Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

It’s a stunning performance by Reform – politicalbetting.com

SystemSystem Posts: 12,447
edited May 2 in General
It’s a stunning performance by Reform – politicalbetting.com

We’re just under halfway through all the councils declaring and so far it is a stunning performance by Reform. Nigel Farage must feel like Napoleon after the Battle of Austerlitz.

Read the full story here

«134567

Comments

  • nico67nico67 Posts: 5,245
    Yes stunning that the pandemic of idiocy has now spread to these shores.
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 65,689
    First. Stop the counting.
  • tlg86tlg86 Posts: 26,567
    What's curious is just how unimportant Trump is over here. Or maybe Reform would be doing even better if Farage wasn't associated with the orange one.
  • Pro_RataPro_Rata Posts: 5,579
    An array of stunning..... performances
  • Peter_the_PunterPeter_the_Punter Posts: 14,693
    Gloucestershire final: LDs one seat short of an 'overall'.

    Lib Dem - 27 - +11
    Reform 11 - +11
    Green 9 - +5
    Conservative 6 - 20
    Labour 1 - -3
    Independent 1 - -1
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 79,328
    From Womborne to Grimsby

    We are now woke free.
  • TazTaz Posts: 17,844

    Gloucestershire final: LDs one seat short of an 'overall'.

    Lib Dem - 27 - +11
    Reform 11 - +11
    Green 9 - +5
    Conservative 6 - 20
    Labour 1 - -3
    Independent 1 - -1

    LD-Green coalition then.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 79,328

    Gloucestershire final: LDs one seat short of an 'overall'.

    Lib Dem - 27 - +11
    Reform 11 - +11
    Green 9 - +5
    Conservative 6 - 20
    Labour 1 - -3
    Independent 1 - -1

    Massive NIMBY majority.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 60,093
    edited May 2
    tlg86 said:

    What's curious is just how unimportant Trump is over here. Or maybe Reform would be doing even better if Farage wasn't associated with the orange one.

    Yeah, that's a crucal observation. Trump is having zero effect on Reform's popularity

    So it was just the 51st state nonsense that did for Piolievrioerivre
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 34,569
    The most surprising thing about these results for me isn't that RefUK are winning working-class areas, it's that they're also winning quite a few posh middle-class areas as well such as Arden in Warwickshire.

    https://apps.warwickshire.gov.uk/ElectionResults/elections/2025/areas/Arden
  • nico67nico67 Posts: 5,245
    tlg86 said:

    What's curious is just how unimportant Trump is over here. Or maybe Reform would be doing even better if Farage wasn't associated with the orange one.

    The media have failed to nail him on this and Labour and the Tories are too frightened to talk about it .

    Congrats to all the Reform voters and their so called patriotism. Voting for a Putin fan and Trump arselicker.
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 34,569
    tlg86 said:

    What's curious is just how unimportant Trump is over here. Or maybe Reform would be doing even better if Farage wasn't associated with the orange one.

    Maybe it's more that Canada is a special case.
  • MattWMattW Posts: 26,856
    One area that needs attention is what impact, if any, there will be on Council reorganisation.

    I'm going to have to recover some Reform flyers from the recycling pile.

    It's good job I haven't shredded it yet.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 60,093
    Reform now on 484

    They have won 7 councils, 5 are NOC, no other party has won a council, yet

    Mind-blowing
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 65,689
    MattW said:

    One area that needs attention is what impact, if any, there will be on Council reorganisation.

    I'm going to have to recover some Reform flyers from the recycling pile.

    It's good job I haven't shredded it yet.

    v good question.
  • FossFoss Posts: 1,438
    Andy_JS said:

    The most surprising thing about these results for me isn't that RefUK are winning working-class areas, it's that they're also winning quite a few posh middle-class areas as well such as Arden in Warwickshire.

    https://apps.warwickshire.gov.uk/ElectionResults/elections/2025/areas/Arden

    Some of that will be the 'We don't want to end up like Birmingham' vote.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 53,817
    nico67 said:

    Yes stunning that the pandemic of idiocy has now spread to these shores.

    SORE-LOSERMAN.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 60,093
    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly
  • DopermeanDopermean Posts: 970
    So Betfair market is year "next permanent leader", anyone think Kemi will resign or is laying 2025 value?
  • isamisam Posts: 41,394
    Leon said:

    Reform now on 484

    They have won 7 councils, 5 are NOC, no other party has won a council, yet

    Mind-blowing

    Not ‘anaemic’?
  • LeonLeon Posts: 60,093
    edited May 2
    isam said:

    Leon said:

    Reform now on 484

    They have won 7 councils, 5 are NOC, no other party has won a council, yet

    Mind-blowing

    Not ‘anaemic’?
    I'm waiting for @Scott_xP to explain how this shows, yet again, what a lightweight idiot Nigel Farage is
  • EabhalEabhal Posts: 10,246
    edited May 2
    tlg86 said:

    What's curious is just how unimportant Trump is over here. Or maybe Reform would be doing even better if Farage wasn't associated with the orange one.

    In Canada the Trump effect was to stimulate tactical voting on the left, not a collapse in the right-wing vote.

    Given Reform look increasingly likely to form the main opposition, I think we should start to think about a similar effect in the UK. Looking very good for the Lib Dems in the rural south of England.
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 79,328
    Kemi surely in the most trouble short term ?

    Starmer is PM with a huge majority no matter how shaky his locals base is. Badenoch has lost 456 out of 645 councillors declared so far. In opposition !

    Disaster doesn't begin to cover it.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 127,267
    edited May 2
    Andy_JS said:

    tlg86 said:

    What's curious is just how unimportant Trump is over here. Or maybe Reform would be doing even better if Farage wasn't associated with the orange one.

    Maybe it's more that Canada is a special case.
    The Conservatives in Canada (a merged party of their Tories and Reform) still got over 40% of the vote, it was tactical voting by the NDP for the Liberals that won it for them.

    Hence at the moment at looks like Farage is heading for PM with Reform winning most seats at the next general election unless LD and Green voters in particular tactically vote on a massive scale for Labour MPs
  • MattWMattW Posts: 26,856
    FPT:
    Eabhal said:

    nico67 said:

    So Reform haven’t got a clue and have duped the gullible. Apparently they’ll start with cutting traffic calming measures so more people can end up as roadkill .

    This will be the most interesting bit for me. Whenever there is outrage over something like 20mph, speed bumps, LTNs etc, it's quickly forgotten when it's outside your school, your house. That's why you get the fun of councillors in Wales finding it very difficult to find any roads to revert to 30mph.

