Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Surely the reason LAB’s not pulling away in the polls is that

13

Comments

  • JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,307
    I am mightily relieved that young Max is practicing his distinctive brand of election campaigning in Switzerland than on these shores. Some Tories did vote Labour in 2017 for a variety of reasons: I want them all back for 2022.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 54,461
    SeanT said:

    Not published yet. The Danakil is so obscure and hard-to-get-to, it's one of those pieces my editor will publish when she literally has nothing else to hand. That's just the way it is. My Bolivia piece took a year to emerge for the same reason.

    If I write about a glamorous new hotel in Venice or the Maldives it is published immediately. Advertisers like to see their adverts next to these glitzy pieces.
    And it is your duty to ensure that the hopper of such pieces is constantly topped up!
  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 39,809

    So MPs that do not follow the government line on Brexit are traitors? That's what Jo Cox's assassin called her, isn't it?

    The instructions of the people, not the executive. Those 11 MPs are defying the people, having been given a specific instruction.

    I'm just calling it what it is, I'm not issuing any threats or calling for them to be murdered. They are traitors to our party and the country. If you think that's comparable to an MP getting murdered by a crazy person then that's on you.

    Your attempt to silence any dissent on their betrayal won't work. You can say what you like, it doesn't change the fact that they voted against our party and against the people. Call me names or whatever you want. It doesn't bother me.
  • JohnO said:

    I am mightily relieved that young Max is practicing his distinctive brand of election campaigning in Switzerland than on these shores. Some Tories did vote Labour in 2017 for a variety of reasons: I want them all back for 2022.

    Max is the exact Tory mirror of a Corbynista. It’s fascinating.

  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 39,809
    JohnO said:

    I am mightily relieved that young Max is practicing his distinctive brand of election campaigning in Switzerland than on these shores. Some Tories did vote Labour in 2017 for a variety of reasons: I want them all back for 2022.

    Don't get me wrong, if voters switched to Labour because of some issue like the NHS or housing, we can and should win them back.
  • It's a step beyond that. Erstwhile Conservative voters who do not follow the government line on Brexit are traitors.

    Yep - just realised that. Not sure it’s a vote-winner myself.

  • AnazinaAnazina Posts: 3,487
    MaxPB said:

    Eh?

    I voted to leave, if that's what you're asking.
    Apologies – my question was meant for Ishmael.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    Max is neatly illustrating why our host is wrong. No committed Remainer is going to vote for the Conservatives while such unhinged views form part of their mainstream. Labour offer far more promising prospects of some kind of return movement towards EU values.
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758
    IanB2 said:

    If you drain a tiny swamp, what do you have left?

    Wall Street?
  • JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,307

    Max is neatly illustrating why our host is wrong. No committed Remainer is going to vote for the Conservatives while such unhinged views form part of their mainstream. Labour offer far more promising prospects of some kind of return movement towards EU values.

    Please. Max is emphatically not part of the Conservative mainstream.
  • AnazinaAnazina Posts: 3,487
    edited January 2018

    Your sneer is uncannily similar to Emily's.....
    Here's an experiment for you. Let us know how you get on.

    1. Go and ask your wife whether she would like to live next to house that is covered in England flags.

    2. When she says, 'no', directly accuse her of "sneering".

    3. To further prove her snobbery, immediately go outside and cover your own house in England flags.

    I'm looking forward to your report!
  • AnazinaAnazina Posts: 3,487
    HYUFD said:

    There is a slim chance he would have voted for Corbyn though he probably voted for UKIP rather than Ed Miliband
    And the house. Would you like to live next to a house covered in England flags?
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 54,747
    MaxPB said:

    Don't get me wrong, if voters switched to Labour because of some issue like the NHS or housing, we can and should win them back.
    This is even more extreme than the HYUFD test.

    If you vote Tory once, you're marked down as a Tory, and if you then subsequently deviate from Tory policy on a litmus test issue like Brexit, you're a traitor and should be banished to hell.
  • MaxPB said:

    The instructions of the people, not the executive. Those 11 MPs are defying the people, having been given a specific instruction.

    I'm just calling it what it is, I'm not issuing any threats or calling for them to be murdered. They are traitors to our party and the country. If you think that's comparable to an MP getting murdered by a crazy person then that's on you.

    Your attempt to silence any dissent on their betrayal won't work. You can say what you like, it doesn't change the fact that they voted against our party and against the people. Call me names or whatever you want. It doesn't bother me.

