politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Beto O’Rourke says he can’t decide whether to run for the Pres
Comments
-
We shall see. Difficult to see Labour underperforming 2017 there even before considering the impact of Salmond /Sturgeon shenanigans.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Predictable comment Justin but wrongjustin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/10912746663443701790 -
Without checking, I expect he means at university level.kinabalu said:Wants to be a teacher! Virtue well & truly signalled. Clever.
0 -
At present labour are underwater in Scotland with no sign of any chance of recovery anytime soonjustin124 said:
We shall see. Difficult to see Labour underperforming 2017 there even before considering the impact of Salmond /Sturgeon shenanigans.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Predictable comment Justin but wrongjustin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/10912746663443701790 -
It probably says something about my age, but I blame Blair for killing off the notion that politicians should try to tell a story to persuade people to change their minds, rather than to work out what platitudes the public want you to tell them.Cyclefree said:
Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -OblitusSumMe said:Gary Younge articulating many of my thoughts on what is so wrong-headed about most Remainer rhetoric.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/feb/01/poorer-brexiters-worse-off-working-class-leavers
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.0 -
No Man's Land in a war zone?SandyRentool said:
How would you describe it?Sunil_Prasannan said:
Is Kashmir still a British Colony??SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.0 -
PB's Old Faithful spouts his stuff, as predictable as UK weather-related gridlock.justin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/10912746663443701790 -
The last poll I saw had Labour & Tories both on 26% - ie little changed from 2017 though Tories down 3 %. TSE referred me to a crossbreak putting Labour ahead with SNP in 3rd place - not that I take that too seriously. No Scotland wide polls since internal SNP ructions kicked off.Big_G_NorthWales said:
At present labour are underwater in Scotland with no sign of any chance of recovery anytime soonjustin124 said:
We shall see. Difficult to see Labour underperforming 2017 there even before considering the impact of Salmond /Sturgeon shenanigans.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Predictable comment Justin but wrongjustin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/10912746663443701790 -
Scott - you need to learn to love the Uk and it's inhabitants.Scott_P said:
But that's the tragedy of Brexit in reverse.Cyclefree said:Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.
It turned "we" into "them' and "us"
Putting that genie back in the bottle is not easy
0 -
Possibly it showed that there was no "we", that we were labouring under a comfortable delusion that there was and that we were wrong to think that it was only malicious people like Farage and co who turned that "we" into "them" and "us".Scott_P said:
But that's the tragedy of Brexit in reverse.Cyclefree said:Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.
It turned "we" into "them' and "us"
Putting that genie back in the bottle is not easy
Clearly, there was - and is - a lot of unhappiness about and the referendum helped crystallise that. It is, IMO, the wrong answer to a question that needed asking - not whether to remain in the EU or not - but how to create an economic, social and political settlement that works for the majority not a fortunate minority. That question might be asked by the young, for instance, as well as Leave voters in places a long way away from London.
The tragedy of Brexit it seems to me is that it diverts attention away from all the issues which do need addressing into a somewhat sterile argument about trade with the EU, which - even if reasonably amicably resolved - will do little to deal with these other issues0 -
Dura_Ace said:
The fucker even looks like Ken Wind.Cyclefree said:So completely off the wall - but what about this chap? https://twitter.com/davidaxelrod/status/1088049704955465728
Who is Ken Wind?0 -
Perhaps you were one of the many on here back in May 2017 who were so dismissive of the suggestion that the SNP would fall below 50 seats. Even a few days before Polling Day nationalist supporters were still in denial.Theuniondivvie said:
PB's Old Faithful spouts his stuff, as predictable as UK weather-related gridlock.justin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/10912746663443701790 -
Labour are underwater in Scotland as those on here he know Scotland will affirmjustin124 said:
The last poll I saw had Labour & Tories both on 26% - ie little changed from 2017 though Tories down 3 %. TSE referred me to a crossbreak putting Labour ahead with SNP in 3rd place - not that I take that too seriously. No Scotland wide polls since internal SNP ructions kicked off.Big_G_NorthWales said:
At present labour are underwater in Scotland with no sign of any chance of recovery anytime soonjustin124 said:
We shall see. Difficult to see Labour underperforming 2017 there even before considering the impact of Salmond /Sturgeon shenanigans.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Predictable comment Justin but wrongjustin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/10912746663443701790 -
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.0 -
Doubtless you took that view in May/June 2017.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Labour are underwater in Scotland as those on here he know Scotland will affirmjustin124 said:
The last poll I saw had Labour & Tories both on 26% - ie little changed from 2017 though Tories down 3 %. TSE referred me to a crossbreak putting Labour ahead with SNP in 3rd place - not that I take that too seriously. No Scotland wide polls since internal SNP ructions kicked off.Big_G_NorthWales said:
At present labour are underwater in Scotland with no sign of any chance of recovery anytime soonjustin124 said:
We shall see. Difficult to see Labour underperforming 2017 there even before considering the impact of Salmond /Sturgeon shenanigans.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Predictable comment Justin but wrongjustin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/10912746663443701790 -
I think that if you are going to have a chance of persuading people to change their minds or at least to concede that you have a point, you need to make a real effort to understand them and why they think the way they do. You need to listen, really listen. That requires a deal of empathy and emotional intelligence which, when spin and PR and soundbites on Twitter and getting easy applause are seen as the high points of the politicians' art, is not going to be easy to develop or much valued if you have it.OblitusSumMe said:
It probably says something about my age, but I blame Blair for killing off the notion that politicians should try to tell a story to persuade people to change their minds, rather than to work out what platitudes the public want you to tell them.Cyclefree said:
Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -OblitusSumMe said:Gary Younge articulating many of my thoughts on what is so wrong-headed about most Remainer rhetoric.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/feb/01/poorer-brexiters-worse-off-working-class-leavers
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.0 -
Name and shame. There were many PBers who were expecting the SNP to fall below 50 seats and backed the 20/1 on the Scottish Tories to have more than 10 Scottish MPs.justin124 said:
Perhaps you were one of the many on here back in May 2017 who were so dismissive of the suggestion that the SNP would fall below 50 seats. Even a few days before Polling Day nationalist supporters were still in denial.Theuniondivvie said:
PB's Old Faithful spouts his stuff, as predictable as UK weather-related gridlock.justin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/1091274666344370179
Iirc in May 2017 you were saying the best thing for Labour was for Corbyn to have a heart attack.0 -
Llanveynoe to WalesOldKingCole said:
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.?
0 -
Or maybe he's seen "A Man For All Seasons" and, unlike Rich, has taken the hint.DecrepitJohnL said:
Without checking, I expect he means at university level.kinabalu said:Wants to be a teacher! Virtue well & truly signalled. Clever.
“Sir Thomas More: Why not be a teacher? You'd be a fine teacher; perhaps a great one.
Richard Rich: If I was, who would know it?
Sir Thomas More: You; your pupils; your friends; God. Not a bad public, that.”0 -
So what, it's still teaching.DecrepitJohnL said:
Without checking, I expect he means at university level.kinabalu said:Wants to be a teacher! Virtue well & truly signalled. Clever.
0 -
The underlying issues must be addressed but the last few days have not seen the EU at their finest and their attitude to discussing the backstop at all, will result in many more wanting to leave and, sadly, without a deal.Cyclefree said:
Possibly it showed that there was no "we", that we were labouring under a comfortable delusion that there was and that we were wrong to think that it was only malicious people like Farage and co who turned that "we" into "them" and "us".Scott_P said:
But that's the tragedy of Brexit in reverse.Cyclefree said:Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.
It turned "we" into "them' and "us"
Putting that genie back in the bottle is not easy
Clearly, there was - and is - a lot of unhappiness about and the referendum helped crystallise that. It is, IMO, the wrong answer to a question that needed asking - not whether to remain in the EU or not - but how to create an economic, social and political settlement that works for the majority not a fortunate minority. That question might be asked by the young, for instance, as well as Leave voters in places a long way away from London.