    Local government is micro enough for Reform councillors to have to deal with constant complaints about crap driving around playgrounds and so on. How will they react?
    I'm not sure where RefUK stand on this, especially locally.

    I've heard a fair bit of windy knee jerking, but they about to discover a lot of constraints that they did not perhaps know existed - except perhaps in the knowledge of defecting Councillors.

    LTNs may be like the standard rhetoric - the people demanding that LTNs not be introduced tend to be those who live in them at home (ie on anything built since 1960) and want to rat-run through other people's communities.
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,184
    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
  • RochdalePioneersRochdalePioneers Posts: 29,961
    tlg86 said:

    What's curious is just how unimportant Trump is over here. Or maybe Reform would be doing even better if Farage wasn't associated with the orange one.

    If Trump was threatening to invade as he is Canada then maybe it would be an issue. As he is not the election is about people being utterly fed up with their lot and what they see as useless politicians of red and blue.

    Don't tell anyone, but DOGE is actually pretty well liked by a lot of people in the UK. With obvious gazillions being wasted or spent on Other People, the idea of taxing an axe to stop that spend is seen as a good idea...
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 121,770
    Pulpstar said:

    Kemi surely in the most trouble short term ?

    Starmer is PM with a huge majority no matter how shaky his locals base is. Badenoch has lost 456 out of 645 councillors declared so far. In opposition !

    Disaster doesn't begin to cover it.

    Judging by my WhatsApps it’s going to be a Bobby J coronation.
  • nico67nico67 Posts: 5,245
    The official opposition are supposed to clean up in local elections . So it’s been a dreadful set of results for the Tories.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 60,093
    edited May 2

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 65,689
    The worst of it is going to be the endless crowing from Goodwin.

  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,588
    My two take aways:

    (1)
    The challenge the Conservatives face was well described on the last thread: how do they simultaneously appeal to those they have lost to Reform, and those they have lost to the Liberal Democrats.

    It is clear that they have to tack right: but if they do that, how do they even begin to differentiate themselves from Reform, especially as all Reform needs to do is to attack them for their previous period in government?

    (2)
    The fragmentation of voting patterns is on a scale we've never seen before. Reform is winning close to half of all councillors. But it's doing in on an National Equivalent Vote share that is only a few point more than the LibDems managed in 2009.

    We see this is the Mayoral elections: winning parties are coming in with sub 30% numbers. We could see MPs - multiple MPs - elected with less than a quarter of the vote in 2029.
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,944
    Pulpstar said:

    From Womborne to Grimsby

    We are now woke free.

    It's spelled Wombourne.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,588
    edited May 2
    Andy_JS said:

    tlg86 said:

    What's curious is just how unimportant Trump is over here. Or maybe Reform would be doing even better if Farage wasn't associated with the orange one.

    Maybe it's more that Canada is a special case.
    It's also the fact that Trump is threatening to take over Canada. If Trump was threatening the sovereignty of the United Kingdom, he'd be a much bigger deal here too.
  • Richard_TyndallRichard_Tyndall Posts: 33,292
    So on face value we currently have:

    Reform majority councils

    Derbyshire
    Durham
    Kent
    Lancashire
    Lincolnshire
    Nottinghamshire
    Staffordshire

    Reform largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Tories to join them.

    Leicestershire
    Warwickshire
    Worcestershire

    Tory largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade Reform to join them.

    Northumberland

    Lib Dem largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Greens to join them.

    Devon
    Gloucestershire

    I expect Cambridgeshire to go Lib Dem overall majority. The others I don't really know yet. Some are VERY late in starting counting.
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 65,689
    Tories all but wiped out in Kent.

  • nico67nico67 Posts: 5,245
    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
  • DM_AndyDM_Andy Posts: 1,346
    How on earth does Rallings & Trasher work out a National Equivalent Vote out of these results?
  • rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 65,689
    Chris said:

    Pulpstar said:

    From Womborne to Grimsby

    We are now woke free.

    It's spelled Wombourne.
    Womb? Womb? You can't use that word. So trans aggressive. or something...
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 127,267
    rcs1000 said:

    My two take aways:

    (1)
    The challenge the Conservatives face was well described on the last thread: how do they simultaneously appeal to those they have lost to Reform, and those they have lost to the Liberal Democrats.

    It is clear that they have to tack right: but if they do that, how do they even begin to differentiate themselves from Reform, especially as all Reform needs to do is to attack them for their previous period in government?

    (2)
    The fragmentation of voting patterns is on a scale we've never seen before. Reform is winning close to half of all councillors. But it's doing in on an National Equivalent Vote share that is only a few point more than the LibDems managed in 2009.

    We see this is the Mayoral elections: winning parties are coming in with sub 30% numbers. We could see MPs - multiple MPs - elected with less than a quarter of the vote in 2029.

    At the moment it looks like either Farage becomes PM at the next GE, in which case if we stay under FPTP the Tories will probably end up merging with Reform like their Canadian cousins did with a few moving to the LDs. Only PR would likely make the Tories viable as an independent party in such a scenario.

    Or Labour wins again, probably narrowly as a minority government with LD, SNP and Green support, Farage fails for a second time to become PM and defeat the Labour Party and the Conservatives elect a leader like Jenrick who can win back rightwing voters who have gone to Reform who want to beat Labour
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,588
    On the subject of Trump: don't forget that a quarter of Brits are fans of his. So, while being seen as being close to Trump may make it difficult for Reform to get to 40%, it doesn't harm them in getting to 25-30%.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 60,093

    Pulpstar said:

    Kemi surely in the most trouble short term ?

    Starmer is PM with a huge majority no matter how shaky his locals base is. Badenoch has lost 456 out of 645 councillors declared so far. In opposition !

    Disaster doesn't begin to cover it.

    Judging by my WhatsApps it’s going to be a Bobby J coronation.
    I've been saying this for a while. Bobby J has cullions and brains, he's a ruthless bastard but - frankly - the Tories need that

    I can see him duffing up Starmer at PMQs quite easily - hs speaks pretty well, and to the point; he is also really good at using social media, as I noted months ago

    Bobby J is the only hope, now. And he will probably have to seek an alliance with Farage, nonetheless

    If the Tories tack left they are utterly doomed, if they tack right they might still be doomed, but they will have a chance of surviving - perhaps via a long term merger with Reform

    And on that ecumenical note, I am off to the shops to buy picnicky things for Regents Park
  • IcarusIcarus Posts: 1,006
    "Nigel Farage must feel like Napoleon after the Battle of Austerlitz." Does St Helena need a new Governor General??