    You are calling Dominic Grieve, Ken Clarke. Anna Soubry and others traitors. That’s crazy talk. Sorry. It just is. As someone who is profoundly anti-Tory, I am all for you shouting out your claims of treachery from the rooftops - it will help to ensure the Tories do not get a majority at the next election.

  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    JohnO said:

    Please. Max is emphatically not part of the Conservative mainstream.
    Today Jacob Rees-Mogg announced that Britain should respond to the insult of being loaned the Bayeux Tapestry by revenge-loaning the French the Victory's flag to show "we usually win the battles". Like it or not, swivel-eyed mania is part of the Conservative mainstream.
  • JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,307
    Anazina said:

    Here's an experiment for you. Let us know how you get on.

    1. Go and ask your wife whether she would like to live next to house that is covered in England flags.

    2. When she says, 'no', directly accuse her of "sneering".

    3. To further prove her snobbery, immediately go outside and cover your own house in England flags.

    I'm looking forward to your report!
    I'm afraid your three words "dullards of Mansfield" says all we need to know about your attitudes.
  • JohnO said:

    Please. Max is emphatically not part of the Conservative mainstream.

    Traitor.

  • AnazinaAnazina Posts: 3,487

    This is even more extreme than the HYUFD test.

    If you vote Tory once, you're marked down as a Tory, and if you then subsequently deviate from Tory policy on a litmus test issue like Brexit, you're a traitor and should be banished to hell.
    :)

    The smiling face of the modern day broad church Tory Party.
  • Pro_RataPro_Rata Posts: 5,561
    edited January 2018
    I cannot imagine that many of the 2-3%.* of Con 15 -> Lab 17 voters were life long, card carrying Blues. More floating voters just going on impression and gut instinct.

    Not traitors, just never fully signed up in the first place.

    * Going off the FT report of the switching infographic, which does not link the underlying data, so number is approximate.
  • TheuniondivvieTheuniondivvie Posts: 43,242
    edited January 2018


    So MPs that do not follow the government line on Brexit are traitors? That's what Jo Cox's assassin called her, isn't it?

    Amazing the number of folk who can't take 'Little Englander' or 'xenophobe' or 'racist' but are content to hand out 'traitor' and such like. Lucky for them that no one has been murdered with the cry 'Little Englander' on the murderer's lips.
  • Today Jacob Rees-Mogg announced that Britain should respond to the insult of being loaned the Bayeux Tapestry by revenge-loaning the French the Victory's flag to show "we usually win the battles". Like it or not, swivel-eyed mania is part of the Conservative mainstream.
    Nope, the language of "swivel-eyed mania" is divisive and off-putting for non-believers in the REMAIN campaign.
  • HHemmeligHHemmelig Posts: 617
    @MaxPB

    "I'm talking specifically of Tories who turned their back on the party because the leadership decided to implement the result of the referendum. They betrayed our party and then by voting for Corbyn they betrayed our country. It's not a huge group of people but those 11 useful idiots in Parliament are among them"

    Tory Remainer here.

    Though I'm technically not one of your "traitors" as I still voted Con with a heavy heart in 2017, I was delighted that May lost her majority and conversely was mighty relieved the swing didn't go quite so far as to let Corbyn in. An ideal result IMO. It's pretty undeniable that May's awful election result is going to give us a far softer and more realistic Brexit than would have occurred had she got a huge majority.
  • JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,307
    edited January 2018

    Traitor.

    I'd better ask for body guards at County Hall in case Max is seen lurking armed with ten tonne boxes of toblerone.
  • AnazinaAnazina Posts: 3,487
    JohnO said:

    I'm afraid your three words "dullards of Mansfield" says all we need to know about your attitudes.
    Thank you for your intelligent and helpful contribution to the challenge.
  • ElliotElliot Posts: 1,516

    Today Jacob Rees-Mogg announced that Britain should respond to the insult of being loaned the Bayeux Tapestry by revenge-loaning the French the Victory's flag to show "we usually win the battles". Like it or not, swivel-eyed mania is part of the Conservative mainstream.
    Jacob Rees-Mogg would have been a reactionary 100 years ago. But this is clearly what is known as a "joke".
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 54,461

