Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

It’s a 12.5% betting chance that Putin will be out by May 1st – politicalbetting.com

1234689

Comments

  • CarnyxCarnyx Posts: 42,829

    HYUFD said:

    Applicant said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Beautiful beautiful day here. Bright blue skies, 14C, the first real day of spring

    March 10! Somehow it is always March 10, the second week of March, the true end of winter.

    Life is still shit, but, hey, spring. That's something

    No, the true end of winter and start of spring is March 20th, so we still have 10 days of astronomical winter to go
    Seriously, what is wrong with you?
    Nothing, I still keep my winter coat and scarf on and drink red wine and eat winter vegetables until March 20th.

    I only take off my coat and scarf and switch to white wine and salad once spring starts on March 21st
    Bloody hell, Putin won't have a clue what he's up against if he takes on the English.
    If I’d said that they’d be asking for Patel to string me up by my bollocks.
    That's a 'stimulating' fantasy for some of them, her and the Truss tightening the straps with the speeches of the Blessed Margaret on a loop. Far too good for Jocks.
    We have to make do witrh our own jockstraps.
  • EabhalEabhal Posts: 8,647

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    Surprised it's so low. Most stay in hotels the night before (even if same city), security, the coach/plane, gym/physio space. Staff, food (not sure how you'd allocate those costs).
  • StuartDicksonStuartDickson Posts: 12,146
    Taz said:

    dixiedean said:

    Blooming heck!
    Just reading Chelsea can't sell any more tickets.

    Chelsea will be in the championship in 2 years if they still exist
    Chelsea 2022, the newly formed club from the embers of the current club when it goes bump, should start at the very foot of the football league pyramid.

    Same for Everton 2022 when that happens

    Same as Rangers.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 17,405

    The Tories are finished on current polling.

    What does that even mean? Do you mean likely to be out of power after the next election? Or do you mean will never regain power?

    I think and hope that the first is correct. Time for a change. Time for Starmer to build a team and a plan to make Britain better. Time for the Conservatives to remember that politics isn't just about trousering cash, and getting lucrative side jobs.
  • ApplicantApplicant Posts: 3,379
    dixiedean said:

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    What on Earth does that consist of?
    Travelling party has to be 30+ and I think they now always stay over the night before the game, even on the shortest trips (at least some clubs IIRC stay overnight in a hotel the night before home games).

    And they ain't staying in a Travelodge.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 81,991
    edited March 2022
    Eabhal said:

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    Surprised it's so low. Most stay in hotels the night before (even if same city), security, the coach/plane, gym/physio space. Staff, food (not sure how you'd allocate those costs).
    I am sure its much higher for Chelsea. Burley, they probably bring the average down a fair bit, probably have to drive themselves there and sleep at a local campground.
  • AslanAslan Posts: 1,673

    Aslan said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    It seems "likely" to you based on no evidence at all except Russia claims it.
    No, it seemed likely to me BEFORE I read the Russians' claims. As I said, basing themselves in a building like a hospital is a common and logical tactic for a military defending urban territory. It also seemed unlikely that Russia would actively bomb a hospital full of expectant mothers and newborns, even if they were the embodiment of evil, because it would hand a propaganda coup to the other side. The other alternative was that it was a cock up, which was highly possible.
    Russia has spent the last week completely leveling a Russian speaking city to the ground. After their Plan A has fallen apart, and they know they can't win militarily so hope to force Ukraine to give some concessions to avoid the sort of destruction seen in Chechnya. They have deliberately switched to a policy of terror so don't care about PR value any more. It serves their purposes that stuff is as brutal as possible.
  • MISTYMISTY Posts: 1,594

    Scholz and Macron demand immediate ceasefire in telephone call with Putin

    Falling on deaf ears

    we want an immediate ceasefire

    or what?

    Or we will be really, really annoyed.

  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    edited March 2022
    I see PB's Assad boot lickers are homing in on their angle for this conflict.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 17,405

    BUPA been absolutely bloody useless in refusing to cover my mental health treatment, steer clear

    Probably because they only cover humans, not horses...

    Seriously - hope you are ok.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 81,991
    edited March 2022
    Applicant said:

    dixiedean said:

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    What on Earth does that consist of?
    Travelling party has to be 30+ and I think they now always stay over the night before the game, even on the shortest trips (at least some clubs IIRC stay overnight in a hotel the night before home games).

    And they ain't staying in a Travelodge.
    I think Spurs even built their own hotel at the training ground.

    If you go and watch Ben Foster on Youtube you can see the hotel they stay in before home games, its very nice. And of course they have their own chefs make all the food for them. For a Saturday game, they go straight after training on a Friday lunchtime and stay there until midday on th3 Saturday.
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    Alistair said:

    I see PB's Assad boot lickers are honing in on their angle for this conflict.

    They are HOMING in on it. like pigeons. Honing is sharpening razors.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 54,582

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    That’s only £500 each for 60 people. There’s plenty of stories of them chartering planes for anything longer than about three hours in the bus, they often travel the day before the match and stay in an hotel even for reasonably local games.

    Footballers are cheapskates compared to F1 team travel expenses!
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    I've jist discovered that the "immunity window" for Covid has been revised down from 90 days to 28.

    When did that happen?
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    Alistair said:

    I've jist discovered that the "immunity window" for Covid has been revised down from 90 days to 28.

    When did that happen?

    In the fog of war.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    IshmaelZ said:

    Alistair said:

    I see PB's Assad boot lickers are honing in on their angle for this conflict.

    They are HOMING in on it. like pigeons. Honing is sharpening razors.
    Don't know what you are talking about. Clear propaganda.
  • dixiedean said:

    Taz said:

    dixiedean said:

    Blooming heck!
    Just reading Chelsea can't sell any more tickets.

    Chelsea will be in the championship in 2 years if they still exist
    Chelsea 2022, the newly formed club from the embers of the current club when it goes bump, should start at the very foot of the football league pyramid.

    Same for Everton 2022 when that happens

    Everton ain't going bust though.
    Well nobody wants to buy their players, so they would be uneffected by that :-)
    Man Utd want Richarlison
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,561
    edited March 2022

    Taz said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Volcano is an interesting one.

    The Yellowstone Caldera will go up one day and this one I read about recently caused cooling for 100 years

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory
    It will also bury much of North America in ash many, many inches deep.
    Back of a fag packet....

    I see wiki says 190 cubic miles of ash. That equates to 3.6m square miles at 4 inches deep.

    The whole of the USA (excluding Alaska and Hawaii) is some 8.1m square miles. So maybe half of the US would be uninhabitable/unfit for growing crops.

    Oh, and bees dying out wouldn't be great, but moths do a surprising amount of the heavy lifting on pollination. And travel much further distances than bees, so are better for broadening the gene pool.
  • TazTaz Posts: 14,376

    Taz said:

    dixiedean said:

    Blooming heck!
    Just reading Chelsea can't sell any more tickets.

    Chelsea will be in the championship in 2 years if they still exist
    Chelsea 2022, the newly formed club from the embers of the current club when it goes bump, should start at the very foot of the football league pyramid.

    Same for Everton 2022 when that happens

    Same as Rangers.
    Also Chester City, Halifax, Macclesfield, Bury, Boston Utd, Aldershot, Newport and some others.

    Cannot wait to see it with Chelsea and Neverton.
  • kamskikamski Posts: 5,190

    Taz said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Volcano is an interesting one.

    The Yellowstone Caldera will go up one day and this one I read about recently caused cooling for 100 years

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory
    It will also bury much of North America in ash many, many inches deep.
    Back of a fag packet....

    I see wiki says 190 cubic miles of ash. That equates to 3.6m square miles at 4 inches deep.

    The whole of the USA (excluding Alaska and Hawaii) is some 8.1m square miles. So maybe half of the US would be uninhabitable/unfit for growing crops.
    Would 4 inches of ash really make ground unfit for growing crops? Just plough it into the earth surely?
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 81,991
    edited March 2022

    dixiedean said:

    Taz said:

    dixiedean said:

    Blooming heck!
    Just reading Chelsea can't sell any more tickets.