The tragedy of Brexit it seems to me is that it diverts attention away from all the issues which do need addressing into a somewhat sterile argument about trade with the EU, which - even if reasonably amicably resolved - will do little to deal with these other issues
Italy is in recession and Germany not far behind and if we crash out, and all those German cars for our market, left rusting in Munich, flower growers in Holland with no market, Irish freight stranded at Dublin, Spanish, Portugese, Italian and French food and drink stopped in 30 mile queus at the Channel ports the, people of the EU will say we are happy to be sacrificed on a political obsession, and Merkel, Macron, Junckers, Tusk and Barnier are our heroes0 -
I agree re- Blair , though actually it started with Thatcher in the 1979 campaign when the Tories hired Saatchi & Saatchi. Then in 1987 Labour turned to Mandleson and all that developed from that.OblitusSumMe said:
It probably says something about my age, but I blame Blair for killing off the notion that politicians should try to tell a story to persuade people to change their minds, rather than to work out what platitudes the public want you to tell them.Cyclefree said:
Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -OblitusSumMe said:Gary Younge articulating many of my thoughts on what is so wrong-headed about most Remainer rhetoric.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/feb/01/poorer-brexiters-worse-off-working-class-leavers
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.0 -
I think you mean Danzig and Königsburg :-)Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.0 -
As someone who lives in Wales and has lived here almost all my life I could not have told you exactly how the election would have gone in 2017 in Wales or how the next one will.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Labour are underwater in Scotland as those on here he know Scotland will affirmjustin124 said:
The last poll I saw had Labour & Tories both on 26% - ie little changed from 2017 though Tories down 3 %. TSE referred me to a crossbreak putting Labour ahead with SNP in 3rd place - not that I take that too seriously. No Scotland wide polls since internal SNP ructions kicked off.Big_G_NorthWales said:
At present labour are underwater in Scotland with no sign of any chance of recovery anytime soonjustin124 said:
We shall see. Difficult to see Labour underperforming 2017 there even before considering the impact of Salmond /Sturgeon shenanigans.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Predictable comment Justin but wrongjustin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/1091274666344370179
Unless you or the people you know have magical powers it will be much the same for you and the people you know. So despite your Scottish connections you cannot tell people exactly how the Scottish part of a general election will go. Especially seen as we don't even know when that would be.
If you could I assume you would have proved incredibly useful for elections here in the past, despite the fact you don't bet others would bet on what you know is going to happen (after you had proved your foresight at previous elections)
Justin's arguments might be wrong but knowing people from somewhere does not equal knowing exactly how an election will go in that area.
Edit: To clarify I'm not claiming any particular side will do better/worse in Scotland, just the argument about knowing people from an area equalling perfect foresight into electoral future seems flawed.0 -
https://marvel.fandom.com/wiki/Ken_Wind_(Earth-616)Cyclefree said:Dura_Ace said:
The fucker even looks like Ken Wind.Cyclefree said:So completely off the wall - but what about this chap? https://twitter.com/davidaxelrod/status/1088049704955465728
Who is Ken Wind?
"He lit his candle in the rain at Woodstock, spilled his very own blood at Altamont, burned his draft card at Berkeley, marched on Washington, carried U.S. banner of peace through the bullets at Kent State, he cried for John, for Martin, for Bobby, he is the sould of the love generation, the spirit of the '68. Democrat. Liberal."0 -
There are several places in Herefordshire which ought to be returned to Wales, are there not? Including the place where Owain Glyndwr died/is buried.Pulpstar said:
Llanveynoe to WalesOldKingCole said:
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.?
0 -
On Danish radio this morning they were saying it was good, as they could send all the pork exports to the Japanese instead of the English (they always use England and English for Britain) - proving that fantasy Brexit outcomes aren't the preserve of the BritishDura_Ace said:
It's ok the UK can take full advantage of it for 57 days. Isn't Brexit brilliant?OldKingCole said:Just popped up on my Facebook page:
'Dubbed the world's largest free trade agreement, the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement has entered into force today!
The deal removes duties on almost all agricultural and industrial products and opens up the service sector and procurement. For the first time, the text also includes the countries' Paris climate deal commitments.'
Great job, Liam......... er...........0 -
As a past resident of Berwick upon Tweed, the lower tax rates than Scotland would ensure that Berwick does not change hands for the fourteenth timeOldKingCole said:
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.0 -
The population transfers (forced or not) after WWII were enormous. I doubt that there are few people in either area whose forebears lived there.eristdoof said:
I think you mean Danzig and Königsburg :-)Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.0 -
A lot of this is media rubbishBig_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
This is getting very nasty and indictitive that the EU are realising that if a no deal happens it will be a complete failure by all parties, while ordinary workers across the UK and the EU are sacrificed on the altar of political obsession
They wrote “colony of the British crown” rather than “crown colony”
Crown Colony is the old name for British Overseas Territory (admittedly changed in 1981).
It’s about as controversial as arguing Monmouthshire should be part of England0 -
USA to revert to British Overseas Territory.Pulpstar said:
Llanveynoe to WalesOldKingCole said:
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.?
0 -
but you need to wait at least 30 generationsDavid_Evershed said:
The Uk is surely full of French Normans and German Anglo Saxons - who voted to Leave the EU.TheScreamingEagles said:
If we brought over 60 million French million people and let them vote in the next UK general election then that's not self determination if they all voted for us to join France.David_Evershed said:TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Edit - The treaty of Utrecht also helped expand Britain's role in the slave trade.
SHAMEFUL.
So you don't accept self determination?
Opens up claims to territory all over the world.0 -
I have spent several enjoyable days reading through the PB archives from 18th April 2017 to 31st May. There were indeed people - including myself - predicting significant Tory gains in Scotland. In addition, I suggested that Labour could end up with 4 or 5 with the SNP struggling to reach 40. There were SNP supporters who ridiculed the idea of their party falling below 50 seats - MalcolmG was offering to bet on that basis. Very happy to 'cut & paste' if you want the evidence.TheScreamingEagles said:
Name and shame. There were many PBers who were expecting the SNP to fall below 50 seats and backed the 20/1 on the Scottish Tories to have more than 10 Scottish MPs.justin124 said:
Perhaps you were one of the many on here back in May 2017 who were so dismissive of the suggestion that the SNP would fall below 50 seats. Even a few days before Polling Day nationalist supporters were still in denial.Theuniondivvie said:
PB's Old Faithful spouts his stuff, as predictable as UK weather-related gridlock.justin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/1091274666344370179
Iirc in May 2017 you were saying the best thing for Labour was for Corbyn to have a heart attack.0 -
Is he running as an indie?Cyclefree said:So completely off the wall - but what about this chap? https://twitter.com/davidaxelrod/status/1088049704955465728
Interesting. Axelrod is no fool.0 -
They were either careless or deliberately wrong. Like any deep-rooted political issue, the peacemaker has to get it right.Charles said:
A lot of this is media rubbishBig_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
This is getting very nasty and indictitive that the EU are realising that if a no deal happens it will be a complete failure by all parties, while ordinary workers across the UK and the EU are sacrificed on the altar of political obsession
They wrote “colony of the British crown” rather than “crown colony”
Crown Colony is the old name for British Overseas Territory (admittedly changed in 1981).
It’s about as controversial as arguing Monmouthshire should be part of England0 -
But the Beast is clearly controlling another body...Dura_Ace said:
https://marvel.fandom.com/wiki/Ken_Wind_(Earth-616)Cyclefree said:Dura_Ace said:
The fucker even looks like Ken Wind.Cyclefree said:So completely off the wall - but what about this chap? https://twitter.com/davidaxelrod/status/1088049704955465728
Who is Ken Wind?
