politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Harry Hayfield’s guide to the Aberdeen, Donside Scottish Parliamentary By-Election
Aberdeen, Donside is only the seventh constituency by-election to the Scottish Parliament since it was re-founded back in 1999 and in that time only one seat (Ayr in 2000) has changed hands.
'six months later both Jean Urquhart MSP and John Finnie MSP (SNP, Highlands and the Islands) resigned the SNP whip over the party’s change in its policy towards NATO. This means that the SNP have 64 seats at the moment and an SNP loss in Donside would see the SNP lose their overall majority (but still able to pass leglisation with the help of Margo McDonald MSP (Ind, Lothians) and the two Green MSP’s).'
There's no realistic issue on which Finnie and Urquhart wouldn't vote with the SNP (and if there was, Margo & the Greens would be just as likely to bail on it).
Well what a past 30 hours on the financial markets it has been - commodities down, bonds down (yields up), stocks down, and the US Dollar UP UP UP. Its been a long while for this dynamic to establish itself, like the chaos of Autumn 2008.
Its a very canny game that Greece is playing, at a time when Merkel can't afford for anything to go wrong before September. Well that election will be 3 months too late for her. I saw AFD were doing well in a recent poll, it will be fascinating to see if they can gain more traction in the run up to the election. And just when there needed no more reminding of declining social mood, the protests in Brazil and their stockmarket, the Bovespa at a 4 year low.
Once we've got this weekend out of the way, I'm pretty bullish on US markets into around late July, and then finally the greatest financial implosion of all can begin. Its been a long long wait, much longer than I thought possible a few years ago. 2008 will be a tiny footnote in history compared to the financial hurricane lying in wait right now.
It was so OGH could avoid answering this question, FPT... ;-)
Perhaps OGH can give us a local perspective on why this is such a bad thing? It sounds rather positive to me.
So how to smash this system? The model can be found in a Bedford secondary located in one of the nation’s most deprived wards – yet its reputation is such that it steals pupils from nearby private schools. Not that it’s colonised by the rich: a fifth of its intake are poor enough to qualify for free school meals. The children of the wealthy and less fortunate sit together in identical uniforms, knowing little about each other’s circumstances and caring less. The Bedford Free School ought to be a pin-up for anyone who cares about social cohesion. Yet this week, the Labour Party made clear it would strangle this experiment at birth.
Stephen Twigg, the shadow education secretary, didn’t mention the Bedford Free School by name, but he didn’t need to. It was set up by Mark Lehain, a former teacher, in the teeth of opposition from the council, which ran seven other schools of varying quality. There is no need for an eighth, the council said, as some of these schools still have vacancies. But Mr Lehain took a different view: parents should decide if a new school was needed. He has now filled all 200 of his places, leaving his furious rivals to nurse more “surplus” spaces than ever.
My brother and his wife live in Gilmerton and Liberton where there has been a local election today - have just texted them to see if they voted or not, they're hardly the most political animals around so I think rather not!
Once we've got this weekend out of the way, I'm pretty bullish on US markets into around late July, and then finally the greatest financial implosion of all can begin. Its been a long long wait, much longer than I thought possible a few years ago. 2008 will be a tiny footnote in history compared to the financial hurricane lying in wait right now.
You'd have more credibility if you were here more often rather than just posting own the down days in the market.
Once we've got this weekend out of the way, I'm pretty bullish on US markets into around late July, and then finally the greatest financial implosion of all can begin. Its been a long long wait, much longer than I thought possible a few years ago. 2008 will be a tiny footnote in history compared to the financial hurricane lying in wait right now.
You'd have more credibility if you were here more often rather than just posting own the down days in the market.
Sheesh, I've just told you there that I'm no permabear - in fact I've made money on the long side this year, and will do hopefully again over the next month. And when the great implosion gets underway, there'll be days where the market will be up over 5% with violent short covering rallies - when markets overall crash that's when you get the biggest single day up movements amongst them eg Nasdaq crash from 2000-2002, 2008 and 1930-1932, and I'll be around here to comment on them.
Salford pass notes: UKIP a fair second, good result, Labour a comfortable win but lower %, OK result, Tories down and third, weak result, :LibDems 7th, LOL result.