    Chelsea will be in the championship in 2 years if they still exist
    Chelsea 2022, the newly formed club from the embers of the current club when it goes bump, should start at the very foot of the football league pyramid.

    Same for Everton 2022 when that happens

    Everton ain't going bust though.
    Well nobody wants to buy their players, so they would be uneffected by that :-)
    Man Utd want Richarlison
    Why do Man Utd want yet another attacking wide player? They only have about 12...
  • dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 29,401
    Taz said:

    Taz said:

    dixiedean said:

    Blooming heck!
    Just reading Chelsea can't sell any more tickets.

    Chelsea will be in the championship in 2 years if they still exist
    Chelsea 2022, the newly formed club from the embers of the current club when it goes bump, should start at the very foot of the football league pyramid.

    Same for Everton 2022 when that happens

    Same as Rangers.
    Also Chester City, Halifax, Macclesfield, Bury, Boston Utd, Aldershot, Newport and some others.

    Cannot wait to see it with Chelsea and Neverton.
    Except Everton are at no risk of that whatever your fevered fantasies.
    We aren't even Russian owned.
    Incompetently owned I'll grant you.
  • philiphphiliph Posts: 4,704
    kamski said:

    Taz said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Volcano is an interesting one.

    The Yellowstone Caldera will go up one day and this one I read about recently caused cooling for 100 years

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory
    It will also bury much of North America in ash many, many inches deep.
    Back of a fag packet....

    I see wiki says 190 cubic miles of ash. That equates to 3.6m square miles at 4 inches deep.

    The whole of the USA (excluding Alaska and Hawaii) is some 8.1m square miles. So maybe half of the US would be uninhabitable/unfit for growing crops.
    Would 4 inches of ash really make ground unfit for growing crops? Just plough it into the earth surely?
    I suspect highy acidic?
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,561

    TimT said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    All of which is true, but still does not preclude the possibility that it was still nothing more than a functioning hospital
    According to RT (I know), the Russians reported the change of use of the building to the UN days ago. This would be verifiable I suppose. I am not going down the rabbit hole.
    RT reporting the use of ambulances to ferry Russian munitions around? Na, thought not....
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,070
    .

    IanB2 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Applicant said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Beautiful beautiful day here. Bright blue skies, 14C, the first real day of spring

    March 10! Somehow it is always March 10, the second week of March, the true end of winter.

    Life is still shit, but, hey, spring. That's something

    No, the true end of winter and start of spring is March 20th, so we still have 10 days of astronomical winter to go
    Seriously, what is wrong with you?
    Nothing, I still keep my winter coat and scarf on and drink red wine and eat winter vegetables until March 20th.

    I only take off my coat and scarf and switch to white wine and salad once spring starts on March 21st
    Really - you are jesting surely
    It’s quite an observation that most of us are wondering whether this is serious or not…
    I've had a brief moment of doubt and considered that HYUFD might be SeanT's only successful deep cover creation, then remembered that he'd be far too lazy to pore over all these polls, let alone base the fiction on them that HYUFD does.
    Either he just committed a joke - in which case there's hope for society - or he's stranger than we thought.
    I lean to the former.
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 28,419
    Aslan said:

    Aslan said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    It seems "likely" to you based on no evidence at all except Russia claims it.
    No, it seemed likely to me BEFORE I read the Russians' claims. As I said, basing themselves in a building like a hospital is a common and logical tactic for a military defending urban territory. It also seemed unlikely that Russia would actively bomb a hospital full of expectant mothers and newborns, even if they were the embodiment of evil, because it would hand a propaganda coup to the other side. The other alternative was that it was a cock up, which was highly possible.
    Russia has spent the last week completely leveling a Russian speaking city to the ground. After their Plan A has fallen apart, and they know they can't win militarily so hope to force Ukraine to give some concessions to avoid the sort of destruction seen in Chechnya. They have deliberately switched to a policy of terror so don't care about PR value any more. It serves their purposes that stuff is as brutal as possible.
    I've seen the argument that the Russians just don't care because they now just want to kill, and the alternative riff, which is that they are attempting actively to provoke a NATO response. I really don't buy either of these. I think they're determined to plow on and are prepared to kill some civilians in the process (which is bad) but I don't think they benefit from bombing normal hospitals. Qui Bono is a sound principle, and the benefit in this to me is all the Ukrainians'.
  • kamskikamski Posts: 5,190
    philiph said:

    kamski said:

    Taz said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Volcano is an interesting one.

    The Yellowstone Caldera will go up one day and this one I read about recently caused cooling for 100 years

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory
    It will also bury much of North America in ash many, many inches deep.
    Back of a fag packet....

    I see wiki says 190 cubic miles of ash. That equates to 3.6m square miles at 4 inches deep.

    The whole of the USA (excluding Alaska and Hawaii) is some 8.1m square miles. So maybe half of the US would be uninhabitable/unfit for growing crops.
    Would 4 inches of ash really make ground unfit for growing crops? Just plough it into the earth surely?
    I suspect highy acidic?
    possibly, although areas with loads of volcanic ash falling on them (eg around Etna) are very fertile, so dunno?
  • AslanAslan Posts: 1,673

    dixiedean said:

    Taz said:

    dixiedean said:

    Blooming heck!
    Just reading Chelsea can't sell any more tickets.

    Chelsea will be in the championship in 2 years if they still exist
    Chelsea 2022, the newly formed club from the embers of the current club when it goes bump, should start at the very foot of the football league pyramid.

    Same for Everton 2022 when that happens

    Everton ain't going bust though.
    Well nobody wants to buy their players, so they would be uneffected by that :-)
    Man Utd want Richarlison
    Why do Man Utd want yet another attacking wide player? They only have about 12...
    Man Utd need to spend all their money on two top rate DMs.
  • AslanAslan Posts: 1,673

    Aslan said:

    Aslan said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    It seems "likely" to you based on no evidence at all except Russia claims it.
    No, it seemed likely to me BEFORE I read the Russians' claims. As I said, basing themselves in a building like a hospital is a common and logical tactic for a military defending urban territory. It also seemed unlikely that Russia would actively bomb a hospital full of expectant mothers and newborns, even if they were the embodiment of evil, because it would hand a propaganda coup to the other side. The other alternative was that it was a cock up, which was highly possible.
    Russia has spent the last week completely leveling a Russian speaking city to the ground. After their Plan A has fallen apart, and they know they can't win militarily so hope to force Ukraine to give some concessions to avoid the sort of destruction seen in Chechnya. They have deliberately switched to a policy of terror so don't care about PR value any more. It serves their purposes that stuff is as brutal as possible.
    I've seen the argument that the Russians just don't care because they now just want to kill, and the alternative riff, which is that they are attempting actively to provoke a NATO response. I really don't buy either of these. I think they're determined to plow on and are prepared to kill some civilians in the process (which is bad) but I don't think they benefit from bombing normal hospitals. Qui Bono is a sound principle, and the benefit in this to me is all the Ukrainians'.
    They have already completely leveled the center of Kharkiv. That goes way beyond "kill some civilians in the process".
  • Luckyguy1983Luckyguy1983 Posts: 28,419
    edited March 2022

    TimT said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    All of which is true, but still does not preclude the possibility that it was still nothing more than a functioning hospital
    According to RT (I know), the Russians reported the change of use of the building to the UN days ago. This would be verifiable I suppose. I am not going down the rabbit hole.
    RT reporting the use of ambulances to ferry Russian munitions around? Na, thought not....
    Not that I could see. I hop on every other day to see what they're saying (during this conflict, not as a normal habit!). I used to read it a lot more uncritically back in the day. Now I read it a lot more cynically.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 81,991
    edited March 2022
    Aslan said:

    dixiedean said:

    Taz said:

    dixiedean said:

    Blooming heck!
    Just reading Chelsea can't sell any more tickets.

    Chelsea will be in the championship in 2 years if they still exist
    Chelsea 2022, the newly formed club from the embers of the current club when it goes bump, should start at the very foot of the football league pyramid.

    Same for Everton 2022 when that happens

    Everton ain't going bust though.
    Well nobody wants to buy their players, so they would be uneffected by that :-)
    Man Utd want Richarlison
    Why do Man Utd want yet another attacking wide player? They only have about 12...
    Man Utd need to spend all their money on two top rate DMs.
    Man Utd problems go way deeper. Tifo football explained how they can't play so many common leading strategies because their squad is so unbalanced and too many players who can't (or won't) play in certain roles.