  • carnforthcarnforth Posts: 5,799
    Pulpstar said:

    Kemi surely in the most trouble short term ?

    Starmer is PM with a huge majority no matter how shaky his locals base is. Badenoch has lost 456 out of 645 councillors declared so far. In opposition !

    Disaster doesn't begin to cover it.

    Worth pointing out though that, for many years, the tories were gaining council seats whilst in government - a similarly unusual thing.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,588

    So on face value we currently have:

    Reform majority councils

    Derbyshire
    Durham
    Kent
    Lancashire
    Lincolnshire
    Nottinghamshire
    Staffordshire

    Reform largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Tories to join them.

    Leicestershire
    Warwickshire
    Worcestershire

    Tory largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade Reform to join them.

    Northumberland

    Lib Dem largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Greens to join them.

    Devon
    Gloucestershire

    I expect Cambridgeshire to go Lib Dem overall majority. The others I don't really know yet. Some are VERY late in starting counting.

    Effectively, it's 10 Reform councils, 3 LibDem ones, and a solitary Conservative one.
  • Sunil_PrasannanSunil_Prasannan Posts: 53,817
    edited May 2

    Tories all but wiped out in Kent.

    Oh dear, what a shame, never mind.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,270

    So on face value we currently have:

    Reform majority councils

    Derbyshire
    Durham
    Kent
    Lancashire
    Lincolnshire
    Nottinghamshire
    Staffordshire

    Reform largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Tories to join them.

    Leicestershire
    Warwickshire
    Worcestershire

    Tory largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade Reform to join them.

    Northumberland

    Lib Dem largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Greens to join them.

    Devon
    Gloucestershire

    I expect Cambridgeshire to go Lib Dem overall majority. The others I don't really know yet. Some are VERY late in starting counting.

    Cambs would be done were it not for the peculiar slowness of the city. With Labour having such a bad night, surely the LibDems will regain enough of wards they’ve held in the past there, to capture the whole county.
  • Smart51Smart51 Posts: 72
    There's no point in replacing Kemi now with whoever is next out of the same mould. They need to wait for a good leader, then replace Kemi. They need to do that quickly.
  • david_herdsondavid_herdson Posts: 18,229
    The changing of the guard at such pace also means a huge loss of institutional memory and a lot of newbies with no experience taking up responsible roles. Look at Kent, for example, a Reform gain:

    After 55 of 81 seats, the scores are Reform 40 (+40), LD 11 (+7), Lab 2 (-2), Con 1 (-42), Grn 1 (-1).

    (yes, 40 isn't quite half of 81 but apparently they have got a 41st; it's just not added in yet - I've not included it as other parties may have wins too).

    So that's *at least* 51 out of 58 novices, including the leader and all cabinet members (or equivalent, if they have committees). There will need to be some fast learners.
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,588
    Leon said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Kemi surely in the most trouble short term ?

    Starmer is PM with a huge majority no matter how shaky his locals base is. Badenoch has lost 456 out of 645 councillors declared so far. In opposition !

    Disaster doesn't begin to cover it.

    Judging by my WhatsApps it’s going to be a Bobby J coronation.
    I've been saying this for a while. Bobby J has cullions and brains, he's a ruthless bastard but - frankly - the Tories need that

    I can see him duffing up Starmer at PMQs quite easily - hs speaks pretty well, and to the point; he is also really good at using social media, as I noted months ago

    Bobby J is the only hope, now. And he will probably have to seek an alliance with Farage, nonetheless

    If the Tories tack left they are utterly doomed, if they tack right they might still be doomed, but they will have a chance of surviving - perhaps via a long term merger with Reform

    And on that ecumenical note, I am off to the shops to buy picnicky things for Regents Park
    What's in it for Reform to do a deal with the Conservatives?
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,270
    So is Angela really going to press ahead and create a whole new tranche of mayors for Reform to win, next year?
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,184
    rcs1000 said:

    My two take aways:

    (1)
    The challenge the Conservatives face was well described on the last thread: how do they simultaneously appeal to those they have lost to Reform, and those they have lost to the Liberal Democrats.

    It is clear that they have to tack right: but if they do that, how do they even begin to differentiate themselves from Reform, especially as all Reform needs to do is to attack them for their previous period in government?

    (2)
    The fragmentation of voting patterns is on a scale we've never seen before. Reform is winning close to half of all councillors. But it's doing in on an National Equivalent Vote share that is only a few point more than the LibDems managed in 2009.

    We see this is the Mayoral elections: winning parties are coming in with sub 30% numbers. We could see MPs - multiple MPs - elected with less than a quarter of the vote in 2029.

    In 2017 we had a dramatic reversal of the trend towards fragmentation of the vote, because voters felt the outcome was more consequential than at previous elections.

    The potential of a Reform victory at the next GE may similarly concentrate minds, and concentrate votes.
  • TazTaz Posts: 17,844
    So Lib Dem’s now official oppostion on Durham council. As much as I dislike them I was pleased to see Craig Martin win for them in North Lodge. He’s been a good local councillor for a nice ward.
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 34,569

    The worst of it is going to be the endless crowing from Goodwin.

    Well he was right wasn't he?
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,628

    So on face value we currently have:

    Reform majority councils

    Derbyshire
    Durham
    Kent
    Lancashire
    Lincolnshire
    Nottinghamshire
    Staffordshire

    Reform largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Tories to join them.

    Leicestershire
    Warwickshire
    Worcestershire

    Tory largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade Reform to join them.

    Northumberland

    Lib Dem largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Greens to join them.

    Devon
    Gloucestershire

    I expect Cambridgeshire to go Lib Dem overall majority. The others I don't really know yet. Some are VERY late in starting counting.

    Hertfordshire looks like Lib Dem largest party, but Con and Ref having a majority between them.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 60,093
    rcs1000 said:

    Leon said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Kemi surely in the most trouble short term ?

    Starmer is PM with a huge majority no matter how shaky his locals base is. Badenoch has lost 456 out of 645 councillors declared so far. In opposition !

    Disaster doesn't begin to cover it.