Salford pass notes: UKIP a fair second, good result, Labour a comfortable win but lower %, OK result, Tories down and third, weak result, :LibDems 7th, LOL result.
Nick - how is the renomination campaign going in Broxtowe? When's the date of the final selection? Good luck - parliament needs more MP's like you, whatever one's political persuasion.
Well what a past 30 hours on the financial markets it has been - commodities down, bonds down (yields up), stocks down, and the US Dollar UP UP UP. Its been a long while for this dynamic to establish itself, like the chaos of Autumn 2008.
Its a very canny game that Greece is playing, at a time when Merkel can't afford for anything to go wrong before September. Well that election will be 3 months too late for her. I saw AFD were doing well in a recent poll, it will be fascinating to see if they can gain more traction in the run up to the election. And just when there needed no more reminding of declining social mood, the protests in Brazil and their stockmarket, the Bovespa at a 4 year low.
Once we've got this weekend out of the way, I'm pretty bullish on US markets into around late July, and then finally the greatest financial implosion of all can begin. Its been a long long wait, much longer than I thought possible a few years ago. 2008 will be a tiny footnote in history compared to the financial hurricane lying in wait right now.
Hi Hunchman, surely the most important market-related story is Max Keiser was just on BBC This Week!
Liberton and Gilmerton will apparently count tomorrow morning!
Thanks for that, I await it with interest. It was amazing that the SNP polled highest there, admittedly in their high noon of 2011, when you think that it is wholly contained within the outer wedge part of Edinburgh South where they're a poor 4th in the Westminster election just 12 months earlier.
Well what a past 30 hours on the financial markets it has been - commodities down, bonds down (yields up), stocks down, and the US Dollar UP UP UP. Its been a long while for this dynamic to establish itself, like the chaos of Autumn 2008.
Its a very canny game that Greece is playing, at a time when Merkel can't afford for anything to go wrong before September. Well that election will be 3 months too late for her. I saw AFD were doing well in a recent poll, it will be fascinating to see if they can gain more traction in the run up to the election. And just when there needed no more reminding of declining social mood, the protests in Brazil and their stockmarket, the Bovespa at a 4 year low.
Once we've got this weekend out of the way, I'm pretty bullish on US markets into around late July, and then finally the greatest financial implosion of all can begin. Its been a long long wait, much longer than I thought possible a few years ago. 2008 will be a tiny footnote in history compared to the financial hurricane lying in wait right now.
Hi Hunchman, surely the most important market-related story is Max Keiser was just on BBC This Week!
You're right - that is the most important story, and I missed it! Oh well, I'll catch up with it on IPlayer tomorrow now!
Meanwhile Hollande and co are engaging in tyrannical financial repression measures, which anybody with a grain of sense could tell you will be 100% counter-productive:
Liberton and Gilmerton will apparently count tomorrow morning!
Thanks for that, I await it with interest. It was amazing that the SNP polled highest there, admittedly in their high noon of 2011, when you think that it is wholly contained within the outer wedge part of Edinburgh South where they're a poor 4th in the Westminster election just 12 months earlier.
SNP did not poll the highest vote the total votes were Labour 3,709 SNP 2,864 with 2 Labour and 1 SNP councillor elected . Should therefore be a Labour gain as SNP are defending .
Liberton and Gilmerton will apparently count tomorrow morning!
Thanks for that, I await it with interest. It was amazing that the SNP polled highest there, admittedly in their high noon of 2011, when you think that it is wholly contained within the outer wedge part of Edinburgh South where they're a poor 4th in the Westminster election just 12 months earlier.
SNP did not poll the highest vote the total votes were Labour 3,709 SNP 2,864 with 2 Labour and 1 SNP councillor elected . Should therefore be a Labour gain as SNP are defending .
Sorry about that, my memory playing tricks with me.
"I see the Cybernats are conspicuous by their absence!"
Wrong again, Sunil. I was put at my ease about an hour and a half ago when the sainted Kezia claimed that "anything less than 50%" would be an unmitigated disaster for the SNP.
Labour do seem to be suffering from an ambition deficit in Scotland. As the thread-header points out, this is solid Labour territory at Westminster level, and the SNP are in mid-term. Labour really should be winning.
Lord Monckton out of his depth on STV....it appears he just said Salmond has been expelled from Labour once...and there has been a famous Stirling by-election....
