad polling for Labour. Seen one Labour MP already tweeting the 40% of Lab GE2015 voters prefer May over Corbyn polling.

    Shh. It's only a poll. Nothing to see here, move right along.
  • nunununu Posts: 6,024
    GIN1138 said:

    On topic, even allowing for the fact these figures are the apotheosis of Theresa May's honeymoon, these are horrific numbers for Corbyn and Labour.

    @MSmithsonPB: By 40% to 36% LAB GE2015 voters tell ComRes that May would make a better PM than Corbyn.

    AND AND Mrs May is beating Jez by nearly 10 to 1 with over 65s

    77% of those aged 65+ think that Theresa May would make a better PM, compared to 8% who said the same for Corbyn

    If she can orchestrate a crisis that would require an autumn election it must be tempting on these numbers...

    Enter Nicola, stage left? ;)
    Enter the Turkish millatry.
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,769
    nunu said:

    Deutsche Welle had a good 'why France again?' article. Their reasoning:

    1. French military active in Iraq and Syria
    2. large muslim population, dual citizenship common.
    3. high unemployment amongst young immigrant community
    4. easier to get to france from middle east than USA/UK.

    http://www.dw.com/en/why-france-again/a-19403348
    also muslim population are msinly from Arab countries.
    French terrorism has a long history. Was caught in the aftermath of this.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1995_Paris_Métro_and_RER_bombings
  • PongPong Posts: 4,693
    edited July 2016
    74% of leavers dissatisfied if we continue to allow EU immigration in return for access to single market.

    P15

    http://www.comres.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/BBC-News_Tables_Brexit-Expectations_11072016.pdf

    This ain't going to be a happy Brexit.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,411
    RobD said:

    RobD said:

    Excellent poll. ComRes confirmed as new Gold Standard :D

    The scientist in you is going to love my morning thread, especially the opening.

    Everyone else, it contains rancorous filth.
    Then I will love all of the thread (especially the rancorous bit) :p
    I should stress the science bit is the filth as well
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,158
    Pong said:

    74% of leavers dissatisfied if we continue to allow EU immigration in return for access to single market.

    P15

    http://www.comres.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/BBC-News_Tables_Brexit-Expectations_11072016.pdf

    This ain't going to be a happy Brexit.

    Unless that doesn't happen, of course.
  • ParistondaParistonda Posts: 1,843

    I see this poll busts another false narrative that was pushed in some quarters of this nationwide regret & mass desire for a second referendum / chance to change our mind.

    This polling tallies with my personal experience working in a heavily remain dominated sector that think it is the wrong outcome but are just getting on with things with the assumption it is going to happen in the next few years.

    To be fair if we had voted 52-48 remain, there would have been Leavers calling for a re-run at the earliest possibility as well. Nigel Farage said as much himself, and the petition to rerun the referendum was actually set up by a leaver before the referendum results when he expected to lose.
  • glwglw Posts: 10,019

    To be fair if we had voted 52-48 remain, there would have been Leavers calling for a re-run at the earliest possibility as well. Nigel Farage said as much himself, and the petition to rerun the referendum was actually set up by a leaver before the referendum results when he expected to lose.

    So what you are saying is that the remainer losers calling for a rerun are like Nigel Farage? ;)
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,405

    RobD said:

    Excellent poll. ComRes confirmed as new Gold Standard :D

    The scientist in you is going to love my morning thread, especially the opening.

    Everyone else, it contains rancorous filth.
    Who's your new Avatar?
  • PongPong Posts: 4,693
    edited July 2016
    53% of leavers expect the economy to be better in 2 years' time. Only 19% expect it to be worse.

    p26.

    http://www.comres.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/BBC-News_Tables_Brexit-Expectations_11072016.pdf

    Boris is going to have some explainin' to do.
  • PongPong Posts: 4,693
    edited July 2016
    50% of brexiters expect a fall in unemployment within a couple of years. Just 12% think it'll rise.

    p28.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,411

    RobD said:

    Excellent poll. ComRes confirmed as new Gold Standard :D

    The scientist in you is going to love my morning thread, especially the opening.

    Everyone else, it contains rancorous filth.
    Who's your new Avatar?
    Former Girls Aloud member and future member of my harem, Kimberley Walsh
  • bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 22,768
    edited July 2016
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 52,920
    John_M said:

    Of course, there is always the possibility of Euro-fudge. Germany is currently undergoing a long dark teatime of the soul on FoM. However, Davis is irritating the living fuck out of me by peddling this 'tariff-free access to SIngle Market, no problemo mate' line.

    Nevertheless I think he's right. When was the last time tariffs between western countries went up.
  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503
    edited July 2016
    MT
  • nunununu Posts: 6,024
    Slightly fewer people calling the Tory nasty, how does that feel.
  • MarkHopkinsMarkHopkins Posts: 5,584
    John_M said:

    John_M said:

    Of course, there is always the possibility of Euro-fudge. Germany is currently undergoing a long dark teatime of the soul on FoM. However, Davis is irritating the living fuck out of me by peddling this 'tariff-free access to SIngle Market, no problemo mate' line.