    Judging by my WhatsApps it’s going to be a Bobby J coronation.
    I've been saying this for a while. Bobby J has cullions and brains, he's a ruthless bastard but - frankly - the Tories need that

    I can see him duffing up Starmer at PMQs quite easily - hs speaks pretty well, and to the point; he is also really good at using social media, as I noted months ago

    Bobby J is the only hope, now. And he will probably have to seek an alliance with Farage, nonetheless

    If the Tories tack left they are utterly doomed, if they tack right they might still be doomed, but they will have a chance of surviving - perhaps via a long term merger with Reform

    And on that ecumenical note, I am off to the shops to buy picnicky things for Regents Park
    What's in it for Reform to do a deal with the Conservatives?
    Infrastructure, donors, history, credibility
  • Dura_AceDura_Ace Posts: 14,369
    nico67 said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
    Hopefully the 40 x Silk Cut/day will put an actual cancer on him soon.
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 65,082
    Good afternoon

    Stunning success for Farage snd Reform as the two big parties collapse to approx 38% of the vote according to Sky

    I have no idea how Kemi or the conservatives regain these lost votes but not sure sacking her will make any difference

    Sky saying shades of Brexit vote, and certainly we are seeing Reform voters classed as unintelligent and a disgrace whilst failing to recognize that if you do not help voters with their day to day lives and thrust policies on them.then they will vote accordingly

    I expect immigration and the boats together with net zero to become Reform's main agenda and I am not sure they are of the right as they support nationalisation and making millionaires pay to use the NHS whilst keeping it free to most

    One thing I have always accepted that change happens, and certainly I am more intrigued than dismayed with this dramatic change
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,270
    edited May 2
    rcs1000 said:

    Leon said:

    Pulpstar said:

    Kemi surely in the most trouble short term ?

    Starmer is PM with a huge majority no matter how shaky his locals base is. Badenoch has lost 456 out of 645 councillors declared so far. In opposition !

    Disaster doesn't begin to cover it.

    Judging by my WhatsApps it’s going to be a Bobby J coronation.
    I've been saying this for a while. Bobby J has cullions and brains, he's a ruthless bastard but - frankly - the Tories need that

    I can see him duffing up Starmer at PMQs quite easily - hs speaks pretty well, and to the point; he is also really good at using social media, as I noted months ago

    Bobby J is the only hope, now. And he will probably have to seek an alliance with Farage, nonetheless

    If the Tories tack left they are utterly doomed, if they tack right they might still be doomed, but they will have a chance of surviving - perhaps via a long term merger with Reform

    And on that ecumenical note, I am off to the shops to buy picnicky things for Regents Park
    What's in it for Reform to do a deal with the Conservatives?
    that the Tories lose another tranche of voters preferring to vote for the real thing and another tranche who are unwilling even to vote for the pale imitation.

    that the Tories might face the curse of being the junior alliance/coalition partner, and the electoral consequences that will follow, would be the ultimate KARMA in capital letters….
  • rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 59,588

    rcs1000 said:

    My two take aways:

    (1)
    The challenge the Conservatives face was well described on the last thread: how do they simultaneously appeal to those they have lost to Reform, and those they have lost to the Liberal Democrats.

    It is clear that they have to tack right: but if they do that, how do they even begin to differentiate themselves from Reform, especially as all Reform needs to do is to attack them for their previous period in government?

    (2)
    The fragmentation of voting patterns is on a scale we've never seen before. Reform is winning close to half of all councillors. But it's doing in on an National Equivalent Vote share that is only a few point more than the LibDems managed in 2009.

    We see this is the Mayoral elections: winning parties are coming in with sub 30% numbers. We could see MPs - multiple MPs - elected with less than a quarter of the vote in 2029.

    In 2017 we had a dramatic reversal of the trend towards fragmentation of the vote, because voters felt the outcome was more consequential than at previous elections.

    The potential of a Reform victory at the next GE may similarly concentrate minds, and concentrate votes.
    This is very true.

    And it's the big issue Reform faces: are the voters of the other parties willing to gang up on you?

    In Scotland in 1997, where it was the Conservatives who were ganged up on; or Scotland in 2024, where it was the SNP, you can see the extraordinary disproportionate nature of FPTP where there is a lot of tactical voting.

    I would argue that we saw that to some extent in the Runcorn byelection. The Labour vote held up remarkably well thanks to tactical voting.

    With that said...

    The advantage that Reform has is that -in the current highly fragmented world- who do you vote for if you want to stop Reform?
  • PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 79,328
    Dura_Ace said:

    nico67 said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
    Hopefully the 40 x Silk Cut/day will put an actual cancer on him soon.
    Do you remember Boris' ratings when he got covid ?
  • LeonLeon Posts: 60,093
    nico67 said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
    Which is fine and understandable

    The people I’m mocking are the PBers who continually insist Farage is useless at politics, “he never won a seat in the commons” - oops - “he just got lucky”, he was “nothing to do with brexit winning”

    People like @Nigel_Foremain and @Scott_P snd many many others
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 121,770
    Icarus said:

    "Nigel Farage must feel like Napoleon after the Battle of Austerlitz." Does St Helena need a new Governor General??

    Hopefully.
  • BurgessianBurgessian Posts: 2,993

    The changing of the guard at such pace also means a huge loss of institutional memory and a lot of newbies with no experience taking up responsible roles. Look at Kent, for example, a Reform gain:

    After 55 of 81 seats, the scores are Reform 40 (+40), LD 11 (+7), Lab 2 (-2), Con 1 (-42), Grn 1 (-1).

    (yes, 40 isn't quite half of 81 but apparently they have got a 41st; it's just not added in yet - I've not included it as other parties may have wins too).

    So that's *at least* 51 out of 58 novices, including the leader and all cabinet members (or equivalent, if they have committees). There will need to be some fast learners.

    My second-hand experience of council politics is that a lot of elected councillors prove to be pretty unbiddable, and that's with members of established parties, with local party apparatuses, and a degree of discipline.

    My small knowledge of RefUK wannabe politicians is that they are, ahem, likely to prove even more challenging to manage.

    Well, we'll soon see, once the glow of triumph has dissipated and the work of actual administration begins.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,270
    Leon said:

    nico67 said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
    Which is fine and understandable

    The people I’m mocking are the PBers who continually insist Farage is useless at politics, “he never won a seat in the commons” - oops - “he just got lucky”, he was “nothing to do with brexit winning”

    People like @Nigel_Foremain and @Scott_P snd many many others
    Being a useless chancer isn’t incompatible with persuasively selling a lot of folk some snake oil. Indeed there’s a considerable overlap in the skills required.
  • TazTaz Posts: 17,844
    rcs1000 said:

    So on face value we currently have:

    Reform majority councils

    Derbyshire
    Durham
    Kent
    Lancashire
    Lincolnshire
    Nottinghamshire
    Staffordshire

    Reform largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Tories to join them.