"He lit his candle in the rain at Woodstock, spilled his very own blood at Altamont, burned his draft card at Berkeley, marched on Washington, carried U.S. banner of peace through the bullets at Kent State, he cried for John, for Martin, for Bobby, he is the sould of the love generation, the spirit of the '68. Democrat. Liberal."0 -
You can’t give the Falklands BACK to Argentina as they never owned themSunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.0 -
I think Thatcher used the PR people to help her tell her story which, at the time, was a new story that she had to persuade people to support. This is very different to Blair's approach, which was that no radical change to the status quo established by Thatcher was possible.justin124 said:
I agree re- Blair , though actually it started with Thatcher in the 1979 campaign when the Tories hired Saatchi & Saatchi. Then in 1987 Labour turned to Mandleson and all that developed from that.OblitusSumMe said:
It probably says something about my age, but I blame Blair for killing off the notion that politicians should try to tell a story to persuade people to change their minds, rather than to work out what platitudes the public want you to tell them.Cyclefree said:
Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -OblitusSumMe said:Gary Younge articulating many of my thoughts on what is so wrong-headed about most Remainer rhetoric.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/feb/01/poorer-brexiters-worse-off-working-class-leavers
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.0 -
F1: Sauber are no more.
https://twitter.com/robwattsf1/status/1091269652603420673
And with that, I must be off.-1 -
Blair took it a stage further than Thatcher with total obsession with 'spin' and being 'on message' etc.OblitusSumMe said:
I think Thatcher used the PR people to help her tell her story which, at the time, was a new story that she had to persuade people to support. This is very different to Blair's approach, which was that no radical change to the status quo established by Thatcher was possible.justin124 said:
I agree re- Blair , though actually it started with Thatcher in the 1979 campaign when the Tories hired Saatchi & Saatchi. Then in 1987 Labour turned to Mandleson and all that developed from that.OblitusSumMe said:
It probably says something about my age, but I blame Blair for killing off the notion that politicians should try to tell a story to persuade people to change their minds, rather than to work out what platitudes the public want you to tell them.Cyclefree said:
Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -OblitusSumMe said:Gary Younge articulating many of my thoughts on what is so wrong-headed about most Remainer rhetoric.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/feb/01/poorer-brexiters-worse-off-working-class-leavers
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.0 -
My knowledge and connection with Scotland goes back 68 years, having lived there, been married there, have family across Scotland, have voted there, and regular go back to the north of Scotland.TheJezziah said:
As someone who lives in Wales and has lived here almost all my life I could not have told you exactly how the election would have gone in 2017 in Wales or how the next one will.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Labour are underwater in Scotland as those on here he know Scotland will affirmjustin124 said:
The last poll I saw had Labour & Tories both on 26% - ie little changed from 2017 though Tories down 3 %. TSE referred me to a crossbreak putting Labour ahead with SNP in 3rd place - not that I take that too seriously. No Scotland wide polls since internal SNP ructions kicked off.Big_G_NorthWales said:
At present labour are underwater in Scotland with no sign of any chance of recovery anytime soonjustin124 said:
We shall see. Difficult to see Labour underperforming 2017 there even before considering the impact of Salmond /Sturgeon shenanigans.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Predictable comment Justin but wrongjustin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/1091274666344370179
Unless you or the people you know have magical powers it will be much the same for you and the people you know. So despite your Scottish connections you cannot tell people exactly how the Scottish part of a general election will go. Especially seen as we don't even know when that would be.
If you could I assume you would have proved incredibly useful for elections here in the past, despite the fact you don't bet others would bet on what you know is going to happen (after you had proved your foresight at previous elections)
Justin's arguments might be wrong but knowing people from somewhere does not equal knowing exactly how an election will go in that area.
Edit: To clarify I'm not claiming any particular side will do better/worse in Scotland, just the argument about knowing people from an area equalling perfect foresight into electoral future seems flawed.
The SNP have replaced labour as the party of the left but also are pro business and continue to occupy the space that labour would have previously dominated. There is no evidence labour are making inroads into the SNP0 -
Do you think that somebody who aimed to predict elections could do a good job by getting a single person from each region with similar credentials and asking them what they think will happen?Big_G_NorthWales said:
My knowledge and connection with Scotland goes back 68 years, having lived there, been married there, have family across Scotland, have voted there, and regular go back to the north of Scotland.
The SNP have replaced labour as the party of the left but also are pro business and continue to occupy the space that labour would have previously dominated. There is no evidence labour are making inroads into the SNP
Personally I'd be extremely skeptical.0 -
How did Labour manage to win six seats from the SNP in 2017 and come so close to picking up a further seven? Why is Labour now polling 25% - 28% in Scotland compared with just 13% - 17% in early May 2017?Big_G_NorthWales said:
My knowledge and connection with Scotland goes back 68 years, having lived there, been married there, have family across Scotland, have voted there, and regular go back to the north of Scotland.TheJezziah said:
As someone who lives in Wales and has lived here almost all my life I could not have told you exactly how the election would have gone in 2017 in Wales or how the next one will.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Labour are underwater in Scotland as those on here he know Scotland will affirmjustin124 said:
The last poll I saw had Labour & Tories both on 26% - ie little changed from 2017 though Tories down 3 %. TSE referred me to a crossbreak putting Labour ahead with SNP in 3rd place - not that I take that too seriously. No Scotland wide polls since internal SNP ructions kicked off.Big_G_NorthWales said:
At present labour are underwater in Scotland with no sign of any chance of recovery anytime soonjustin124 said:
We shall see. Difficult to see Labour underperforming 2017 there even before considering the impact of Salmond /Sturgeon shenanigans.Big_G_NorthWales said:
Predictable comment Justin but wrongjustin124 said:
Labour likely to be higher at expense of SNP.TheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/1091274666344370179
Unless you or the people you know have magical powers it will be much the same for you and the people you know. So despite your Scottish connections you cannot tell people exactly how the Scottish part of a general election will go. Especially seen as we don't even know when that would be.
If you could I assume you would have proved incredibly useful for elections here in the past, despite the fact you don't bet others would bet on what you know is going to happen (after you had proved your foresight at previous elections)
Justin's arguments might be wrong but knowing people from somewhere does not equal knowing exactly how an election will go in that area.
Edit: To clarify I'm not claiming any particular side will do better/worse in Scotland, just the argument about knowing people from an area equalling perfect foresight into electoral future seems flawed.
The SNP have replaced labour as the party of the left but also are pro business and continue to occupy the space that labour would have previously dominated. There is no evidence labour are making inroads into the SNP0 -
There is an old story about an elderly farmer who lived on the border between Russia and Poland. During his lifetime the border was moved several times so that sometimes he was Russian, sometimes Polish.Big_G_NorthWales said:
As a past resident of Berwick upon Tweed, the lower tax rates than Scotland would ensure that Berwick does not change hands for the fourteenth timeOldKingCole said:
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.
Eventually he was told that the border was fixed for all time, and he was a Pole.
He was very grateful as 'he couldn't stand another Russian winter'!0 -
This is one of Corbyn's weaknesses. He shows no interest in people who disagree with him. As you say, you can't hope to persuade anyone if you can't understand them.Cyclefree said:
I think that if you are going to have a chance of persuading people to change their minds or at least to concede that you have a point, you need to make a real effort to understand them and why they think the way they do. You need to listen, really listen. That requires a deal of empathy and emotional intelligence which, when spin and PR and soundbites on Twitter and getting easy applause are seen as the high points of the politicians' art, is not going to be easy to develop or much valued if you have it.OblitusSumMe said:
It probably says something about my age, but I blame Blair for killing off the notion that politicians should try to tell a story to persuade people to change their minds, rather than to work out what platitudes the public want you to tell them.Cyclefree said:
Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -OblitusSumMe said:Gary Younge articulating many of my thoughts on what is so wrong-headed about most Remainer rhetoric.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/feb/01/poorer-brexiters-worse-off-working-class-leavers
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.0 -
Put enough of the right kind of anecdotes together in the right way, and you get a representative sample...Stereotomy said:
Do you think that somebody who aimed to predict elections could do a good job by getting a single person from each region with similar credentials and asking them what they think will happen?Big_G_NorthWales said:
My knowledge and connection with Scotland goes back 68 years, having lived there, been married there, have family across Scotland, have voted there, and regular go back to the north of Scotland.
