Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » The big unknown – the large number of polling respondents s

135

Comments

  • Options
    DairDair Posts: 6,108
    SeanT said:

    Just realised double brilliance of the Tories' Miliband=Sturgeon meme. Yes, it worries rUK voters into voting Tory, or quitting Labour, but it also annoys even MORE Scots into voting SNP, which guarantees the total wipe-out of Labour North of the Border, perhaps forever.

    Thus the further surge to Sturgeon, in recent days, destroying the last Labour citadels in Caledonia. An extermination event - which hobbles Labour for all time.

    No wonder this Tory attack line angers Labour so much. It makes it impossible for Miliband to really win this election, even if he scrapes a plurality, but it also makes Labour virtually unelectable in future.

    The problem is that it doesn't work as a double whammy.

    Yes in Scotland it is a very positive message for the SNP, so they get a lot more votes.

    In England it is a negative message. Negative campaigning does not work in multi-party elections. You have no control where these votes go. In England they are just (maybe more) likely to go UKIP than Conservative.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,990

    Pulpstar said:

    Is the Daily Labourgov out :D ?

    2 MINS
    ONE WHOLE MINUTE...... :D:D:D


    Sorry, I'm too excitable.....
  • Options
    RobD said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Is the Daily Labourgov out :D ?

    2 MINS
    ONE WHOLE MINUTE...... :D:D:D


    Sorry, I'm too excitable.....
    TIE?
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @SunPolitics: YouGov/Sun poll tonight - Tories take a one-point lead: CON 35%, LAB 34%, LD 9%, UKIP 12%, GRN 5%
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,990

    RobD said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Is the Daily Labourgov out :D ?

    2 MINS
    ONE WHOLE MINUTE...... :D:D:D


    Sorry, I'm too excitable.....
    TIE?
    I have no idea!
  • Options
    compouter2compouter2 Posts: 2,371
    BUY SHARES IN TISSUES NOW!
  • Options
    TheWatcherTheWatcher Posts: 5,262
    Scott_P said:

    @SunPolitics: YouGov/Sun poll tonight - Tories take a one-point lead: CON 35%, LAB 34%, LD 9%, UKIP 12%, GRN 5%

    HA HA HA.
  • Options
    Tissue_PriceTissue_Price Posts: 9,039
    That Tom Newton-Dunn is a sneaky one...
  • Options
    NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,369
    CON - 35% (+2)
    LAB - 34% (-)
    UKIP - 12% (-2)
    LDEM - 9% (+1)
    GRN - 5% (-)
  • Options
    Greenwich_FloaterGreenwich_Floater Posts: 389
    edited April 2015
    Scott_P said:

    @SunPolitics: YouGov/Sun poll tonight - Tories take a one-point lead: CON 35%, LAB 34%, LD 9%, UKIP 12%, GRN 5%

    Wow

    Tories up 1, Lab down 1 is quite a seismic move by YG standards.

    Correction Tories up 2 Labour n/c
    Even more seismic
  • Options
    acf2310acf2310 Posts: 141
    Con lead! And no Newton-Dunn tweet. The world is thrown upside down.
  • Options
    Ishmael_XIshmael_X Posts: 3,664
    Why? He is not a pollster.

    I sometimes travel by taxi. That does not make me a cabbie.
  • Options
    dr_spyndr_spyn Posts: 11,291
    Britain Elects ‏@britainelects 14s15 seconds ago
    Latest YouGov poll (26 - 27 Apr):
    CON - 35% (+2)
    LAB - 34% (-)
    UKIP - 12% (-2)
    LDEM - 9% (+1)
    GRN - 5% (-)
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,990
    Get in!!! :D it's all about the MOE movements :D
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002
    OPh God they have Edi South as the "Most marginal"...
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,316
    Oh my!

    Will we look back and say today was the day?
  • Options

    CON - 35% (+2)
    LAB - 34% (-)
    UKIP - 12% (-2)
    LDEM - 9% (+1)
    GRN - 5% (-)

    Tick tock?
  • Options
    bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 21,900
    Good days polling for Tories.

    Could it be we finally have momentum.

    Next few days "interesting"
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,292
    edited April 2015
    dr_spyn said:

    Britain Elects ‏@britainelects 14s15 seconds ago
    Latest YouGov poll (26 - 27 Apr):
    CON - 35% (+2)
    LAB - 34% (-)
    UKIP - 12% (-2)
    LDEM - 9% (+1)
    GRN - 5% (-)