    Nevertheless I think he's right. When was the last time tariffs between western countries went up.
    https://twitter.com/afneil/status/753682339532836868

    In one tweet, why we were right to leave.

  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503
    John_M said:

    John_M said:

    Of course, there is always the possibility of Euro-fudge. Germany is currently undergoing a long dark teatime of the soul on FoM. However, Davis is irritating the living fuck out of me by peddling this 'tariff-free access to SIngle Market, no problemo mate' line.

    Nevertheless I think he's right. When was the last time tariffs between western countries went up.
    https://twitter.com/afneil/status/753682339532836868
    Tariff levels aren't the problem. With the GBP devaluation, we could live with WTO access on goods right now. They could crucify us with NTMs and TBTs. If you look at the WTO site itself, you can see that this kind of protectionism is on the rise.
  • SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 39,783
    JWisemann said:

    John_M said:

    On topic, even allowing for the fact these figures are the apotheosis of Theresa May's honeymoon, these are horrific numbers for Corbyn and Labour.

    @MSmithsonPB: By 40% to 36% LAB GE2015 voters tell ComRes that May would make a better PM than Corbyn.

    AND AND Mrs May is beating Jez by nearly 10 to 1 with over 65s

    77% of those aged 65+ think that Theresa May would make a better PM, compared to 8% who said the same for Corbyn

    Do you know, I'm beginning to suspect that Mr Corbyn is a bit crap. I don't know why. Possibly I'm psychic.
    Corbyn knows he is crap. He is but John the baptist. He will stay until he is confident that someone from the hard left with charisma and ability can safely succeed him and then bide his time until the Tory party is exhausted from office and/or events discredit them - then will come the Glorious Day when Britain embraces true socialism, and heaven help us if that day arrives.

    These guys are long term planners.
    Corbyn is soft left these days (basic social democracy). It is just a sign of how far right the seditious wing of the party has gone that they can paint him as beyond the pale. Which in turn is why vast swathes of very moderate normal membership like myself are getting ever firmer behind him.

    That'll teach the Blairites :-D

  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 52,920

    John_M said:

    John_M said:

    Of course, there is always the possibility of Euro-fudge. Germany is currently undergoing a long dark teatime of the soul on FoM. However, Davis is irritating the living fuck out of me by peddling this 'tariff-free access to SIngle Market, no problemo mate' line.

    Nevertheless I think he's right. When was the last time tariffs between western countries went up.
    https://twitter.com/afneil/status/753682339532836868

    In one tweet, why we were right to leave.
    Because it will be lethal for the EU? ;)
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,405

    RobD said:

    Excellent poll. ComRes confirmed as new Gold Standard :D

    The scientist in you is going to love my morning thread, especially the opening.

    Everyone else, it contains rancorous filth.
    Who's your new Avatar?
    Former Girls Aloud member and future member of my harem, Kimberley Walsh
    Ah, I see, didn't recognise her (though I have heard of her :)
  • nunununu Posts: 6,024

    I can't help thinking that the only way to understand what is going on in France is to view it as a sequel of The Algerian War.

    That would be unhelpful, they wanted something tangiable to negotiate we can't negotiate with ISIS.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 120,411
    Last week, some wise fellow tipped 2019 as our Brexit date

    https://twitter.com/hendopolis/status/754421263104368640
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    No link for this yet

    @ZoraSuleman: ICM survey for The Sun on Sunday shows the Tories now have a 10-point lead over Labour - a 2-point increase on the last opinion poll.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 52,920
    nunu said:

    I can't help thinking that the only way to understand what is going on in France is to view it as a sequel of The Algerian War.

    That would be unhelpful, they wanted something tangiable to negotiate we can't negotiate with ISIS.
    They want something tangible too: France.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,405
    nunu said:

    Slightly fewer people calling the Tory nasty, how does that feel.
    First we have Crooked Hillary, now Nasty Jeremy :lol:
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,405
    glw said:

    To be fair if we had voted 52-48 remain, there would have been Leavers calling for a re-run at the earliest possibility as well. Nigel Farage said as much himself, and the petition to rerun the referendum was actually set up by a leaver before the referendum results when he expected to lose.

    So what you are saying is that the remainer losers calling for a rerun are like Nigel Farage? ;)
    REMOANERS :lol:

    :lol::lol:
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 21,769
    SeanT said:

    Off-topic:

    I think I need to lose some weight. My two-year old just pointed at a picture of a lying-down frog in a nursery rhyme book and said: "Daddy!"

    Be of good cheer. I knew when I had to lose weight (and how) when three things happened.