    For example they can't play attacking right / left back strategies because Shaw can, Wan-Bassika can't and vice versa, Shaw loves his England role of being attacking rather than solely defensive.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 55,277
    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:


    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"


    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg
  • mwadamsmwadams Posts: 3,590
    HYUFD said:

    mwadams said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Wrath of God nul points.
    It was not an option, if it was the very religious would likely have got it to at least 10 to 20%
    Really? When 1.5% of the population are regular attenders of religious worship, and a whole bunch of those are probably not that radically superstitious, a 10x multiplier on that number seems a bit heavy.

    17% attend services at least once a month whether Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu etc, over a third less regularly. So wrong

    http://www.brin.ac.uk/changes-in-attendance-at-religious-services-in-britain/
    Yes, but weekly attendance is at about 1.5% of the population; You can multiply up from my figure, or divide down from yours, but I don't think it is realistic to suggest that the sporadic attenders include a high proportion of zealots who genuinely believe in a vengeful old testament God in any meaningful sense that isn't covered by the actuarial "acts of god" already in the list.
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830
    kamski said:

    Taz said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Volcano is an interesting one.

    The Yellowstone Caldera will go up one day and this one I read about recently caused cooling for 100 years

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory
    It will also bury much of North America in ash many, many inches deep.
    Back of a fag packet....

    I see wiki says 190 cubic miles of ash. That equates to 3.6m square miles at 4 inches deep.

    The whole of the USA (excluding Alaska and Hawaii) is some 8.1m square miles. So maybe half of the US would be uninhabitable/unfit for growing crops.
    Would 4 inches of ash really make ground unfit for growing crops? Just plough it into the earth surely?
    And it's not going to fall selectively at 4 ins deep, why would it? It's going to fall in the places and at the depth dictated by mother nature

    4 ins of ash would be a lot to plough in. The problem really is lack of sun for 10 years tho
  • AslanAslan Posts: 1,673

    Aslan said:

    dixiedean said:

    Taz said:

    dixiedean said:

    Blooming heck!
    Just reading Chelsea can't sell any more tickets.

    Chelsea will be in the championship in 2 years if they still exist
    Chelsea 2022, the newly formed club from the embers of the current club when it goes bump, should start at the very foot of the football league pyramid.

    Same for Everton 2022 when that happens

    Everton ain't going bust though.
    Well nobody wants to buy their players, so they would be uneffected by that :-)
    Man Utd want Richarlison
    Why do Man Utd want yet another attacking wide player? They only have about 12...
    Man Utd need to spend all their money on two top rate DMs.
    Man Utd problems go way deeper. Tifo football explained how they can't play so many common leading strategies because their squad is so unbalanced and too many players who can't (or won't) play in certain roles.
    They have good AMs and forwards. They have defenders that have played well in the past or for their national teams. The problem is their DMs are just way out of their depth and are critical for a 4-2-3-1. Once they get them they have the spine of a decent team and can then shed the deadwood.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,561
    edited March 2022
    kamski said:

    Taz said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Volcano is an interesting one.

    The Yellowstone Caldera will go up one day and this one I read about recently caused cooling for 100 years

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory
    It will also bury much of North America in ash many, many inches deep.
    Back of a fag packet....

    I see wiki says 190 cubic miles of ash. That equates to 3.6m square miles at 4 inches deep.

    The whole of the USA (excluding Alaska and Hawaii) is some 8.1m square miles. So maybe half of the US would be uninhabitable/unfit for growing crops.
    Would 4 inches of ash really make ground unfit for growing crops? Just plough it into the earth surely?
    You are going to plough 3.6m square miles? And it is alkaline - 8.5 to 8.9.
  • SandpitSandpit Posts: 54,582
    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
  • mwadamsmwadams Posts: 3,590
    mwadams said:

    HYUFD said:

    mwadams said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Wrath of God nul points.
    It was not an option, if it was the very religious would likely have got it to at least 10 to 20%
    Really? When 1.5% of the population are regular attenders of religious worship, and a whole bunch of those are probably not that radically superstitious, a 10x multiplier on that number seems a bit heavy.

    17% attend services at least once a month whether Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu etc, over a third less regularly. So wrong

    http://www.brin.ac.uk/changes-in-attendance-at-religious-services-in-britain/
    Yes, but weekly attendance is at about 1.5% of the population; You can multiply up from my figure, or divide down from yours, but I don't think it is realistic to suggest that the sporadic attenders include a high proportion of zealots who genuinely believe in a vengeful old testament God in any meaningful sense that isn't covered by the actuarial "acts of god" already in the list.
    Oh, and Christian church attendance is down about 15% between 2014 (your figures) and 2019, according to Statistica, so I think you'll find those numbers are probably on the high side.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,070

    Aslan said:

    Aslan said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    It seems "likely" to you based on no evidence at all except Russia claims it.
    No, it seemed likely to me BEFORE I read the Russians' claims. As I said, basing themselves in a building like a hospital is a common and logical tactic for a military defending urban territory. It also seemed unlikely that Russia would actively bomb a hospital full of expectant mothers and newborns, even if they were the embodiment of evil, because it would hand a propaganda coup to the other side. The other alternative was that it was a cock up, which was highly possible.
    Russia has spent the last week completely leveling a Russian speaking city to the ground. After their Plan A has fallen apart, and they know they can't win militarily so hope to force Ukraine to give some concessions to avoid the sort of destruction seen in Chechnya. They have deliberately switched to a policy of terror so don't care about PR value any more. It serves their purposes that stuff is as brutal as possible.
    I've seen the argument that the Russians just don't care because they now just want to kill, and the alternative riff, which is that they are attempting actively to provoke a NATO response. I really don't buy either of these. I think they're determined to plow on and are prepared to kill some civilians in the process (which is bad) but I don't think they benefit from bombing normal hospitals. Qui Bono is a sound principle, and the benefit in this to me is all the Ukrainians'.
    And those damn Syrian rebels just levelled Aleppo to give the Russians a bad name, too.

    You are effectively claiming that Russia is not bombarding cities with unguided munitions.
  • kyf_100kyf_100 Posts: 4,941

    BUPA been absolutely bloody useless in refusing to cover my mental health treatment, steer clear

    I had what I thought was very good health cover through my former employer. However, the only times I used it they tried to wiggle out of paying absolutely every bill on the slightest of pretences. I won't name names, but similar experience.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,188

    Taz said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Volcano is an interesting one.

    The Yellowstone Caldera will go up one day and this one I read about recently caused cooling for 100 years

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory
    It will also bury much of North America in ash many, many inches deep.
    Would yellowstone erupting basically make the CO2 heating argument moot ?
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 81,991
    edited March 2022
    Aslan said:

    Aslan said:

    dixiedean said:

    Taz said:

    dixiedean said:

    Blooming heck!
    Just reading Chelsea can't sell any more tickets.

    Chelsea will be in the championship in 2 years if they still exist
    Chelsea 2022, the newly formed club from the embers of the current club when it goes bump, should start at the very foot of the football league pyramid.

    Same for Everton 2022 when that happens

    Everton ain't going bust though.
    Well nobody wants to buy their players, so they would be uneffected by that :-)
    Man Utd want Richarlison
    Why do Man Utd want yet another attacking wide player? They only have about 12...
    Man Utd need to spend all their money on two top rate DMs.
    Man Utd problems go way deeper. Tifo football explained how they can't play so many common leading strategies because their squad is so unbalanced and too many players who can't (or won't) play in certain roles.
    They have good AMs and forwards. They have defenders that have played well in the past or for their national teams. The problem is their DMs are just way out of their depth and are critical for a 4-2-3-1. Once they get them they have the spine of a decent team and can then shed the deadwood.
    Even the forwards are a problem, too many want / are best at playing the same role or roles that don't compliment one another. The video is on youtube its worth watching, as they go through 3-4 different strategies and explain if they to play x, this means wek here and here and they can easily get picked off.