    Don't do it...its not worth it....come down off the bird feeder...it is only marrgggginnnn of ..nooooooooooooo

    https://freehdwallpaper.in/walls/squirrel-jump-normal.jpg
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 92,048

    htps://twitter.com/TSEofPB/status/592802320490078208

    I just love that Twitter has for some reason encouraged even billionaires to act like normal people in sharing unscreened and very normal thoughts about often very mundane things. Who knew what the billionaire powerbrokers of the past really thought about things? But now you have Rupert Murdoch trolling politicians and the Good Lord responding in, let's say, unfiltered fashion to such minor things, to give but two examples. It's great. Not that I've ever used twitter myself - I don't think such a restrictive character limit fits my style.
  • Options
    isamisam Posts: 41,002
    edited April 2015
    Updated SPUD after 4 polls today / 21 in total (11 Pollsters/Organisations)
    The truest test of the direction of the political wind

    CON +6/-2
    LAB +1/-12
    UKIP -2/+6
    LD -1/NC
    GREEN +3/+4

    If someone wants to do a Scottish version, I will happily franchise the formula... I advise calling it "TATTIES" (Tories and Trots Trail Independence Expectant Scots"
  • Options
    SeanT said:

    THAT'S IT. ELECTION OVER.

    LABOUR ARE FINISHED IN SCOTLAND. TORIES AHEAD IN YOUGOV

    I CANNOT FIND THE KEY TO STOP CAPLOCKS.

    But Sean, IIRC you called the GE for Miliband a week or so ago did you not?
  • Options
    DairDair Posts: 6,108


    Just like SLab, the party you *might* be voting for? Though SLab's voting intentions in Westminster seem to be approaching peak irrelevance.

    don't let the rhetoric fool you, DavidL is desperate for a Labour-SNP government so the Legal Aid system is restored and his £50,000 of our taxes becomes £100,000.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    @May2015NS: Time to dust off the old front page... http://t.co/UczafT6cXC
  • Options
    NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,369
    Think we can agree that the Tories have edged up today, mostly at UKIP's expense, but Miliband still heading for Downing Street unless one focuses on Ashcroft, which makes it a toss-up.
  • Options
    bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 21,900
    TSE ‏@TSEofPB 22s23 seconds ago
    History is made, The Sun/YouGov poll has the Tories ahead, and Tom Newton Dunn didn't tweet about it beforehand.

    Is he still breathing?
  • Options
    compouter2compouter2 Posts: 2,371
    The Day the Polls moved/ It was Daves rolled up sleeves/ Its the SNP hitting home etc etc etc. What polls do we have tomorrow?
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,990
    acf2310 said:

    Con lead! And no Newton-Dunn tweet. The world is thrown upside down.

    Yeah, I've always believed this was never a thing.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002

    SeanT said:

    THAT'S IT. ELECTION OVER.

    LABOUR ARE FINISHED IN SCOTLAND. TORIES AHEAD IN YOUGOV

    I CANNOT FIND THE KEY TO STOP CAPLOCKS.

    But Sean, IIRC you called the GE for Miliband a week or so ago did you not?
    What about that 10-11 284.5- seat tip for the Tories :D ?
  • Options

    It was in the 2010 manifesto. The policy is a vote in government time. I doubt it would be whipped.
    Your logic about being a LD supporter but turning against them for joining a tory coalition but happy to see the tories carry on does not tie up. Try again.

    I haven't turned against them - the Coalition has been a good thing. Unfortunately it's been good for the Tories and not for the Lib Dems. Any future Tory Government would be very, very different.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 92,048
    Ishmael_X said:

    Why? He is not a pollster.

    I sometimes travel by taxi. That does not make me a cabbie.
    One doesn't have to be a cabbie to say something on their behalf of course. Though it would be best to know the world and insights of cabbies intimately if one were to do so. The Good Lord may not be a pollster himself, exactly, but his association with a lot of pollsters probably permits him enough connection to speak up for them if he wants.
  • Options
    Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091
    There's a bit of poetic justice in that so many Scottish Labour MPs campaigned against AV.

    Had it gone through, they might have actually saved a decent number of the seats if a lot of Tory voters 2nd-pref'ed for them, since after all independence voters are in the minority in most constituencies.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,990
    Scott_P said:

    @May2015NS: Time to dust off the old front page... http://t.co/UczafT6cXC

    Titter
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,292
    Scott_P said:

    @May2015NS: Time to dust off the old front page... http://t.co/UczafT6cXC

    Unless the current polls are really really wrong....that will go down along side the Sion Simon article.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,990

    TSE ‏@TSEofPB 22s23 seconds ago
    History is made, The Sun/YouGov poll has the Tories ahead, and Tom Newton Dunn didn't tweet about it beforehand.

    Is he still breathing?