The SNP have replaced labour as the party of the left but also are pro business and continue to occupy the space that labour would have previously dominated. There is no evidence labour are making inroads into the SNP
Personally I'd be extremely skeptical.0 -
Half a moment, half a moment. We're not settling just for parts of Herefordshire.OldKingCole said:
There are several places in Herefordshire which ought to be returned to Wales, are there not? Including the place where Owain Glyndwr died/is buried.Pulpstar said:
Llanveynoe to WalesOldKingCole said:
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.?
The whole island of Britain should be returned to the Welsh (excepting Pictish and Goidelic parts of North Scotland). There were no Anglo-Saxons here originally. King Arthur and Boudicca were Welsh.
Even at the time of the Tripartite Indenture, Glyndwr was to get the whole of the West Midlands.
Parts of Herefordshire ... no way.0 -
Sadly, Mrs May gives a similar impression. That's the tragedy of contemporary British politics.OblitusSumMe said:
This is one of Corbyn's weaknesses. He shows no interest in people who disagree with him. As you say, you can't hope to persuade anyone if you can't understand them.Cyclefree said:
I think that if you are going to have a chance of persuading people to change their minds or at least to concede that you have a point, you need to make a real effort to understand them and why they think the way they do. You need to listen, really listen. That requires a deal of empathy and emotional intelligence which, when spin and PR and soundbites on Twitter and getting easy applause are seen as the high points of the politicians' art, is not going to be easy to develop or much valued if you have it.OblitusSumMe said:
It probably says something about my age, but I blame Blair for killing off the notion that politicians should try to tell a story to persuade people to change their minds, rather than to work out what platitudes the public want you to tell them.Cyclefree said:
Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -OblitusSumMe said:Gary Younge articulating many of my thoughts on what is so wrong-headed about most Remainer rhetoric.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/feb/01/poorer-brexiters-worse-off-working-class-leavers
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.0 -
No. I lived in Scotland when labour was as dominant as they are in Wales but the SNP being a party of the left, and of course very pro Independence, managed to be very pro business especially under Salmond and appealed across the divide. That appeal still exists but of course it's Independence obsession opens the way for a pro union - pro business conservative party under a very capable leader to provide a genuine alternative.Stereotomy said:
Do you think that somebody who aimed to predict elections could do a good job by getting a single person from each region with similar credentials and asking them what they think will happen?Big_G_NorthWales said:
My knowledge and connection with Scotland goes back 68 years, having lived there, been married there, have family across Scotland, have voted there, and regular go back to the north of Scotland.
The SNP have replaced labour as the party of the left but also are pro business and continue to occupy the space that labour would have previously dominated. There is no evidence labour are making inroads into the SNP
Personally I'd be extremely skeptical.
Of course it could change but it is not happening at present and in any GE soon I would expect both conservative and labour to lose seats to the SNP
0 -
Mrs May has a bullet-proof method of persuasion: get people into a room just before a vote and lie to them about concessions she'll make. That it keeps working is a good indicator of just how stupid Tory MPs are.OldKingCole said:
Sadly, Mrs May gives a similar impression. That's the tragedy of contemporary British politics.OblitusSumMe said:
This is one of Corbyn's weaknesses. He shows no interest in people who disagree with him. As you say, you can't hope to persuade anyone if you can't understand them.Cyclefree said:
I think that if you are going to have a chance of persuading people to change their minds or at least to concede that you have a point, you need to make a real effort to understand them and why they think the way they do. You need to listen, really listen. That requires a deal of empathy and emotional intelligence which, when spin and PR and soundbites on Twitter and getting easy applause are seen as the high points of the politicians' art, is not going to be easy to develop or much valued if you have it.OblitusSumMe said:
It probably says something about my age, but I blame Blair for killing off the notion that politicians should try to tell a story to persuade people to change their minds, rather than to work out what platitudes the public want you to tell them.Cyclefree said:
Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -OblitusSumMe said:Gary Younge articulating many of my thoughts on what is so wrong-headed about most Remainer rhetoric.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/feb/01/poorer-brexiters-worse-off-working-class-leavers
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.0 -
Bring it on, quality of pork products is Japan's third-worst problem. (After the criminal justice system and refugee policy)kingbongo said:
On Danish radio this morning they were saying it was good, as they could send all the pork exports to the Japanese instead of the English (they always use England and English for Britain) - proving that fantasy Brexit outcomes aren't the preserve of the BritishDura_Ace said:
It's ok the UK can take full advantage of it for 57 days. Isn't Brexit brilliant?OldKingCole said:Just popped up on my Facebook page:
'Dubbed the world's largest free trade agreement, the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement has entered into force today!
The deal removes duties on almost all agricultural and industrial products and opens up the service sector and procurement. For the first time, the text also includes the countries' Paris climate deal commitments.'
Great job, Liam......... er...........0 -
I think once we do that, we have to return the whole of Britain to the Irish. Which, right now, is looking like it might solve a few other problems.YBarddCwsc said:
Half a moment, half a moment. We're not settling just for parts of Herefordshire.OldKingCole said:
There are several places in Herefordshire which ought to be returned to Wales, are there not? Including the place where Owain Glyndwr died/is buried.Pulpstar said:
Llanveynoe to WalesOldKingCole said:
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.?
The whole island of Britain should be returned to the Welsh (excepting Pictish and Goidelic parts of North Scotland). There were no Anglo-Saxons here originally. King Arthur and Boudicca were Welsh.
Even at the time of the Tripartite Indenture, Glyndwr was to get the whole of the West Midlands.
Parts of Herefordshire ... no way.0 -
While my paternal heritage suggest I should agree with you, AIUI, modern genetic research doesn't entirely support that view.YBarddCwsc said:
Half a moment, half a moment. We're not settling just for parts of Herefordshire.OldKingCole said:
There are several places in Herefordshire which ought to be returned to Wales, are there not? Including the place where Owain Glyndwr died/is buried.Pulpstar said:
Llanveynoe to WalesOldKingCole said:
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.?
The whole island of Britain should be returned to the Welsh (excepting Pictish and Goidelic parts of North Scotland). There were no Anglo-Saxons here originally. King Arthur and Boudicca were Welsh.
Even at the time of the Tripartite Indenture, Glyndwr was to get the whole of the West Midlands.
Parts of Herefordshire ... no way.
Glyndwr was, of course, rather let down by the French who failed to supply him with cannon.0 -
German salami is superior to Danish.edmundintokyo said:
Bring it on, quality of pork products is Japan's third-worst problem. (After the criminal justice system and refugee policy)kingbongo said:
On Danish radio this morning they were saying it was good, as they could send all the pork exports to the Japanese instead of the English (they always use England and English for Britain) - proving that fantasy Brexit outcomes aren't the preserve of the BritishDura_Ace said:
It's ok the UK can take full advantage of it for 57 days. Isn't Brexit brilliant?OldKingCole said:Just popped up on my Facebook page:
'Dubbed the world's largest free trade agreement, the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement has entered into force today!
The deal removes duties on almost all agricultural and industrial products and opens up the service sector and procurement. For the first time, the text also includes the countries' Paris climate deal commitments.'
Great job, Liam......... er...........