    Today Jacob Rees-Mogg announced that Britain should respond to the insult of being loaned the Bayeux Tapestry by revenge-loaning the French the Victory's flag to show "we usually win the battles". Like it or not, swivel-eyed mania is part of the Conservative mainstream.
    Was a time, now lost in pre-history, when you exhibited a sense of humour.....
  • JohnOJohnO Posts: 4,307
    edited January 2018
    Anazina said:

    Thank you for your intelligent and helpful contribution to the challenge.
    My pleasure and glad it was so appreciated.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 54,747
    Elliot said:

    Jacob Rees-Mogg would have been a reactionary 100 years ago. But this is clearly what is known as a "joke".
    The Tory MP who thinks we shouldn't build a bridge to France to save ourselves from invasion doesn't appear to be joking.
    https://twitter.com/MPritchardUK/status/954325791000748032
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 53,553
    edited January 2018


    Amazing the number of folk who can't take 'traitor' and such like, but are content to hand out 'Little Englander' or 'xenophobe' or 'racist'.

  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    Elliot said:

    Jacob Rees-Mogg would have been a reactionary 100 years ago. But this is clearly what is known as a "joke".
    Jokes were once upon a time supposed to be funny. Perhaps this is wildly hilarious if you have an insular, chauvinistic view of the world. For anyone not completely bats in the belfry, it just sounds nuts.
  • Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    SeanT said:

    Notice you haven't mentioned the £ is now worth almost $1.40. That is to say: it is now worth almost exactly what it was the months BEFORE the Brexit referendum.

    Against the Euro?

    Oh...
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 55,118

    The Tory MP who thinks we shouldn't build a bridge to France to save ourselves from invasion doesn't appear to be joking.
    https://twitter.com/MPritchardUK/status/954325791000748032
    I preferred the Matt cartoon suggesting we had to drive on the left until half way across.
  • Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,822
    edited January 2018
    HHemmelig said:

    An ideal result IMO. It's pretty undeniable that May's awful election result is going to give us a far softer and more realistic Brexit than would have occurred had she got a huge majority.

    That is highly deniable. If anything, the opposite is true, given that Mrs May is now very much having to worry about Brexiteer rebellions. Having said that, it might not have made much difference either way given that there really isn't much room for manoeuvre in either direction. I think the only real difference noticeable so far is that we might have agreed to overpay a bit as a result of her weakened position.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 55,118

    Jokes were once upon a time supposed to be funny. Perhaps this is wildly hilarious if you have an insular, chauvinistic view of the world. For anyone not completely bats in the belfry, it just sounds nuts.
    You've been skipping over those cartoons from the Standard haven't you?
  • Traitor.

    Did you say that with a Kylo Ren voice? Or with that of the stormtrooper that attacks Finn outside Maz's castle? :lol:
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 55,118

    That is highly deniable. If anything, the opposite is true, given that Mrs May is now very much having to worry about Brexiteer rebellions. Having said that, it might not have made much difference either way given that there really isn't much room for manoeuvre in either direction. I think the only real difference noticeable so far is that we might have agreed to overpay a bit.
    Whilst I agree with that and accept that May's weakness probably means a less attractive deal I am increasingly relieved that she has not been given the unrestrained power of a substantial majority.
  • Sky announced Sanchez swop deal is complete
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    DavidL said:

    You've been skipping over those cartoons from the Standard haven't you?
    Perhaps Jacob Rees-Mogg should try out as the cartoonist in the Express. I can't think of any role he's better suited to and at least he'd be out of harm's way there.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 55,118

    Sky announced Sanchez swop deal is complete

    I fear Rashford's game time is about to become somewhat limited. Not great for England.
  • CharlesCharles Posts: 35,758


    With global warming, the best wine growing regions of France are moving to southern England. Any way the best wines come from New Zealand so tarrifs on their wines will come down.
    I don't know. Saturday was pretty nice :smiley:

    https://www.millesima.co.uk/chateau-pichon-longueville-baron-2002.html
  • RecidivistRecidivist Posts: 4,679

    Amazing the number of folk who can't take 'traitor' and such like, but are content to hand out 'Little Englander' or 'xenophobe' or 'racist'.

    Name one.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 54,461

    Amazing the number of folk who can't take 'traitor' and such like, but are content to hand out 'Little Englander' or 'xenophobe' or 'racist'.

    Snowflakes!
  • NigelbNigelb Posts: 76,496
    HHemmelig said:

    @MaxPB

    "I'm talking specifically of Tories who turned their back on the party because the leadership decided to implement the result of the referendum. They betrayed our party and then by voting for Corbyn they betrayed our country. It's not a huge group of people but those 11 useful idiots in Parliament are among them"

    Tory Remainer here.