    Apparently it's one of the ways sub captains know when to launch their missiles. That, and no Radio 4.
  • Options
    compouter2compouter2 Posts: 2,371

    dr_spyn said:

    Britain Elects ‏@britainelects 14s15 seconds ago
    Latest YouGov poll (26 - 27 Apr):
    CON - 35% (+2)
    LAB - 34% (-)
    UKIP - 12% (-2)
    LDEM - 9% (+1)
    GRN - 5% (-)

    Don't do it...its not worth it....come down off the bird feeder...it is only marrgggginnnn of ..nooooooooooooo

    https://freehdwallpaper.in/walls/squirrel-jump-normal.jpg
    Basil flying through the air with delight. He has a whole night off carrying the goalposts.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,663

    CON - 35% (+2)
    LAB - 34% (-)
    UKIP - 12% (-2)
    LDEM - 9% (+1)
    GRN - 5% (-)

    Tick tock?
    Tipping point.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002

    CON - 35% (+2)
    LAB - 34% (-)
    UKIP - 12% (-2)
    LDEM - 9% (+1)
    GRN - 5% (-)

    Tick tock?
    Nick is in on that one, not on the Ashcroft I reckon.
  • Options
    saddenedsaddened Posts: 2,245
    The sun must be thinking, daily yougov polling, not quite the box office we where hoping for
  • Options
    I think Tom Newton Dunn is going to stop following me on twitter now

    https://twitter.com/TSEofPB/status/592803551019200512
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    MikeL said:

    Oh my!

    Will we look back and say today was the day?

    We might look back and say Friday was the day, when the opportunistic little shit Ed Miliband tried and failed to tar David Cameron with the blood of drowned migrants
  • Options
    Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091

    Think we can agree that the Tories have edged up today, mostly at UKIP's expense, but Miliband still heading for Downing Street unless one focuses on Ashcroft, which makes it a toss-up.

    Would you want Labour to try and get in government if they finish with less seats than the Tories? It would trigger a whole spate of hysterical tabloid headlines about coups.
  • Options
    bigjohnowlsbigjohnowls Posts: 21,900
    MikeL said:

    Oh my!

    Will we look back and say today was the day?

    Or will 7th May be the day
  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,977
    If a Labour/SNP understanding in the Commons keeps 35% of the electorate onside, it's pretty much job done. I don't get this automatic assumption that "England" will rebel when around that percentage will probably end up voting Labour or Green. Throw in the 4% the SNP gets in Scotland and you start off with quite a fair bit of support. Then what happens if we don't get the worst crisis since the abdication and by and large things work out pretty normally: major legislation passed, the odd row, defence sorted with Tory votes etc?

    It's unlikely, but not impossible. Catastrophe and revolt affecting the whole of England seems unlikely. The Tories and UKIP will be furious; the LDs less so.
  • Options

    Think we can agree that the Tories have edged up today, mostly at UKIP's expense, but Miliband still heading for Downing Street unless one focuses on Ashcroft, which makes it a toss-up.

    ICM tables were good for tories too. Probably better than the headline figures.

    You never know, Populus could be right.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002
    @Shadsy Any chance of paying out on 6.5+ seats for the SNP :D ?
  • Options

    TOPPING said:

    Ishmael_X said:

    Ishmael_X said:

    kle4 said:



    It was in the 2010 manifesto. The policy is a vote in government time. I doubt it would be whipped.
    Your logic about being a LD supporter but turning against them for joining a tory coalition but happy to see the tories carry on does not tie up. Try again.

    I haven't turned against them - the Coalition has been a good thing. Unfortunately it's been good for the Tories and not for the Lib Dems. Any future Tory Government would be very, very different.
  • Options
    DairDair Posts: 6,108

    I think there's a Survation poll for the Record with the Nats on 51%

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CDoK8NGXIAQefU1.jpg

    Last two Survation Scotland polls were 47% SNP.

    WOW.
  • Options
    TheWatcherTheWatcher Posts: 5,262
    SeanT said:

    Given total wipeout likely for all the main parties in Scotland, I wonder how wedded to the union they will be.

    Tories will fight to the end against independence but is it possible Labour (with nothing left to lose) will soften their stance.

    Are you daft? Labour desperately need Scotland back onside. Without it they are 40 MPs in deficit, FOREVER.

    That's not something they can just shrug off.

    And recall how many of their recent Big Beasts were Scots, John Smith, Gordon Brown, Robin Cook, George Galloway (OK that's a joke) all gone, all inconceivable now.

    The loss of Scotland is not just gonna make elections very difficult for Labour, it is gonna make the future difficult. What are they? Just an English party that allies with the SNP? If so they will have to readjust to more conservative English values.

    Delicious.
    Perhaps some of the ghastly Labour droners from south of the border, can step up to the plate?
  • Options
    PurseybearPurseybear Posts: 766
    Got a real '92 feeling about this. The media started gunning for Kinnock & Major upped his tempo. May be v wrong but somethings shifting. Could be the SNP issue cos Ive heard lots talking about it. Are things turning blue all of sudden?
  • Options
    compouter2compouter2 Posts: 2,371
    So what polling delights do we get tomorrow?
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,913
    SeanT said:

    Given total wipeout likely for all the main parties in Scotland, I wonder how wedded to the union they will be.