Are there any British salami producers?0 -
The DUP aren't much better, although they do insist on the cash being on the table.Stereotomy said:
Mrs May has a bullet-proof method of persuasion: get people into a room just before a vote and lie to them about concessions she'll make. That it keeps working is a good indicator of just how stupid Tory MPs are.OldKingCole said:
Sadly, Mrs May gives a similar impression. That's the tragedy of contemporary British politics.OblitusSumMe said:
This is one of Corbyn's weaknesses. He shows no interest in people who disagree with him. As you say, you can't hope to persuade anyone if you can't understand them.Cyclefree said:
I think that if you are going to have a chance of persuading people to change their minds or at least to concede that you have a point, you need to make a real effort to understand them and why they think the way they do. You need to listen, really listen. That requires a deal of empathy and emotional intelligence which, when spin and PR and soundbites on Twitter and getting easy applause are seen as the high points of the politicians' art, is not going to be easy to develop or much valued if you have it.OblitusSumMe said:
It probably says something about my age, but I blame Blair for killing off the notion that politicians should try to tell a story to persuade people to change their minds, rather than to work out what platitudes the public want you to tell them.Cyclefree said:
Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -OblitusSumMe said:Gary Younge articulating many of my thoughts on what is so wrong-headed about most Remainer rhetoric.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/feb/01/poorer-brexiters-worse-off-working-class-leavers
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.0 -
O'Rourke might be better off waiting until 2024.
Otherwise he could hope for the VP slot in 2020, that did not work out too badly for another former teacher and Texas politician Lyndon Baines Johnson when he got the VP slot in 1960. Plus as O'Rourke' s father in law is a billionaire he does not need the money0 -
I think we already knew that Cory Booker was running but Cory Booker is running0
-
+1OldKingCole said:
There is an old story about an elderly farmer who lived on the border between Russia and Poland. During his lifetime the border was moved several times so that sometimes he was Russian, sometimes Polish.Big_G_NorthWales said:
As a past resident of Berwick upon Tweed, the lower tax rates than Scotland would ensure that Berwick does not change hands for the fourteenth timeOldKingCole said:
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.
Eventually he was told that the border was fixed for all time, and he was a Pole.
He was very grateful as 'he couldn't stand another Russian winter'!0 -
There are 7 SNP seats more vulnerable to Labour than is Aberconway in North Wales.Big_G_NorthWales said:
No. I lived in Scotland when labour was as dominant as they are in Wales but the SNP being a party of the left, and of course very pro Independence, managed to be very pro business especially under Salmond and appealed across the divide. That appeal still exists but of course it's Independence obsession opens the way for a pro union - pro business conservative party under a very capable leader to provide a genuine alternative.Stereotomy said:
Do you think that somebody who aimed to predict elections could do a good job by getting a single person from each region with similar credentials and asking them what they think will happen?Big_G_NorthWales said:
My knowledge and connection with Scotland goes back 68 years, having lived there, been married there, have family across Scotland, have voted there, and regular go back to the north of Scotland.
The SNP have replaced labour as the party of the left but also are pro business and continue to occupy the space that labour would have previously dominated. There is no evidence labour are making inroads into the SNP
Personally I'd be extremely skeptical.
Of course it could change but it is not happening at present and in any GE soon I would expect both conservative and labour to lose seats to the SNP0 -
Labour plus SNP likely with LD support on most issues but on those numbers almost certainly the Tories will have a majority in EnglandTheScreamingEagles said:A rainbow alliance?
https://twitter.com/ElectCalculus/status/10912746663443701790 -
Donkeys make good salami. The Donkey Sanctuary should get into the business.OblitusSumMe said:
German salami is superior to Danish.edmundintokyo said:
Bring it on, quality of pork products is Japan's third-worst problem. (After the criminal justice system and refugee policy)kingbongo said:
On Danish radio this morning they were saying it was good, as they could send all the pork exports to the Japanese instead of the English (they always use England and English for Britain) - proving that fantasy Brexit outcomes aren't the preserve of the BritishDura_Ace said:
It's ok the UK can take full advantage of it for 57 days. Isn't Brexit brilliant?OldKingCole said:Just popped up on my Facebook page:
'Dubbed the world's largest free trade agreement, the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement has entered into force today!
The deal removes duties on almost all agricultural and industrial products and opens up the service sector and procurement. For the first time, the text also includes the countries' Paris climate deal commitments.'
Great job, Liam......... er...........
Are there any British salami producers?0 -
None of your imperialist names, please.justin124 said:
There are 7 SNP seats more vulnerable to Labour than is Aberconway in North Wales.Big_G_NorthWales said:
No. I lived in Scotland when labour was as dominant as they are in Wales but the SNP being a party of the left, and of course very pro Independence, managed to be very pro business especially under Salmond and appealed across the divide. That appeal still exists but of course it's Independence obsession opens the way for a pro union - pro business conservative party under a very capable leader to provide a genuine alternative.Stereotomy said:
Do you think that somebody who aimed to predict elections could do a good job by getting a single person from each region with similar credentials and asking them what they think will happen?Big_G_NorthWales said:
My knowledge and connection with Scotland goes back 68 years, having lived there, been married there, have family across Scotland, have voted there, and regular go back to the north of Scotland.
The SNP have replaced labour as the party of the left but also are pro business and continue to occupy the space that labour would have previously dominated. There is no evidence labour are making inroads into the SNP
Personally I'd be extremely skeptical.
Of course it could change but it is not happening at present and in any GE soon I would expect both conservative and labour to lose seats to the SNP
It is Harare, not Salisbury.
It is Aberconwy, not Aberconway.0 -
OblitusSumMe said:
I think Thatcher used the PR people to help her tell her story which, at the time, was a new story that she had to persuade people to support. This is very different to Blair's approach, which was that no radical change to the status quo established by Thatcher was possible.justin124 said:
I agree re- Blair , though actually it started with Thatcher in the 1979 campaign when the Tories hired Saatchi & Saatchi. Then in 1987 Labour turned to Mandleson and all that developed from that.OblitusSumMe said:
It probably says something about my age, but I blame Blair for killing off the notion that politicians should try to tell a story to persuade people to change their minds, rather than to work out what platitudes the public want you to tell them.Cyclefree said:
Yes it is. And the last two sentences nail it -OblitusSumMe said:Gary Younge articulating many of my thoughts on what is so wrong-headed about most Remainer rhetoric.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/feb/01/poorer-brexiters-worse-off-working-class-leavers
"Our challenge is not to mock, but to tell a better story. One that includes them, has a future for all of us and, ultimately, turns “them” and “us” into “we”."
Our politicians have failed to tell a story for all of us, or even try to do so.
Thatcher had a story to tell, an idea of what Britain should be and she was more than prepared to argue for it and seek to change peoples minds. And she did so when times were really hard and there was a lot of opposition to her views.
Blair spent so long persuading his party to change that, in an odd sort of way, he'd run out persuasive steam by the time he became PM. He coasted on his victories and on the fact that the economy was doing well. So he seemed to have won the argument but in fact this was all rather shallow and fell apart when really tested e.g. the utter failure of the Blairites to have anything to say when they came onto the stage following Blair's departure.0 -
They would be safe for SNP for any election today.justin124 said:
There are 7 SNP seats more vulnerable to Labour than is Aberconway in North Wales.Big_G_NorthWales said:
No. I lived in Scotland when labour was as dominant as they are in Wales but the SNP being a party of the left, and of course very pro Independence, managed to be very pro business especially under Salmond and appealed across the divide. That appeal still exists but of course it's Independence obsession opens the way for a pro union - pro business conservative party under a very capable leader to provide a genuine alternative.Stereotomy said:
Do you think that somebody who aimed to predict elections could do a good job by getting a single person from each region with similar credentials and asking them what they think will happen?Big_G_NorthWales said:
My knowledge and connection with Scotland goes back 68 years, having lived there, been married there, have family across Scotland, have voted there, and regular go back to the north of Scotland.
The SNP have replaced labour as the party of the left but also are pro business and continue to occupy the space that labour would have previously dominated. There is no evidence labour are making inroads into the SNP
Personally I'd be extremely skeptical.