    The conclusion was they don't have a team. They have a collection of mismatching players and too many who play the same role.
  • If Chelsea and/or Everton go bust/get relegated I think I might actually die of laughter.

    Forget the quadruple, this would be the double.

    FWIW - I think Chelsea are screwed, they lost close to £150 million last season, and net losses of over a £1.5 billion over the last decade or two.

    If Roman cannot pump money into the club, they are buggered.

    I reckon they could get deducted points this season which might knock them out the CL places and more likely points deduction next season.

    It was also reported yesterday that Everton might also get points deduction next season.
  • IshmaelZIshmaelZ Posts: 21,830

    kamski said:

    Taz said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Volcano is an interesting one.

    The Yellowstone Caldera will go up one day and this one I read about recently caused cooling for 100 years

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory
    It will also bury much of North America in ash many, many inches deep.
    Back of a fag packet....

    I see wiki says 190 cubic miles of ash. That equates to 3.6m square miles at 4 inches deep.

    The whole of the USA (excluding Alaska and Hawaii) is some 8.1m square miles. So maybe half of the US would be uninhabitable/unfit for growing crops.
    Would 4 inches of ash really make ground unfit for growing crops? Just plough it into the earth surely?
    You are going to plough 3.6m square miles? And it is alkaline - 8.5 to 8.9.
    Acidic...
  • MalmesburyMalmesbury Posts: 50,249

    Aslan said:

    Aslan said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    It seems "likely" to you based on no evidence at all except Russia claims it.
    No, it seemed likely to me BEFORE I read the Russians' claims. As I said, basing themselves in a building like a hospital is a common and logical tactic for a military defending urban territory. It also seemed unlikely that Russia would actively bomb a hospital full of expectant mothers and newborns, even if they were the embodiment of evil, because it would hand a propaganda coup to the other side. The other alternative was that it was a cock up, which was highly possible.
    Russia has spent the last week completely leveling a Russian speaking city to the ground. After their Plan A has fallen apart, and they know they can't win militarily so hope to force Ukraine to give some concessions to avoid the sort of destruction seen in Chechnya. They have deliberately switched to a policy of terror so don't care about PR value any more. It serves their purposes that stuff is as brutal as possible.
    I've seen the argument that the Russians just don't care because they now just want to kill, and the alternative riff, which is that they are attempting actively to provoke a NATO response. I really don't buy either of these. I think they're determined to plow on and are prepared to kill some civilians in the process (which is bad) but I don't think they benefit from bombing normal hospitals. Qui Bono is a sound principle, and the benefit in this to me is all the Ukrainians'.
    I don't think that the Russians are dong this for The Evuls.

    Looking at the rest of what is going on, they have a rather uncoordinated military capability, with emphasis on lower tech - very little use of guided munitions, planes dropping vintage dumb bombs etc.

    They are using more and more indiscriminate firepower, because that is what they have.
  • AslanAslan Posts: 1,673
    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    Shit will really hit the fan when they default without an IMF backstop.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,561
    Aslan said:

    Aslan said:

    Aslan said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    It seems "likely" to you based on no evidence at all except Russia claims it.
    No, it seemed likely to me BEFORE I read the Russians' claims. As I said, basing themselves in a building like a hospital is a common and logical tactic for a military defending urban territory. It also seemed unlikely that Russia would actively bomb a hospital full of expectant mothers and newborns, even if they were the embodiment of evil, because it would hand a propaganda coup to the other side. The other alternative was that it was a cock up, which was highly possible.
    Russia has spent the last week completely leveling a Russian speaking city to the ground. After their Plan A has fallen apart, and they know they can't win militarily so hope to force Ukraine to give some concessions to avoid the sort of destruction seen in Chechnya. They have deliberately switched to a policy of terror so don't care about PR value any more. It serves their purposes that stuff is as brutal as possible.
    I've seen the argument that the Russians just don't care because they now just want to kill, and the alternative riff, which is that they are attempting actively to provoke a NATO response. I really don't buy either of these. I think they're determined to plow on and are prepared to kill some civilians in the process (which is bad) but I don't think they benefit from bombing normal hospitals. Qui Bono is a sound principle, and the benefit in this to me is all the Ukrainians'.
    They have already completely leveled the center of Kharkiv. That goes way beyond "kill some civilians in the process".
    That'll teach them for being ethnically Russian. Hah!!

    Oh.....
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 41,955
    edited March 2022
    Nigelb said:

    .

    IanB2 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Applicant said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Beautiful beautiful day here. Bright blue skies, 14C, the first real day of spring

    March 10! Somehow it is always March 10, the second week of March, the true end of winter.

    Life is still shit, but, hey, spring. That's something

    No, the true end of winter and start of spring is March 20th, so we still have 10 days of astronomical winter to go
    Seriously, what is wrong with you?
    Nothing, I still keep my winter coat and scarf on and drink red wine and eat winter vegetables until March 20th.

    I only take off my coat and scarf and switch to white wine and salad once spring starts on March 21st
    Really - you are jesting surely
    It’s quite an observation that most of us are wondering whether this is serious or not…
    I've had a brief moment of doubt and considered that HYUFD might be SeanT's only successful deep cover creation, then remembered that he'd be far too lazy to pore over all these polls, let alone base the fiction on them that HYUFD does.
    Either he just committed a joke - in which case there's hope for society - or he's stranger than we thought.
    I lean to the former.
    Optimist!
    HYUFD does show occasional signs of having a soh but he only lets it escape on one out of every five blue moons, and when polling supports its release.
  • MISTYMISTY Posts: 1,594

    If Chelsea and/or Everton go bust/get relegated I think I might actually die of laughter.

    Forget the quadruple, this would be the double.

    FWIW - I think Chelsea are screwed, they lost close to £150 million last season, and net losses of over a £1.5 billion over the last decade or two.

    If Roman cannot pump money into the club, they are buggered.

    I reckon they could get deducted points this season which might knock them out the CL places and more likely points deduction next season.

    It was also reported yesterday that Everton might also get points deduction next season.

    Patrick O'Flynn points out that, at this week-ends Chelsea/Newcastle match, it'll be the Geordies waving their wads at the West Londoners...
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,188
    Aslan said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    Shit will really hit the fan when they default without an IMF backstop.
    They'll just have to remortgage with the bank of China. Price, all Russian minerals for the next hundred years.
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 71,070
    Selebian said:

    Dura_Ace said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    We do seem to have plenty on here who believe, with childlike credulity, any old toss the Ukranians say.
    True. And others* who give credence to Russian claims, despite the ample evidence that they've been largely talking bollocks for weeks.

    *not you
    While Ukraine is literally teasing us with occasionally releasing Bayraktar TB2 drone strikes, the best Russia can come up with is footage of its attack helicopters firing rockets at targets in the far distance.
    https://mobile.twitter.com/oryxspioenkop/status/1501900574241046531
  • mwadamsmwadams Posts: 3,590
    IshmaelZ said:

    kamski said:

    Taz said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Volcano is an interesting one.

    The Yellowstone Caldera will go up one day and this one I read about recently caused cooling for 100 years

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toba_catastrophe_theory
    It will also bury much of North America in ash many, many inches deep.
    Back of a fag packet....

    I see wiki says 190 cubic miles of ash. That equates to 3.6m square miles at 4 inches deep.

    The whole of the USA (excluding Alaska and Hawaii) is some 8.1m square miles. So maybe half of the US would be uninhabitable/unfit for growing crops.
    Would 4 inches of ash really make ground unfit for growing crops? Just plough it into the earth surely?
    You are going to plough 3.6m square miles? And it is alkaline - 8.5 to 8.9.
    Acidic...
    3.6m square miles would take at least 2 Ukrainian farmers.
  • FWIW - I have so much sympathy for Everton fans, none for Chelsea.

    Their success since 2003 is built on dirty money.