    Tories will fight to the end against independence but is it possible Labour (with nothing left to lose) will soften their stance.

    Are you daft? Labour desperately need Scotland back onside. Without it they are 40 MPs in deficit, FOREVER.

    That's not something they can just shrug off.

    And recall how many of their recent Big Beasts were Scots, John Smith, Gordon Brown, Robin Cook, George Galloway (OK that's a joke) all gone, all inconceivable now.

    The loss of Scotland is not just gonna make elections very difficult for Labour, it is gonna make the future difficult. What are they? Just an English party that allies with the SNP? If so they will have to readjust to more conservative English values.

    Delicious.
    Well if SNP do well and we get a Tory govt as a result, theyll be hammed next time much like the LDs are today.
  • Options
    SeanT said:

    Given total wipeout likely for all the main parties in Scotland, I wonder how wedded to the union they will be.

    Tories will fight to the end against independence but is it possible Labour (with nothing left to lose) will soften their stance.

    Are you daft? Labour desperately need Scotland back onside. Without it they are 40 MPs in deficit, FOREVER.

    That's not something they can just shrug off.

    And recall how many of their recent Big Beasts were Scots, John Smith, Gordon Brown, Robin Cook, George Galloway (OK that's a joke) all gone, all inconceivable now.

    The loss of Scotland is not just gonna make elections very difficult for Labour, it is gonna make the future difficult. What are they? Just an English party that allies with the SNP? If so they will have to readjust to more conservative English values.

    Delicious.
    Your right of course.
    However, moving right isn't going to help them get any votes back in Scotland.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 92,048

    If a Labour/SNP understanding in the Commons keeps 35% of the electorate onside, it's pretty much job done. I don't get this automatic assumption that "England" will rebel when around that percentage will probably end up voting Labour or Green. Throw in the 4% the SNP gets in Scotland and you start off with quite a fair bit of support. Then what happens if we don't get the worst crisis since the abdication and by and large things work out pretty normally: major legislation passed, the odd row, defence sorted with Tory votes etc?

    It's unlikely, but not impossible. Catastrophe and revolt affecting the whole of England seems unlikely. The Tories and UKIP will be furious; the LDs less so.

    As long as the SNP are sensible, and we have no reason to believe they will not be unless they get a bit overexcited, and don't start off by making all sorts of silly and unreasonable demands which are obviously designed to benefit Scotland and only Scotland at the expense of England - which should not be too hard to manage - then although there is a good indication a fair few people have concerns about such a pact, those concerns will be mollified for the first little while, and if they can manage that, then it just becomes another government from then on.
  • Options
    MP_SEMP_SE Posts: 3,642
    edited April 2015
    The Tory candidate fighting Nigel Farage for South Thanet has been exposed as the owner of a business advising EU migrants on how to claim tax credits:

    http://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/573235/Craig-Mackinlay-website-immigrants-claim-tax-benefit-credit-UK-Nigel-Farage-South-Thanet
  • Options
    Tissue_PriceTissue_Price Posts: 9,039

    Think we can agree that the Tories have edged up today, mostly at UKIP's expense, but Miliband still heading for Downing Street unless one focuses on Ashcroft, which makes it a toss-up.

    A toss-up with a 6 point lead? Your seat, maybe.
  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633
    RobD said:

    Scott_P said:

    @May2015NS: Time to dust off the old front page... http://t.co/UczafT6cXC

    Titter
    The day that Ed was spurned..
  • Options
    Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091

    SeanT said:

    Given total wipeout likely for all the main parties in Scotland, I wonder how wedded to the union they will be.

    Tories will fight to the end against independence but is it possible Labour (with nothing left to lose) will soften their stance.

    Are you daft? Labour desperately need Scotland back onside. Without it they are 40 MPs in deficit, FOREVER.

    That's not something they can just shrug off.

    And recall how many of their recent Big Beasts were Scots, John Smith, Gordon Brown, Robin Cook, George Galloway (OK that's a joke) all gone, all inconceivable now.

    The loss of Scotland is not just gonna make elections very difficult for Labour, it is gonna make the future difficult. What are they? Just an English party that allies with the SNP? If so they will have to readjust to more conservative English values.

    Delicious.
    Your right of course.
    However, moving right isn't going to help them get any votes back in Scotland.
    And moving further to the right would also mean the North of England and Wales going the same way for Labour as Scotland.
  • Options
    TheWatcherTheWatcher Posts: 5,262

    Think we can agree that the Tories have edged up today, mostly at UKIP's expense, but Miliband still heading for Downing Street unless one focuses on Ashcroft, which makes it a toss-up.

    A toss-up with a 6 point lead? Your seat, maybe.
    By rights it should be described as Soubry's seat, until it changes hands. If it does.
  • Options
    TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 40,273
    edited April 2015
    Pulpstar said:

    @Shadsy Any chance of paying out on 6.5+ seats for the SNP :D ?