"Lord Monckton out of his depth on STV....it appears he just said Salmond has been expelled from Labour once...during the Stirling by-election...."
Oh damn, I'm watching the wrong channel. This "Stirling by-election" business seems to be developing into a fully-fledged mythology over at UKIP HQ. There'll be leprichauns involved before too long.
Sorry, I got confused..Salmond has been expelled...and there has been the famous Stirling by-election...but the 2 things are unrelated also on UKIP mind!
BBC showing very funny archive footage of Vincent Hanna covering the Hillhead by-election. It started with Roy Jenkins (as Plato might say) creepily stalking people outside a bingo hall, plaintively asking them "Where do you live?", but only finding one actual Hillhead voter (who was planning to vote Labour).
Seems fairly clear that the Conservatives have slipped from third to fourth. Which means...
*puts on Canadian accent*
It's another terrrr-ible night for the Conservatives.
LOL. Just finished watching Road to Referendum. Great result for the SNP in mid-term. Can't wait for September next year. After the convulsions in Spring next year, which will dwarf autumn 2008, its very much up for grabs. There really will be very little to lose for Scotland by quitting a union that will be morally and economically bust in every sense of the word. And in that light, I think Scotland will break 307 years of union. Without a major economic collapse, it wouldn't be possible ie economic collapse is a necessary, but not sufficient condition for Scotland to vote yes next year.
Curtice : Labour only up 1 or 2% on 2011, not up at all on 2007.
it's SNP who is down 15 points compared to 2011
Labour candidate was out of his depth. On the defensive and that's when he could answer a question.
SNP basically run the campaign as they were voting for Aberdeen council elections (run by Lab-Con) which is a sensible idea in mid term (like Labour turning Glenrothes parliamentary elections into a referendum on the SNP led council).
So the outcome is more or less what you could have expected 1 month ago. A reduced majority but nothing threatening.
A better Labour candidate could have gave them more a run for their money trying to turn their table on them. Maybe.
"I see the Cybernats are conspicuous by their absence!"
Wrong again, Sunil. I was put at my ease about an hour and a half ago when the sainted Kezia claimed that "anything less than 50%" would be an unmitigated disaster for the SNP.
Labour do seem to be suffering from an ambition deficit in Scotland. As the thread-header points out, this is solid Labour territory at Westminster level, and the SNP are in mid-term. Labour really should be winning.
Comments
There's no realistic issue on which Finnie and Urquhart wouldn't vote with the SNP (and if there was, Margo & the Greens would be just as likely to bail on it).
Salford-Weaste and Seedley
Lab 785 UKIP 401 Con 260 Green 80 BNP 74 Ind 64 LD 58 TUSC 30 Ind 15
Well what a past 30 hours on the financial markets it has been - commodities down, bonds down (yields up), stocks down, and the US Dollar UP UP UP. Its been a long while for this dynamic to establish itself, like the chaos of Autumn 2008.
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-06-20/charting-king-dollars-creeping-attempt-takeover-world
We've had some very interesting developments in China:
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-06-19/china-interbank-market-freezes-overnight-repo-explodes-25
And note well the goings on of China Everbright Bank - it will be the first of many many missed debt payments:
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-06-13/market-would-have-collapsed-had-pboc-drained-chinese-liquidity-shortage-hits-all-tim
Its no surprise that the interbank lending market freezed up quickly after that.
And Greece refuses to go away:
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-06-20/stocks-plunge-imf-tells-greece-plug-holes-or-it-pulls-plug
Its a very canny game that Greece is playing, at a time when Merkel can't afford for anything to go wrong before September. Well that election will be 3 months too late for her. I saw AFD were doing well in a recent poll, it will be fascinating to see if they can gain more traction in the run up to the election. And just when there needed no more reminding of declining social mood, the protests in Brazil and their stockmarket, the Bovespa at a 4 year low.
Once we've got this weekend out of the way, I'm pretty bullish on US markets into around late July, and then finally the greatest financial implosion of all can begin. Its been a long long wait, much longer than I thought possible a few years ago. 2008 will be a tiny footnote in history compared to the financial hurricane lying in wait right now.
Perhaps OGH can give us a local perspective on why this is such a bad thing? It sounds rather positive to me.
