BannedinnParis

Moffat's weakness is that he thinks the questions/mysteries are interesting in and of themselves. Which is true - not knowing anything before the moment the Dr steps foot into a faulty TARDIS is infi… (View Post)

Of course its a matter of tastes but, for example, Kill the Moon is really good and atmospheric for maybe the first 3/4 but has a truly bizarre ending. (View Post)

Targets and audio, I'm afraid. There's a random episode in Web of Fear made up of audio and snap shots, which really jars. A comedy in which nearly everybody dies ... Comedy is 'a space helmet for a … (View Post)

Harsh, think the Capaldi stuff is generally good (no really bad episodes) and the very last season is excellent. (View Post)

He's responsible for The Massacre, which is one of the very darkest themed episodes, missing and also relies on William Hartnell playing two roles slightly differently. I've only really caught up Har… (View Post)