    Though I'm technically not one of your "traitors" as I still voted Con with a heavy heart in 2017, I was delighted that May lost her majority and conversely was mighty relieved the swing didn't go quite so far as to let Corbyn in. An ideal result IMO. It's pretty undeniable that May's awful election result is going to give us a far softer and more realistic Brexit than would have occurred had she got a huge majority.

    Anyone who thinks voters owe any particular political party allegiance has a rather skewed view of the world, to put it as mildly as possible.
  • DavidL said:

    Whilst I agree with that and accept that May's weakness probably means a less attractive deal I am increasingly relieved that she has not been given the unrestrained power of a substantial majority.
    A modest working majority would have been much, much better than what we've got. She basically can't do anything about non-Brexit issues, and Brexit is riskier than it needs to be because of her lack of a majority.
  • HHemmeligHHemmelig Posts: 617
    @JohnO

    "I am mightily relieved that young Max is practicing his distinctive brand of election campaigning in Switzerland than on these shores. Some Tories did vote Labour in 2017 for a variety of reasons: I want them all back for 2022."

    Then he has no right at all to lecture those of us who haven't abandoned our country what we should or shouldn't think about Brexit. Call those who disagree with Brexit traitiors from the comfort of Switzerland - beyond parody.
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 55,118

    A modest working majority would have been much, much better than what we've got. She basically can't do anything about non-Brexit issues, and Brexit is riskier than it needs to be because of her lack of a majority.
    And Timothy and Hill would still be in Number 10. They are doing enough damage outside it.
  • hunchmanhunchman Posts: 2,591
    Andrea 'Tara' Davison lol
  • DavidL said:

    And Timothy and Hill would still be in Number 10. They are doing enough damage outside it.
    That's true.
  • DavidL said:

    I fear Rashford's game time is about to become somewhat limited. Not great for England.
    Hope not but what a deal by Mourinho.

    No transfer fee and Mkhitaryan wages of approx £150,000 contributes to Sanchez £450,000

    Added to that Mourinho has proved he can buy the top players in the World (maybe not Messi)

  • HHemmelig said:

    @JohnO

    "I am mightily relieved that young Max is practicing his distinctive brand of election campaigning in Switzerland than on these shores. Some Tories did vote Labour in 2017 for a variety of reasons: I want them all back for 2022."

    Then he has no right at all to lecture those of us who haven't abandoned our country what we should or shouldn't think about Brexit. Call those who disagree with Brexit traitiors from the comfort of Switzerland - beyond parody.

    Not just Switzerland - Davos!
  • DavidLDavidL Posts: 55,118

    Hope not but what a deal by Mourinho.

    No transfer fee and Mkhitaryan wages of approx £150,000 contributes to Sanchez £450,000

    Added to that Mourinho has proved he can buy the top players in the World (maybe not Messi)

    Its a fantastic swop for United, no doubt about it.
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,517
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-42778184

    Although Mr Osborne was not charged with a terrorist offence, Mr Rees said "the note and the comments he made after his detention establish that this act of extreme violence was, indeed, an act of terrorism".

    I see this guy hasn't been charged with terror offences. Can anyone explain why that's the case?
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,517
    DavidL said:

    Its a fantastic swop for United, no doubt about it.
    As someone who has watched him play for the last three and a half seasons, I disagree. You'll be infuriated by him.
  • AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    tlg86 said:

    As someone who has watched him play for the last three and a half seasons, I disagree. You'll be infuriated by him.
    Good Sanchez is incredible. Bad Sanchez is a waste of space. And you do get the impression that he's a disruptive presence in the dressing room.

    For all that, watching him at his best has been a privilege.
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 65,011
    edited January 2018
    tlg86 said:

    As someone who has watched him play for the last three and a half seasons, I disagree. You'll be infuriated by him.
    Genine question - Are Arsenal pleased he has left for Man Utd

    I used to get infuriated with Eric (Cantona), Beckham and Ronaldo but they bought something special to the tea
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,517

    Good Sanchez is incredible. Bad Sanchez is a waste of space. And you do get the impression that he's a disruptive presence in the dressing room.