    Leicestershire
    Warwickshire
    Worcestershire

    Tory largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade Reform to join them.

    Northumberland

    Lib Dem largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Greens to join them.

    Devon
    Gloucestershire

    I expect Cambridgeshire to go Lib Dem overall majority. The others I don't really know yet. Some are VERY late in starting counting.

    Effectively, it's 10 Reform councils, 3 LibDem ones, and a solitary Conservative one.
    When you view it in those terms it is, as Heathener would say, an absolute shellacking.

  • david_herdsondavid_herdson Posts: 18,229
    edited May 2
    FWIW, my scores on the doors, out of ten.

    Reform: 9.8

    Council results beyond their wildest dreams, and a win in Runcorn, no matter how narrow. At least one and probably two mayors as well. It could have been even better, they missed out on three more mayors by fractions, but they have delivered a revolution.

    Lib Dems: 6.5

    Very solid set of council results, though will be disappointed to miss Devon. Other opportunities still in the bag though. Also disappointing if they've missed out on the target Hull & E Riding mayoralty.

    Green: 6

    Similar to the Lib Dems. Another advance across council chamber but missing the bigger prizes, including the West of England mayor, for which they had been favourites.

    Labour: 1.5

    Catastrophic. Down two-thirds in councillors and dicing with the Greens for fourth place (of fifth, if you count independents), which is awful even allowing for the notionally Con/LD-friendly round of elections. The only bright spark was holding three mayoralties (just) - though even that could be a mixed blessing if they become straws to be grasped.

    Tories: 0.5

    Extinction level event. This is probably what the Liberals felt like in 1918. Half a point for winning the Cambs mayor, against which the caveat noted on Labour also applies.
  • EabhalEabhal Posts: 10,246
    MattW said:

    FPT:

    Eabhal said:

    nico67 said:

    So Reform haven’t got a clue and have duped the gullible. Apparently they’ll start with cutting traffic calming measures so more people can end up as roadkill .

    This will be the most interesting bit for me. Whenever there is outrage over something like 20mph, speed bumps, LTNs etc, it's quickly forgotten when it's outside your school, your house. That's why you get the fun of councillors in Wales finding it very difficult to find any roads to revert to 30mph.

    Local government is micro enough for Reform councillors to have to deal with constant complaints about crap driving around playgrounds and so on. How will they react?
    I'm not sure where RefUK stand on this, especially locally.

    I've heard a fair bit of windy knee jerking, but they about to discover a lot of constraints that they did not perhaps know existed - except perhaps in the knowledge of defecting Councillors.

    LTNs may be like the standard rhetoric - the people demanding that LTNs not be introduced tend to be those who live in them at home (ie on anything built since 1960) and want to rat-run through other people's communities.
    At the election they pledged to ban LTNs, which would involve building roads between all housing estates and run into £10s of billions.
  • CookieCookie Posts: 14,921
    IanB2 said:

    Leon said:

    nico67 said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
    Which is fine and understandable

    The people I’m mocking are the PBers who continually insist Farage is useless at politics, “he never won a seat in the commons” - oops - “he just got lucky”, he was “nothing to do with brexit winning”

    People like @Nigel_Foremain and @Scott_P snd many many others
    Being a useless chancer isn’t incompatible with persuasively selling a lot of folk some snake oil. Indeed there’s a considerable overlap in the skills required.
    I think it's the word 'useless' which I'd question, given where he's got to.
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,184
    rcs1000 said:

    rcs1000 said:

    My two take aways:

    (1)
    The challenge the Conservatives face was well described on the last thread: how do they simultaneously appeal to those they have lost to Reform, and those they have lost to the Liberal Democrats.

    It is clear that they have to tack right: but if they do that, how do they even begin to differentiate themselves from Reform, especially as all Reform needs to do is to attack them for their previous period in government?

    (2)
    The fragmentation of voting patterns is on a scale we've never seen before. Reform is winning close to half of all councillors. But it's doing in on an National Equivalent Vote share that is only a few point more than the LibDems managed in 2009.

    We see this is the Mayoral elections: winning parties are coming in with sub 30% numbers. We could see MPs - multiple MPs - elected with less than a quarter of the vote in 2029.

    In 2017 we had a dramatic reversal of the trend towards fragmentation of the vote, because voters felt the outcome was more consequential than at previous elections.

    The potential of a Reform victory at the next GE may similarly concentrate minds, and concentrate votes.
    This is very true.

    And it's the big issue Reform faces: are the voters of the other parties willing to gang up on you?

    In Scotland in 1997, where it was the Conservatives who were ganged up on; or Scotland in 2024, where it was the SNP, you can see the extraordinary disproportionate nature of FPTP where there is a lot of tactical voting.

    I would argue that we saw that to some extent in the Runcorn byelection. The Labour vote held up remarkably well thanks to tactical voting.

    With that said...

    The advantage that Reform has is that -in the current highly fragmented world- who do you vote for if you want to stop Reform?
    Yes. There's also the difficulty that the obvious answer at a GE is Labour, and for many reasons a lot of people will be reluctant to vote for the incumbent government.

    This is why I was going to add to my post that the Lib Dems may come to see GE2024 as a missed opportunity. If they'd eclipsed the Tories to become the official opposition they would have been better placed to convince voters to vote Lib Dem to stop Reform, even in seats currently held by Labour.
  • TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 121,770

    FWIW, my scores on the doors, out of ten.

    Reform: 9.8

    Council results beyond their wildest dreams, and a win in Runcorn, no matter how narrow. At least one and probably two mayors as well. It could have been even better, they missed out on three more mayors by fractions, but they have delivered a revolution.

    Lib Dems: 6.5

    Very solid set of council results, though will be disappointed to miss Devon. Other opportunities still in the bag though. Also disappointing if they've missed out on the target Hull & E Riding mayoralty.

    Green: 6

    Similar to the Lib Dems. Another advance across council chamber but missing the bigger prizes, including the West of England mayor, for which they had been favourites.

    Labour: 1.5

    Catastrophic. Down two-thirds in councillors and dicing with the Greens for fourth place (of fifth, if you count independents), which is awful even allowing for the notionally Con/LD-friendly round of elections. The only bright spark was holding three mayoralties (just) - though even that could be a mixed blessing if they become straws to be grasped.

    Tories: 0.5

    Extinction level event. This is probably what the Liberals felt like in 1918. Half a point for winning the Cambs mayor, against which the caveat noted on Labour also applies.