    More funds for re-investment?
  • Options
    I think we will only get one poll tomorrow (YouGov) possibly TNS but I'm not sure.

    There's been a few people polled by ComRes in Con/Lab marginals, so I'm expecting an aggregate marginals poll in the next few days.
  • Options
    AndrewAndrew Posts: 2,900
    Not much movement on SPIN yet ..... midpoints have Con285+LD25 = 310, still a little short even with the DUP.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 92,048

    Think we can agree that the Tories have edged up today, mostly at UKIP's expense, but Miliband still heading for Downing Street unless one focuses on Ashcroft, which makes it a toss-up.

    A toss-up with a 6 point lead? Your seat, maybe.
    By rights it should be described as Soubry's seat, until it changes hands. If it does.
    Technically isn't it no-one's seat at present? If it is technically the case we have no MPs at present.
  • Options
    PurseybearPurseybear Posts: 766

    The Day the Polls moved/ It was Daves rolled up sleeves/ Its the SNP hitting home etc etc etc. What polls do we have tomorrow?

    This Camerons newfound passion has been a media hit for sure. That Sun headlines storming for tories too.

    Love the way Nick Palmer confidently says Milibands still heading for No.10. Not if this is momentum he isn't.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002

    Pulpstar said:

    @Shadsy Any chance of paying out on 6.5+ seats for the SNP :D ?

    More funds for re-investment?
    All my cash tied up in Scotland and the Southwest lol
  • Options
    tysontyson Posts: 6,050

    SeanT said:

    Given total wipeout likely for all the main parties in Scotland, I wonder how wedded to the union they will be.

    Tories will fight to the end against independence but is it possible Labour (with nothing left to lose) will soften their stance.

    Are you daft? Labour desperately need Scotland back onside. Without it they are 40 MPs in deficit, FOREVER.

    That's not something they can just shrug off.

    And recall how many of their recent Big Beasts were Scots, John Smith, Gordon Brown, Robin Cook, George Galloway (OK that's a joke) all gone, all inconceivable now.

    The loss of Scotland is not just gonna make elections very difficult for Labour, it is gonna make the future difficult. What are they? Just an English party that allies with the SNP? If so they will have to readjust to more conservative English values.

    Delicious.
    Perhaps some of the ghastly Labour droners from south of the border, can step up to the plate?
    Watcher- you are not watching very well. The Labour posters here are and have always been constrained. I can't remember one calling most seats for Labour even.

    We realise though that the Tories have to be doing very well indeed to get back, and even on todays polls it doesn't seem like they are quite doing enough.

    So Tick Tock- not hubristic. Until there is a day giving all polls of 5% Tory leads it'll remain thus.
  • Options
    DairDair Posts: 6,108
    Alistair said:

    notme said:

    Is the record, like its sister Mirror paper, normally a strong labour rag?
    The Daily Rangers is an exceptionally strong Labour paper.
    The DayLate Rebel is not a pro-Rangers paper. It is and always has been a pro-Celtic rag.
  • Options
    Tories need to spend the rest of the campaign on the economy. It's likely they will get reasonable GDP stats to play with.

    They don't need to bring up Scotland any more. Every time Nicola is in the national media, it brings the subject to the forefront of everyone's minds.

    They can, or course, continue to mercilessly tease Labour about Scotland on every occasion that Labour deny a deal with the SNP.

    If they get the next week right, I can see them getting the 290-295 that they will need to carry on. If they get that many and Clegg wins, then I can't see LDs not backing Tories as they would be so far ahead on Labour on votes and seats that it would impossible to back Labour.

    Still short of a majority as things stand, but things could change. I'd say CONS are in a better position than they were ten days before the election in 1992.
  • Options
    DairDair Posts: 6,108
    edited April 2015
    kle4 said:

    Have SLAB hit their floor in the mid20s? At least they don't need to worry about finishing below the Tories in Scotland I guess. Small mercies for them.

    SLAB floor is about 18% going by the polling figures on certainty to vote and certainty to stay SLAB.

    We are getting into Czechoslovakia territory btw.

    18 months after a No vote the two countries went their own way without further referenda.
  • Options
    notmenotme Posts: 3,293
    Dair said:

    SeanT said:

    Just realised double brilliance of the Tories' Miliband=Sturgeon meme. Yes, it worries rUK voters into voting Tory, or quitting Labour, but it also annoys even MORE Scots into voting SNP, which guarantees the total wipe-out of Labour North of the Border, perhaps forever.

    Thus the further surge to Sturgeon, in recent days, destroying the last Labour citadels in Caledonia. An extermination event - which hobbles Labour for all time.

    No wonder this Tory attack line angers Labour so much. It makes it impossible for Miliband to really win this election, even if he scrapes a plurality, but it also makes Labour virtually unelectable in future.

    The problem is that it doesn't work as a double whammy.