    1. My older daughter, then age 6, started spontaneously calling me "Big Fat Daddy"

    2. My father referred to me, playfully, as "looking like Henry the Eighth"

    3. Worst of all, I got so tubby I literally burst a belt. A strong leather belt with a fat steel buckle.


    At that point I got a grip, and lost 25 pounds, and I've never regained it. With health apps and modern scales it's quite easy to lose weight: you simply stop eating until you are the weight desired (and eat fruit for energy in between).
    What apps, scales?
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @SBuckinghamUK: Let's be clear they aren't saying don't to it. They are saying don't get caught. New politics. https://t.co/AiXrz8tpjh
  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503
    Jonathan said:

    SeanT said:

    Off-topic:

    I think I need to lose some weight. My two-year old just pointed at a picture of a lying-down frog in a nursery rhyme book and said: "Daddy!"

    Be of good cheer. I knew when I had to lose weight (and how) when three things happened.

    1. My older daughter, then age 6, started spontaneously calling me "Big Fat Daddy"

    2. My father referred to me, playfully, as "looking like Henry the Eighth"

    3. Worst of all, I got so tubby I literally burst a belt. A strong leather belt with a fat steel buckle.


    At that point I got a grip, and lost 25 pounds, and I've never regained it. With health apps and modern scales it's quite easy to lose weight: you simply stop eating until you are the weight desired (and eat fruit for energy in between).
    What apps, scales?
    I love my Fitbit + Fitbit Aria. Lost 4 stone (put 1 stone back on due to my leg injury. Nothing to do these days but graze and post on PB :) ). Gamification of weight loss works for me.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 52,920
    John_M said:

    Jonathan said:

    SeanT said:

    Off-topic:

    I think I need to lose some weight. My two-year old just pointed at a picture of a lying-down frog in a nursery rhyme book and said: "Daddy!"

    Be of good cheer. I knew when I had to lose weight (and how) when three things happened.

    1. My older daughter, then age 6, started spontaneously calling me "Big Fat Daddy"

    2. My father referred to me, playfully, as "looking like Henry the Eighth"

    3. Worst of all, I got so tubby I literally burst a belt. A strong leather belt with a fat steel buckle.


    At that point I got a grip, and lost 25 pounds, and I've never regained it. With health apps and modern scales it's quite easy to lose weight: you simply stop eating until you are the weight desired (and eat fruit for energy in between).
    What apps, scales?
    I love my Fitbit + Fitbit Aria. Lost 4 stone (put 1 stone back on due to my leg injury. Nothing to do these days but graze and post on PB :) ). Gamification of weight loss works for me.
    Try hunting some Pokemon.
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,726
    Jonathan said:

    nunu said:

    Deutsche Welle had a good 'why France again?' article. Their reasoning:

    1. French military active in Iraq and Syria
    2. large muslim population, dual citizenship common.
    3. high unemployment amongst young immigrant community
    4. easier to get to france from middle east than USA/UK.

    http://www.dw.com/en/why-france-again/a-19403348
    also muslim population are msinly from Arab countries.
    French terrorism has a long history. Was caught in the aftermath of this.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1995_Paris_Métro_and_RER_bombings
    nunu said:

    Deutsche Welle had a good 'why France again?' article. Their reasoning:

    1. French military active in Iraq and Syria
    2. large muslim population, dual citizenship common.
    3. high unemployment amongst young immigrant community
    4. easier to get to france from middle east than USA/UK.

    http://www.dw.com/en/why-france-again/a-19403348
    also muslim population are msinly from Arab countries.
    I would suggest that it is also worth looking at the events of October 1961 in Paris for other reasons why Algerian French particularly feel resentment towards their adopted country.
  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503

    John_M said:

    Jonathan said:

    SeanT said:

    Off-topic:

    I think I need to lose some weight. My two-year old just pointed at a picture of a lying-down frog in a nursery rhyme book and said: "Daddy!"

    Be of good cheer. I knew when I had to lose weight (and how) when three things happened.

    1. My older daughter, then age 6, started spontaneously calling me "Big Fat Daddy"

    2. My father referred to me, playfully, as "looking like Henry the Eighth"

    3. Worst of all, I got so tubby I literally burst a belt. A strong leather belt with a fat steel buckle.


    At that point I got a grip, and lost 25 pounds, and I've never regained it. With health apps and modern scales it's quite easy to lose weight: you simply stop eating until you are the weight desired (and eat fruit for energy in between).
    What apps, scales?
    I love my Fitbit + Fitbit Aria. Lost 4 stone (put 1 stone back on due to my leg injury. Nothing to do these days but graze and post on PB :) ). Gamification of weight loss works for me.
    Try hunting some Pokemon.
    I can't walk very well atm. I manage 45 minutes per day. Pokemon are probably a bit beyond me for a while. Do love all the vids of the nerds staggering about under the blazing heat of the daystar though.
  • TomsToms Posts: 2,478
    Okay. Corbyn is weak and incompetent. Next.