    As I’ve said a few times

    Kemi Badenoch = Herbert Samuel.
  • RochdalePioneersRochdalePioneers Posts: 29,961
    rcs1000 said:

    My two take aways:

    (1)
    The challenge the Conservatives face was well described on the last thread: how do they simultaneously appeal to those they have lost to Reform, and those they have lost to the Liberal Democrats.

    It is clear that they have to tack right: but if they do that, how do they even begin to differentiate themselves from Reform, especially as all Reform needs to do is to attack them for their previous period in government?

    (2)
    The fragmentation of voting patterns is on a scale we've never seen before. Reform is winning close to half of all councillors. But it's doing in on an National Equivalent Vote share that is only a few point more than the LibDems managed in 2009.

    We see this is the Mayoral elections: winning parties are coming in with sub 30% numbers. We could see MPs - multiple MPs - elected with less than a quarter of the vote in 2029.

    Reform are a political Black Hole. A Nigel-sized singularity which is now sucking everything else towards it.

    Whilst there is a major challenge for the Tories as described, the gravitational challenge for Labour is just as existential.

    What is at the heart of the Black Hole? The need to significantly reform the UK from top to bottom. Labour and the Tories can't tack their way around the edges of the event horizon - they'll get torn apart. Their only solution is to become a bigger black hole.

    How do you defeat populism? By fixing the problems that drive populism. In this country that means fixing public services, making work pay, putting the pride back into our communities. You can't do that by cutting WFA or scrapping HS2 or performative tossery about penises.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,270

    The changing of the guard at such pace also means a huge loss of institutional memory and a lot of newbies with no experience taking up responsible roles. Look at Kent, for example, a Reform gain:

    After 55 of 81 seats, the scores are Reform 40 (+40), LD 11 (+7), Lab 2 (-2), Con 1 (-42), Grn 1 (-1).

    (yes, 40 isn't quite half of 81 but apparently they have got a 41st; it's just not added in yet - I've not included it as other parties may have wins too).

    So that's *at least* 51 out of 58 novices, including the leader and all cabinet members (or equivalent, if they have committees). There will need to be some fast learners.

    My second-hand experience of council politics is that a lot of elected councillors prove to be pretty unbiddable, and that's with members of established parties, with local party apparatuses, and a degree of discipline.

    My small knowledge of RefUK wannabe politicians is that they are, ahem, likely to prove even more challenging to manage.

    Well, we'll soon see, once the glow of triumph has dissipated and the work of actual administration begins.
    To be an effective council group, and hence an effective administration (or opposition) needs a few people with the necessary knowledge and skills who are able to take the rest of their colleagues - many of whom, regardless of party, will be dead weights in the chamber - along with them. Whether Reform’s new council groups sink or swim depends most heavily on the calibre of their local leadership teams - assuming of course that they have such, and aren’t merely a bunch of folks elected at random.
  • carnforthcarnforth Posts: 5,799
    Britain wins sand eel dispute:

    https://www.politico.eu/article/brexit-britain-sand-eel-safe-haven-fishing-environment-protection-europe-legislation/

    Notable because it's the first big arbitration under the UK-EU brexit agreements.
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 34,635

    The changing of the guard at such pace also means a huge loss of institutional memory and a lot of newbies with no experience taking up responsible roles. Look at Kent, for example, a Reform gain:

    After 55 of 81 seats, the scores are Reform 40 (+40), LD 11 (+7), Lab 2 (-2), Con 1 (-42), Grn 1 (-1).

    (yes, 40 isn't quite half of 81 but apparently they have got a 41st; it's just not added in yet - I've not included it as other parties may have wins too).

    So that's *at least* 51 out of 58 novices, including the leader and all cabinet members (or equivalent, if they have committees). There will need to be some fast learners.

    It won't be the only county like that. Someone posted the results from, IIRC, Devon, showing an enormous proportion of new councillors.
    Going to be very difficult for the Officers.
  • ChrisChris Posts: 11,944
    Given that (on the BBC's latest figures) both the Tories and Labour have lost about 70% net of the seats they were defending, it's rather remarkable that the net changes in councillors for Ref+Con and Lab+LD+Grn are just +4% and -2% respectively.
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 34,569
    edited May 2
    A suboptimal day/night for Rupert Lowe MP.
  • MattWMattW Posts: 26,856
    edited May 2
    This is a pledge card from Reform UK Nott's Facebook page from last summer.

    You want to know how decayed they are upstairs? Try this.

    Take just one - how will NHS Waiting Lists be "zeroed" with all the other pledges?



    I've asked them for details of the policies they plan to implement. Let's see what they say.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 51,270
    Cookie said:

    IanB2 said:

    Leon said:

    nico67 said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
    Which is fine and understandable

    The people I’m mocking are the PBers who continually insist Farage is useless at politics, “he never won a seat in the commons” - oops - “he just got lucky”, he was “nothing to do with brexit winning”

    People like @Nigel_Foremain and @Scott_P snd many many others
    Being a useless chancer isn’t incompatible with persuasively selling a lot of folk some snake oil. Indeed there’s a considerable overlap in the skills required.
    I think it's the word 'useless' which I'd question, given where he's got to.
    Boris was essentially useless, achieving nothing that wasn’t damaging to his party, his country, and ultimately to himself, despite being skilled at working his way to the top.
  • pm215pm215 Posts: 1,250
    IanB2 said:

    So on face value we currently have:

    Reform majority councils

    Derbyshire
    Durham
    Kent
    Lancashire
    Lincolnshire
    Nottinghamshire
    Staffordshire

    Reform largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Tories to join them.

    Leicestershire
    Warwickshire
    Worcestershire

    Tory largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade Reform to join them.

    Northumberland

    Lib Dem largest party - Able to form a working majority if they can persuade the Greens to join them.

    Devon
    Gloucestershire

    I expect Cambridgeshire to go Lib Dem overall majority. The others I don't really know yet. Some are VERY late in starting counting.

    Cambs would be done were it not for the peculiar slowness of the city. With Labour having such a bad night, surely the LibDems will regain enough of wards they’ve held in the past there, to capture the whole county.
    I dunno, I think it has a fair chance to stay no overall control. The LDs need another five seats for a majority out of the total 12 city seats. They won three in 2021, with the rest Labour, and presumably will retain those three. Maybe they can take another two, but maybe not.
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 34,569

    FWIW, my scores on the doors, out of ten.

    Reform: 9.8

    Council results beyond their wildest dreams, and a win in Runcorn, no matter how narrow. At least one and probably two mayors as well. It could have been even better, they missed out on three more mayors by fractions, but they have delivered a revolution.