    Yes in Scotland it is a very positive message for the SNP, so they get a lot more votes.

    In England it is a negative message. Negative campaigning does not work in multi-party elections. You have no control where these votes go. In England they are just (maybe more) likely to go UKIP than Conservative.
    And they are burning bridges that Ruth Davidson is trying very hard to rebuild.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 92,048
    We might have to feed off YouGov alone tomorrow? I'm already feeling the shakes from poll withdrawal.
  • Options
    DadgeDadge Posts: 2,038
    TOPPING said:

    The Guardian poll projection LAB + SNP 324

    EICIPM

    Lab + SNP = dead parrot.

    Get over it.
    Yup. And the SNP and the Scots themselves will get so much hate for this from Labour - the political tension will be unbearable.

    I see Nicola's still gabbling on about how she's going to work with Labour in Westminster. Why doesn't she put a sock in it? Either she's too hubristic or stupid to see how she's destroying Labour's chances, or she's calculated she can get more out of the Tories.

    Which brings us to the question of what Cameron's relationship with the Jock 50 will be. What can he bribe them with to make sure their voters don't switch back to Labour?

  • Options
    SouthamObserverSouthamObserver Posts: 38,977
    kle4 said:

    If a Labour/SNP understanding in the Commons keeps 35% of the electorate onside, it's pretty much job done. I don't get this automatic assumption that "England" will rebel when around that percentage will probably end up voting Labour or Green. Throw in the 4% the SNP gets in Scotland and you start off with quite a fair bit of support. Then what happens if we don't get the worst crisis since the abdication and by and large things work out pretty normally: major legislation passed, the odd row, defence sorted with Tory votes etc?

    It's unlikely, but not impossible. Catastrophe and revolt affecting the whole of England seems unlikely. The Tories and UKIP will be furious; the LDs less so.

    As long as the SNP are sensible, and we have no reason to believe they will not be unless they get a bit overexcited, and don't start off by making all sorts of silly and unreasonable demands which are obviously designed to benefit Scotland and only Scotland at the expense of England - which should not be too hard to manage - then although there is a good indication a fair few people have concerns about such a pact, those concerns will be mollified for the first little while, and if they can manage that, then it just becomes another government from then on.

    That's pretty much the way I see it, but with Labour 30-40 seats behind the Tories we'll never find out. This time next month they'll be looking for a new leader and we'll be starting two years of major constitutional fun under a minority Tory government supported by the LDs and the DUP.

  • Options
    CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758

    Got a real '92 feeling about this. The media started gunning for Kinnock & Major upped his tempo. May be v wrong but somethings shifting. Could be the SNP issue cos Ive heard lots talking about it. Are things turning blue all of sudden?

    I was with someone today who is significantly involved in a very politicised segment of the economy. Not worried about Labour or the Tories winning. Very worried about Sturgeon having any influence.
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,913

    Tories need to spend the rest of the campaign on the economy. It's likely they will get reasonable GDP stats to play with.

    They don't need to bring up Scotland any more. Every time Nicola is in the national media, it brings the subject to the forefront of everyone's minds.

    They can, or course, continue to mercilessly tease Labour about Scotland on every occasion that Labour deny a deal with the SNP.

    If they get the next week right, I can see them getting the 290-295 that they will need to carry on. If they get that many and Clegg wins, then I can't see LDs not backing Tories as they would be so far ahead on Labour on votes and seats that it would impossible to back Labour.

    Still short of a majority as things stand, but things could change. I'd say CONS are in a better position than they were ten days before the election in 1992.

    Don't be daft. The Tories were defending a 100 seat majority and only had to hold seats. Today the Tories have to make gains to winca majority. Obviously a much harder task.
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 8,006
    Danny565 said:

    Think we can agree that the Tories have edged up today, mostly at UKIP's expense, but Miliband still heading for Downing Street unless one focuses on Ashcroft, which makes it a toss-up.

    Would you want Labour to try and get in government if they finish with less seats than the Tories? It would trigger a whole spate of hysterical tabloid headlines about coups.
    There is a whole spate of hysterical tabloid headlines e.g. about Stalin at the moment. The secret is to just ignore them. That's the British way with hysterics.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 76,002
    Why are people so worried about Sturgoen winning, did they not read @Antifrank's blog ?
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 92,048
    tyson said:

    SeanT said:

    Given total wipeout likely for all the main parties in Scotland, I wonder how wedded to the union they will be.

    Tories will fight to the end against independence but is it possible Labour (with nothing left to lose) will soften their stance.

    Are you daft? Labour desperately need Scotland back onside. Without it they are 40 MPs in deficit, FOREVER.

    That's not something they can just shrug off.

    And recall how many of their recent Big Beasts were Scots, John Smith, Gordon Brown, Robin Cook, George Galloway (OK that's a joke) all gone, all inconceivable now.