Of course it could change but it is not happening at present and in any GE soon I would expect both conservative and labour to lose seats to the SNP
Bebb in Aberconwy (no a) is in great difficulty and may be de-selected but it is possible it will go labour0 -
O'Rourke would be far more use to any Democrat ticket by running again for the Senate than he would as an unlikely pick for the VP slot.HYUFD said:O'Rourke might be better off waiting until 2024.
Otherwise he could hope for the VP slot in 2020, that did not work out too badly for another former teacher and Texas politician Lyndon Baines Johnson when he got the VP slot in 1960. Plus as O'Rourke' s father in law is a billionaire he does not need the money0 -
I'm a little bit saddened to hear you say that. Gibraltar is a colony, although we don't use the word anymore. It has a popularly-elected parliament, a governor appointed by the British crown, a head of government appointed by the Crown that can command a majority in that house, its monarch is the British monarch and its defences are underwritten by the British Armed Forces. That's a very British structure and one that works quite well. But it's a colonial structure until it gets its own monarch (and if memory serves the power to rewrite its own constitution), and its final court of appeal is still the privy council in LondonBig_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
This is getting very nasty and indictitive that the EU are realising that if a no deal happens it will be a complete failure by all parties, while ordinary workers across the UK and the EU are sacrificed on the altar of political obsession0 -
Yep. I stand to be proved wrong in fairly short order, but this all looks like a somewhat calculated attempt to do things differently, because there is such appetite for that, especially on the left. @Richard_Nabavi notes he is inexperienced - well, yes and no. He's an experienced campaigner, who has previously beaten an incumbent in a House primary, and just given Ted Cruz a pretty good fright. His fundraising and campaigning skills are what he needs to win.rottenborough said:
And, given the American public elected Trump, his 6 years of House experience looks like a decent enough political CV, even though it would be traditional to have state or national-level responsibility first.
Most of all, I don't understand his tilt at Cruz if not with a view to running for President if he lost, which he must have anticipated.
Perhaps we shall see soon enough.0 -
I received my copy of Wetherspoons News through the door today. Did they reach an agreement with the Telegraph, FT, etc, for carrying copyrighted material, or is that still a matter in dispute?0
-
I'm not sure how much use that is to Beto when he loses again, though.Nigelb said:
O'Rourke would be far more use to any Democrat ticket by running again for the Senate than he would as an unlikely pick for the VP slot.HYUFD said:O'Rourke might be better off waiting until 2024.
Otherwise he could hope for the VP slot in 2020, that did not work out too badly for another former teacher and Texas politician Lyndon Baines Johnson when he got the VP slot in 1960. Plus as O'Rourke' s father in law is a billionaire he does not need the money0 -
Maybot! No one can salami slice a political process like Maybot. That must count for somethingOblitusSumMe said:
German salami is superior to Danish.edmundintokyo said:
Bring it on, quality of pork products is Japan's third-worst problem. (After the criminal justice system and refugee policy)kingbongo said:
On Danish radio this morning they were saying it was good, as they could send all the pork exports to the Japanese instead of the English (they always use England and English for Britain) - proving that fantasy Brexit outcomes aren't the preserve of the BritishDura_Ace said:
It's ok the UK can take full advantage of it for 57 days. Isn't Brexit brilliant?OldKingCole said:Just popped up on my Facebook page:
'Dubbed the world's largest free trade agreement, the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement has entered into force today!
The deal removes duties on almost all agricultural and industrial products and opens up the service sector and procurement. For the first time, the text also includes the countries' Paris climate deal commitments.'
Great job, Liam......... er...........
Are there any British salami producers?
0 -
Recipes here:Sean_F said:
Donkeys make good salami. The Donkey Sanctuary should get into the business.OblitusSumMe said:
German salami is superior to Danish.edmundintokyo said:
Bring it on, quality of pork products is Japan's third-worst problem. (After the criminal justice system and refugee policy)kingbongo said:
On Danish radio this morning they were saying it was good, as they could send all the pork exports to the Japanese instead of the English (they always use England and English for Britain) - proving that fantasy Brexit outcomes aren't the preserve of the BritishDura_Ace said:
It's ok the UK can take full advantage of it for 57 days. Isn't Brexit brilliant?OldKingCole said:Just popped up on my Facebook page:
'Dubbed the world's largest free trade agreement, the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement has entered into force today!
The deal removes duties on almost all agricultural and industrial products and opens up the service sector and procurement. For the first time, the text also includes the countries' Paris climate deal commitments.'
Great job, Liam......... er...........
Are there any British salami producers?
https://www.fondazioneslowfood.com/en/ark-of-taste-slow-food/donkey-salami/0 -
He's got an outside shot at the nomination. Though IMO he's more likely just to take some of the heat off Harris as the left of the party attack him for his Wall St ties.edmundintokyo said:I think we already knew that Cory Booker was running but Cory Booker is running
0 -
I think he could win.Tissue_Price said:
I'm not sure how much use that is to Beto when he loses again, though.Nigelb said:
O'Rourke would be far more use to any Democrat ticket by running again for the Senate than he would as an unlikely pick for the VP slot.HYUFD said:O'Rourke might be better off waiting until 2024.
Otherwise he could hope for the VP slot in 2020, that did not work out too badly for another former teacher and Texas politician Lyndon Baines Johnson when he got the VP slot in 1960. Plus as O'Rourke' s father in law is a billionaire he does not need the money0 -
And it is Llanelly not Llanelli.YBarddCwsc said:
None of your imperialist names, please.justin124 said:
There are 7 SNP seats more vulnerable to Labour than is Aberconway in North Wales.Big_G_NorthWales said:
No. I lived in Scotland when labour was as dominant as they are in Wales but the SNP being a party of the left, and of course very pro Independence, managed to be very pro business especially under Salmond and appealed across the divide. That appeal still exists but of course it's Independence obsession opens the way for a pro union - pro business conservative party under a very capable leader to provide a genuine alternative.Stereotomy said:
Do you think that somebody who aimed to predict elections could do a good job by getting a single person from each region with similar credentials and asking them what they think will happen?Big_G_NorthWales said:
My knowledge and connection with Scotland goes back 68 years, having lived there, been married there, have family across Scotland, have voted there, and regular go back to the north of Scotland.
The SNP have replaced labour as the party of the left but also are pro business and continue to occupy the space that labour would have previously dominated. There is no evidence labour are making inroads into the SNP
Personally I'd be extremely skeptical.
Of course it could change but it is not happening at present and in any GE soon I would expect both conservative and labour to lose seats to the SNP
It is Harare, not Salisbury.
It is Aberconwy, not Aberconway.0 -
Yes! I like this optimism! And it's not even slightly related to my bet on "leave on time", oh deary me no...Big_G_NorthWales said:I am feeling optimistic this morning and I predict we will sign TM deal, modified or not, and will leave on the 29th March 2019
0 -
Trump was an A+list celebrity and a billionaire when he ran thoughTissue_Price said:
Yep. I stand to be proved wrong in fairly short order, but this all looks like a somewhat calculated attempt to do things differently, because there is such appetite for that, especially on the left. @Richard_Nabavi notes he is inexperienced - well, yes and no. He's an experienced campaigner, who has previously beaten an incumbent in a House primary, and just given Ted Cruz a pretty good fright. His fundraising and campaigning skills are what he needs to win.rottenborough said:
And, given the American public elected Trump, his 6 years of House experience looks like a decent enough political CV, even though it would be traditional to have state or national-level responsibility first.
Most of all, I don't understand his tilt at Cruz if not with a view to running for President if he lost, which he must have anticipated.
Perhaps we shall see soon enough.0 -
I cannot see a referendum now. It needed Corbyn and he has turned his back on itrottenborough said:0 -
Perhaps he genuinely hasn't made his mind up. Probably only gets one shot at it.Tissue_Price said:
Yep. I stand to be proved wrong in fairly short order, but this all looks like a somewhat calculated attempt to do things differently, because there is such appetite for that, especially on the left. @Richard_Nabavi notes he is inexperienced - well, yes and no. He's an experienced campaigner, who has previously beaten an incumbent in a House primary, and just given Ted Cruz a pretty good fright. His fundraising and campaigning skills are what he needs to win.rottenborough said:
And, given the American public elected Trump, his 6 years of House experience looks like a decent enough political CV, even though it would be traditional to have state or national-level responsibility first.