So how to smash this system? The model can be found in a Bedford secondary located in one of the nation’s most deprived wards – yet its reputation is such that it steals pupils from nearby private schools. Not that it’s colonised by the rich: a fifth of its intake are poor enough to qualify for free school meals. The children of the wealthy and less fortunate sit together in identical uniforms, knowing little about each other’s circumstances and caring less. The Bedford Free School ought to be a pin-up for anyone who cares about social cohesion. Yet this week, the Labour Party made clear it would strangle this experiment at birth.
Stephen Twigg, the shadow education secretary, didn’t mention the Bedford Free School by name, but he didn’t need to. It was set up by Mark Lehain, a former teacher, in the teeth of opposition from the council, which ran seven other schools of varying quality. There is no need for an eighth, the council said, as some of these schools still have vacancies. But Mr Lehain took a different view: parents should decide if a new school was needed. He has now filled all 200 of his places, leaving his furious rivals to nurse more “surplus” spaces than ever.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/ed-miliband/10132323/The-Tories-are-fighting-for-the-people-Labour-has-abandoned.html
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-06-20/greek-coalition-verge-collapse-snap-elections-scenario-returns
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.co.uk/2013/06/no-hiding-places.html
38% turnout
Liberton and Gilmerton will apparently count tomorrow morning!
Lab 1896 SNP 1711 Con 272 UKIP 176 Lib Dems 83
Turnout 29.21%
http://www.acting-man.com/?p=24258
Meanwhile Hollande and co are engaging in tyrannical financial repression measures, which anybody with a grain of sense could tell you will be 100% counter-productive:
http://www.acting-man.com/?p=24253
http://player.stv.tv/programmes/road-referendum/2013-06-18-2000/?yes
Wrong again, Sunil. I was put at my ease about an hour and a half ago when the sainted Kezia claimed that "anything less than 50%" would be an unmitigated disaster for the SNP.
Labour do seem to be suffering from an ambition deficit in Scotland. As the thread-header points out, this is solid Labour territory at Westminster level, and the SNP are in mid-term. Labour really should be winning.
Oh damn, I'm watching the wrong channel. This "Stirling by-election" business seems to be developing into a fully-fledged mythology over at UKIP HQ. There'll be leprichauns involved before too long.
Sorry, I got confused..Salmond has been expelled...and there has been the famous Stirling by-election...but the 2 things are unrelated also on UKIP mind!
But is there really room for two independence parties in Scotland?
I think my head hurts.
Really?
According to Curtice it was roughly SNP 38%, Labour 32%, so if that's true the SNP might even be slightly exceeding that.
*puts on Canadian accent*
It's another terrrr-ible night for the Conservatives.
Lab +4.9 SNP -6.2 Con +0.8 UKIP 4.3 from nowhere LD +0.5
Good night all.
Labour candidate was out of his depth. On the defensive and that's when he could answer a question.
SNP basically run the campaign as they were voting for Aberdeen council elections (run by Lab-Con) which is a sensible idea in mid term (like Labour turning Glenrothes parliamentary elections into a referendum on the SNP led council).
So the outcome is more or less what you could have expected 1 month ago. A reduced majority but nothing threatening.
A better Labour candidate could have gave them more a run for their money trying to turn their table on them. Maybe.
What else would you expect in the face of the UKIP surge, Andrea?
"Willie Young is the candidate. Makes me feel like they're not going all out to win."
On May 8th, he started his campaign with this gem
http://news.stv.tv/north/224503-labours-willie-young-refuses-to-say-party-would-reverse-college-cuts/
When @thesnp got a 9% swing in Inverclyde by-election, Labour said 'the SNP bandwagon had ground to a halt'!
Lab 33.31
LD 8.29
Con 7.66
UKIP 4.8
Greens 1.7
National Front 1
Christians 0.9
SDA 0.14
good night
What?
Anas says it's a great result for #SLab, but sounds like his dog just died.
Labour's psychology - they say they never expected to win tonight. Contrast with @theSNP approach in 07 or Glasgow East.
Shadsy: I keep suggesting interesting markets. Where are you? Are you frit?
Yes 34%
No 29%
http://news.stv.tv/politics/230185-ukips-christopher-monckton-in-alex-salmond-expelled-from-labour-gaffe/