    Do not be deceived, God is not mocked; for whatever a man sows, that he will also reap. For he who sows to his flesh will of the flesh reap corruption, but he who sows to the Spirit will of the Spirit reap everlasting life.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,083

    kle4 said:

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    I dread to think what is is for the NFL.
    Oh its totally nuts. They all have special modified jumbo jets because of the size of the players and all the kit. I think Wendover Productions did an epsiode on the logistics of NFL.
    I saw that, but dont remember a dollar amount. I like their channel, and to plane lovers it must be heaven.
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,175
    https://order-order.com/2022/03/10/real-reason-pidcock-abandoned-parliamentary-return-attempt/

    Whilst it's amusing to think that Labour wanted to screw over Pidcock, my guess is they want to radically change the seats in the North East so as to reduce the incumbency bonus that the Tories may get.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 55,277
    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    The whole thread is fascinating - check the queues for McDonald's and ATMs in Moscow. And this is after just a couple of weeks of sanctions

    As you say, societies can crumble very quickly in situations like this. There will also be a chain reaction, unexpected problems will multiply. The West has basically taken the world's biggest spanner and shoved it in the Russian economy and it is already spitting with sparks, and grinding metal on metal

    Dangerous situation, tho. If Putin starts to panic... hmm. We do need to give him some kind of exit route, even if it sticks in the craw. Some face saving shit that he can just about sell to his people
  • CD13CD13 Posts: 6,366
    I suspect that the fog of war is used for a lot of things, but some things are certain.

    Putin and poisoning - they go together like mustard and cress. We know for sure that in 2004/2005, Victor Yushchenko was poisoned by a mixture of dioxins, the most potent of the 75 congeners being the 2,3,7,8 congener. They cause a disorder called chloracne which give facial skin an ugly appearance somewhat like acne and he suffered from a massve dose. An unfortunate happening if you're in a battle for the Presidency of the Ukraine with a gentlemen called Victor Yanukovych.

    There was no way this was accidental poisoning, he can only have been deliberately poisoned because of the doses and congener pattern involved.

    Cui Bono? A gentleman sat in the Kremiln called Valdimir. He has form with using any method he can to achieve his aim and poisoning is one of his favourites.
  • Northern_AlNorthern_Al Posts: 8,375

    IanB2 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Applicant said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Beautiful beautiful day here. Bright blue skies, 14C, the first real day of spring

    March 10! Somehow it is always March 10, the second week of March, the true end of winter.

    Life is still shit, but, hey, spring. That's something

    No, the true end of winter and start of spring is March 20th, so we still have 10 days of astronomical winter to go
    Seriously, what is wrong with you?
    Nothing, I still keep my winter coat and scarf on and drink red wine and eat winter vegetables until March 20th.

    I only take off my coat and scarf and switch to white wine and salad once spring starts on March 21st
    Really - you are jesting surely
    It’s quite an observation that most of us are wondering whether this is serious or not…
    I've had a brief moment of doubt and considered that HYUFD might be SeanT's only successful deep cover creation, then remembered that he'd be far too lazy to pore over all these polls, let alone base the fiction on them that HYUFD does.
    86.4% of PB posters agree with you, although that has declined significantly from a high of 86.5% last October.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,083
    IshmaelZ said:

    Alistair said:

    I see PB's Assad boot lickers are honing in on their angle for this conflict.

    They are HOMING in on it. like pigeons. Honing is sharpening razors.
    So they could be honing their arguments, or homing in on their angle.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 78,188
    HYUFD said:

    mwadams said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Wrath of God nul points.
    It was not an option, if it was the very religious would likely have got it to at least 10 to 20%
    Really? When 1.5% of the population are regular attenders of religious worship, and a whole bunch of those are probably not that radically superstitious, a 10x multiplier on that number seems a bit heavy.

    17% attend services at least once a month whether Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu etc, over a third less regularly. So wrong

    http://www.brin.ac.uk/changes-in-attendance-at-religious-services-in-britain/
    The main reason I've heard about for church attendance these days is to get kids into some school or other...
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,561
    Aslan said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    Shit will really hit the fan when they default without an IMF backstop.
    If they are already fighting over the last IKEA frying pan, what is going to like when they are fighting over the last bottle of vodka? Or the last potato?

    Life in Russia is very, very soon going to be very, very unpleasant. But hey, nobody is bombing the shit out of their apartment blocks, or their maternity hospitals, so it could be worse....
  • CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 60,216
    Ed Davey all over the shop on R4, sort of suggesting that Chelsea FC be sold to help subsidise domestic energy bills….then saying he’s not.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,485
    Leon said:

    Beautiful beautiful day here. Bright blue skies, 14C, the first real day of spring

    March 10! Somehow it is always March 10, the second week of March, the true end of winter.

    Life is still shit, but, hey, spring. That's something

    Interestingly (perhaps?) 10 March is the first day of thermal spring. The thermal seasons in England run approximately 10th to 10th, they are midway between the astronomical dates and the ludicrous 1st of the month date set by the Met Office for statistical convenience.

    Anyway, glad to see the great Seasons Dates debate continuing on PB. A classic.
  • MISTYMISTY Posts: 1,594
    Dan Hodges gets much wrong.

    But when he says that our strategy of confronting and defeating Putin, but doing so in a way that doesn't overly upset him, is neither stable nor coherent, he has hit the nail squarely on the head.

  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,485
    edited March 2022
    HYUFD said:

    Applicant said:

    HYUFD said:

    Leon said:

    Beautiful beautiful day here. Bright blue skies, 14C, the first real day of spring

    March 10! Somehow it is always March 10, the second week of March, the true end of winter.

    Life is still shit, but, hey, spring. That's something

    No, the true end of winter and start of spring is March 20th, so we still have 10 days of astronomical winter to go
    Seriously, what is wrong with you?
    Nothing, I still keep my winter coat and scarf on and drink red wine and eat winter vegetables until March 20th.

    I only take off my coat and scarf and switch to white wine and salad once spring starts on March 21st
    I admire your gastronomical discipline!
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 81,991
    edited March 2022
    I remember Peter Couch talking about games with Liverpool, he said basically he turned up with a washbag and that was it. All travel, clothes, meals etc etc etc all provided, even down to clean pants. And for holidays, he has a lady he phones who sorts everything, that did basically the same.

    When he stopped playing it was a massive shock that all of a sudden every meal wasn't just there, that he had to think about making sure had clean clothes etc...
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,561
    CD13 said:

    I suspect that the fog of war is used for a lot of things, but some things are certain.

    Putin and poisoning - they go together like mustard and cress.

    Or mustard and gas....
  • TazTaz Posts: 14,376
    MISTY said:

    If Chelsea and/or Everton go bust/get relegated I think I might actually die of laughter.

    Forget the quadruple, this would be the double.

    FWIW - I think Chelsea are screwed, they lost close to £150 million last season, and net losses of over a £1.5 billion over the last decade or two.

    If Roman cannot pump money into the club, they are buggered.

    I reckon they could get deducted points this season which might knock them out the CL places and more likely points deduction next season.

    It was also reported yesterday that Everton might also get points deduction next season.

    Patrick O'Flynn points out that, at this week-ends Chelsea/Newcastle match, it'll be the Geordies waving their wads at the West Londoners...
    They need to be careful. Things can change very quickly.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,485
    dixiedean said:

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    What on Earth does that consist of?

    Doesn't strike me as very much. Assuming 30 people travel, spend of £1,000 per person for two night in a five star hotel including meals and other stuff. Easy to see how they reach £30k.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 51,625
    Pulpstar said:

    Aslan said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    Shit will really hit the fan when they default without an IMF backstop.
    They'll just have to remortgage with the bank of China. Price, all Russian minerals for the next hundred years.
    It's possible that might be the moment that triggers a pro-Western coup. The Russian elite are much more culturally inclined towards the West.
  • turbotubbsturbotubbs Posts: 17,405
    kle4 said:

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    I dread to think what is is for the NFL.
    They seem to have so many players, for an 11-a-side game.
  • edmundintokyoedmundintokyo Posts: 17,708
    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:


    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"


    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    They mention losing support for Cisco kit. That partly results in stuff just stopping, but in a lot of cases what'll happen with software is that stuff will fail to get security updates and end up with more and more known vulnerabilities, and anything in Russia connected to the internet will end up a very easy target for hackers. Maybe that's why they haven't been escalating on the cyber front.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 55,277

    Aslan said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    Shit will really hit the fan when they default without an IMF backstop.
    If they are already fighting over the last IKEA frying pan, what is going to like when they are fighting over the last bottle of vodka? Or the last potato?