    Lib Dems: 6.5

    Very solid set of council results, though will be disappointed to miss Devon. Other opportunities still in the bag though. Also disappointing if they've missed out on the target Hull & E Riding mayoralty.

    Green: 6

    Similar to the Lib Dems. Another advance across council chamber but missing the bigger prizes, including the West of England mayor, for which they had been favourites.

    Labour: 1.5

    Catastrophic. Down two-thirds in councillors and dicing with the Greens for fourth place (of fifth, if you count independents), which is awful even allowing for the notionally Con/LD-friendly round of elections. The only bright spark was holding three mayoralties (just) - though even that could be a mixed blessing if they become straws to be grasped.

    Tories: 0.5

    Extinction level event. This is probably what the Liberals felt like in 1918. Half a point for winning the Cambs mayor, against which the caveat noted on Labour also applies.

    Did Cambridge City save the Tories? Ironic if so.
  • eekeek Posts: 29,839
    So Farage is celebrating in Newton Aycliffe saying anyone working on climate change or diversity in Durham council should start job hunting.

    So thats probably zero people on climate change and 2 (max) people in HR job hunting total saving £100,000 max
  • Andy_JSAndy_JS Posts: 34,569
    Dover Town is a Ref win.

    The winning candidate's name is Defriend.

    https://x.com/Kent_cc/status/1918317847169683794
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 65,082
    The extent of Reforms success across England would suggest that in conjunction with the Lib Dems NIMBYISM is alive and well
  • david_herdsondavid_herdson Posts: 18,229

    FWIW, my scores on the doors, out of ten.

    Reform: 9.8

    Council results beyond their wildest dreams, and a win in Runcorn, no matter how narrow. At least one and probably two mayors as well. It could have been even better, they missed out on three more mayors by fractions, but they have delivered a revolution.

    Lib Dems: 6.5

    Very solid set of council results, though will be disappointed to miss Devon. Other opportunities still in the bag though. Also disappointing if they've missed out on the target Hull & E Riding mayoralty.

    Green: 6

    Similar to the Lib Dems. Another advance across council chamber but missing the bigger prizes, including the West of England mayor, for which they had been favourites.

    Labour: 1.5

    Catastrophic. Down two-thirds in councillors and dicing with the Greens for fourth place (of fifth, if you count independents), which is awful even allowing for the notionally Con/LD-friendly round of elections. The only bright spark was holding three mayoralties (just) - though even that could be a mixed blessing if they become straws to be grasped.

    Tories: 0.5

    Extinction level event. This is probably what the Liberals felt like in 1918. Half a point for winning the Cambs mayor, against which the caveat noted on Labour also applies.

    As I’ve said a few times

    Kemi Badenoch = Herbert Samuel.
    That reminds me of a quote from David Lloyd George about him: "when they circumcised Herbert Samuel they threw away the wrong bit".
  • LeonLeon Posts: 60,093
    IanB2 said:

    Leon said:

    nico67 said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
    Which is fine and understandable

    The people I’m mocking are the PBers who continually insist Farage is useless at politics, “he never won a seat in the commons” - oops - “he just got lucky”, he was “nothing to do with brexit winning”

    People like @Nigel_Foremain and @Scott_P snd many many others
    Being a useless chancer isn’t incompatible with persuasively selling a lot of folk some snake oil. Indeed there’s a considerable overlap in the skills required.
    IanB2 said:

    Leon said:

    nico67 said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
    Which is fine and understandable

    The people I’m mocking are the PBers who continually insist Farage is useless at politics, “he never won a seat in the commons” - oops - “he just got lucky”, he was “nothing to do with brexit winning”

    People like @Nigel_Foremain and @Scott_P snd many many others
    Being a useless chancer isn’t incompatible with persuasively selling a lot of folk some snake oil. Indeed there’s a considerable overlap in the skills required.
    Saying such things is just fucking stupid at this point - but then, it is you talking

    Farage is a politician. In what possible universe - outside of your miniature brain - is he “useless” at politics given the course of British history this last decade? He’s started or harnessed TWO parties and used both to change the course of our politics very dramatically. Yours is a laughable perspective. Childishly dim
  • TazTaz Posts: 17,844
    David Cameron, this is your legacy (sorry TSE)

    https://x.com/elshadkarbasi/status/1918206416805937385?s=61
  • DM_AndyDM_Andy Posts: 1,346
    Andy_JS said:

    FWIW, my scores on the doors, out of ten.

    Reform: 9.8

    Council results beyond their wildest dreams, and a win in Runcorn, no matter how narrow. At least one and probably two mayors as well. It could have been even better, they missed out on three more mayors by fractions, but they have delivered a revolution.

    Lib Dems: 6.5

    Very solid set of council results, though will be disappointed to miss Devon. Other opportunities still in the bag though. Also disappointing if they've missed out on the target Hull & E Riding mayoralty.

    Green: 6

    Similar to the Lib Dems. Another advance across council chamber but missing the bigger prizes, including the West of England mayor, for which they had been favourites.

    Labour: 1.5

    Catastrophic. Down two-thirds in councillors and dicing with the Greens for fourth place (of fifth, if you count independents), which is awful even allowing for the notionally Con/LD-friendly round of elections. The only bright spark was holding three mayoralties (just) - though even that could be a mixed blessing if they become straws to be grasped.

    Tories: 0.5

    Extinction level event. This is probably what the Liberals felt like in 1918. Half a point for winning the Cambs mayor, against which the caveat noted on Labour also applies.

    Did Cambridge City save the Tories? Ironic if so.
    No, changing the law saved the Tories, in 2021 they got 40.5% of the vote and then lost on Lib Dem transfers, they switched to FPTP and won on 28.4% (though to be fair, they would have won on the old system as Reform wouldn't have bridged a 5% gap on Labour, Lib Dem and Green transfers)
  • kinabalukinabalu Posts: 44,922
    Leon said:

    nico67 said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
    Which is fine and understandable

    The people I’m mocking are the PBers who continually insist Farage is useless at politics, “he never won a seat in the commons” - oops - “he just got lucky”, he was “nothing to do with brexit winning”

    People like @Nigel_Foremain and @Scott_P snd many many others
    You name two hard Remainers there but the (imo) risible "nothing to do with Brexit winning" (or even that it was won despite him) comes mainly from non-primitive Leavers who are uncomfortable with the xenophobic aspect of the project. I've had this exact tumble with a few of them.
  • DopermeanDopermean Posts: 970
    Seems doubtful that their vetting will have improved but surely it would be more reasonable to hope that it hasn't. It seems that people will only learn by lived experience, if even then, sadly they'll have to experience that voting Reform will mean a collapse in local services, incompetence and farce.
  • LeonLeon Posts: 60,093
    God help us if Farage ever gets “quite useful” at politics. He’ll probably win the US presidency and become supreme galactic warlord
  • RobDRobD Posts: 60,384
    DM_Andy said:

    Andy_JS said:

    FWIW, my scores on the doors, out of ten.