    Irrelevant remark: I saw a family of four today, two teenagers and parents, having coffees. They were all lean and, apparently healthy.
    Just like the old days.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 52,405

    Jonathan said:

    nunu said:

    Deutsche Welle had a good 'why France again?' article. Their reasoning:

    1. French military active in Iraq and Syria
    2. large muslim population, dual citizenship common.
    3. high unemployment amongst young immigrant community
    4. easier to get to france from middle east than USA/UK.

    http://www.dw.com/en/why-france-again/a-19403348
    also muslim population are msinly from Arab countries.
    French terrorism has a long history. Was caught in the aftermath of this.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1995_Paris_Métro_and_RER_bombings
    nunu said:

    Deutsche Welle had a good 'why France again?' article. Their reasoning:

    1. French military active in Iraq and Syria
    2. large muslim population, dual citizenship common.
    3. high unemployment amongst young immigrant community
    4. easier to get to france from middle east than USA/UK.

    http://www.dw.com/en/why-france-again/a-19403348
    also muslim population are msinly from Arab countries.
    I would suggest that it is also worth looking at the events of October 1961 in Paris for other reasons why Algerian French particularly feel resentment towards their adopted country.
    But that's like saying British Indians feel resentment to Britain because of Amritsar.
  • notmenotme Posts: 3,293
    SeanT said:

    Jonathan said:

    SeanT said:

    Off-topic:

    I think I need to lose some weight. My two-year old just pointed at a picture of a lying-down frog in a nursery rhyme book and said: "Daddy!"

    Be of good cheer. I knew when I had to lose weight (and how) when three things happened.

    1. My older daughter, then age 6, started spontaneously calling me "Big Fat Daddy"

    2. My father referred to me, playfully, as "looking like Henry the Eighth"

    3. Worst of all, I got so tubby I literally burst a belt. A strong leather belt with a fat steel buckle.


    At that point I got a grip, and lost 25 pounds, and I've never regained it. With health apps and modern scales it's quite easy to lose weight: you simply stop eating until you are the weight desired (and eat fruit for energy in between).
    What apps, scales?
    Any of the new breed of sensitive scales that tell you your BMI, water retention etc. They don't cost much.

    MyFitnessPal is a great app for monitoring weight, exercise, food intake, and the relations between.

    i lost 125 lbs three years ago... changed my life
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,855
    edited July 2016
    Of course no one but those who are struggling to accept the result want a second referendum, of any type, right now. So much chaos could ensure, and it's too soon to know if things will truly be going badly so even most remainers will be inclined to say let's go on with things. The important point is how many will still be saying they don't want one in 6 months if we haven't declared article 50. I would guess so long as there is no complete disaster, the proportion would remain similar to now, but it is how people feel after time has passed (and if we haven't formally declared) that will make it a more relevant question than now.

    Initial Bremorse is to be expected, it's a question of if the level rises to the point something can be done about it before we are truly out - I would say not, both on the level rising so significantly and anything being done about it, but asking now is pointless.
  • HaroldOHaroldO Posts: 1,185
    SeanT said:

    Jonathan said:

    SeanT said:

    Off-topic:

    I think I need to lose some weight. My two-year old just pointed at a picture of a lying-down frog in a nursery rhyme book and said: "Daddy!"

    Be of good cheer. I knew when I had to lose weight (and how) when three things happened.

    1. My older daughter, then age 6, started spontaneously calling me "Big Fat Daddy"

    2. My father referred to me, playfully, as "looking like Henry the Eighth"

    3. Worst of all, I got so tubby I literally burst a belt. A strong leather belt with a fat steel buckle.


    At that point I got a grip, and lost 25 pounds, and I've never regained it. With health apps and modern scales it's quite easy to lose weight: you simply stop eating until you are the weight desired (and eat fruit for energy in between).
    What apps, scales?
    Any of the new breed of sensitive scales that tell you your BMI, water retention etc. They don't cost much.

    MyFitnessPal is a great app for monitoring weight, exercise, food intake, and the relations between.
    I've been using it, lost 1 stone 9lbs this year. A lot more to go but it has been excellent so far.

    A friend of mine has lost over 5 stone in two years.
  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503
    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
  • PaulyPauly Posts: 897
    edited July 2016
    The state of the current Labour party is so similar to the crisis of the Tory party described in the Selsdon Manifesto. This may give a small bit of reassurance to those in terminal distress, however I'm not confident they have policy space reflecting the one the free-marketeers provided the right to grow into.

    "Electorally the situation is serious in that the
    continuing failure of the Government’s counterinflation
    strategy will, if prolonged, lead to nemesis
    at the polls; and to the victory of a Labour Party
    committed to the most extreme socialist programme
    since 1945; but electoral considerations are not
    all-important. What is of far greater moment is that
    the Government’s apparent abandonment of its
    previous electoral commitment to the free economy
    invites the question ‘whether the Conservative
    Party is at present fulfilling any meaningful function
    in British politics.’"

    People have been asking in practically the same words...
    'whether the Labour Party is at present fulfilling any meaningful function in British politics.’
    Spooky.
  • anotherDaveanotherDave Posts: 6,746
    John_M said:

    John_M said:

    Jonathan said:

    SeanT said:

    Off-topic:

    I think I need to lose some weight. My two-year old just pointed at a picture of a lying-down frog in a nursery rhyme book and said: "Daddy!"

