I think this is a really good point. I am gender critical - I don't believe a man can become a woman, even with hormones and surgery etc. Others will disagree. How that plays out at the BBC is a conc… (View Post)

I don't want to go into a lot of details and people will probably bridle because Steve Macintyre is someone who attracts abuse. But with Ross Mckitrick they analysed a lot of Mann's papers around the… (View Post)

I don't think its the BBC its the nexus of science reporters and University Press Officers. The Uni press office likes to push interesting stories that the press will pick up. Stories such as "C… (View Post)

One of the biggest issues I had with Mann and his colleagues was a refusal to share data. In chemistry we are required to make data available when we publish. This should be standard but at the time … (View Post)

See - this is exactly why I didn't want to go into it. Have you seriously looked at Mckitrick and Macintyre's criticism? Because if you do you may be surprised. Do you think data should be open to be… (View Post)