    Life in Russia is very, very soon going to be very, very unpleasant. But hey, nobody is bombing the shit out of their apartment blocks, or their maternity hospitals, so it could be worse....
    All the Russians I have met REALLY enjoy a western-style consumer society. They LOVE western products, fashions, etc (tho I guess some can be replaced by China), they adore escaping the Russian winter and going on hols to the tropics

    Putin has taken all of that away, for the next ten years Russians will be holidaying in Crimea, if they can get there over the landmines. Their roubles are now worthless so they will be eating parsnips

    Putin could become wildly unpopular in a short space of time. And for what? Russia was not threatened. Such madness
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,561
    Leon said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    The whole thread is fascinating - check the queues for McDonald's and ATMs in Moscow. And this is after just a couple of weeks of sanctions

    As you say, societies can crumble very quickly in situations like this. There will also be a chain reaction, unexpected problems will multiply. The West has basically taken the world's biggest spanner and shoved it in the Russian economy and it is already spitting with sparks, and grinding metal on metal

    Dangerous situation, tho. If Putin starts to panic... hmm. We do need to give him some kind of exit route, even if it sticks in the craw. Some face saving shit that he can just about sell to his people
    His exit strategy is to turn his columns round and go back over the border into Russia proper. Now. Politically unpalatable? Tough shit. Plan B is they go home in body bags. And the sanctions stay in place months longer, just to make sure he has got the message.
  • NorthofStokeNorthofStoke Posts: 1,758
    MISTY said:

    Dan Hodges gets much wrong.

    But when he says that our strategy of confronting and defeating Putin, but doing so in a way that doesn't overly upset him, is neither stable nor coherent, he has hit the nail squarely on the head.

    I disagree. We are abiding by clearly defined rules of engagement between NATO and Russia that are understood by the Russian military and other players within Russia. It is true that a maddened Putin, perhaps drug addled or tipped over into insanity may break them and try to launch a nuclear attack but we have done everything we can to enable internal forces in Russia to move to prevent that. If Putin is ruthless and paranoid but also rational in decision making the policy is also the correct one.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 81,991
    edited March 2022

    dixiedean said:

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    What on Earth does that consist of?

    Doesn't strike me as very much. Assuming 30 people travel, spend of £1,000 per person for two night in a five star hotel including meals and other stuff. Easy to see how they reach £30k.
    Do premier league players even share rooms these day? I think they do, at least I remember staying in hotel with an European team over here playing champions league and i know they did, as they were on our floor.
  • Scott_xPScott_xP Posts: 35,990
    Leon said:

    All the Russians I have met REALLY enjoy a western-style consumer society. They LOVE western products, fashions, etc (tho I guess some can be replaced by China), they adore escaping the Russian winter and going on hols to the tropics

    Quite the thread, about Lavrov's stepdaugther, living the life in London. https://twitter.com/pevchikh/status/1501878715709632518
  • pingping Posts: 3,805
    edited March 2022
    Taz said:

    MISTY said:

    If Chelsea and/or Everton go bust/get relegated I think I might actually die of laughter.

    Forget the quadruple, this would be the double.

    FWIW - I think Chelsea are screwed, they lost close to £150 million last season, and net losses of over a £1.5 billion over the last decade or two.

    If Roman cannot pump money into the club, they are buggered.

    I reckon they could get deducted points this season which might knock them out the CL places and more likely points deduction next season.

    It was also reported yesterday that Everton might also get points deduction next season.

    Patrick O'Flynn points out that, at this week-ends Chelsea/Newcastle match, it'll be the Geordies waving their wads at the West Londoners...
    They need to be careful. Things can change very quickly.
    Indeed.

    The Overton window has shifted. I can see us, in the future, being much more assertive in using these kind of severe sanctions to achieve foreign policy goals. We’ve entered a “dodgy money be damned” era.

    It’ll be fascinating to watch how this plays out over the next few years.

    I heard some military guy on iirc, times radio a few days ago who thought we’re probably entering a new phase of globalisation, with different economic spheres which don’t interact much with each other. We’re seeing disinvestment on a huge scale.
  • AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 23,485

    dixiedean said:

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    What on Earth does that consist of?

    Doesn't strike me as very much. Assuming 30 people travel, spend of £1,000 per person for two night in a five star hotel including meals and other stuff. Easy to see how they reach £30k.
    Do premier league players even share rooms these day?
    I doubt it. Anything that risks making sleep harder to attain will surely be avoided.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,918
    Leon said:

    Aslan said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    Shit will really hit the fan when they default without an IMF backstop.
    If they are already fighting over the last IKEA frying pan, what is going to like when they are fighting over the last bottle of vodka? Or the last potato?

    Life in Russia is very, very soon going to be very, very unpleasant. But hey, nobody is bombing the shit out of their apartment blocks, or their maternity hospitals, so it could be worse....
    All the Russians I have met REALLY enjoy a western-style consumer society. They LOVE western products, fashions, etc (tho I guess some can be replaced by China), they adore escaping the Russian winter and going on hols to the tropics

    Putin has taken all of that away, for the next ten years Russians will be holidaying in Crimea, if they can get there over the landmines. Their roubles are now worthless so they will be eating parsnips

    Putin could become wildly unpopular in a short space of time. And for what? Russia was not threatened. Such madness
    Yes but I would imagine the Russians you know are more likely to be middle class and more educated, liberal and wealthier than the average Russian and living in big cities like Moscow and St Petersburg. There is resistance already to Putin there.

    Out in rural Russia though where voters are less wealth off, less likely to travel abroad and less educated voters are more nationalist and more pro Putin
  • NorthofStokeNorthofStoke Posts: 1,758
    ping said:

    Taz said:

    MISTY said:

    If Chelsea and/or Everton go bust/get relegated I think I might actually die of laughter.

    Forget the quadruple, this would be the double.

    FWIW - I think Chelsea are screwed, they lost close to £150 million last season, and net losses of over a £1.5 billion over the last decade or two.

    If Roman cannot pump money into the club, they are buggered.

    I reckon they could get deducted points this season which might knock them out the CL places and more likely points deduction next season.

    It was also reported yesterday that Everton might also get points deduction next season.

    Patrick O'Flynn points out that, at this week-ends Chelsea/Newcastle match, it'll be the Geordies waving their wads at the West Londoners...
    They need to be careful. Things can change very quickly.
    Indeed.

    The Overton window has shifted. I can see us, in the future, being much more assertive in using these kind of severe sanctions to achieve foreign policy goals. We’ve entered a “dodgy money be damned” era.

    It’ll be fascinating to watch how this plays out over the next few years.
    Yes, there are going to be big political changes. I also predict more realistic energy policies with Green agendas side-lined and big increases in military expenditure.
  • eekeek Posts: 28,368

    Leon said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    The whole thread is fascinating - check the queues for McDonald's and ATMs in Moscow. And this is after just a couple of weeks of sanctions

    As you say, societies can crumble very quickly in situations like this. There will also be a chain reaction, unexpected problems will multiply. The West has basically taken the world's biggest spanner and shoved it in the Russian economy and it is already spitting with sparks, and grinding metal on metal

    Dangerous situation, tho. If Putin starts to panic... hmm. We do need to give him some kind of exit route, even if it sticks in the craw. Some face saving shit that he can just about sell to his people
    His exit strategy is to turn his columns round and go back over the border into Russia proper. Now. Politically unpalatable? Tough shit. Plan B is they go home in body bags. And the sanctions stay in place months longer, just to make sure he has got the message.
    The sanctions are going to stay in place for years - it's the final kick in the arse to get a Net Zero policy implemented.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,918
    edited March 2022
    Pulpstar said:

    HYUFD said:

    mwadams said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Wrath of God nul points.
    It was not an option, if it was the very religious would likely have got it to at least 10 to 20%
    Really? When 1.5% of the population are regular attenders of religious worship, and a whole bunch of those are probably not that radically superstitious, a 10x multiplier on that number seems a bit heavy.

    17% attend services at least once a month whether Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu etc, over a third less regularly. So wrong

    http://www.brin.ac.uk/changes-in-attendance-at-religious-services-in-britain/
    The main reason I've heard about for church attendance these days is to get kids into some school or other...
    For some and nothing wrong with that, there are many excellent church schools.