    Be of good cheer. I knew when I had to lose weight (and how) when three things happened.

    1. My older daughter, then age 6, started spontaneously calling me "Big Fat Daddy"

    2. My father referred to me, playfully, as "looking like Henry the Eighth"

    3. Worst of all, I got so tubby I literally burst a belt. A strong leather belt with a fat steel buckle.


    At that point I got a grip, and lost 25 pounds, and I've never regained it. With health apps and modern scales it's quite easy to lose weight: you simply stop eating until you are the weight desired (and eat fruit for energy in between).
    What apps, scales?
    I love my Fitbit + Fitbit Aria. Lost 4 stone (put 1 stone back on due to my leg injury. Nothing to do these days but graze and post on PB :) ). Gamification of weight loss works for me.
    Try hunting some Pokemon.
    I can't walk very well atm. I manage 45 minutes per day. Pokemon are probably a bit beyond me for a while. Do love all the vids of the nerds staggering about under the blazing heat of the daystar though.
    What's wrong with your leg?
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,554
    SeanT said:

    Anecdotage: drinks with lefty friend tonight, who works, in Berlin, for the German equivalent of the BBC

    He's a Remainer.

    He said Germans are horrified by Brexit (they think we're mad not to understand the benefits of the EU) but also he said they literally have no clue as to why Brits might vote OUT (things like inequality, sovereignty, independence), hence their perplexity and recoil. He is of course talking about educated liberal Germans who work in broadcasting.

    He was also interesting on Labour: his partner is a staunch Labourite with decades as a party member. After months of vacillation his partner now despairs of Corbyn, but sees no way of getting rid of him. A split looms.

    The discussion ended with him saying he thought May was "really competent and electable". My guess is he'd vote for May over Corbyn, or, maybe, abstain.

    He still hates Tories, though.


    I am guessing your lefty friend has never been to stoke.....
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @MSmithsonPB: ICM poll for Sun on Sunday has CON 10% lead
  • ChameleonChameleon Posts: 4,264
    edited July 2016
    John_M said:

    Jonathan said:

    SeanT said:

    Off-topic:

    I think I need to lose some weight. My two-year old just pointed at a picture of a lying-down frog in a nursery rhyme book and said: "Daddy!"

    Be of good cheer. I knew when I had to lose weight (and how) when three things happened.

    1. My older daughter, then age 6, started spontaneously calling me "Big Fat Daddy"

    2. My father referred to me, playfully, as "looking like Henry the Eighth"

    3. Worst of all, I got so tubby I literally burst a belt. A strong leather belt with a fat steel buckle.


    At that point I got a grip, and lost 25 pounds, and I've never regained it. With health apps and modern scales it's quite easy to lose weight: you simply stop eating until you are the weight desired (and eat fruit for energy in between).
    What apps, scales?
    I love my Fitbit + Fitbit Aria. Lost 4 stone (put 1 stone back on due to my leg injury. Nothing to do these days but graze and post on PB :) ). Gamification of weight loss works for me.
    MyFitnessPal is very good to measure your calories in via calories out. I'm down ~15kg in 3ish months.

    For support and guidance I'd try www.reddit/r/loseit.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,554
    I Wnder how long this Pokemon craze is going to last. I saw grown men running around the week chasing f##king virtual creature is around town. Heidi klum could have been butt naked & they wouldn't have noticed.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,855
    edited July 2016
    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too. We can get a good deal still, we have that opportunity, but there's going to be plenty of tough talk from both sides, and people need to not get overly emotional about it.

    PS Lost 2 stone thanks to my FitBit - good motivator.
  • anotherDaveanotherDave Posts: 6,746
    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503

    SeanT said:

    Anecdotage: drinks with lefty friend tonight, who works, in Berlin, for the German equivalent of the BBC

    He's a Remainer.

    He said Germans are horrified by Brexit (they think we're mad not to understand the benefits of the EU) but also he said they literally have no clue as to why Brits might vote OUT (things like inequality, sovereignty, independence), hence their perplexity and recoil. He is of course talking about educated liberal Germans who work in broadcasting.

    He was also interesting on Labour: his partner is a staunch Labourite with decades as a party member. After months of vacillation his partner now despairs of Corbyn, but sees no way of getting rid of him. A split looms.

    The discussion ended with him saying he thought May was "really competent and electable". My guess is he'd vote for May over Corbyn, or, maybe, abstain.

    He still hates Tories, though.


    I am guessing your lefty friend has never been to stoke.....
    Between Andy Haldane, John Harris and Robert's magnum opus on "the discontented", we should all have a good handle on what's going on in the UK.

    Don't think all our problems are going to magically disappear with Brexit. (As you may have noticed, I'm a grim-dark Brexiteer ;) ).
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,855

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
    Hence our opportunity as well. But there will be tough talk, and while people can get in a flap about it, it is ultimately just talk. We're in prenegotiations essentially.