    For all that, watching him at his best has been a privilege.
    His biggest weakness is that he's utterly predictable. He always cuts inside and never goes down the outside. You have to put up with a huge amount of rubbish to get some gems.
  • HHemmeligHHemmelig Posts: 617
    @Richard Navabi

    "That is highly deniable. If anything, the opposite is true, given that Mrs May is now very much having to worry about Brexiteer rebellions. Having said that, it might not have made much difference either way given that there really isn't much room for manoeuvre in either direction. I think the only real difference noticeable so far is that we might have agreed to overpay a bit as a result of her weakened position."

    She has caved in to numerous Remainer rebellions and had to guarantee regulatory equivalence across the Irish border. None of that would have been likely with a working majority. The Brexiteers have so far been strangely quiet and un-rebellious despite their red lines being almost totally rubbed out. May be this will change as the negotiations rumble on.
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,517

    Genine question - Are Arsenal pleased he has left for Man Utd

    I used to get infuriated with Eric (Cantona), Beckham and Ronaldo but they bought something special to the tea
    I'm annoyed that he wasn't sold in the summer. He strikes me as very petulant and very difficult manage. I bet plenty of the other players were pleased to see the back of him.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,087
    SeanT said:

    Notice you haven't mentioned the £ is now worth almost $1.40. That is to say: it is now worth almost exactly what it was the months BEFORE the Brexit referendum.
    The £ went down and then the $ went down. Whoopeedoo.
  • tlg86 said:

    I'm annoyed that he wasn't sold in the summer. He strikes me as very petulant and very difficult manage. I bet plenty of the other players were pleased to see the back of him.

    £450,000 a week is ridiculous and unsustainable, even for United. Other players in their squad have a benchmark now.

  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981
    tlg86 said:

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-42778184

    Although Mr Osborne was not charged with a terrorist offence, Mr Rees said "the note and the comments he made after his detention establish that this act of extreme violence was, indeed, an act of terrorism".

    I see this guy hasn't been charged with terror offences. Can anyone explain why that's the case?

    I think it's because as he has actually killed someone, a plain old murder charge is adequate and straightforward. The terrorist offences are for people who haven't actually got that far, but are preparing/planning/encouraging others to commit murder.
  • tlg86 said:

    I'm annoyed that he wasn't sold in the summer. He strikes me as very petulant and very difficult manage. I bet plenty of the other players were pleased to see the back of him.
    I think his wage increase will help to focus his team building though others players will be seeking increases as a result
  • DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300

    Today Jacob Rees-Mogg announced that Britain should respond to the insult of being loaned the Bayeux Tapestry by revenge-loaning the French the Victory's flag to show "we usually win the battles". Like it or not, swivel-eyed mania is part of the Conservative mainstream.
    JRM's Portillo moment? Not losing his seat but the crass who dares wins speech.
  • williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 54,747
    "Business leaders push for new campaign to reverse Brexit "

    https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2018/jan/22/business-leaders-push-for-new-campaign-to-reverse-brexit

    Behind the scenes, senior figures on the CBI policy council are urging the lobby group to toughen its message still further and spell out their belief that this logic should ultimately lead to a national rethink of the decision to leave the EU, perhaps through a second referendum or an election.

    ...

    “It’s not for us to say [whether to reverse Brexit], we are simply pointing out that you need single market access and you need a customs union,” said a spokesman, Charles Naylor. “If someone concludes that we therefore need to retest this, that’s a political decision, we are just being very practical about it.”
  • MJWMJW Posts: 2,011

    You are calling Dominic Grieve, Ken Clarke. Anna Soubry and others traitors. That’s crazy talk. Sorry. It just is. As someone who is profoundly anti-Tory, I am all for you shouting out your claims of treachery from the rooftops - it will help to ensure the Tories do not get a majority at the next election.

    It's also nonsense. Of the Tory rebels only Ken Clarke has really said he's out and out opposed to Brexit. The others have strongly disagreed with the form of Brexit the PM is currently advocating (such as it is) because they believe it to be disastrous. If, say May had come out and announced after becoming leader that she wanted to leave the EU but opt to stay in the single market and customs union then another set of Tory MPs would be rebelling for their preferred form of Brexit. We don't want MPs to just rubberstamp contentious policies but use their judgement.

    But then this problem goes back to the in-out referendum. It's an oblique instruction requiring, often contradictory interpretations none of which commands obvious clear support in the country. Which is why everything's a bit of a mess. There is no settled will of the people - as there's not an agreed way to faithfully carry out the instruction.
  • CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,633

    Max is neatly illustrating why our host is wrong. No committed Remainer is going to vote for the Conservatives while such unhinged views form part of their mainstream. Labour offer far more promising prospects of some kind of return movement towards EU values.