    The loss of Scotland is not just gonna make elections very difficult for Labour, it is gonna make the future difficult. What are they? Just an English party that allies with the SNP? If so they will have to readjust to more conservative English values.

    Delicious.
    Perhaps some of the ghastly Labour droners from south of the border, can step up to the plate?
    Watcher- you are not watching very well. The Labour posters here are and have always been constrained. I can't remember one calling most seats for Labour even.
    Weirdly, it does seem there are more Tory supporters calling it as most seats for Labour at least.
  • Options
    TykejohnnoTykejohnno Posts: 7,362
    I thought the rightwing press was getting desperate,this is desperate.

  • Options
    Ishmael_XIshmael_X Posts: 3,664
    kle4 said:

    Ishmael_X said:

    Why? He is not a pollster.

    I sometimes travel by taxi. That does not make me a cabbie.
    One doesn't have to be a cabbie to say something on their behalf of course. Though it would be best to know the world and insights of cabbies intimately if one were to do so. The Good Lord may not be a pollster himself, exactly, but his association with a lot of pollsters probably permits him enough connection to speak up for them if he wants.
    But Lord A thinking that you can present a string of polls conducted by more than one pollster as a series, is like a cabbie thinking that Chelsea is south of the river.
  • Options
    glwglw Posts: 9,554
    Danny565 said:

    There's a bit of poetic justice in that so many Scottish Labour MPs campaigned against AV.

    That's a good point, they thought they were campaigning to keep their cozy safe seats, they may have in fact ended their political careers.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,990

    Think we can agree that the Tories have edged up today, mostly at UKIP's expense, but Miliband still heading for Downing Street unless one focuses on Ashcroft, which makes it a toss-up.

    A toss-up with a 6 point lead? Your seat, maybe.
    By rights it should be described as Soubry's seat, until it changes hands. If it does.
    It's no ones seat right now!
  • Options
    Quite a challenge for Mike Smithson to maintain his "Tories are doomed" meme into tomorrow morning's thread.
  • Options
    CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    kle4 said:

    Think we can agree that the Tories have edged up today, mostly at UKIP's expense, but Miliband still heading for Downing Street unless one focuses on Ashcroft, which makes it a toss-up.

    A toss-up with a 6 point lead? Your seat, maybe.
    By rights it should be described as Soubry's seat, until it changes hands. If it does.
    Technically isn't it no-one's seat at present? If it is technically the case we have no MPs at present.
    And I reckon we've managed pretty well without them...
  • Options
    Eh_ehm_a_ehEh_ehm_a_eh Posts: 552

    That @Survation Scotland poll would see the following seat allocations

    SNP 55 (+49) Lab 3 (-38) LD 1 (-10) Con 0 (-1)

    4 unionists left, not good enough.
    Get it sorted Nicola.

  • Options
    TheWatcherTheWatcher Posts: 5,262
    edited April 2015
    tyson said:

    SeanT said:

    Given total wipeout likely for all the main parties in Scotland, I wonder how wedded to the union they will be.

    Tories will fight to the end against independence but is it possible Labour (with nothing left to lose) will soften their stance.

    Are you daft? Labour desperately need Scotland back onside. Without it they are 40 MPs in deficit, FOREVER.

    That's not something they can just shrug off.

    And recall how many of their recent Big Beasts were Scots, John Smith, Gordon Brown, Robin Cook, George Galloway (OK that's a joke) all gone, all inconceivable now.

    The loss of Scotland is not just gonna make elections very difficult for Labour, it is gonna make the future difficult. What are they? Just an English party that allies with the SNP? If so they will have to readjust to more conservative English values.

    Delicious.
    Perhaps some of the ghastly Labour droners from south of the border, can step up to the plate?
    Watcher- you are not watching very well. The Labour posters here are and have always been constrained. I can't remember one calling most seats for Labour even.

    We realise though that the Tories have to be doing very well indeed to get back, and even on todays polls it doesn't seem like they are quite doing enough.

    So Tick Tock- not hubristic. Until there is a day giving all polls of 5% Tory leads it'll remain thus.
    Odd. I've made no mention of hubris - is it a matter that's weighing heavily on your mind in 'Firenze' this evening?
  • Options
    sarissasarissa Posts: 1,800
    kle4 said:

    Have SLAB hit their floor in the mid20s? At least they don't need to worry about finishing below the Tories in Scotland I guess. Small mercies for them.

    Probably (Ashcroft sub-samples excepted!) - but don't discount the attraction of jumping on the SNP bandwagon at the last minute.
  • Options
    hamiltonacehamiltonace Posts: 642

    Given total wipeout likely for all the main parties in Scotland, I wonder how wedded to the union they will be.

    Tories will fight to the end against independence but is it possible Labour (with nothing left to lose) will soften their stance.