    However that is less true of evangelical churches, Mosques, synagogues, temples etc and also obviously less true for more elderly worshippers in the Church of England and Roman Catholic church
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,083

    Aslan said:

    Aslan said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    It seems "likely" to you based on no evidence at all except Russia claims it.
    No, it seemed likely to me BEFORE I read the Russians' claims. As I said, basing themselves in a building like a hospital is a common and logical tactic for a military defending urban territory. It also seemed unlikely that Russia would actively bomb a hospital full of expectant mothers and newborns, even if they were the embodiment of evil, because it would hand a propaganda coup to the other side. The other alternative was that it was a cock up, which was highly possible.
    Russia has spent the last week completely leveling a Russian speaking city to the ground. After their Plan A has fallen apart, and they know they can't win militarily so hope to force Ukraine to give some concessions to avoid the sort of destruction seen in Chechnya. They have deliberately switched to a policy of terror so don't care about PR value any more. It serves their purposes that stuff is as brutal as possible.
    I've seen the argument that the Russians just don't care because they now just want to kill, and the alternative riff, which is that they are attempting actively to provoke a NATO response. I really don't buy either of these. I think they're determined to plow on and are prepared to kill some civilians in the process (which is bad) but I don't think they benefit from bombing normal hospitals. Qui Bono is a sound principle, and the benefit in this to me is all the Ukrainians'.
    That doesn't make any sense. Faking a hospital bombing or rather lying about military use of it which would make it a legitimate target would not benefit the Ukrainians in the slightes since it would come out and would prevent an international response to a future event as it would be doubted.

    If it doesnt benefit Russia to do it it makes even less sense and doesn't benefit Ukraine to lie about provoking it.

    This seems on the same lines as 'X wouldn't do Y because theyd know it would hinder them, therefore it must be Z' yet people do counterproductive things all the time - the invasion itself being a case in point.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,561
    Leon said:

    Aslan said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    Shit will really hit the fan when they default without an IMF backstop.
    If they are already fighting over the last IKEA frying pan, what is going to like when they are fighting over the last bottle of vodka? Or the last potato?

    Life in Russia is very, very soon going to be very, very unpleasant. But hey, nobody is bombing the shit out of their apartment blocks, or their maternity hospitals, so it could be worse....
    All the Russians I have met REALLY enjoy a western-style consumer society. They LOVE western products, fashions, etc (tho I guess some can be replaced by China), they adore escaping the Russian winter and going on hols to the tropics

    Putin has taken all of that away, for the next ten years Russians will be holidaying in Crimea, if they can get there over the landmines. Their roubles are now worthless so they will be eating parsnips

    Putin could become wildly unpopular in a short space of time. And for what? Russia was not threatened. Such madness
    This is already the most stupid action of the 21st Century. The smart Russians have already legged it out of there with foreign currency/gold bars. For the rest, it is a long decline, with hungry bellies ruminating on how they cheered on their troops going on another foreign excursion.

    To protect their lifestyles. Well, how did that pan out?
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 122,918
    edited March 2022
    mwadams said:

    mwadams said:

    HYUFD said:

    mwadams said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    61% now see Nuclear War as one of the most likely causes of human extinction, as it takes a clear lead over global warming in second

    Nuclear War 61% (+18%)
    Global Warming 41% (-1%)
    Pandemic 29% (-1%)
    Meteor 25% (nc)
    Volcano 18% (-5%)
    Bees dying out 16% (nc)

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1501893049089150976?s=20&t=U5v3vnWGKdUFKBfAaHOnNA

    Wrath of God nul points.
    It was not an option, if it was the very religious would likely have got it to at least 10 to 20%
    Really? When 1.5% of the population are regular attenders of religious worship, and a whole bunch of those are probably not that radically superstitious, a 10x multiplier on that number seems a bit heavy.

    17% attend services at least once a month whether Christian, Muslim, Jewish, Hindu etc, over a third less regularly. So wrong

    http://www.brin.ac.uk/changes-in-attendance-at-religious-services-in-britain/
    Yes, but weekly attendance is at about 1.5% of the population; You can multiply up from my figure, or divide down from yours, but I don't think it is realistic to suggest that the sporadic attenders include a high proportion of zealots who genuinely believe in a vengeful old testament God in any meaningful sense that isn't covered by the actuarial "acts of god" already in the list.
    Oh, and Christian church attendance is down about 15% between 2014 (your figures) and 2019, according to Statistica, so I think you'll find those numbers are probably on the high side.
    Still over 10% though and still way higher than the 1.5% you said.

    1.5% is just the number who attend weekly Church of England services and members of the Church of England are only a minority of Christians and Christians are only a minority of religions as a whole
  • mwadamsmwadams Posts: 3,590

    Leon said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    The whole thread is fascinating - check the queues for McDonald's and ATMs in Moscow. And this is after just a couple of weeks of sanctions

    As you say, societies can crumble very quickly in situations like this. There will also be a chain reaction, unexpected problems will multiply. The West has basically taken the world's biggest spanner and shoved it in the Russian economy and it is already spitting with sparks, and grinding metal on metal

    Dangerous situation, tho. If Putin starts to panic... hmm. We do need to give him some kind of exit route, even if it sticks in the craw. Some face saving shit that he can just about sell to his people
    His exit strategy is to turn his columns round and go back over the border into Russia proper. Now. Politically unpalatable? Tough shit. Plan B is they go home in body bags. And the sanctions stay in place months longer, just to make sure he has got the message.
    At any time, Putin can declare "mission succeeded, the Nazis are gone, rule of law back in place" and roll the tanks home. Given that there weren't any Nazis (meaningfully) that is essentially true. That is his get out.

    We (the international community) would probably allow him to get away with that.
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 42,572
    Carnyx said:

    FPT:

    Carnyx said:

    https://www.theguardian.com/business/2022/mar/10/wrongly-built-drainage-system-led-to-stonehaven-train-crash-investigators-find

    Quite unexpected to find it is not old Victorian engineering* that was the problem but very modern contractor work.

    Indeed. Also note that there were issues with Network Rail not inspecting the upper parts of the drainage system, at all - because it had not been entered onto the system. This is where (in the good old days) linesmen would have known 'their' patrol stretch like the back of their hand, and would have known to look at the state of the drains.

    Having said that, these sorts of things were also much more frequent in those days...

    RAIB have produced a chilling video showing what happened:
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6iP0PJMu_8s

    And RAIB's report:
    https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/1059412/R022022_220310_Carmont.pdf
    Thanks for pointing those out. Washouts and debris are nothijng new as you say - Carr Bridge, the Eye Water in 1948 ... https://www.aytonhistory.com/the-1948-flood

    The video you cite video is quite the modern equivalent of those engravings in the Sapper Colonels' reports for the Railway Inspectorate in Victorian times. Very substantial report, too; have only dipped into it; look forward to taking a proper look later.
    RAIB reports are always excellent; technically, in terms of language, and in developing robust conclusions without screeching: "There's the witch!"
  • LeonLeon Posts: 55,277
    Scott_xP said:

    Leon said:

    All the Russians I have met REALLY enjoy a western-style consumer society. They LOVE western products, fashions, etc (tho I guess some can be replaced by China), they adore escaping the Russian winter and going on hols to the tropics

    Quite the thread, about Lavrov's stepdaugther, living the life in London. https://twitter.com/pevchikh/status/1501878715709632518
    Illuminating

    And yes, Russians like that will already be cursing Putin. But it won't stop with the kids-of-oligarchs, it will soon be any middle class Russian with any aspirations. Putin has fucked their dreams
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 81,991
    edited March 2022

    dixiedean said:

    Football bod saying on Sky typical spend for EPL club on away travel to other EPL games is £30k. Puts into perspective what a totally different world players live in.

    What on Earth does that consist of?

    Doesn't strike me as very much. Assuming 30 people travel, spend of £1,000 per person for two night in a five star hotel including meals and other stuff. Easy to see how they reach £30k.
    Do premier league players even share rooms these day?
    I doubt it. Anything that risks making sleep harder to attain will surely be avoided.
    Other than Burley, they more than likely stay in a Travelodge specificly because you can have 4 in a room via those sofa beds....