Most of all, I don't understand his tilt at Cruz if not with a view to running for President if he lost, which he must have anticipated.
Perhaps we shall see soon enough.
0 -
Yes, win a Senate seat, show he can win in a general election then run for PresidentNigelb said:
O'Rourke would be far more use to any Democrat ticket by running again for the Senate than he would as an unlikely pick for the VP slot.HYUFD said:O'Rourke might be better off waiting until 2024.
Otherwise he could hope for the VP slot in 2020, that did not work out too badly for another former teacher and Texas politician Lyndon Baines Johnson when he got the VP slot in 1960. Plus as O'Rourke' s father in law is a billionaire he does not need the money0 -
It sounds delicious.MarqueeMark said:
Recipes here:Sean_F said:
Donkeys make good salami. The Donkey Sanctuary should get into the business.OblitusSumMe said:
German salami is superior to Danish.edmundintokyo said:
Bring it on, quality of pork products is Japan's third-worst problem. (After the criminal justice system and refugee policy)kingbongo said:
On Danish radio this morning they were saying it was good, as they could send all the pork exports to the Japanese instead of the English (they always use England and English for Britain) - proving that fantasy Brexit outcomes aren't the preserve of the BritishDura_Ace said:
It's ok the UK can take full advantage of it for 57 days. Isn't Brexit brilliant?OldKingCole said:Just popped up on my Facebook page:
'Dubbed the world's largest free trade agreement, the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement has entered into force today!
The deal removes duties on almost all agricultural and industrial products and opens up the service sector and procurement. For the first time, the text also includes the countries' Paris climate deal commitments.'
Great job, Liam......... er...........
Are there any British salami producers?
https://www.fondazioneslowfood.com/en/ark-of-taste-slow-food/donkey-salami/0 -
Roger Stone - a stirring finger in every mud pie:
https://www.thedailybeast.com/bezos-investigators-question-the-brother-of-his-mistress-lauren-sanchez-in-national-enquirer-leak-probe
Jeff Bezos’ top personal security consultant has questioned his mistress’ brother as part of the probe into how the couple’s text messages wound up in the hands of the National Enquirer.
Gavin de Becker, the Amazon chief’s longtime personal security consultant and the point person for the investigation, confirmed to The Daily Beast on Wednesday that his probe has scrutinized Michael Sanchez, the brother of Bezos mistress Lauren Sanchez and a personal and business associate of Trumpworld figures including Roger Stone, Carter Page, and Scottie Nell Hughes…0 -
Remainers insist that post-Brexit, Britain will have been returned to the Neanderthals....Endillion said:
I think once we do that, we have to return the whole of Britain to the Irish. Which, right now, is looking like it might solve a few other problems.YBarddCwsc said:
Half a moment, half a moment. We're not settling just for parts of Herefordshire.OldKingCole said:
There are several places in Herefordshire which ought to be returned to Wales, are there not? Including the place where Owain Glyndwr died/is buried.Pulpstar said:
Llanveynoe to WalesOldKingCole said:
OK, this'll stir things up:Pulpstar said:
Strasbourg, Gdansk and Kaliningrad back to Germany.OldKingCole said:
Shetlands to Norway, surely.SandyRentool said:
Kashmir to Pakistan???Sunil_Prasannan said:
What next? Give the Isle of Man back to Norway? Falklands to Argentina?TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Berwick-upon-Tweed back to Scotland.?
The whole island of Britain should be returned to the Welsh (excepting Pictish and Goidelic parts of North Scotland). There were no Anglo-Saxons here originally. King Arthur and Boudicca were Welsh.
Even at the time of the Tripartite Indenture, Glyndwr was to get the whole of the West Midlands.
Parts of Herefordshire ... no way.0 -
It is the only logical conclusion but logic does not seem to be a quality most mps possessviewcode said:
Yes! I like this optimism! And it's not even slightly related to my bet on "leave on time", oh deary me no...Big_G_NorthWales said:I am feeling optimistic this morning and I predict we will sign TM deal, modified or not, and will leave on the 29th March 2019
0 -
Plus if he got the nomination and Trump beat him (and history still fsbpurs an incumbent president after only 1 term of his party in the White House winning re election) then O'Rourke is done and someone like Bobby Kennedy's grandson Congressman Joseph P Kennedy III would be favourite in 2024rottenborough said:
Perhaps he genuinely hasn't made his mind up. Probably only gets one shot at it.Tissue_Price said:
Yep. I stand to be proved wrong in fairly short order, but this all looks like a somewhat calculated attempt to do things differently, because there is such appetite for that, especially on the left. @Richard_Nabavi notes he is inexperienced - well, yes and no. He's an experienced campaigner, who has previously beaten an incumbent in a House primary, and just given Ted Cruz a pretty good fright. His fundraising and campaigning skills are what he needs to win.rottenborough said:
And, given the American public elected Trump, his 6 years of House experience looks like a decent enough political CV, even though it would be traditional to have state or national-level responsibility first.
Most of all, I don't understand his tilt at Cruz if not with a view to running for President if he lost, which he must have anticipated.
Perhaps we shall see soon enough.0 -
A Democratic Senator from Texas would probably get another shot.rottenborough said:
Perhaps he genuinely hasn't made his mind up. Probably only gets one shot at it.Tissue_Price said:
Yep. I stand to be proved wrong in fairly short order, but this all looks like a somewhat calculated attempt to do things differently, because there is such appetite for that, especially on the left. @Richard_Nabavi notes he is inexperienced - well, yes and no. He's an experienced campaigner, who has previously beaten an incumbent in a House primary, and just given Ted Cruz a pretty good fright. His fundraising and campaigning skills are what he needs to win.rottenborough said:
And, given the American public elected Trump, his 6 years of House experience looks like a decent enough political CV, even though it would be traditional to have state or national-level responsibility first.
Most of all, I don't understand his tilt at Cruz if not with a view to running for President if he lost, which he must have anticipated.
Perhaps we shall see soon enough.0 -
I'm also moving away from thinking there'll be a referendum, because it'd need May's backing, and from her perspective a GE has all the advantages of a referendum without most of the disadvantages.Big_G_NorthWales said:
I cannot see a referendum now. It needed Corbyn and he has turned his back on itrottenborough said:0 -
Once again, we see the tired old line it's all Europe's fault (having blamed those who voted REMAIN, the ERG, Jeremy Corbyn and anyone else within range).Big_G_NorthWales said:
The underlying issues must be addressed but the last few days have not seen the EU at their finest and their attitude to discussing the backstop at all, will result in many more wanting to leave and, sadly, without a deal.
Italy is in recession and Germany not far behind and if we crash out, and all those German cars for our market, left rusting in Munich, flower growers in Holland with no market, Irish freight stranded at Dublin, Spanish, Portugese, Italian and French food and drink stopped in 30 mile queus at the Channel ports the, people of the EU will say we are happy to be sacrificed on a political obsession, and Merkel, Macron, Junckers, Tusk and Barnier are our heroes
I would love to hear for once a mea culpa from the May supporters admitting that perhaps in just a tiny regard, the Prime Minister might just bear a scintilla of responsibility for the current situation.
What we get regrettably are vacuous personal slurs against individuals in the EU - Juncker (Druncker you mean), Sabine Weygand (a "fat bossy German" as someone on here said the other day), Barnier (untrustworthy) etc and at the slightest hint of an attack on the UK, up go the hands in horror - it's another outrage comparable to the "humiliation" of Theresa May at Salzburg and now the perfidious Europeans are trying to take Gibraltar (95%+ REMAIN voting but who cares) from us.
