Thing is, B has picked an apple from his bag of 4 *at random* and it was good. A has looked at all 3 and on that basis has made his "at least one is good" statement. There is a difference t… (View Post)

I had it like that at first - but when you factor in that B picked one *at random* and it was good this changes things. And the puzzle setter agrees, I now see. ProRata wins the sports car and the we… (View Post)

I think it is because he picked one at random from his 4. That is a more powerful "at least one is good" attribute compared to looking at all 4 and then making the (true) statement. The rem… (View Post)

Thornberry's London-ness is a major handicap. I doubt she'll win. (View Post)

Well Farage states many things. Eg that he'd bought the house. (View Post)