    The decision for independence was made by the Scots and is not a plaything for the political parties. Anyone including the SNP who try and question the result of the referendum is in trouble.

    This election has been lost by Labour in Scotland not won by the SNP. The big issues here such as how will the financial system work in the future, defence, international relationships and welfare reform have been mostly ignored while issues such as the NHS, house building and education which only apply to England have often been at the forefront of the news. No wonder the SNP are heading for success. This is an English and partially Welsh election not a UK election.

    While not mentioned often the East Lothian question is still a burning issue. Up here we cant see how Milliband could do a deal with the SNP. If he uses their votes to change the English NHS or English education system he is surely putting Labour's future at risk. The best he can do is agree with the SNP on the big issues and work with the Lib Dems only for English laws.










  • Options
    steve_garnersteve_garner Posts: 1,019
    Can't believe Nick Palmer thinks it might be a toss up who is in No 10 if the election is as per Ashcroft today. Outrageous.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,397
    Dair said:


    Just like SLab, the party you *might* be voting for? Though SLab's voting intentions in Westminster seem to be approaching peak irrelevance.

    don't let the rhetoric fool you, DavidL is desperate for a Labour-SNP government so the Legal Aid system is restored and his £50,000 of our taxes becomes £100,000.
    Dair, I even gave you the link to the Legal Aid site. My LA income does not even reach 5 figures most years and it is by far the least profitable part of my practice. The idea of doing more LA fills me with horror. I turn it away regularly. You have said this a few times now. If it is supposed to be a joke it is not very funny.
  • Options
    saddosaddo Posts: 534
    I reckon the Tories are pretty much on plan.

    Stage one - smash Labour in Scotland. Job done

    Stage two - raise the Jock Terror to clear and immediate danger level. Job done

    Stage three - let Labour go early & run out of momentum. Job done

    Stage four - blitz finish with major asset Cameron at the front. Job started

    Underpinned by consistent don't risk it economic message

    Working well me thinks.
  • Options
    TykejohnnoTykejohnno Posts: 7,362

    Nick Sutton ✔ @suttonnick

    Tuesday's Yorkshire Post:
    Deal with the SNP would be 'foolish', says Balls
    #tomorrowspaperstoday #bbcpapers
  • Options
    DairDair Posts: 6,108
    kle4 said:

    Dair said:

    Mhairi Black getting featured on main BBC news at 10.

    Is she the one who's going to beat Murphy?
    No Mhairi Black will take Dougie Alexander's seat. Murphy will be beaten by Kristen Oswald. There's no wiki for her but I would guess from her name she is Jewish or Jewish background which will trump Murphy's Henry Jackson Zionism in Newton Mearns.
  • Options
    Jonathan said:

    Tories need to spend the rest of the campaign on the economy. It's likely they will get reasonable GDP stats to play with.

    They don't need to bring up Scotland any more. Every time Nicola is in the national media, it brings the subject to the forefront of everyone's minds.

    They can, or course, continue to mercilessly tease Labour about Scotland on every occasion that Labour deny a deal with the SNP.

    If they get the next week right, I can see them getting the 290-295 that they will need to carry on. If they get that many and Clegg wins, then I can't see LDs not backing Tories as they would be so far ahead on Labour on votes and seats that it would impossible to back Labour.

    Still short of a majority as things stand, but things could change. I'd say CONS are in a better position than they were ten days before the election in 1992.

    Don't be daft. The Tories were defending a 100 seat majority and only had to hold seats. Today the Tories have to make gains to winca majority. Obviously a much harder task.
    I was referring to polling and momentum really.

    Granted it's harder to defend and win, then defend only, which is why I still think even if momentum continues with the blues through to next Thursday then a majority is still very unlikely.
  • Options
    Tim_BTim_B Posts: 7,669
    Meanwhile Baltimore is suffering and may be about to explode.

    The protests have turned violent, the street gangs are turning on the police, with 7 cops with broken bones and 1 'unresponsive'.

    Stores are being looted and cars (mainly police) burned and destroyed. The police were clearly unprepared for the escalation of the unrest and have not thus far handled it well. Unless they get things under control by nightfall - just over an hour - it will be a long night.

    To my knowledge the Baltimore PD have yet to release any formal statement regarding the details of how Freddie Gray died in police custody 9 days ago, with a 'nearly severed' spine and a crushed windpipe.

    That is not a good sign for the police.

    The mayor of Baltimore gave a news conference earlier, and she said that we will make space for those who wish to destroy. She must be regretting it by now.
  • Options
    TykejohnnoTykejohnno Posts: 7,362

    That @Survation Scotland poll would see the following seat allocations

    SNP 55 (+49) Lab 3 (-38) LD 1 (-10) Con 0 (-1)

    4 unionists left, not good enough.
    Get it sorted Nicola.

    Brilliant how Cameron let labour take charge to save the Union,just bloody brilliant ;-)

This discussion has been closed.