    Reform: 9.8

    Council results beyond their wildest dreams, and a win in Runcorn, no matter how narrow. At least one and probably two mayors as well. It could have been even better, they missed out on three more mayors by fractions, but they have delivered a revolution.

    Lib Dems: 6.5

    Very solid set of council results, though will be disappointed to miss Devon. Other opportunities still in the bag though. Also disappointing if they've missed out on the target Hull & E Riding mayoralty.

    Green: 6

    Similar to the Lib Dems. Another advance across council chamber but missing the bigger prizes, including the West of England mayor, for which they had been favourites.

    Labour: 1.5

    Catastrophic. Down two-thirds in councillors and dicing with the Greens for fourth place (of fifth, if you count independents), which is awful even allowing for the notionally Con/LD-friendly round of elections. The only bright spark was holding three mayoralties (just) - though even that could be a mixed blessing if they become straws to be grasped.

    Tories: 0.5

    Extinction level event. This is probably what the Liberals felt like in 1918. Half a point for winning the Cambs mayor, against which the caveat noted on Labour also applies.

    Did Cambridge City save the Tories? Ironic if so.
    No, changing the law saved the Tories, in 2021 they got 40.5% of the vote and then lost on Lib Dem transfers, they switched to FPTP and won on 28.4% (though to be fair, they would have won on the old system as Reform wouldn't have bridged a 5% gap on Labour, Lib Dem and Green transfers)
    So changing the law didn’t save them as the outcome would have been the same?
  • Sean_FSean_F Posts: 38,628
    Leon said:

    nico67 said:

    Leon said:

    Leon said:

    Is any PB still gonna trot out their "Farage is a useless chancer" bollocks?

    I hope not, after this. It would be embarrassing, to put it lightly

    Farage wouldn't be the first "useless chancer" to become PM, if indeed he makes it that far.
    Do you still believe he is a "uselss chancer"?

    In a way, I really hope you do, and that you explain your workings here. It will add to the gaiety of the nation
    He’s had a huge impact on the UK and I get people like him. But I think personally he’s a cancer on the UK .
    Which is fine and understandable

    The people I’m mocking are the PBers who continually insist Farage is useless at politics, “he never won a seat in the commons” - oops - “he just got lucky”, he was “nothing to do with brexit winning”

    People like @Nigel_Foremain and @Scott_P snd many many others
    I wonder if anyone still thinks Reform’s performance is “underwhelming.”
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 65,082
    Here's a thought

    If Farage and Reform continue their successes this time next year Farage could be running Wales.!!!
  • TazTaz Posts: 17,844
    eek said:

    So Farage is celebrating in Newton Aycliffe saying anyone working on climate change or diversity in Durham council should start job hunting.

    So thats probably zero people on climate change and 2 (max) people in HR job hunting total saving £100,000 max

    Let him have his moment in the sun, literally, as the coalition found spouting from the sidelines in opposition is easy. They have to deliver now and heaven knows what will happen with Milburngate.
  • kinabalukinabalu Posts: 44,922
    Taz said:

    David Cameron, this is your legacy (sorry TSE)

    https://x.com/elshadkarbasi/status/1918206416805937385?s=61

    More Johnson's legacy imo. Or perhaps we say both since one begat the other.
  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 39,873

    It's complicated, but if I had to identify one single thing behind the Reform surge it would be asylum seekers in hotels. There's enough outrage about this to add quite a few percent to the Reform vote everywhere as, rightly or wrongly (probably the latter), people think they could solve it.

    Yes, housing asylum seekers/illegal immigrants in 4* hotels, giving them NHS queue jumps, free money is all causing a huge number of votes to go for Reform. The drum beat of ridiculous judgements on deporting foreign criminals has also been a huge driver as well. I think people probably feel as though voting in a tough as nails socially conservative reform government which will likely start sinking illegal immigrant boats in the channel is going to also start deporting illegals already here and end asylum seeking in the UK except for those we specifically invite such as Ukrainians and Hong Kongers.
  • LostPasswordLostPassword Posts: 19,184
    Dopermean said:

    Seems doubtful that their vetting will have improved but surely it would be more reasonable to hope that it hasn't. It seems that people will only learn by lived experience, if even then, sadly they'll have to experience that voting Reform will mean a collapse in local services, incompetence and farce.

    Local services in lots of places are collapsing already because central government has starved local government of money.

    How sure are you that people will be able to tell the difference?
  • MaxPBMaxPB Posts: 39,873
    TOPPING said:

    .

    TOPPING said:

    It's complicated, but if I had to identify one single thing behind the Reform surge it would be asylum seekers in hotels. There's enough outrage about this to add quite a few percent to the Reform vote everywhere as, rightly or wrongly (probably the latter), people think they could solve it.

    This ties in with the boats. Now, this election notwithstanding, where I think those who don't like foreigners are making their position known, the UK has consistently shown that it is happy to have immigrants, and plenty of them. What they don't like is being out of control, or freeloaders.

    The boats represent a tangible example of the government not being able to control its own borders, and hence why successive governments are so keen to stop them, despite the tiny numbers arriving in this way.

    Likewise, "asylum hotels" are seen as freeloading and jumping the queue. And every freeborn Englishman detests queue jumpers.
    The people in hotels would love to have jobs. That’s what they’re hoping for, to get asylum and to be allowed to get a job. The rules don’t let them have jobs. The system forces them not to do anything and the Tories then produced these very long proceeding times.
    Sure. Not the point. People (UK people) see them as freeloading and getting room service of coffee and pain au chocolat plus a spa treatment at the taxpayers' expense.
    And people who we don't want in the country in the first place. I think Labour needs to seriously consider closing the UK to new asylum applications and temporarily pause our members of whatever treaties is required to achieve this. If we're to avoid a Reform majority in 2029 we need a period of 4 years with no new asylum seekers and to deport all of the ones we do have as well as revoking visas for the low wage legal migrants and "students" that overstay and work illegally.

    They really, really need to get tough or watch as more and more people turn to Farage and we sleepwalk into a reform majority.
Sign In or Register to comment.