    Besides, it looks like May is not planning to go for too much, she's aiming for HardBrexit if her Cabinet choices are an indication, so trying to wrangle things from the EU may be easier. I'd prefer LiteBrexit, but there you go.
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,158
    Scott_P said:

    @MSmithsonPB: ICM poll for Sun on Sunday has CON 10% lead

    :D
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 64,132
    Monday see's the EU holding a foreign minister's meeting with John Kerry as their special guest but everyone, absolutely everyone, will have their cameras and coverage on Boris.

    Inspired choice by TM with Boris putting the US in the shade and Juncker's spluttering into his whisky
  • TomsToms Posts: 2,478
    edited July 2016
    Fireworks have just started for the Bedford River Festival. As it's just about on on my doorstep not even I could sleep through that.
    Pretty neat.
  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503
    SeanT said:

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
    Yes. The Commission will be sidelined, in the end. This is about jobs, money, prosperity, and votes. Not airy fairy notions of Federalism, from an unelected eurocracy.

    The EU capitals will exert power over Brussels.
    If you recall, the first European polls had the French and German voters (in particular) wanting the EU to play hardball with us.

    I hope they do more of those polls so we can track the trend.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,855
    John_M said:

    SeanT said:

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
    Yes. The Commission will be sidelined, in the end. This is about jobs, money, prosperity, and votes. Not airy fairy notions of Federalism, from an unelected eurocracy.

    The EU capitals will exert power over Brussels.
    If you recall, the first European polls had the French and German voters (in particular) wanting the EU to play hardball with us.

    I hope they do more of those polls so we can track the trend.
    I imagine if and when the Scots go Indy English voters will want to play hardball - hopefully the leaders for us then and the French and Germans now will go for something that they can sell as playing hardball but suits everyone. Though with their elections coming up...
  • SimonStClareSimonStClare Posts: 7,976
    JWisemann said:

    John_M said:

    SNIP

    Corbyn is soft left these days (basic social democracy). It is just a sign of how far right the seditious wing of the party has gone that they can paint him as beyond the pale. Which in turn is why vast swathes of very moderate normal membership like myself are getting ever firmer behind him.
    Why do you bother with such utter nonsense.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,554
    Independent running story that an akp supporter beheaded a solider.
  • SeanT said:

    Look at this. I mean, LOOK AT IT

    https://twitter.com/FromSteveHowell/status/754423720349986816


    The modern British Left. Actively moronic.

    They are just pursuing the same path as they have in Scotland. 'The electorate will come around', 'We're just not communicating our message clearly enough', and, post every defeat 'Lessons will be learned'.

    They got 18.6% of the seats at Holyrood in May 16.
  • wasdwasd Posts: 276
    SeanT said:

    I've possibly changed my mind.

    On these stats May should probably call a GE. Crush Labour.

    She'd get a big fat majority. And Labour would remain riven and doomed as the membership cried foul. At the next election after that, in 2021, or 2022, she'd likely be facing UKIP rather than Labour as main opposition.

    Strategically early September would probably be the best for May.
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,726

    Jonathan said:

    nunu said:

    Deutsche Welle had a good 'why France again?' article. Their reasoning:

    1. French military active in Iraq and Syria
    2. large muslim population, dual citizenship common.
    3. high unemployment amongst young immigrant community
    4. easier to get to france from middle east than USA/UK.

    http://www.dw.com/en/why-france-again/a-19403348
    also muslim population are msinly from Arab countries.
    French terrorism has a long history. Was caught in the aftermath of this.

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1995_Paris_Métro_and_RER_bombings
    nunu said:

    Deutsche Welle had a good 'why France again?' article. Their reasoning:

    1. French military active in Iraq and Syria
    2. large muslim population, dual citizenship common.
    3. high unemployment amongst young immigrant community
    4. easier to get to france from middle east than USA/UK.

    http://www.dw.com/en/why-france-again/a-19403348
    also muslim population are msinly from Arab countries.
    I would suggest that it is also worth looking at the events of October 1961 in Paris for other reasons why Algerian French particularly feel resentment towards their adopted country.
    But that's like saying British Indians feel resentment to Britain because of Amritsar.
    They did. The difference is that Amritsar was almost 100 years ago. And I am sure it stoked part of the resentment that led to Independence. The difference is that there are still plenty of Algerians alive today who were around for the events of 1961 and have children and grandchildren who they fill with stories about it.

    This not in anyway an excuse - anymore than French involvement in the Middle East is an excuse. But it is undoubtedly the case that there were murderous actions that were taken on French soil against French Algerians in living memory that contribute to the hatred some Algerians feel towards their adopted country.
  • edmundintokyoedmundintokyo Posts: 17,709
    edited July 2016
    John_M said:

    SeanT said:

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
    Yes. The Commission will be sidelined, in the end. This is about jobs, money, prosperity, and votes. Not airy fairy notions of Federalism, from an unelected eurocracy.

    The EU capitals will exert power over Brussels.
    If you recall, the first European polls had the French and German voters (in particular) wanting the EU to play hardball with us.