This isn't a staring match to see who blinks first though it seems like it. The EU move today to waive any notion of visas and charging for visas for UK citizens if we leave without a Deal is a generous gesture to be welcomed.
Now, before everyone gets all irate I'm not being sufficiently patriotic, the EU aren't blameless in this and it's quite clear there is an underlying agenda to make us "pay" (poor choice of words) for leaving pour ne pas encourager les autres as it were and it may be the real crisis is over Italy and the Italian banks and that potentially could be much worse for the EU.
For now, as has so often happened in history, we are sleepwalking toward a situation because none of the alternatives work for at least one or more of the key players.
Revocation would destroy the Conservative Party (which I'd consider no great loss but that might be a minority view). May has even turned on her own WDA by passing the "magic unicorn" version which she must know the EU won't accept so it was a cynical political gimmick to try to hold together her Cabinet and Party.
So it's either an extension to A50 or all hell breaks loose on March 30th when the population discover the last Big Mac is being served in a McDonalds in Leeds and Waitrose runs out of avocadoes.0 -
The possibility of losing to Trump must be a factor for all of them, in the sense of how could you live with yourself afterwards.HYUFD said:
Plus if he got the nomination and Trump beat him (and history still fsbpurs an incumbent president after only 1 term of his party in the White House winning re election) then O'Rourke is done and someone like Bobby Kennedy's grandson Congressman Joseph P Kennedy III would be favourite in 2024rottenborough said:
Perhaps he genuinely hasn't made his mind up. Probably only gets one shot at it.Tissue_Price said:
Yep. I stand to be proved wrong in fairly short order, but this all looks like a somewhat calculated attempt to do things differently, because there is such appetite for that, especially on the left. @Richard_Nabavi notes he is inexperienced - well, yes and no. He's an experienced campaigner, who has previously beaten an incumbent in a House primary, and just given Ted Cruz a pretty good fright. His fundraising and campaigning skills are what he needs to win.rottenborough said:
And, given the American public elected Trump, his 6 years of House experience looks like a decent enough political CV, even though it would be traditional to have state or national-level responsibility first.
Most of all, I don't understand his tilt at Cruz if not with a view to running for President if he lost, which he must have anticipated.
Perhaps we shall see soon enough.0 -
It is Cair Guinntguic not Norwich.justin124 said:
And it is Llanelly not Llanelli.YBarddCwsc said:
None of your imperialist names, please.justin124 said:
There are 7 SNP seats more vulnerable to Labour than is Aberconway in North Wales.Big_G_NorthWales said:
No. I lived in Scotland when labour was as dominant as they are in Wales but the SNP being a party of the left, and of course very pro Independence, managed to be very pro business especially under Salmond and appealed across the divide. That appeal still exists but of course it's Independence obsession opens the way for a pro union - pro business conservative party under a very capable leader to provide a genuine alternative.Stereotomy said:
Do you think that somebody who aimed to predict elections could do a good job by getting a single person from each region with similar credentials and asking them what they think will happen?Big_G_NorthWales said:
My knowledge and connection with Scotland goes back 68 years, having lived there, been married there, have family across Scotland, have voted there, and regular go back to the north of Scotland.
The SNP have replaced labour as the party of the left but also are pro business and continue to occupy the space that labour would have previously dominated. There is no evidence labour are making inroads into the SNP
Personally I'd be extremely skeptical.
Of course it could change but it is not happening at present and in any GE soon I would expect both conservative and labour to lose seats to the SNP
It is Harare, not Salisbury.
It is Aberconwy, not Aberconway.
It is Llanelly and Mynydd Mawr Railway Company, as that became defunct before the anglicised name Llanelly was changed to Llanelli (by referendum!)0 -
Maybe he's just not that careerist and ran against Cruz because he thought he might win. I mean it was a long shot but it wasn't a crazy impossible long shot. One if the things that helped the Dems this time was that Trump felt like a serious enough problem get good people working hard on races without much certainty of success.Tissue_Price said:
Most of all, I don't understand his tilt at Cruz if not with a view to running for President if he lost, which he must have anticipated.0 -
We should all write to our MPs, tell them to stop buggering about - and get Brexit done and dusted by 29th March. No Deal if they must - just get it done. "Because Viewcode is worried..."viewcode said:
Yes! I like this optimism! And it's not even slightly related to my bet on "leave on time", oh deary me no...Big_G_NorthWales said:I am feeling optimistic this morning and I predict we will sign TM deal, modified or not, and will leave on the 29th March 2019
(Plus, they can make a few bob themselves if they put some money on....)0 -
History may favour Trump, but Betfair - and political wisdom based on Mueller etc. - doesn't. This is why the Democratic field is so high-profile and crowded; miss out now and you probably don't get a shot until 2028.HYUFD said:
Plus if he got the nomination and Trump beat him (and history still fsbpurs an incumbent president after only 1 term of his party in the White House winning re election) then O'Rourke is done and someone like Bobby Kennedy's grandson Congressman Joseph P Kennedy III would be favourite in 2024rottenborough said:
Perhaps he genuinely hasn't made his mind up. Probably only gets one shot at it.Tissue_Price said:
Yep. I stand to be proved wrong in fairly short order, but this all looks like a somewhat calculated attempt to do things differently, because there is such appetite for that, especially on the left. @Richard_Nabavi notes he is inexperienced - well, yes and no. He's an experienced campaigner, who has previously beaten an incumbent in a House primary, and just given Ted Cruz a pretty good fright. His fundraising and campaigning skills are what he needs to win.rottenborough said:
And, given the American public elected Trump, his 6 years of House experience looks like a decent enough political CV, even though it would be traditional to have state or national-level responsibility first.
Most of all, I don't understand his tilt at Cruz if not with a view to running for President if he lost, which he must have anticipated.
Perhaps we shall see soon enough.0 -
Self-determination works both ways. Yes, the inhabitants get to choose what country they want to be in, but the host country has to agree too. You can't just vote to be part of São Tomé and Príncipe and they have to accept.David_Evershed said:TheScreamingEagles said:
Not only that, we obtained it via war, and Gibraltar only became British thanks to mass immigration.SandyRentool said:
"British-occupied Spain"TheScreamingEagles said:
We say it is a BOT.edmundintokyo said:
What do the British say it is???Big_G_NorthWales said:The bitterness continues with the EU calling Gibraltar a British colony resulting in an angry rebuttal from the UK
British Overseas Territory.
Prior to 1983 we called it a British Crown Colony.
If we had any sense of honour and shame we'd repudiate the treaty of Utrecht and give Gibraltar back to Spain.
Edit - The treaty of Utrecht also helped expand Britain's role in the slave trade.
SHAMEFUL.
So you don't accept self determination?
Opens up claims to territory all over the world.
So if Britain says it no longer wants Gibraltar - possibly under duress - then Gibraltar needs to find a new home. Or Northern Ireland, for that matter.0 -
Why are you surprised? Whatever happens, it is never anything to do with "Leave". It is always nefarious "others" working to frustrate the Will Of The Nation (all 37% of them).stodge said:Once again, we see the tired old line it's all Europe's fault (having blamed those who voted REMAIN, the ERG, Jeremy Corbyn and anyone else within range).
I would love to hear for once a mea culpa from the May supporters admitting that perhaps in just a tiny regard, the Prime Minister might just bear a scintilla of responsibility for the current situation.0 -
Yes, that's the plausible alternative reading of it. But generally people don't sacrifice their safe seat for a gamble without a view of what to do next if they lose (which might of course include retirement).edmundintokyo said:
Maybe he's just not that careerist and ran against Cruz because he thought he might win. I mean it was a long shot but it wasn't a crazy impossible long shot. One if the things that helped the Dems this time was that Trump felt like a serious enough problem get good people working hard on races without much certainty of success.Tissue_Price said:
Most of all, I don't understand his tilt at Cruz if not with a view to running for President if he lost, which he must have anticipated.0 -
0