    I agree with your first two sentences. But not your last. The term "traitor" is not unknown in Labour though it is not often used in connection with Brexit. Corbyn does not value the EU and has no intention of returning to it or the SM/CU, however much some may wish it to be so.

    Only the Lib Dems do that and they are both irrelevant and invisible.
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,517
    Ishmael_Z said:

    I think it's because as he has actually killed someone, a plain old murder charge is adequate and straightforward. The terrorist offences are for people who haven't actually got that far, but are preparing/planning/encouraging others to commit murder.
    Thomas Mair was done under the Terrorism Act 2000.
  • Amazing the number of folk who can't take 'traitor' and such like, but are content to hand out 'Little Englander' or 'xenophobe' or 'racist'.

    That's clever.

    Why didn't you do your wee reverse trick with all of my post? Oh, that's right.

  • £450,000 a week is ridiculous and unsustainable, even for United. Other players in their squad have a benchmark now.

    Not when it is effectively a free transfer but your point about other players is valid
  • IanB2 said:

    The £ went down and then the $ went down. Whoopeedoo.
    And exports went up and up
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,087
    MJW said:

    It's also nonsense. Of the Tory rebels only Ken Clarke has really said he's out and out opposed to Brexit. The others have strongly disagreed with the form of Brexit the PM is currently advocating (such as it is) because they believe it to be disastrous. If, say May had come out and announced after becoming leader that she wanted to leave the EU but opt to stay in the single market and customs union then another set of Tory MPs would be rebelling for their preferred form of Brexit. We don't want MPs to just rubberstamp contentious policies but use their judgement.

    But then this problem goes back to the in-out referendum. It's an oblique instruction requiring, often contradictory interpretations none of which commands obvious clear support in the country. Which is why everything's a bit of a mess. There is no settled will of the people - as there's not an agreed way to faithfully carry out the instruction.
    Cameron, had he not been so arrogant as to think he could stroll the referendum, should have agreed to it on condition that the leave campaigners first agree amongst themselves a prospectus setting out, in outline, what Brexit would look like.
  • CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,633
    MaxPB said:

    The instructions of the people, not the executive. Those 11 MPs are defying the people, having been given a specific instruction.

    I'm just calling it what it is, I'm not issuing any threats or calling for them to be murdered. They are traitors to our party and the country. If you think that's comparable to an MP getting murdered by a crazy person then that's on you.

    Your attempt to silence any dissent on their betrayal won't work. You can say what you like, it doesn't change the fact that they voted against our party and against the people. Call me names or whatever you want. It doesn't bother me.
    I don't normally go all personal. But - really - do grow up.

    Disagreement in a democracy does not make one a traitor. MPs are there to represent. Not take instructions. Read some Edmund Burke.

    Or even this - http://www2.politicalbetting.com/index.php/archives/2017/12/15/to-get-the-tone-right-it-has-to-come-from-the-top/
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,087

    And exports went up and up
    Fake news. Almost.

    https://www.theguardian.com/business/2017/sep/08/uk-exports-eu-weak-pound-trade-europe
  • FoxyFoxy Posts: 51,133
    tlg86 said:

    I'm annoyed that he wasn't sold in the summer. He strikes me as very petulant and very difficult manage. I bet plenty of the other players were pleased to see the back of him.
    Mikytarian should suit Arsenal well, better than the sulky Chilean.

    Good business as far as I can see. ManU are crazy.
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,517

    Not when it is effectively a free transfer but your point about other players is valid
    Yes, that's what happened with Sol Campbell. It probably led to a few of the senior players at Arsenal seeking a rise but I don't think it caused any major problem in that regard.

    I know Ray Parlour thought it was brilliant and spent the first few weeks winding Sol up something rotten. But football was different back then. I can imagine Pogba being miffed.
  • MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 54,461
    edited January 2018
    tlg86 said:

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-42778184

    Although Mr Osborne was not charged with a terrorist offence, Mr Rees said "the note and the comments he made after his detention establish that this act of extreme violence was, indeed, an act of terrorism".

    I see this guy hasn't been charged with terror offences. Can anyone explain why that's the case?

    Because wanting the Prime Minister Theresa May chopped up in bags in his freezer is adequately covered by the existing crim.....