    I hope they do more of those polls so we can track the trend.
    Yup, this is going to be an elites vs populism thing. The elites will want to compromise, Britain will have to hope they don't listen to their voters.
  • anotherDaveanotherDave Posts: 6,746
    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    SeanT said:

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
    Yes. The Commission will be sidelined, in the end. This is about jobs, money, prosperity, and votes. Not airy fairy notions of Federalism, from an unelected eurocracy.

    The EU capitals will exert power over Brussels.
    If you recall, the first European polls had the French and German voters (in particular) wanting the EU to play hardball with us.

    I hope they do more of those polls so we can track the trend.
    I imagine if and when the Scots go Indy English voters will want to play hardball - hopefully the leaders for us then and the French and Germans now will go for something that they can sell as playing hardball but suits everyone. Though with their elections coming up...
    I recall reading that the German media followed the UK referendum campaign closely, and this led to an education of the german public of how important an export market the UK is for them.

    Trade deals are reciprocal. If the german public don't see that right now, I'm sure their exporters, and politicians do.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 55,602
    Scott_P said:

    @MSmithsonPB: ICM poll for Sun on Sunday has CON 10% lead

    Gold Standard! :)
  • john_zimsjohn_zims Posts: 3,399
    @TheScreamingEagles

    Last week, some wise fellow tipped 2019 as our Brexit date

    https://twitter.com/hendopolis/status/754421263104368640

    Apparently the US is about to pull the plug on the EU TTIP trade deal as without the UK it's not worth it.

    So much for being at the back of the queue.

  • edmundintokyoedmundintokyo Posts: 17,709
    SeanT said:

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
    Yes. The Commission will be sidelined, in the end. This is about jobs, money, prosperity, and votes. Not airy fairy notions of Federalism, from an unelected eurocracy.

    The EU capitals will exert power over Brussels.
    Yup, the Commission has power where the member states don't have strong opinions and will let somebody lead them, but in situations like this it has its hands full just trying to find something the member states can agree to.

    However, The European Parliament also has a veto...
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 32,726

    SeanT said:

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
    Yes. The Commission will be sidelined, in the end. This is about jobs, money, prosperity, and votes. Not airy fairy notions of Federalism, from an unelected eurocracy.

    The EU capitals will exert power over Brussels.
    Yup, the Commission has power where the member states don't have strong opinions and will let somebody lead them, but in situations like this it has its hands full just trying to find something the member states can agree to.

    However, The European Parliament also has a veto...
    No it doesn't. Under Article 50 the decision on the future relationship between the EU and the UK rests entirely with the member states through the EU Council. And even there the decision is by QMV with no country having a veto.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    SeanT said:

    I'm increasingly convinced Scots won't even call a new indyref, let alone go indy. The economics have not changed. Scotland is bankrupt, without England, with oil at $70, let alone $50 (where it is now).

    Economics did not win the Brexit vote.

    The SNP will lie to the electorate as the Brexiteers did in order to win a vote

    The details can be sorted out later...
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 82,554
    SeanT said:

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    SeanT said:

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
    Yes. The Commission will be sidelined, in the end. This is about jobs, money, prosperity, and votes. Not airy fairy notions of Federalism, from an unelected eurocracy.

    The EU capitals will exert power over Brussels.
    If you recall, the first European polls had the French and German voters (in particular) wanting the EU to play hardball with us.

    I hope they do more of those polls so we can track the trend.
    I imagine if and when the Scots go Indy English voters will want to play hardball - hopefully the leaders for us then and the French and Germans now will go for something that they can sell as playing hardball but suits everyone. Though with their elections coming up...
    I'm increasingly convinced Scots won't even call a new indyref, let alone go indy. The economics have not changed. Scotland is bankrupt, without England, with oil at $70, let alone $50 (where it is now).

    Moreover I think that, following EUref, there is an emotional voter-aversion to risk, change, and historic referendums in general (hence the honeymoon for the comfortingly maternal Ms May)

    Are the Scots minded to cut the UK in two, so as to return to rule from Brussels and Frankfurt?

    Nah



    Sturgeon gone very quiet on calling another vote.
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    edited July 2016
    SeanT said:

    Independent running story that an akp supporter beheaded a solider.

    The video is all over Twitter. It's not a claim. Turkey has descended into Ottoman barbarity. Let us never speak of this awful country again
    The Economist still wants Turkey to join the EU, I assume.
  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503

    SeanT said:

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
    Yes. The Commission will be sidelined, in the end. This is about jobs, money, prosperity, and votes. Not airy fairy notions of Federalism, from an unelected eurocracy.

    The EU capitals will exert power over Brussels.
    Yup, the Commission has power where the member states don't have strong opinions and will let somebody lead them, but in situations like this it has its hands full just trying to find something the member states can agree to.

    However, The European Parliament also has a veto...
    No it doesn't. Under Article 50 the decision on the future relationship between the EU and the UK rests entirely with the member states through the EU Council. And even there the decision is by QMV with no country having a veto.