    I've actually met Sean Dyche, he is a top bloke and super grounded. He is really big on players not thinking they are Billy Big Bollocks just because they play in the premier league.
  • kle4kle4 Posts: 96,083
    MISTY said:

    Dan Hodges gets much wrong.

    But when he says that our strategy of confronting and defeating Putin, but doing so in a way that doesn't overly upset him, is neither stable nor coherent, he has hit the nail squarely on the head.

    Yes. Doesn't make deciding what to do simpler, but he's correct it is not entirely coherent.
  • mwadamsmwadams Posts: 3,590
    mwadams said:

    Leon said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    The whole thread is fascinating - check the queues for McDonald's and ATMs in Moscow. And this is after just a couple of weeks of sanctions

    As you say, societies can crumble very quickly in situations like this. There will also be a chain reaction, unexpected problems will multiply. The West has basically taken the world's biggest spanner and shoved it in the Russian economy and it is already spitting with sparks, and grinding metal on metal

    Dangerous situation, tho. If Putin starts to panic... hmm. We do need to give him some kind of exit route, even if it sticks in the craw. Some face saving shit that he can just about sell to his people
    His exit strategy is to turn his columns round and go back over the border into Russia proper. Now. Politically unpalatable? Tough shit. Plan B is they go home in body bags. And the sanctions stay in place months longer, just to make sure he has got the message.
    At any time, Putin can declare "mission succeeded, the Nazis are gone, rule of law back in place" and roll the tanks home. Given that there weren't any Nazis (meaningfully) that is essentially true. That is his get out.

    We (the international community) would probably allow him to get away with that.
    I supposed the one sticking point there is that they'd probably have to leave a heck of a lot of materiel in the field, as it is incapable of being driven back home.
  • geoffwgeoffw Posts: 8,717
    Chelsea, Everton, Rangers - what's in common?
    The blues blew it.
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:


    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"


    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    I'm sorry, that is clearly faked- two people pulling on an IKEA frying pan like that for that long would have easily bent the fucker in half.

  • Chelsea to seek changes to the licence so it can operate normally

    It does not get it does it
  • AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    kle4 said:

    Aslan said:

    Aslan said:

    Regarding the maternity hospital, the Russians claim that the hospital had ceased to function as a hospital several days ago, and had become a base for a Ukrainian military division. This seemed likely to me yesterday, even without the claims - using schools, hospitals, Churches, Mosques etc. as military bases is a very common tactic of urban warfare, because when they're attacked, it's of course considered an atrocity.

    One side of this conflict is in the right, one side is in the wrong, but that doesn't stop the Ukrainians from fighting a propaganda war. As Western countries, we need to be extremely conscious of this, because the Ukrainians are desperate for Western nations to attack Russia, and will use every lever possible to make this a reality.

    It seems "likely" to you based on no evidence at all except Russia claims it.
    No, it seemed likely to me BEFORE I read the Russians' claims. As I said, basing themselves in a building like a hospital is a common and logical tactic for a military defending urban territory. It also seemed unlikely that Russia would actively bomb a hospital full of expectant mothers and newborns, even if they were the embodiment of evil, because it would hand a propaganda coup to the other side. The other alternative was that it was a cock up, which was highly possible.
    Russia has spent the last week completely leveling a Russian speaking city to the ground. After their Plan A has fallen apart, and they know they can't win militarily so hope to force Ukraine to give some concessions to avoid the sort of destruction seen in Chechnya. They have deliberately switched to a policy of terror so don't care about PR value any more. It serves their purposes that stuff is as brutal as possible.
    I've seen the argument that the Russians just don't care because they now just want to kill, and the alternative riff, which is that they are attempting actively to provoke a NATO response. I really don't buy either of these. I think they're determined to plow on and are prepared to kill some civilians in the process (which is bad) but I don't think they benefit from bombing normal hospitals. Qui Bono is a sound principle, and the benefit in this to me is all the Ukrainians'.
    That doesn't make any sense. Faking a hospital bombing or rather lying about military use of it which would make it a legitimate target would not benefit the Ukrainians in the slightes since it would come out and would prevent an international response to a future event as it would be doubted.

    If it doesnt benefit Russia to do it it makes even less sense and doesn't benefit Ukraine to lie about provoking it.

    This seems on the same lines as 'X wouldn't do Y because theyd know it would hinder them, therefore it must be Z' yet people do counterproductive things all the time - the invasion itself being a case in point.
    You have to commend the Ukrainians commitment to the deception - getting a pregnant women in to be stretchered across the blast zone


  • NorthofStokeNorthofStoke Posts: 1,758
    eek said:

    Leon said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    The whole thread is fascinating - check the queues for McDonald's and ATMs in Moscow. And this is after just a couple of weeks of sanctions

    As you say, societies can crumble very quickly in situations like this. There will also be a chain reaction, unexpected problems will multiply. The West has basically taken the world's biggest spanner and shoved it in the Russian economy and it is already spitting with sparks, and grinding metal on metal

    Dangerous situation, tho. If Putin starts to panic... hmm. We do need to give him some kind of exit route, even if it sticks in the craw. Some face saving shit that he can just about sell to his people
    His exit strategy is to turn his columns round and go back over the border into Russia proper. Now. Politically unpalatable? Tough shit. Plan B is they go home in body bags. And the sanctions stay in place months longer, just to make sure he has got the message.
    The sanctions are going to stay in place for years - it's the final kick in the arse to get a Net Zero policy implemented.
    Probably right in your first point, unfortunately I don't think accelerating renewables will solve the short-fall of a boycott, other fossil fuel resources will have to be substituted at least for a while. Cost will be a critical factor as well as technology, wea re riding through the biggest economic storm since WW2, COVID and now this war.
  • FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 81,991
    edited March 2022

    Chelsea to seek changes to the licence so it can operate normally

    It does not get it does it

    Actually i don't blame them. Not being able to sell match day tickets is really silly. That's totally different from you can't spend £100 million on a new player. I imagine they don't think they will get total free nornal operation, but get some concessions to the licence.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 52,561
    eek said:

    Leon said:

    Sandpit said:

    Leon said:

    Excellent thread on relevant Russian history (esp the Russo-Jap war) and sanctions. Loved this bit:

    "Economic sufferings in Russia are now absolutely obvious. Here you see two women fighting over a frying pan in the last day before IKEA closes its business in Russia"

    https://twitter.com/kamilkazani/status/1501684994502443009?s=20&t=IZT62Q7JIFEYGCv1678XSg

    It’s still very much first world problems in Moscow at the moment, but it’s not going to take too long before it’s bread lines and soup kitchens in many Russian cities.
    The whole thread is fascinating - check the queues for McDonald's and ATMs in Moscow. And this is after just a couple of weeks of sanctions

    As you say, societies can crumble very quickly in situations like this. There will also be a chain reaction, unexpected problems will multiply. The West has basically taken the world's biggest spanner and shoved it in the Russian economy and it is already spitting with sparks, and grinding metal on metal

    Dangerous situation, tho. If Putin starts to panic... hmm. We do need to give him some kind of exit route, even if it sticks in the craw. Some face saving shit that he can just about sell to his people
    His exit strategy is to turn his columns round and go back over the border into Russia proper. Now. Politically unpalatable? Tough shit. Plan B is they go home in body bags. And the sanctions stay in place months longer, just to make sure he has got the message.
    The sanctions are going to stay in place for years - it's the final kick in the arse to get a Net Zero policy implemented.
    Well, I'm not sure. As I have said before, I can see Putin demanding the lifting of all sanctions before they stop levelling Ukrainian cities, even if the Ukrainians conceded to all their demands.

    "These deaths in Ukraine, they could stop - if only you lift all sanctions...."

    Invidious choice for us. But even so, no western companies are going to be investing in Russia for twenty years because of the extreme risk they will have to do a BP or a Shell and walk away from it as a total loss. China will fill the gap, people say. Not if that puts at risk people buying their products. "Until they stop supporting Russia, buy China last." Not worth siding with Russia to have that spring up.
This discussion has been closed.