    Ah. Not that Mr. Osborne.....
  • ydoethurydoethur Posts: 73,368

    £450,000 a week is ridiculous and unsustainable, even for United. Other players in their squad have a benchmark now.

    Should Andy Burnham put that on the side of a bus, with the words 'let's give that money to the NHS instead?' next to it?

    Would have thought it would be a winner...
  • RoyalBlueRoyalBlue Posts: 3,223
    @MaxPB - I think you’ve gone too far. While it was not pleasant to see the 11 rebels celebrating the government’s defeat, I think any accusations of treachery to party or country are utterly unjustified at this stage.

    If they vote against the deal, threatening the country with a general election which might see Corbyn come to power, or actively support a second referendum of any kind, we can reassess.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 126,896

    Cultural values are linked to economic outcomes. The flag will get the Tories so far, but crumbling public services and stagnating living standards will do for them if they are not addressed. In our FPTP system not being on the far left would be enough to see Thornberry home, especially as she is fluent and credible enough to come up with some form of words on her Tweet for the very small number who do remember it. However, this is all academic as Jeremy Corbyn will almost certainly be Labour leader at the next election.
    Did not work for Ed Miliband though did it
  • CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,633

    Jokes were once upon a time supposed to be funny. Perhaps this is wildly hilarious if you have an insular, chauvinistic view of the world. For anyone not completely bats in the belfry, it just sounds nuts.
    As a direct descendant of the most famous Frenchman ever (Napoleon) and one of the most famous French Jewish women ever (Rachel) I am prepared, in a spirit of British self-sacrifice, akin to Scott going outside for some time, to be loaned to the French. Despite this quasi-@SeanT style boasting, I only require a modest apartment - with roof garden and exquisite courtyard garden in the centre of Paris where I can in my immaculate French (courtesy of my French grandmother) do my bit for Anglo-French relations. I could have a salon and invite people to discourse on matters of the day, a sort of 19th century version of PB, only with madeleines, proper coffee and fine wines.

    I await the call...........
  • NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,673

    You are calling Dominic Grieve, Ken Clarke. Anna Soubry and others traitors. That’s crazy talk. Sorry. It just is. As someone who is profoundly anti-Tory, I am all for you shouting out your claims of treachery from the rooftops - it will help to ensure the Tories do not get a majority at the next election.

    Anna is locally seen by some Remainders as a RINO (Remainer in Name Only) - usually she votes with the whips in the end after lots of sound and fury. Ken Clarke is more willing to vote with his conscience.

    But Max and SeanT share with the Trots of this world a willingness to use nutty abuse merely because they disagree with someone. They're all a bit weird.
  • Foxy said:

    Mikytarian should suit Arsenal well, better than the sulky Chilean.

    Good business as far as I can see. ManU are crazy.
    Mikytarian started all guns blazing but he has completely lost his way and I see no upside for Arsenal in this.

    I think you will find Man U supporters are really pleased at the swop deal, indeed amazed
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,654

    Sky announced Sanchez swop deal is complete

    He's become a woman???
  • That's clever.

    Why didn't you do your wee reverse trick with all of my post? Oh, that's right.

    Well the first sentence is relevant to PB this evening.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,462
    MaxPB said:

    I'm talking specifically of Tories who turned their back on the party because the leadership decided to implement the result of the referendum. They betrayed our party and then by voting for Corbyn they betrayed our country. It's not a huge group of people but those 11 useful idiots in Parliament are among them.
    The 11 are not traitors. They've always made their views plain, and indeed, have given little trouble to the government.
  • JRM's Portillo moment? Not losing his seat but the crass who dares wins speech.
    Michael Portillo has a famous motto:

    Who dares wins!

    WE dare! WE will WIN!!!

    [Sunil goes and lies down for a while...]
  • He's become a woman???
    The funny thing is that his first game is likely to be away to Yeovil this friday in the cup
  • Ishmael_ZIshmael_Z Posts: 8,981
    Cyclefree said:

    As a direct descendant of the most famous Frenchman ever (Napoleon) and one of the most famous French Jewish women ever (Rachel) I am prepared, in a spirit of British self-sacrifice, akin to Scott going outside for some time, to be loaned to the French. Despite this quasi-@SeanT style boasting, I only require a modest apartment - with roof garden and exquisite courtyard garden in the centre of Paris where I can in my immaculate French (courtesy of my French grandmother) do my bit for Anglo-French relations. I could have a salon and invite people to discourse on matters of the day, a sort of 19th century version of PB, only with madeleines, proper coffee and fine wines.