    2. A Member State which decides to withdraw shall notify the European Council of its intention. In the light of the guidelines provided by the European Council, the Union shall negotiate and conclude an agreement with that State, setting out the arrangements for its withdrawal, taking account of the framework for its future relationship with the Union. That agreement shall be negotiated in accordance with Article 218(3) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. It shall be concluded on behalf of the Union by the Council, acting by a qualified majority, after obtaining the consent of the European Parliament.


    Looks like the parliament does play a role. Whether we can describe that as a veto is unclear.
  • nunununu Posts: 6,024

    SeanT said:

    Look at this. I mean, LOOK AT IT

    https://twitter.com/FromSteveHowell/status/754423720349986816


    The modern British Left. Actively moronic.

    They are just pursuing the same path as they have in Scotland. 'The electorate will come around', 'We're just not communicating our message clearly enough', and, post every defeat 'Lessons will be learned'.

    They got 18.6% of the seats at Holyrood in May 16.
    In Scotland they said the public were just not listening to them but the policies were right.

    Alex Salmond said there just isn't votes to be had to the Left of the SNP in Scotland and the fact that Scot Lab can't see that is sad.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @scotsdiaspora: Of course this was bound to happen. "Wales told not to expect same level of funding as from EU after voting Brexit" https://t.co/2ea4VWMW8f
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    SeanT said:

    Quite hard to gloss over the oil price.

    Oil is just a bonus.

    On the side of a bus.

    5 Feet tall
  • John_MJohn_M Posts: 7,503
    edited July 2016
    Scott_P said:

    @scotsdiaspora: Of course this was bound to happen. "Wales told not to expect same level of funding as from EU after voting Brexit" https://t.co/2ea4VWMW8f

    Goodness gracious Scott, I don't mind you fighting your corner, but it's not even £80 per head per year. That's 22p per day.

    Let's try and keep a sense of perspective.
  • HaroldOHaroldO Posts: 1,185
    Hmmm looks line Frau Abbott has written a new column; https://twitter.com/HackneyAbbott/status/754381471956238336

    For the morning star, take that in for a moment. A newspaper with a circulation of less than 10,000 and she is writing big time columns for it.
    Peter Madelson is probably weeping in a corner somewhere, wondering why he gave his youth (and a bad 'tache) to a cause that would later throw itself into obscurity.
  • TykejohnnoTykejohnno Posts: 7,362
    SeanT said:

    I've possibly changed my mind.

    On these stats May should probably call a GE. Crush Labour.

    She'd get a big fat majority. And Labour would remain riven and doomed as the membership cried foul. At the next election after that, in 2021, or 2022, she'd likely be facing UKIP rather than Labour as main opposition.

    Don't you think a GE would turn into another remain and leave argument with labour and lib dems promising a vote for them is a vote to remain in the EU.

    It could hit a tory majority,especially down south where the lib dems are challenging.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    SeanT said:

    Quite hard to gloss over the oil price.

    Exhibit A

    @_PaulMonaghan: That's the argument, but it doesn't hold water. The flow of money is south. https://t.co/NVq5hK8jaE
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 29,261



    Sturgeon gone very quiet on calling another vote.

    Everyone except kle4 has gone very quiet about it. Still in post-referendum blancmange mode when everyone else has moved on.
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    Scott_P said:

    @scotsdiaspora: Of course this was bound to happen. "Wales told not to expect same level of funding as from EU after voting Brexit" https://t.co/2ea4VWMW8f

    Ask a stupid question....

  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 124,718
    edited July 2016

    John_M said:

    SeanT said:

    kle4 said:

    John_M said:

    He's just stating the blindingly obvious. I can't dislike him for it.
    Me either - it's not even an unreasonable position for an EU leader to take. Punishing us would be self harming for them, but being perceived as helping us too much in exiting would cause ructions across the bloc. Now, that says many things about the institution, and like all institutions its first goal has become to sustain itself rather than any other benefit, it's one of the reasons for its problems, but obviously while they don't want to be seen to be causing us problems for Leaving (though many in the EU would no doubt not shed a tear at doing so), they cannot be perceived as going easy on us either, lest others get ideas.

    The EU will need a deal it can sell to its people too.
    I think there will be a split between EU Commission and the nation states. The nation states are the ones looking at exports to the UK, and jobs of their voters. The EU Commission is just looking at themselves.

    Power is with the nation states on this.
    Yes. The Commission will be sidelined, in the end. This is about jobs, money, prosperity, and votes. Not airy fairy notions of Federalism, from an unelected eurocracy.

    The EU capitals will exert power over Brussels.
    If you recall, the first European polls had the French and German voters (in particular) wanting the EU to play hardball with us.

    I hope they do more of those polls so we can track the trend.
    Yup, this is going to be an elites vs populism thing. The elites will want to compromise, Britain will have to hope they don't listen to their voters.
    If populism in France elects Marine Le Pen as President next year, which is becoming increasingly likely with every terrorist attack, the EU will swiftly collapse anyway
This discussion has been closed.