    I await the call...........
    Oates went outside, not Scott, and did so pretty much under direct instruction from Scott that anyone who couldn't go on was to commit suicide for the sake of the others; he had that morning got Wilson to explain to the entire party the procedure for overdosing on morphine. Oates' mother refused to show up at the Palace to collect a medal on his behalf, and pressed unsuccessfully for an enquiry into Scott's conduct of the expedition. It cannot be overstated what an incompetent, murderous horp* Scott was.

    * Substring of "Scunthorpe". Other substrings are available.
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,462

    Max is neatly illustrating why our host is wrong. No committed Remainer is going to vote for the Conservatives while such unhinged views form part of their mainstream. Labour offer far more promising prospects of some kind of return movement towards EU values.

    What are EU values?
  • StereotomyStereotomy Posts: 4,092
    If the thread header is true, conservatives should be worried. This is not going to be a big issue in 2022
  • Name one.
    Alastair Meeks for one.
  • CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,633
    Ishmael_Z said:

    Oates went outside, not Scott, and did so pretty much under direct instruction from Scott that anyone who couldn't go on was to commit suicide for the sake of the others; he had that morning got Wilson to explain to the entire party the procedure for overdosing on morphine. Oates' mother refused to show up at the Palace to collect a medal on his behalf, and pressed unsuccessfully for an enquiry into Scott's conduct of the expedition. It cannot be overstated what an incompetent, murderous horp* Scott was.

    * Substring of "Scunthorpe". Other substrings are available.
    The things you learn on PB. "Reassessing famous heroes". It could be the salon's first topic.
  • MortimerMortimer Posts: 14,187
    Sean_F said:

    What are EU values?
    A lack of democratic legitimacy, a fear of public referenda, and a contempt for the nation states of Europe and their preferences...?
  • Q. Why did the REMAINERs cross the road?

    A. Because Brussels told them to :lol:

    (I thank you!)
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 126,896

    If the thread header is true, conservatives should be worried. This is not going to be a big issue in 2022

    Corbyn is and whether it is or not depends what Brexit UK looks like in 2022
  • Ishmael_Z said:

    Oates went outside, not Scott, and did so pretty much under direct instruction from Scott that anyone who couldn't go on was to commit suicide for the sake of the others; he had that morning got Wilson to explain to the entire party the procedure for overdosing on morphine. Oates' mother refused to show up at the Palace to collect a medal on his behalf, and pressed unsuccessfully for an enquiry into Scott's conduct of the expedition. It cannot be overstated what an incompetent, murderous horp* Scott was.

    * Substring of "Scunthorpe". Other substrings are available.
    Didn't know most of that (I was aware judgments on RFS were various). Thanks, I've learned something today.
  • JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 45,307
    Cyclefree said:

    The things you learn on PB. "Reassessing famous heroes". It could be the salon's first topic.
    Don't get me started on Thomas Telford ... ;)
  • SandyRentoolSandyRentool Posts: 22,654
    Mortimer said:

    A lack of democratic legitimacy, a fear of public referenda, and a contempt for the nation states of Europe and their preferences...?
    Plus arrogance, intransigence, pettiness and incompetence.
  • MJWMJW Posts: 2,011
    IanB2 said:

    Cameron, had he not been so arrogant as to think he could stroll the referendum, should have agreed to it on condition that the leave campaigners first agree amongst themselves a prospectus setting out, in outline, what Brexit would look like.
    Or, not used his support for a referendum as a handy piece of virtue signalling to keep his eurosceptics on side. If there was a sensible way to conduct Brexit it was for a party to put it forward as part of a full manifesto explaining how it fitted into its economic and social plans and then run for election on it. If they won, they'd have had five years to implement that plan before asking to be judged on whether it was the right one. If it was a disaster they'd be booted out. As it is, we're at a point where the cart has been put before the horse - we know we're leaving but God knows where we'll end up and it's filled politics with chancers who know it's unlikely they'll have to clear up any detritus, and so put political posturing ahead of what's coherent, desirable nd achievable (whichever side you're on).

  • TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633
    "Other LAB figures like Chuka Umunna and Keir Starmer have been articulating Brexit positions which, I’d suggest, are much more palatable to the vast bulk of the Labour movement than Crobyn/Mc"

    Why don't they mount a leadership challenge then ??
This discussion has been closed.